QUANTITATIVE METHODS IN HISTORY, HISTORICAL INFORMATICS
Reference:
Mishina E.M.
The Stalinist repressions of 1935–1937:
an analysis of the social groups’
dynamics on the basis of the
“memorial books” of the Altay kray
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 369-380.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66119
Abstract:
The author analyses the repressive mechanisms of the period, disclosed on the basis of a study of archival
material. The first part of the article consists of a brief historiographical overview of the studies on this subject. The
dominant opinion in scientific literature is that regional officials, usually following central instructions, fabricated
investigational materials on the principles convenient for their regional authorities. The second part is dedicated to the
examination of the repression dynamics on the main social groups: agriculturalists, industrial workers and officials.
The dynamics’ data is divided by years and the author attempts to thus distinguish small repression campaigns of
regional scale. The author comes to the conclusion that in most cases the repressions were conducted within one social
group, with investigation files containing examples of interceding lines of repression of various social groups; however,
the existing data is not enough to expose definite tendencies. Agricultural workers and administrators suffered most from
the repressions. On the basis of archival investigation files, in conjunction with the deductive and inductive methods,
the author distinguishes three repression mechanisms: “bottom-up”, “top-down”, and their synthesis – “mixed” type. In
the given timeframe, the “mixed” type was the most common: it was characteristic for group investigations, falsified in
a significant number of cases.
Keywords:
repressions, regions, Altay, “memorial book”, database, investigation files, social groups, dynamics, campaigns, mechanism of repression.
Ethnography and ethnology
Reference:
Tutorski A.V., Vinetskaya A.A.
The Maclay shore 140 years later
(the figure of the scientist and
the cultural transformation of
the Papuans)
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 381-390.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66120
Abstract:
The article presents an overview of the transformations in the language and mythological notions of the
Papuans on the Maclay shore after the departure of the scientist. A short description of the region’s ethnic composition
permits to take a different look at the cultural processes happening there from the 1890s to the 2010s. The authors
cite several legends connected with the appearance of the Russian scientist in the Astrolabe bay, and also of the soviet
expeditions “in the footsteps of N. N. Miklouho-Maclay” of 1971 and 1977. They analyse as well the Russian-language
adoptions in the Maclay shore languages, while eliminating existing false assumptions of borrowing. The figure of the
scientist in mythological folktales significantly altered during the course of the 20th century: in the 1900–1930s he
appeared as a cultural hero, in the 1940–1970s – as the transmitter of cargo-treasures, in the 1980–2010s he attains the
characteristics of a real person, cooperating with the Bongu Papuans. The article compares the figure of N. N. Miklouho-
Maclay with that of Augustus Hanke, who had lived in Bongu for 30 years. The authors come to the conclusion that
all of the pertinent legendary tales contain little historical facts and are subjected to the general evolutionary laws of
mythological texts. It is therefore necessary to continue the study of the heritage of the Russian scientist in the Papuan
culture of the Maclay shore.
Keywords:
Austronesians, acculturation, Maclay shore, geographical legends, cargo cults, N. N. Miklouho-Maclay, mythology, Madang, Papua – New Guinea, Augustus Hanke.
Historical facts, events, phenomena
Reference:
Kretinin S.V.
The Young German movement
in Poland, 1920–1930s
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 391-401.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66121
Abstract:
The article examines the history of the Young German movement in Poland during the 1920–1930s. Its focal
topics are the reasons and the historical conditions in which the National-socialist Young German party developed, led by
Rudolf Wiesner. The article describes the political program of the movement, its relations with other German political forces
in Poland, including the role of the Young Germans in the debate between “the elders” and “the young” in 1933–1939. It
also defines the relations between the Young German party and the rehabilitation regime of the Second republic. The author
gives light to the reasons of the party’s loyalty to the Polish government. Separate attention is dedicated to the influence of
Nazi Germany on the political life of the Germans in Poland. The foreign policy structures of Nazi Germany led a similar
line of policy towards other Volksdeutsche in the countries of Central, Eastern, and South-Eastern Europe. The policy’s
main goal was to establish control over the local ethnic German groups in these countries, in the first place – over their
political organizations. This was while Berlin officially sought to avoid conflicts with the authorities of countries, where
citizens of German nationality resided and who were seen as potential allies. Thus the absence of a due support by the
radical National-socialists groups in Poland is explained.
Keywords:
Germans in Poland, Young German party in Poland, National-socialism, Polish history, Second Polish Republic, German history, Volksdeutsche, Rudolf Wiesner, Cieszyn Silesia, “fifth column”.
EVOLUTION, REFORM, REVOLUTION
Reference:
Ariskina Y.E.
