Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Conflict Studies / nota bene
Reference:

The role of the North Caucasian Diaspora (Muhajirs) in the Ottoman Empire in bilateral relations between Russia and Turkey in 1917-1921 in the context of revolutions, external and internal conflicts


Israilov Adam Khamzatovich

Postgraduate student at the Department of Theory and History of International Relations of RUDN University

117198, Russia, Moscow, Moscow, Miklukh-Maklaya str., 6

adam-kadet@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0617.2024.1.69730

EDN:

YNKFLM

Received:

01-02-2024


Published:

07-03-2024


Abstract: The author examines the influence of the North Caucasian diaspora (Muhajirs) on the relations of the Ottoman Empire, and later Turkey with Russia in the context of the creation of the Union of Highlanders of the North Caucasus and Dagestan in the region of the same name during the conflicts – the Civil War in Russia and the War of Independence of Turkey. The end of the First World War was marked by the fall of the largest European empires, including the Russian and Ottoman empires. These cataclysms have led to an increase in conflict in the region. In addition, these processes contributed to the growth of national consciousness of the peoples who were part of these states. At the same time, the social upsurge took place not only in the country of origin, but also in the diaspora, which, using its social position in the receiving country, tried to influence foreign policy in order to realize its historical "myth". In turn, the diaspora simultaneously acted as an informal "instrument" in relations between Russia and Turkey. The research used general scientific methods such as analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction, the unity of historical and logical. A wide source and historiographical base was used. The study revealed that representatives of the diaspora had a double identity: on the one hand, they retained the "myth" of their historical homeland, on the other, they considered themselves loyal subjects of the Ottoman state. Based on their dual self-identification, their activities and the policy of the Turkish state in the Caucasus resulted, forming a kind of symbiosis, so the foreign policy interests of the state were intertwined with the desire of the muhajirs to return to their homeland. At the same time, the country of origin, although actively cooperating with the diaspora, also pursued its own interests. However, as the revolutions in Russia and Turkey faded and the state apparatus of the two countries strengthened, the diaspora factor began to decrease – national interests prevailed over the interests of individual ethnic groups.


Keywords:

The Mountain Republic, Turkey, Russia, Civil war, revolution, muhajirs, conflict, The North Caucasus, Chechnya, The Diaspora

This article is automatically translated.

 

 

The situation of the Muhajir diaspora in the Ottoman Empire at the beginning of the First World War (1914)

 

The Chechen diaspora in the Ottoman Empire began to actively form as a result of the phenomenon of muhajirism. After the end of the Caucasian War, about 5,000 Chechen families left Chechnya, and under the influence of the tsarist administration and Turkish emissaries went to the Ottoman Empire.

Chechen muhajirs settled mainly in the area of Diyarbakir in modern Turkey, Ras al-Ain in modern Syria and after 1901 in the city of Al-Zarqa in modern Jordan. Chechens faced significant difficulties, among which typhus and cholera epidemics can be distinguished [1]. Another significant problem was the Middle Eastern climate, which was unusual for people from the North Caucasus to farm. Muhajirs in the Middle East and Asia Minor most often received fertile, but uncultivated, "wild" lands, also in modern Syria and Jordan, the Ottoman authorities considered the highlanders as colonizers and gave them significant land plots exceeding the lands of local Arab peasants [2].

The highlanders were also actively involved in paramilitary service on the outskirts of the empire, in particular, to confront the Armenians, Druze and Bedouins on the territory of modern Turkey and the states of the Middle East [3]. In addition, the sultan's government saw the highlanders as a tool for carrying out its Caucasian policy. In Istanbul's view, the Muhajir mountaineers could become the backbone of national military formations on the hypothetical Russian-Turkish front and were sent to the Caucasus, where they were also supposed to become the backbone of national uprisings against the Russian government.

The active involvement of muhajirs by the Ottoman authorities in voluntary military service led to the fact that by 1908, when the Young Turks seized power in the country, the North Caucasians became an integral part of the Ottoman elite. For example, Shevket Pasha is a descendant of Chechen emigrants, who at various times held the posts of Minister of War, Minister of Foreign Affairs and Grand Vizier of the Ottoman Empire [4].

