Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Philosophy and Culture
Reference:

Iferov R.G., Titlin L.I. Antinomic monodualism of S. L. Frank as a logical-philosophical system

Abstract: The most complete and explicit expression of the S. L. Frank’s epistemological views is the concept of “antinomic monodualism”. The subject of this research is the examination of the logical-philosophical aspect of this concept, while the object is the works of S. L. Frank: “The Subject of Knowledge. On the Foundations and Limits of Abstract Knowledge” and “Incomprehensible. Ontological Introduction into the Philosophy of Religion”. If viewed from the logical-philosophical perspective, Frank starts his concept with the “Subject of Knowledge” in a form of “law of continuity”, and finishes with the “Incomprehensible” in a form of “antinomic monodualism”. The author conducts the analysis of the classified position of Frank’s concept; for the first time the philosophical system of Frank is examined in the logical-philosophical aspect, and as a result, his logical-philosophical system is being explicated. In this regard the antinomic monodualism represents a underdeveloped form of neo-classical modal multivalent logical-philosophical system. Due to this fact, the formulation of the question on the comparative analysis of antinomic monodualism and other modal logical-philosophical systems, can be considered justified.


Keywords:

modal logic, multivalent logic, non-classical logic, logically-philosophical system, S. L. Frank, philosophical logic, history of Russian philosophy, Russian philosophy, antinomic monodualism, antinomism


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Moiseev V. I. Logika vseedinstva. – M., PER SE, 2002. 295 s.
2. Potapchuk V. I. Printsip tselostnosti v russkoy filosofii i ego razvitie v sotsial'no-antropologicheskoy kontseptsii S. L. Franka. Dis… kand. filos. n. Khabarovsk, 2007. 174 s.
3. Nazarova O. A. Ontologicheskoe obosnovanie intuitivizma v filosofii S. L. Franka. M., Ideya-Press, 2003. (Gorizonty russkoy mysli). 146 s.
4. Berdyaev N. A. [Rets. na kn.:] O knige S. L. Franka "Nepostizhimoe". // Put'. ¹60. May-sentyabr' 1939. S. 65-67.
5. Astapov S. N. Otritsatel'naya dialektika russkoy religioznoy filosofii pervoy poloviny KhKh v. R. n/D., Izd. SGU, 2009.
6. Bulgakov S. N. Kritika. Novyy opyt preodoleniya gnoseologizma. [Rets. na:] Frank S. L. Predmet znaniya. Ob osnovakh i predelakh otvlechennogo znaniya. P., 1915. S. VII + 504// Bogoslovskiy vestnik 1916. T. 1. ¹ 1. S. 136 – 154.
7. Astapov S. N. Antinomizm kak sposob teoreticheskoy reprezentatsii religioznogo soznaniya (na materiale russkoy religioznoy filosofii pervoy poloviny KhKh veka). Avtoref. Dis… d-ra filos. nauk. R. n/D., 2010. http://www. dissercat. com/content/antinomizm-kak-sposob-teoreticheskoi-reprezentatsii-religioznogo-soznaniya-na-materiale-russ. data obrashcheniya 21. 09. 14.
8. Motroshilova N. V. Mysliteli Rossii i filosofiya Zapada: V. Solov'ev, N. Berdyaev, S. Frank, L. Shestov. – M., Respublika, Kul'turnaya revolyutsiya, 2007. 478 s.
9. Evlampiev I. I. Metafizika cheloveka v russkoy i zapadnoevropeyskoy filosofii kontsa XIX-nachala XX veka: dis… d-ra filos. nauk. – SPb., 2000. http://www. dissercat. com/content/metafizika-cheloveka-v-russkoi-i-zapadnoevropeiskoi-filosofii-kontsa-xix-nachala-xx-veka. Data obrashcheniya 21. 09. 14.
10. Losskiy N. O. Istoriya russkoy filosofii. – M., Sovetskiy pisatel', 1991. 480 s.
11. Frank S. L. Nepostizhimoe. Ontologicheskoe vvedenie v filosofiyu religii. V: Chelovek i Bog. – Mn., BPTs (BEMP), Kharvest, 2009. – 528 s.
12. Antonov K. M. Filosofiya religii v russkoy metafizike XIKh – nachala XX veka. – M., Izd-vo PSTGU, 2008. 360 s.
13. Gaydenko P. P. Vladimir Solov'ev i filosofiya Serebryanogo veka. Izd-tvo Mosk. gos. un-ta im. M. V. Lomonosova, In-t mirovoy kul'tury – M., Progress-Traditsiya, 2001. (Panorama filosofskoy mysli). 468 s.
14. Ideynoe nasledie S.L.Franka v kontekste sovremennoy kul'tury. – M., BBI sv. ap. Andreya, 2009. (Religioznye mysliteli). Porus V. N. red. 267 s.
15. Zen'kovskiy V. V. prot. Istoriya russkoy filosofii. – M., Akademicheskiy Proekt, Raritet, 2001. 880 s.
16. Moiseev V. I. Filosofiya neovseedinstva: idei i perspektivy. http://vyacheslav-moiseev.narod.ru/Neo-All-Unity/NeoAllUnity.doc. Data obrashcheniya 07.02.15.
17. Akulich N. M. Monodualizm S. L. Franka. Avtoref. dis… kand. filos. nauk. – M., 2010.
18. Nekrasova E. N. Metafizika chelovecheskogo bytiya v russkoy religioznoy filosofii XX veka: dis.... d-ra filos. nauk: M., 1998. http://www. dissercat. com/content/metafizika-chelovecheskogo-bytiya-v-russkoi-religioznoi-filosofii-xx-veka. Data obrashcheniya 21. 09. 14.
19. Sbornik pamyati Semena Lyudvigovicha Franka. Zen'kovskiy V. V. red. Myunkhen, [B. i. ], 1954.
20. Frank S. L. Predmet znaniya. Ob osnovakh i predelakh otvlechennogo znaniya. V knige: Predmet znaniya. Dusha cheloveka. – Mn.: Kharvest, M.: AST, 2000. 992 s.
21. Filosofiya: Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar'. — M.: Gardariki. Pod redaktsiey A.A. Ivina. 2004. http://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/enc_philosophy/1302. data obrashcheniya 07.02.15
22. Kasavin I.T. red. Entsiklopediya epistemologii i filosofii nauki. – M.: «Kanon+», ROOI «Reabilitatsiya». 2009. 1248 s. Str. 1084-1086.
23. Novaya filosofskaya entsiklopediya: V 4 tt. – M.: Mysl'. Pod redaktsiey V. S. Stepina. T. 4.
24. Khintikka Ya. Logiko-epistemologicheskie issledovaniya. Sbornik izbrannykh statey. – M., Progress. 1980. 448 s.
25. Filosofskaya Entsiklopediya. V 5-kh t. — M.: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. Pod red. F. V. Konstantinova. 1960—1970. T. 5.
26. Slovar' po logike. — M.: Tumanit, izd. tsentr VLADOS. A. A. Ivin, A. L. Nikiforov. 1997. 384 s