Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Administrative and municipal law
Reference:

Dobrobaba M.B. The problem of improving the system of disciplinary penalties applied within official delictual disciplinary relations

Abstract: The subject of the study is disciplinary penalties imposed on public servants within official delictual disciplinary relations. The author analyzes the current system of disciplinary penalties imposed on state civil servants, military personnel and law enforcement officers. Particular attention is paid to the nature of disciplinary sanctions, the possibility of determining the extent of their impact on offenders. The author examines the individual types of disciplinary penalties, including demotion, in the sphere of the internal affairs, and dismissal, as a disciplinary penalty, identifies the shortcomings of legal regulation of these matters. The author applies the dialectical method of scientific cognition, the method of logical analysis and synthesis, the systems method, logical analysis, and the method of comparative jurisprudence. The novelty of the research lies in substantinating the necessity to expand the list of disciplinary penalties with punishments, having a material nature and consisting in the temporary restriction or deprivation of benefits of public service, or limiting career growth. This proves the necessity to differentiate the limits of disciplinary penalties in the form of monthly financial incentives cut, depending on the category of the disciplinary offense. It is proposed to exclude from the list of disciplinary sanctions, imposed on the officials of internal affairs agencies, such a type of disciplinary penalty as a transfer to lower official positions as a penalty, not conforming to international law provisions and being a form of forced labor. The author proposes to legislate the division of disciplinary penalties into primary and secondary, taking into consideration that a single disciplinary offense can be punished with a primary or a secondary penalty. The author declares the need for establishing common grounds for particular penalties imposition for particular types of misconduct. The author substantiates the proposal about legislative restriction of financial incentives for public officials incuring disciplinary penalty.


Keywords:

additional penalty, primary penalty, disciplinary responsibility, official delictual disciplinary relationship, public servants, public service, disciplinary offenses, disciplinary penalty, dismissal, financial incentives cut