The "career growth" of the muhajirs led to the fact that the diaspora, in addition to the "myth" of a common homeland – the North Caucasus, which should be independent and where they would return, had another identity – the Ottoman one. Studying in Ottoman educational institutions, including the military, as well as the idea of the Ottoman Empire as the common home of Muslims, contributed to the strengthening of a new identity [5]. Thus, the common identity of the Muhajirs consisted in the idea of a common homeland, the struggle for its independence, as well as in the idea of the Ottoman Empire as a new, albeit in many ways temporary, but still a home with which the Chechen diaspora was linked by a common fate.

For example, Ashraf Senser Kushchubashi, one of the founders of the Ottoman special services, said that, being a Circassian, he could not help but dream of a free Dagestan (approx. author: Dagestan often meant the entire North-Eastern Caucasus, in turn, Eshraf Senser, being of Circassian origin from the Ubykh tribe, could mean the entire modern North Caucasus) but first of all he is a Muslim, a subject of the Ottoman Sultan, who speaks Turkish [5].

At the beginning of the 20th century, the last stage of mass emigration of Chechens from Chechnya to the Ottoman Empire occurred. So, in 1903, a group of Chechens arrived in modern Jordan and founded the city of Al-Zarqa. By 1909, another group of Chechens, together with Circassians, also founded and/or gave a new impetus to the development of the villages of Suwaylih, Sukhna and Ruseifa in Jordan [6].

After the Young Turks from the Unity and Progress party came to power in 1908, the "golden era" began for the muhajirs and their descendants. In addition to integrating North Caucasians into the Ottoman elite, North Caucasians were given the opportunity to create their own public organizations and mass media. The first was the Circassian Mutual Aid Society, which united representatives of the Circassian peoples, and also took under its care representatives of other peoples of the North Caucasus [7]. This organization aimed to support the representatives of the Caucasus until it was possible to repatriate to their homeland. With her, the first Circassian newspaper "?erkes Yardimla ma DerneZi" ("Circassian Aid Association") begins to be published in Turkish [8].

 

World War I and the North Caucasian Diaspora in the Ottoman Empire

 

In 1914, with the outbreak of the First World War, a public organization was established in Istanbul, which set itself political goals for the liberation of the Caucasus from Russian power – the Committee of the Peoples of the Caucasus (KNK), which united both representatives of the North Caucasus and Transcaucasia. The purpose of the organization was to achieve the independence of the Caucasus from Russia and the creation of a pan-Caucasian confederate state headed by one of the Ottoman princes. However, already in 1916, representatives of Transcaucasia left the KNC, and in its place the Committee of Political Emigrants of the North Caucasus (KPESK) was formed, which conducted active political and public activities in order to realize its interests [9]. In 1916, KPESK took part in the Congress of Oppressed Peoples in Lausanne, which was represented by the grandson of Imam Shamil, Said Shamil, whose speech was greeted with ovations by the Congress participants [10].

With the outbreak of the First World War, the KNK and then the KPESK launched active political activities to achieve their goals. Initially, the North Caucasians tried to use the Ottoman special services and generals to achieve their goals. A significant number of mobilized Caucasians and Muhajir officers were concentrated on the Caucasian Front of the First World War. It was supposed to create on their basis a "national army" from among the muhajirs under the patronage of the Ottoman Empire. Abazin Faud Pasha played a significant role in lobbying the interests of the North Caucasian diaspora. However, the failures on the Caucasian Front forced the Ottoman Empire to postpone these plans, in connection with which the descendants of the muhajirs turn to the German and Austro-Hungarian authorities for help with proposals to support the activities of the muhajirs to return to their native lands and declare the independence of the Caucasus and create a national army under their patronage, which also did not happen [11].