Law, legality and constitution as the
ideological basis of the Private
committee’s policy
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 402-412.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66122
Abstract:
The article examines the ideological basis of the Private committee’s activity – the circle of “young friends” of
Alexander I that developed the main internal political changes at the beginning of the 19th century. The concepts of law,
legality and constitution stated in the article’s title were fundamental notions in the discussion and elaboration of a series
of reforms. The principal aim of this article is to elucidate the understanding of these concepts by committee members and the
emperor at the beginning of his reign. The main source for this study is the material from the archive of P. A. Stroganov, the
so-called protocols of the Private committee. At the beginning of his reign, Alexander I and his entourage aimed to establish
a constitution as the final outcome of their work – an unchangeable law (or codex of laws), which would allow to systematise
and define the administrative system, to validate and strengthen the emperor’s authority, to finalise the process of the classes’
rights legalisation. However, apart from asserting the emperor’s authority, there existed the idea of the power of law, which
would restrain despotism and abuse of the monarch, should it become necessary.
Keywords:
government constitutionalism, reforms, class policy, constitution, legality, law, social contract, Alexander I, Private committee, F.-C. Laharpe.
Social history
Reference:
Chagadaeva O.A.
The Social and economic
consequences of the Russian
anti-alcohol campaign during
World War I
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 413-424.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66123
Abstract:
The article presents a complex analysis of the anti-alcohol policy in the Russian state during the years of World
War I. The author gives a general outline of the measures taken to combat alcoholism, analyses the goals of the anti-alcohol
campaign and describes the reasons for its inefficiency and the consequences it had on the country. As well, the article
states the justifications for the suspension of alcohol trade upon the entrance of the Russian empire into the war. Special
attention is given to the social and economic consequences of so à radical move under the conditions of the prolonged and
unprecedented in financial costs world war. The author comes to the conclusion that the anti-alcohol campaign could have
given positive results only had the war ended quickly and favourably, which was the wager of the government and of the
autonomous government bodies. During its first month the campaign played the role of a mobilising factor, however the
extension of the war, complicated by the external political and economic situation, and the degradation of the country’s
well-being undid the initial positive results. The consequences from the campaign in a most serious manner affected the
economic, as well as the political position of the empire and in many ways defined the future revolutionary processes.
Keywords:
anti-alcohol policy, World War I, “alcohol prohibition”, fiscal policy, capital cities, daily life, state wine monopoly, shadow economy, home front, socio-economic crisis.
Social history
Reference:
Akulenko I.V.
Honorary citizenship in the
Russian Empire
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 425-431.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66124
Abstract:
The class of honorary citizens in the Russian empire did not appear by chance: the formation of the class
of eminent (and later – honorary), citizens at the end of the 17th century allowed the Russian sovereign to solve several
governmental problems through it. Some of the main problems included the appeasement of social tensions, the difficulty of
integrating new subjects of various confessions and ethnic groups into the state structure, the distinction of certain citizens
and the conferment of privileges on them (for the purpose of encouraging their benefit to the state), and other questions. The
privileges of the honorary citizens established by Catherine II in the Charter to cities, consisted of: exemption from corporeal
punishment and conscription, possession of suburban yards and gardens (except for populated estates), and travel within
city limits with a two- or four-horse carriage. The titles of eminent citizen were made hereditary, which thus formed them into
a distinct social class. The grandchildren of the eminent citizens, whose fathers and grandfathers bore this citizenship title
faultlessly, at the age of 30 were allowed to request the conferring of nobility. In 1832 emperor Nicholas I formally established
through a manifest the formation of a separate class of eminent citizens. These citizens were divided into singular and
hereditary groups. Famous representatives of the given class were the Morozovs, the Riabouchinskys, the Guchkovs. The title
of honorary citizens was abrogated by the decree of the All-Russian central executive committee and the Council of people’s
commissars on 11 (24) November 1917 regarding the abolition of classes and civil titles. The creation of the new class had
originally not only helped to solve problems of stately magnitude, but also encouraged the expansion of patronage, the system
of government administration locally, and the whole Russian economy.
Keywords:
honorary citizenship, class, nobility, merchant class, guilds, privileges, request, charter, manifest, Russian emperor.
HISTORICAL ANTHROPOLOGY
Reference:
Sak K.V.