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Dobrobaba M.B. Doktrinal'naya kharakteristika distsiplinarnoi otvetstvennosti gosudarstvennykh sluzhashchikh v zarubezhnykh stranakh // Zhurnal zarubezhnogo zakonodatel'stva i sravnitel'nogo pravovedeniya / Journal of foreighn legislation and comparative law. - 2013. - 4. - C. 596 - 605.
2. Sm.: p. 4-6 ch. 1 st. 50 Federal'nyi zakon ot 30 noyabrya 2011 g. ¹ 342-FZ (red. ot 12.02.2015) «O sluzhbe v organakh vnutrennikh del Rossiiskoi Federatsii i vnesenii izmenenii v otdel'nye zakonodatel'nye akty Rossiiskoi Federatsii»
3. Opredelenie Kassatsionnoi kollegii Verkhovnogo Suda RF ot 19 yanvarya 2010 g. ¹ KAS09-650 [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: http://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/ 1694096/#1694096# ixzz3XD8VgV4o (data obrashcheniya 13.04.2015).
4. Federal'nyi zakon ot 22 dekabrya 2014 g. ¹ 431-FZ «O vnesenii izmenenii v otdel'nye zakonodatel'nye akty Rossiiskoi Federatsii po voprosam protivodeistviya korruptsii» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 2014. 24 dek.
5. Sm.: p. 5 ch. 1 st. 50 Federal'nogo zakona ot 30 noyabrya 2011 g. ¹ 342-FZ (red. ot 12.02.2015) «O sluzhbe v organakh vnutrennikh del Rossiiskoi Federatsii i vnesenii izmenenii v otdel'nye zakonodatel'nye akty Rossiiskoi Federatsii».
6. Ivanova S.A. Pravovoe regulirovanie trudovykh otnoshenii gosudarstvennykh sluzhashchikh: dis. ... kand. yurid. nauk. Ekaterinburg, 2002. S. 23.
7. Konventsiya MOT ¹ 29 «O prinuditel'nom ili obyazatel'nom trude»: prinyata 28 iyunya 1930 g. i ratifitsirovana SSSR v 1956 g.
8. Konventsiya MOT ¹ 105 «Ob uprazdnenii prinuditel'nogo truda»: prinyata 29 iyunya 1957 g. i ratifitsirovana uzhe Rossiiskoi Federatsiei v 1994 g.
9. Prikaz FSKN Rossii ot 28 noyabrya 2008 g. ¹ 424 (red. ot 20.09.2012) «Ob utverzhdenii Instruktsii po organizatsii raboty po primeneniyu pooshchrenii i distsiplinarnykh vzyskanii v organakh po kontrolyu za oborotom narkoticheskikh sredstv i psikhotropnykh veshchestv» // Byulleten' normativnykh aktov federal'nykh organov ispolnitel'noi vlasti. 2009. ¹ 6; Rossiiskaya gazeta. 2012. 5 dekabrya.
10. Sm., naprimer: p.. 11 Prilozheniya 2 Prikaza MChS Rossii ot 26 oktyabrya 2006 g. ¹ 616 (red. ot 06.04.2012) «O denezhnom soderzhanii federal'nykh gosudarstvennykh grazhdanskikh sluzhashchikh MChS Rossii», utv. Poryadok vyplaty premii za vypolnenie osobo vazhnykh i slozhnykh zadanii federal'nym gosudarstvennym grazhdanskim sluzhashchim MChS Rossii, zameshchayushchim dolzhnosti federal'noi gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhby» // Byulleten' normativnykh aktov federal'nykh organov ispolnitel'noi vlasti. 2006. ¹ 51. 18 dekabrya; Rossiiskaya gazeta. 2012. 1 iyunya.
11. Sm., naprimer: Prikaz Minfina Rossii ot 9 iyulya 2007 g. ¹ 61n (red. ot 04.12.2012) «Ob utverzhdenii Polozhenii o poryadke vyplaty ezhemesyachnoi nadbavki k dolzhnostnomu okladu za osobye usloviya gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhby gosudarstvennym grazhdanskim sluzhashchim, o poryadke premirovaniya, o poryadke vyplaty material'noi pomoshchi i edinovremennoi vyplaty pri predostavlenii ezhegodnogo oplachivaemogo otpuska gosudarstvennym grazhdanskim sluzhashchim i rabotnikam, zameshchayushchim dolzhnosti, ne yavlyayushchiesya dolzhnostyami federal'noi gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhby, Ministerstva finansov Rossiiskoi Federatsii» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 2007. 15 avgusta; 2013. 22 fevralya.
12. Sm., naprimer: p. 27 Distsiplinarnogo ustava tamozhennoi sluzhby Rossiiskoi Federatsii" ot 16 noyabrya 1998 g. ¹ 1396 (red. ot 30.09.2012), p. 25 Postanovleniya Pravitel'stva RF ot 22 sentyabrya 2000 g. ¹ 715 «Ob utverzhdenii Ustava o distsipline ekipazhei sudov obespecheniya Voenno-Morskogo Flota» i dr.
13. Lemin F. Motivatsiya personala v upravlencheskoi deyatel'nosti Kitaya // Sotsiologiya vlasti. 2009. ¹ 1. S. 229.
14. Zakon Azerbaidzhanskoi Respubliki ot 21 iyulya 2000 goda ¹ 926-IIQ «O gosudarstvennoi sluzhbe» (red. ot 05.03.2010) (st. 25) [Elektronnyi resurs] URL.: http://www.caa.gov.az/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=118:the-republic-of-azerbaijan-civil-service-law&Itemid =173&lang=ru (data obrashcheniya 11.04.2015)
15. Sm.: st. 50 FZ «O gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhbe»; Ukaz Prezidenta RF ot 25 iyulya 2006 g. ¹ 763 (red. ot 31.12.2014) «O denezhnom soderzhanii federal'nykh gosudarstvennykh grazhdanskikh sluzhashchikh» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2006. ¹ 31 (1 ch.). St. 3459; 2015. ¹ 11. St. 1585; Zakon Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 12 marta 2007 g. ¹ 1204-KZ (red. ot 01.11.2013) «O denezhnom soderzhanii gosudarstvennykh grazhdanskikh sluzhashchikh Krasnodarskogo kraya» // Informatsionnyi byulleten' ZS Krasnodarskogo kraya. 2007. ¹ 51; 2013. ¹ 12.