In addition, Professor of the School of Naval Postgraduate Students of the United States R. Gingeras notes that during the First World War, the Ottoman authorities recruited highlanders to serve in a Special organization – the key Ottoman special service, preferring to increase the autonomy of North Caucasian units [5], most likely the purpose of this policy was the formation of the national Caucasian army and the establishment of ties between the Ottomans and Muhajirs on the one hand, and the highlanders of the Caucasus on the other side.

 

The North Caucasus and the Diaspora in the context of the revolutionary events of 1917 in Russia

 

The February Revolution in Russia in 1917 led to an aggravation of the national question in the Russian Empire, many peoples who inhabited the country saw an opportunity to exercise their right to self-determination both within Russia and outside it. The North Caucasus was no exception. In May 1917, a Congress of the North Caucasian Peoples was held in Vladikavkaz, which proclaimed the creation of the Union of United Highlanders of the North Caucasus and Dagestan (hereinafter – the Union; the Mountain Republic). Chechen tsarist officer Abdul-Mezhid Chermoyev was elected Chairman of the Central Executive Committee of the Union. Initially, the Union was considered not as an independent state, but as one of the "states" in the form of a confederation being created by a new democratic and federal Russia [12]. Thus, in the Political Platform of the Union of May 7, 1917, it was emphasized that the Union aims to unite the peoples and tribes of the highlanders of the Caucasus and recognizes itself "... an inseparable part of the Great Russian state, the highlanders, both for the common good of their Homeland Russia, and for their own good and happiness..." (Political Platform and the program of the Union of United Mountaineers of the North Caucasus and Dagestan).

It is noteworthy that during the same period, the Diaspora Society for the Unity of the Caucasus, which operated mainly in the Ottoman Empire, on November 20, 1917, sent an appeal to the authorities of the Quadruple Alliance, as well as the still unrecognized and barely existing Poland, the central government of Russia, the Ukrainian Committee, the Stockholm and Berne Peace Conferences "... to recognize the Caucasian Confederation as part of the Russian Union Republic ..." [11].

The proclamation of the Union was also supported by the main public organization of muhajirs in the Ottoman Empire – the Circassian Mutual Aid Society, which began to provide educational and scientific literature to young public education. The North Caucasian diaspora immediately became more active, striving to establish contacts between the Union and the Ottoman authorities [3]. The creation of a new state entity was also of interest to the Ottoman special services, as a Special organization sent to the North Caucasus the editor-in-chief of the Circassian newspaper "Guase", published in Istanbul, as well as a number of officers of Circassian origin to establish contacts with local national forces, but soon many of them were forced to return [3].

In their view, the creation of the Caucasian Confederation would give them a chance to return to their native lands, free from oppression. At the same time, in this context, we must not forget that by this time the Muhajirs, or rather their descendants, had two homelands: the Caucasus and the Ottoman Empire.

The Ottoman Empire considered the Union of the Highlanders of the North Caucasus primarily as a geopolitical tool to achieve its main goal – the creation of a buffer state between Russia and the Ottoman Empire in the Caucasus [5]. At the same time, as noted above, the Muhajirs used the Ottoman opportunities to achieve their goal – the creation of an independent North Caucasian state. Thus, representatives of the diaspora, on the one hand, fulfilled their duty to the Ottoman Empire as its subjects, on the other hand, realized their personal aspirations, thereby forming a symbiosis.

In early March 1918, a prominent representative of the Diaspora, the Chief of Staff of the Ottoman Navy, Huseyin Rauf Bey, met with a delegation of the Union (the delegation consisted of G. Bammatov, A.M. Chermoeva and M.-K. Dibirova) at the Trabzon Peace Conference. With his support, a meeting of the delegation was organized with Sultan Mehmed V, Grand Vizier of the Ottoman Empire Talaat Pasha, Minister of Defense Enver Pasha. During the meeting, the parties agreed on the creation of an independent North Caucasian state, its unification with Transcaucasia. The Caucasian union itself was to come under the Turkish protectorate, which was in line with Ottoman interests [11].