Milestones in the professional biography
of the Grand duke Konstantin
Konstantinovich
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 432-440.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66125
Abstract:
The article illustrates the key milestones in the professional biography of the Grand duke Konstantin
Konstantinovich (1856–1915), presented in the context of the socio-political events during the reigns of the last three
emperors. The aim of the study is to analyse, on the example of Konstantin Romanov’s biography, the career development
particularities of the Romanov dynasty members, to reveal the objective and subjective factors that influenced their sociopolitical
activity, and to show how the significance of the dynasty’s members in the state life of the Russian empire changed
in the course of the late-imperial period. The author comes to the conclusion that the career advancement of the Grand
duke Konstantin Konstantinovich depended on the monarchs’ individual perceptions of the role of dynasty members in
the socio-political life of the state. At the same time, professional appointments could be made on high officials’ initiatives,
which were eager to reach their ambitions through this. The opposition against Alexander III had a decisive influence on the
careers of the Grand dukes of his time, as the emperor did not deem necessary to engage his relatives in state affairs. This,
in consequence, under Nicholas II led to Konstantin Konstantinovich having the possibility to influence state life, but not
to fulfil his initiatives. The absence of experience gave the Grand duke a sense of incertitude in his abilities as a statesman
and made his private life more appealing than the life of a public figure. Thus, on the example of the professional biography
of the Grand duke Konstantin Konstantinovich, one can see how the dynasty’s members lost their fundamental roles in the
life of the state, which ultimately led to the crisis of the dynasty as a political institute of authority.
Keywords:
Grand duke Konstantin Konstantinovich, Grand duke Konstantin Nikolaevich, Romanov dynasty, Alexander I, Alexander II, Alexander III, Nicholas II, literacy committees, Imperial academy of sciences, military schools, first Russian revolution.
History of ethnicities, peoples, nations
Reference:
Lazareva A.V.
Religious schism and “German”
patriotism. On the question of the
confessional opposition’s role in the
German duchies during the Thirty
year’s war (1618–1848)
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 441-448.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66126
Abstract:
The article examines the questions concerning the religious rupture in Germany and its influence on the
formation of the German national idea in the period of the Thirty years\’ war (1618–1648). The intellectual life of the
Holy Roman empire of the German nation from the second decade of the 17th century was significantly determined
by the Thirty years\’ war. The German intellectuals, mostly authors and publicists, were the first to raise through their
works the subject of the necessity for German unity and love for one\’s homeland, without the traditional division into
Catholics and Protestants developed from the 16th century. For the German duchies, divided by confessional allegiances,
this became a novel challenge. The article is based on a wide range of sources, mainly from the publicist and literary
genres from the middle and second half of the 17th century. The originality of this research is in its analysis of the genesis
of the German national idea through the prism of the confessional uniqueness of the German territorial duchies. The
sources used by the author, in the first place publicist material and literature, in itself also presents the originality of this
research. Despite the fact that among the intellectual elite there were representatives of different religious views, it was the
authors and publicist who presented a unique example of confessional tolerance. This narrow stratum of German society
became the messenger of mental changes and the announcer of transition from confessional doctrines to the new notions
of “state interests”, weaved with the formation of the early Modern national conceptions.
Keywords:
nationalism, confessionalisation, nation, M. Opitz, G. Ph. Harsdörffer, H. J. Ch. Grimmelshausen, intellectual elite, German literature, Germany.
History of ethnicities, peoples, nations
Reference:
Gusev N.S.
The Bulgarian mores and their
changes during the Balkan wars as
perceived by the Russians
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 449-455.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66127
Abstract:
The Russian society focused a lot of its attention on the Balkan wars of 1912–1913, and on Bulgaria
in particular. Correspondents of periodicals went to the peninsula. Many of them had never been to the Balkans and
did not know the character of the population living there, thereby were free from the clichés concerning them and could
evaluate the Bulgarian mores without bias. These correspondents described the Bulgarian character as peace-loving,
hard-working and household-oriented, which was also noted by those visiting the country earlier. But in wartime this
household-orientation sometimes took up rather unsympathetic forms. Along with this, witnesses saw a manifestation of
bellicosity, the wish to fight their adversaries at all costs, and cruelty towards the enemy. Analysing these facts, reporters
defined two sources for them. The first – to revenge the Turks for their century-old subjugation and oppression. The
second – to attain the national ideal, the San Stefano Bulgaria. At the same time, it is impossible to affirm that these
sentiments were not intensified by the government. The success of the official propaganda of historic myths confirms that
in the minds of the Bulgarians the image of a San Stefano Bulgaria and Macedonia was deeply rooted. These were the
symbols capable of exposing the Bulgarian society to changes and to dislodge it fr om its peaceful routine.
Keywords:
attitude towards the enemy, imagology, Bulgaria, Balkan wars, Russian correspondents, mores, San Stefano Bulgaria, Macedonia, Bulgarians, people at war.