16. The public service in Germany. [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: http://www.verwaltung-innovativ.de /Anlage /original_ 548865/The-public-service-in-Germany.pdf, tsit. po Organizatsionnaya struktura i zakonodatel'naya baza gosudarstvennoi sluzhby v Germanii (data obrashcheniya 15.09.2013).
17. Zakon 1947 g. «O gosudarstvennykh publichnykh dolzhnostnykh litsakh» ¹ 120 // Ceponno (Malyi sbornik zakonov). Tokio: «Yukhikaku», 1995. S. 153–167.
18. Timofeev V. Nuzhen novyi vid distsiplinarnoi otvetstvennosti // Zakonnost'. 2006. ¹ 3.
19. Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2011. ¹ 1. St. 15; 2014. N 52 (ch. I). St. 7550.
20. Sergeev A.V. Aktual'nye voprosy otvetstvennosti gosudarstvennykh grazhdanskikh sluzhashchikh po administrativnomu pravu: dis. ... kand. yurid. nauk. M., 2006.
21. Ukaz Prezidenta RF ot 5 iyunya 2003 g. ¹ 613 (red. ot 01.07.2014) «O pravookhranitel'noi sluzhbe v organakh po kontrolyu za oborotom narkoticheskikh sredstv i psikhotropnykh veshchestv» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2003. ¹ 23. St. 2197; 2014. ¹ 27. St. 3754.
22. Sm., naprimer: st. 41.7 Federal'nogo zakona ot 17 yanvarya 1992 g. N 2202-1 (red. ot 22.12.2014) «O prokurature Rossiiskoi Federatsii» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1995. ¹ 47. St. 4472; .2014. ¹ 52 (ch. I). St. 7538; st. 29 Federal'nogo zakona ot 21 iyulya 1997 g. ¹ 114-FZ (red. ot 22.12.2014) «O sluzhbe v tamozhennykh organakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1997. ¹ 30. St. 3586; 2014. ¹ 52. (ch. I). St. 7542; Prikaz GTK RF ot 2 iyulya 1999 g. ¹ 402 «Ob utverzhdenii vremennoi instruktsii o poryadke primeneniya otdel'nykh polozhenii Distsiplinarnogo ustava v tamozhennykh organakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii»; st. 38 Polozheniya o sluzhbe v organakh vnutrennikh del Rossiiskoi Federatsii, utv. Ukazom Prezidenta RF ot 22 noyabrya 2012 g. ¹ 1575 (red. ot 01.07.2014) // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2012. ¹ 48. St. 6668 i dr.
23. St. 2472; Distsiplinarnyi ustav Vooruzhennykh Sil Rossiiskoi Federatsii, utv. Ukazom Prezidenta RF ot 10 noyabrya 2007 g. ¹ 1495 (red. ot 25.03.2015) // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2007. ¹ 47 (1 ch.). St. 5749. 4.Federal'nyi zakon ot 27 iyulya 2004 g. ¹ 79-FZ (red. ot 08.06.2015) «O gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhbe Rossiiskoi Federatsii» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2004. ¹ 31. St. 3215; 2015. ¹ 24. St. 3374.
24. Dobrobaba M.B. Ponyatie i sushchnostnye priznaki distsiplinarnogo vzyskaniya v sluzhebno-deliktnom prave // Administrativnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo. 2013. ¹ 4. S. 357–364.
25. Prikaz Minenergo RF ot 2 oktyabrya 2008 g. ¹102 (red. ot 18.04.2011) «Ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya o poryadke vyplaty ezhemesyachnoi nadbavki k dolzhnostnomu okladu za osobye usloviya gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhby, premirovaniya, vyplaty edinovremennogo pooshchreniya za bezuprechnuyu i effektivnuyu gosudarstvennuyu grazhdanskuyu sluzhbu, edinovremennoi vyplaty k ezhegodnomu oplachivaemomu otpusku, vyplaty material'noi pomoshchi federal'nym gosudarstvennym grazhdanskim sluzhashchim Ministerstva energetiki Rossiiskoi Federatsii» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 2008. 24 oktyabrya; 2011. 18 maya.
26. Dobrobaba M.B. Administrativnye pravootnosheniya s uchastiem gosudarstvennykh grazhdanskikh sluzhashchikh sub''ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii: monografiya. Krasnodar: Kubanskii gos. un-t, 2010. S. 121.
27. Sm., naprimer: Prikaz FTS Rossii ot 10 iyunya 2005 g. ¹ 533 (red. ot 12.04.2013) «O vyplate dolzhnostnym litsam tamozhennykh organov Rossiiskoi Federatsii ezhemesyachnogo denezhnogo pooshchreniya v zavisimosti ot slozhnosti, ob''ema i vazhnosti vypolnyaemykh zadach» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 2005. 26 iyulya; 2013. 28 maya.
28. Sm., naprimer, p. 11 st. 35 Federal'nogo zakona ot 28 dekabrya 2010 g. ¹ 403-FZ (red. ot 22.12.2014) «O Sledstvennom komitete Rossiiskoi Federatsii»; ch. 5 p. 1 st. 44 Federal'nogo zakona ot 17 yanvarya 1992 g. ¹ 2202-1 (red. ot 22.12.2014) «O prokurature Rossiiskoi Federatsii» i dr.
29. Grishkovets A.A. Problemy reformy gosudarstvennoi sluzhby v Rossiiskoi Federatsii // Gosudarstvo i pravo. 2001. ¹ 12. S. 52.
30. Federal'nyi zakon ot 27.05.1998 N 76-FZ (red. ot 20.04.2015) «O statuse voennosluzhashchikh» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1988. ¹ 22. St. 2331; 2015. ¹ 17 (ch.
31. Dobrobaba M.B. Sluzhebno-deliktnye pravootnosheniya: monografiya. M.: Yurlitinform, 2013.-296 s.