In April of the same year, representatives of the Diaspora, members of the highest circles of the Ottoman Empire, organized the Society of the North Caucasus in order to coordinate their activities. The chairman of the society was the director of the Ottoman National Telegraph Agency, Colonel Huseyin Tosun Bey, it also included Faud Pasha, Huseyni Rauf Bey, the future foreign minister in the government of Ataturk Bekir Sami Bey Kundukh (son of the Russian general of Ossetian origin Musa Kundukhov, one of the organizers of muhajirism), as well as a number of other prominent figures of the Ottoman Empire empires of Caucasian origin. The society of the North Caucasus provided mediation services between the governments of the Mountainous Republic and the Ottoman Empire and, according to G.V. Chochiev, contributed to the radicalization of the position of both actors on the issue of the independence of the region [9].

However, the aggravation of the situation in Russia and the October Revolution led to an increase in the desire for full independence. On May 11, 1918, A.-M. Chermoyev, together with other CEC members, declared the independence of the North Caucasus from Soviet Russia [12]. The Second Congress of the Union of the Mountain Peoples of the North Caucasus and Dagestan adopted a constitution that no longer mentioned ties with Russia.

On the eve of the declaration of independence, the North Caucasian diaspora began to actively establish contacts between the Union and the Young Turks in the Ottoman Empire. By the time of the declaration of independence in the Caucasus, both in the North and in the South, the Caucasian Islamic Army, led by General of Circassian origin Ferik Yusuf-Izzet Pasha, consisting of Ottoman soldiers and officers of Caucasian origin, was already operating [3]. At the same time, Yusuf Izzet Pasha began to act even before the official declaration of independence, i.e. before May 11, 1918. Already on April 20, 1918, they sent a congratulatory telegram in connection with the capture of Petrovsk (present-day Makhachkala), which, however, mentions the fall of the old regime, which oppressed all citizens of Russia, not only the highlanders.

Also on April 28, 1918, before the declaration of independence by A.M. Chermoyev, the commander-in-chief of the Caucasian Front of the Turkish army, Vehib Mahmud Pasha, a protege of Shevket Pasha, sent a telegram to the Chairman of the Transcaucasian government on the recognition of the independence of Transcaucasia by the Ottoman Empire and on the declaration of independence of the North Caucasus. It also mentions that at the upcoming Batumi Conference, the unification of the North Caucasian and Transcaucasian projects into a single Caucasian state should take place.

In the early days of its existence, the Mountain Republic continues the policy initiated by the North Caucasian diaspora in the Ottoman Empire to establish relations with Germany and Austria-Hungary. During the Conference in Batumi, the Mountain Republic declared its independence (a note on the declaration of independence was sent to the authorities of the RSFSR on May 13). Partly through the mediation of the Society of the North Caucasus, the Mountainous Republic was immediately recognized by the Ottoman authorities, and on June 8, the parties concluded an Agreement on Friendship and Cooperation [11].

It is noteworthy that at a preliminary meeting of representatives of delegations who arrived at the Batumi conference on the issue of admission of the delegation of the Mountainous Republic to the conference on May 9, 1918, the Foreign Minister of the Mountainous Republic, G. Bammat, stated that the North Caucasus was not going to declare independence from Russia in the near future, but intended to join the Transcaucasian state.

On July 31, 1918, the diplomatic representative of the Mountain Republic, G. Bammat, sent a letter to A.-M. Chermoyev about the policy of Turkey and Germany towards the Caucasus. It follows from the letter that G. Bammat managed to establish strong relations with the North Caucasian diaspora in Turkey. In the letter he writes the following: "... In order to revive our amateur activities, I managed to move the issue of appointing Yusuf Izet Pasha to us and organizing volunteer detachments of fugitive Circassian soldiers. The Circassian Committee also worked in this direction..." (Manuscript Fund of the Institute of IAE of the DNC RAS).

Further, most importantly, he writes about his desire to create an "awareness delegation" with the assistance of the Circassian Committee: "... I am trying to create, with the assistance of the Circassian Club, a special mountain awareness delegation to travel to the countries of the Quadruple Alliance and neutral countries to promote our cause..." (Manuscript Fund of the Institute of IAE DNC RAS).