WEST-RUSSIA-EAST
Reference:
Tikhonova A.V.
Surveillance of foreign doctors in
the Russian empire during the first
half of the 19th century
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 456-463.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66128
Abstract:
The surveillance of foreigners in the Russian empire is a little-researched historiographical subject, with, among
professional groups, only control over foreign teachers and tutors being studied. The aim of the article is to examine the
formation history of the regulatory-legal base for foreign doctors’ sojourn in Russia in the first half of the 19th century, and
to cite concrete examples of surveillance implementation over these professionals on the basis of documents from the Third
section of His imperial majesty’s Own chancellery (State archive of the Russian Federation), the Smolensk governorate office,
the chancellery of the Smolensk civil governor and the governorate medical board (State archive of the Smolensk oblast). The
author draws particular attention to the fact that the main requirement for receiving medical practice permission in Russia
was the validation of a doctor’s qualifications through the passage of exams in Russian specialised facilities. Because
of the Russian authorities’ interest in attracting foreign specialists, these specialists were encouraged to learn Russian
language and to receive Russian citizenship. To justify the logic of the authorities’ actions towards doctor-foreigners, the
author describes the Russian government’s decisions taken during the 1850s. State surveillance was directed at ensuring
the health of the Russian citizens and administering them with qualified medical aid from foreign specialists.
Keywords:
surveillance, control, doctors, medics, foreigners, foreign doctors, prisoners of war, legislation, Russian empire, first half of the 19th century.
REVIEWS, BIBLIOGRAPHY
Reference:
Khitrov D.A.
Stanziani Alessandro. After Oriental
Despotism: Eurasian Growth in a
Global Perspective. London:
Bloomsbury, 2014. 219 p.
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 464-470.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66129
Abstract:
The review introduces the new comparative study of A. Stanziani, a renowned French historian, to the
Russian specialists, discussing the author’s general approach, thesis and arguments. The book considers the dominant
concepts of West European and American historiography on the specifics of Russian variant of the transformations of the
Early Modern era. Using the wide range of modern historiography, A. Stanziani reveals that the conventional perceptions
of the major problems of Russian history of that period strongly affect the general schemes of historical development, which
often contradicts the current level of knowledge attained by specialists. The reviewer suggests that the work of A. Stanziani,
with its balanced and broad vision, is an important step to overcoming the alienation between the studies of Russian history
in Russia and abroad, and is of great importance for both Russian and Western specialists.
Keywords:
Alessandro Stanziani, “Oriental Despotism”, History of Russia, Early Modern period, social and economic history, economic backwardness, “military revolution”, serfdom, kholopy, territorial expansion.
Discussion and debate
Reference:
Filippov I.S.
On the concept of “Middle ages”
and its content
// History magazine - researches.
2014. ¹ 4.
P. 471-484.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=66130
Abstract:
Contemporary Russian and foreign historiography is actively discussing the concept of the Middle ages. Some
of the key problems concerning this notion include its chronological frame, its watershed temporal marks, its applicability to
regions other than Western Europe and the Mediterranean, and its socio-cultural content. Opponents of this term have put
forward claims that this concept lacks an objective basis and that from its appearance during the Renaissance, it has been no
more than a projection of the ideas of scholars from different schools and epochs about the past and their own times. In this line
of reasoning we are advised not to study the Middle ages as such (with the exception of particular periods and phenomena),
but rather to assess this notion at different stages of historiography and decide what particular perception is necessary for our
own contemporary society and, consequently, conduct our research accordingly. In writing this article the author made use of
the general scientific methods, i.e. the historical and logical methods, as well as the systematic and linguistic methods. The
author demonstrates that the critics of the notion of Middle ages have failed to prove its ontological emptiness, just as they have
failed to prove this for the concept of Feudalism, which as they claim has been discarded by modern historiography as useless
for the understanding of the medieval world. The author comes to the conclusion that the idea of the ontological emptiness of
the discussed notion should be considered in the context of the more general historiographical debates about historicism, the
pertinence of contemporary scientific concepts for the study of history, and the very subject of historical research, including the
expediency of posing “global questions” in history. The article shows that the refutation of the notion of Middle ages is connected
with the refusal of studying the system of social relations that enables us to apprehend the medieval world in its wholeness. The
author also considers the place of Medieval European civilization from the point of view of its cultural achievements and its
unique capability of evolution without causing major social catastrophes. A hypothesis is advanced that this capability is in
itself a most important characteristic of the Medieval epoch.
Keywords:
Middle ages, Modern History, European Civilisation, medieval studies, medievalism, history of notions, property relations, Feudalism, fiefs and vassalage, seigneurie.