Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

History magazine - researches
Reference:

Mishina E.M. The Stalinist repressions of 1935–1937:  an analysis of the social groups’  dynamics on the basis of the  “memorial books” of the Altay kray

Abstract: The author analyses the repressive mechanisms of the period, disclosed on the basis of a study of archival material. The first part of the article consists of a brief historiographical overview of the studies on this subject. The dominant opinion in scientific literature is that regional officials, usually following central instructions, fabricated investigational materials on the principles convenient for their regional authorities. The second part is dedicated to the examination of the repression dynamics on the main social groups: agriculturalists, industrial workers and officials. The dynamics’ data is divided by years and the author attempts to thus distinguish small repression campaigns of regional scale. The author comes to the conclusion that in most cases the repressions were conducted within one social group, with investigation files containing examples of interceding lines of repression of various social groups; however, the existing data is not enough to expose definite tendencies. Agricultural workers and administrators suffered most from the repressions. On the basis of archival investigation files, in conjunction with the deductive and inductive methods, the author distinguishes three repression mechanisms: “bottom-up”, “top-down”, and their synthesis – “mixed” type. In the given timeframe, the “mixed” type was the most common: it was characteristic for group investigations, falsified in a significant number of cases.


Keywords:

repressions, regions, Altay, “memorial book”, database, investigation files, social groups, dynamics, campaigns, mechanism of repression.


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Vatlin A. Yu. Terror raionnogo masshtaba: «Massovye operatsii» NKVD v Kuntsevskom raione Moskovskoi oblasti 1937–1938 gg. M.: ROSSPEN, 2004. 256 s.
2. Delo po obvineniyu Varkentina // Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op. 7. D. 24181.
3. Delo po obvineniyu Zakharova // Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op. 7. D. 9796.
4. Delo po obvineniyu Kulakova, Lisitskogo, Marchenko, Nedodela, Pavlyuchenko, Starostenko // Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op. 7. D. 20460.
5. Delo po obvineniyu M. Alekseenko, S. Alekseenko // Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op. 7. D. 23821.
6. Delo po obvineniyu P. Vladimova, I. Krasnoshlykova, A. Krasnoshlykova // Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op.
7. D. 7034. 7. Delo po obvineniyu Plotnikova, Savitskogo, Sladkovskogo // Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op. 7. D. 7034.
8. Zhertvy politicheskogo terrora v Altaiskom krae. T. 2. Barnaul, 1999. 556 s.; T. 3. 1937 g. Ch. 1. Barnaul, 2000. 584 s.; T. 3, 1937 g. Ch. 2. Barnaul, 2000. 440 s.; T. 7. 1920–1965. Barnaul, 2005. 363 s.
9. Zhertvy politicheskogo terrora v SSSR [Elektronnyi resurs]. 4-e izd. M., 2007.
10. Lyagushkina L. A. K otsenke informatsionnogo potentsiala «knig pamyati» v sravnenii so sledstvennymi delami zhertv «Bol'shogo terrora» // Istoricheskii zhurnal: nauchnye issledovaniya. 2014. ¹ 2. C. 157–166.
11. Massovye repressii v Altaiskom krae 1937–1938 gg. Prikaz ¹ 00447. M.: ROSSPEN, 2010. 752 s.
12. Material podgotovlen po dannym BD «Memoriala» (Zhertvy politicheskogo terrora v SSSR). [Elektronnyi resurs]. 4-e izd. M., 2007.
13. Mishina E. M. Professional'nyi sostav repressirovannykh v 1935–1937 gg.: analiz bazy dannykh na osnove «knig pamyati» Altaiskogo kraya // Informatsionnyi byulleten' Assotsiatsii «Istoriya i komp'yuter». ¹ 41. Barnaul, 2013. S. 88–107.
14. Osobennaya chast' UK RSFSR 1926 g. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: http://www.memorial.krsk.ru/Articles/KP/1/05.htm (data obrashcheniya: 21.12.2013)
15. Otdel spetsdokumentatsii upravleniya arkhivnogo dela Altaiskogo kraya. F. R-2. Op. 7. D. 7034, 9796, 20460, 23821, 24181.
16. Papkov S. A. Obyknovennyi terror: politika stalinizma v Sibiri. M.: ROSSPEN, 2010. 440 s.
17. Sbornik zakonodatel'nykh i normativnykh aktov o repressiyakh i reabilitatsii zhertv politicheskikh repressii. M.: Respublika, 1993. 222 s.
18. SZ SSSR 1932 g. ¹ 62. St. 360.
19. Stalinizm v sovetskoi provintsii: 1937–1938 gg. Massovaya operatsiya na osnove prikaza ¹ 00447. M.: ROSSPEN; Germanskii istoricheskii institut v Moskve, 2009. 927 s.
20. Stat'ya 58-2 UK RSFSR: «Vooruzhennoe vosstanie ili vtorzhenie v kontrrevolyutsionnykh tselyakh na sovetskuyu territoriyu vooruzhennykh band, zakhvat vlasti v tsentre ili na meste v tekh zhe tselyakh i, v chastnosti, s tsel'yu nasil'stvenno ottorgnut' ot Soyuza SSR i otdel'noi soyuznoi respubliki kakuyu-libo chast' ee territorii ili rastorgnut' zaklyuchennye Soyuzom SSR s inostrannymi gosudarstvami dogovory». Sm.: Osobennaya chast' UK RSFSR 1926 g. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: http://www.memorial.krsk.ru/Articles/KP/1/05.htm (data obrashcheniya: 21.12.2013)
21. Stat'ya 58-10 UK RSFSR: «Propaganda ili agitatsiya, soderzhashchie prizyv k sverzheniyu, podryvu ili oslableniyu Sovetskoi vlasti ili k soversheniyu otdel'nykh kontrrevolyutsionnykh prestuplenii a ravno rasprostranenie ili izgotovlenie ili khranenie literatury togo zhe soderzhaniya». Sm.: Osobennaya chast' UK RSFSR 1926 g. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: http://www.memorial.krsk.ru/Articles/KP/1/05.htm (data obrashcheniya: 27.12.2013)
22. Suslov A. B. Trudposelentsy – zhertvy «kulatskoi operatsii» NKVD v Permskom raione Sverdlovskoi oblasti // Stalinizm v sovetskoi provintsii: 1937–1938 gg. Massovaya operatsiya na osnove prikaza ¹ 00447. M.: ROSSPEN; Germanskii istoricheskii institut v Moskve, 2009. S. 132–150.
23. Tablitsa sostavlena po dannym BD «Memoriala» (Zhertvy politicheskogo terrora v SSSR). [Elektronnyi resurs]. 4-e izd. M., 2007.
24. Teplyakov A. Personal i povsednevnost' Novosibirskogo UNKVD v 1936–1946 gg. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: http://rusk.ru/st.php?idar=45710 (data obrashcheniya: 27.12.13)
25. Shabalin V. V. Sel'skoe naselenie Prikam'ya kak zhertva massovoi operatsii po prikazu ¹ 00447 // Stalinizm v sovetskoi provintsii: 1937–1938 gg. Massovaya operatsiya na osnove prikaza ¹ 00447. M.: ROSSPEN; Germanskii istoricheskii institut v Moskve, 2009. S. 104–116.
26. Khaustov V., Samuel'son L. Stalin, NKVD i repressii 1936–1938 gg. M.: ROSSPEN; Fond pervogo prezidenta Rossii B. N. El'tsina, 2010. 432 s.
27. Ellman M. Regional Influences on the Formulation and Implementation of NKVD Order 00447 // Europe Asia Studies. Vol. 62. No. 6. August 2010. P. 915–929