He also notes the assistance provided by Fuad Selim Bey, the envoy of the Ottoman Empire to Switzerland, who is of Egyptian Circassian descent.

 

The role of the North Caucasian Diaspora in the events of the Russian Civil War in the North Caucasus after the end of the First World War

 

After the Mudros Truce on October 30, 1918, the highlanders began to look for allies in the face of the Entente, as evidenced by the message of G. Bammat dated November 24, 1918, in which he writes that he is looking for ways to establish ties with leading capitalist countries, among which France has taken a position of support for "great and indivisible Russia", the United States, Japan sympathize, but no more, Britain, after some hesitation, refused Mr. Bammat the right to visit the country.

At the same time, immediately after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire and the occupation of Constantinople by the Entente, the North Caucasian diaspora resumed political activity with renewed vigor. Thus, a delegation headed by the aforementioned Faoud Pasha went to the British Embassy in Constantinople almost immediately after its occupation, where they held talks with the British military attache. During the negotiations, the delegation handed over a petition addressed to His Majesty's Government, which noted the history of the formation of the diaspora, as well as an appeal for help: to recognize the independence of the Mountainous Republic under the protectorate of Great Britain and facilitate the repatriation of muhajirs and their descendants to their homeland [14].

However, the central office of the Foreign Office gave a negative assessment to these requests, considering that the Mountainous Republic is not able, given the multiethnic nature of the region, to create a stable independent state. Also, another expert examination, conducted by A. Toynbee, noted the impossibility of the return of the Adygs to the Western Caucasus, believing that this would lead to a deterioration of relations with the "whites", however, he proposed using the Middle Eastern Caucasians as an ally in future mandated territories [14].

The Mountainous Republic was looking for various opportunities to get closer to the descendants of the Muhajirs in Turkey, considering them on the one hand as a lobbying tool, on the other as brothers who need to be helped. In this context, the letter from the representative of the Mountain Republic H. is noteworthy. Hadzrat in Constantinople to participate in the peace conference to the Chairman of the Government of the Republic P. Kotsev, written in February 1919. The letter is dedicated to the situation regarding the organization of the Paris Peace Conference and its prospects for the Mountain Republic. The paragraph in which X is remarkable is also in it. Hadzrat reports on a meeting with Turkish Circassians in Istanbul. First of all, they were interested in the northern border of the Highlanders' country, which in their view should reach Yeysk. The second issue is the desire of 1.5 million descendants of Muhajirs to return to their homeland. They asked for all possible assistance in this matter. In connection with this issue, they introduced X. Hadzrat with the text of the prepared memorandum, which had to be provided at the Paris Peace Conference, to participate in which they elected a special delegation headed by the already mentioned Sami Bekir Bey, who at the same conference in 1921 would combine the post of Turkish Minister of Foreign Affairs. Interestingly, this letter says that the muhajirs did not treat Russia negatively and asked the government of the Mountainous Republic not to aggravate relations with it.

It is also worth noting here that the broad masses of muhajirs, sharing the goals of independence and return to their homeland, did not want to quarrel with Russia, and as M.V. Frunze noted during his trip to Turkey, passing by the villages of muhajirs: "... all the old people who remember Russia, remember it with love..." [7].

The new Turkey, headed by Ataturk, also maintained its interest in the North Caucasus. Thus, R. Gingeras writes that a few months after the Armistice of Mudros (October 30, 1918), contacts between the Mountain Republic and North Caucasian activists in Istanbul were resumed. In 1919, A.M. Chermoyev and G. Bammat arrived in Istanbul on a visit, where they met with the muhajirs. The results of the meeting were reported to M. Kemal, who, following the meeting, sent a secret mission to the Caucasus consisting of three representatives of the Circassian diaspora: Ismail Hakki (one of the officers of the Caucasian Islamic Army), Aziz Meker, a Turkish teacher of Circassian origin (in 1932 he would hold the post of Deputy Minister of Agriculture of Turkey) and Mustafa Butba (in In 1919, a member of the commission for the development of national alphabets, created the Abkhaz-Circassian alphabet on a Latin basis).

In August-September 1919, the Conference of Political Figures of the North Caucasus in Tiflis was attended by Bekir-semey Kundukh. During the Conference, he stated the following: "We, the emigrants, formed a committee and wanted to move to the Caucasus. However, we failed to do this from the very beginning; now we, the emigrants, are talking about resettlement again. In this regard, the Turkish government also met us halfway. In a difficult moment for the mountaineers, we wanted to help them, but this was not possible due to the fact that the people who gathered in Batumi at the time did not agree ...", he also promised assistance to the Circassian muhajirs in the struggle for the independence of the Caucasus.

In February 1920, B.P. Sheboldaev wrote to the commander of rebel detachments in the North Caucasus, N.F. Gikalo, that Britain was preparing a provocation in order to quarrel between the RSFSR and Turkey. Britain planned, recognizing the independence of Turkey, as well as using the Caucasian Islamic army of Nuri Pasha, consisting of muhajirs, to pit the two revolutionary countries and prevent the Bolsheviks from gaining a foothold in the Caucasus. Which, in principle, was in the interests of the British, who since the revolution had been afraid of the strengthening of Germany and its allies in the Caucasus, but also did not seek to recognize the Mountain Republic until the issue with the Bolsheviks was resolved [13].

It should also be noted here that the government of Attat?rk did not refuse to support the highlanders of the North Caucasus, at least in words. Thus, in April 1919, Attat?rk declared that the Circassians were striving to achieve their goals and were achieving them in cordial cooperation with Turkey. He added that the aspirations of the Highlanders and Turks to achieve national independence are similar in spirit [5].

However, as Soviet Russia and Turkey drew closer, Attat?rk's support for the Mountaineers' aspirations for independence gradually declined. Thus, one of the demands from the RSFSR was the recognition of the establishment of Soviet republics in the North Caucasus and Central Asia. At the same time, some of the muhajirs, apparently, supported the project of Soviet nation-building. Thus, Aziz Meker stated that the Bolsheviks returned to the local population the lands stolen by the Cossacks at one time [5].

By the beginning of 1920, most of the North Caucasus had been captured by the Bolsheviks, the leaders of the Mountain Republic met this news in Paris at a peace conference, which is why they remained in exile [12].

In May 1920, the National Congress of the Highlanders of the North Caucasus took place in the Chechen village of Vedeno, where the Bolshevik Highlanders quarreled with the mountaineers who supported full independence and left the congress. The Congress elected as its leader the son of Imam Shamil – Muhammad-Kamil Pasha, who lived in the Ottoman Empire [15], according to some sources in the city of Medina in the territory of modern Saudi Arabia [16]. However, being seriously ill, he sent his son, Said Shamil, as his representative, who in the future will also have close ties with Caucasian White emigration. Researcher Sultan Murad, without naming the year, notes that a conference of leaders of the North Caucasian muhajirs was also held in Istanbul, who recommended Muhammad Kamil Pasha to go to the Caucasus, taking with him two assistants from Chechens and Circassians. Soon, the participants of the conference were arrested by the British occupation authorities [16].

Earlier, Said Shamil visited Jordan, where he met with the leader of the Chechens in the village of Sukhna, Sultan Murad, as well as with a number of other representatives of the muhajirs in Jordan. Together, by the end of the summer, they reached the North Caucasus. However, having been defeated, they were forced to return [16]. This episode shows that Chechens and Circassians who lived in the Arab territories of the former Ottoman Empire, despite the turbulence in their places of permanent residence, did not forget about the land of their ancestors and sought to maintain contact with it.

 

The factor of the North Caucasus and the Diaspora in the bilateral relations of the RSFSR and the Turkish Republic against the background of the end of the Civil War in Russia in 1920-1921

 

In the summer of 1920, the Turks founded the first permanent diplomatic mission in the RSFSR, headed by Ali Fuat Dzhebesoy, who had mixed Circassian-German origin, and the notorious Muhajir Kundukh Bekir-seven also became the head of the Turkish Foreign Ministry [5]. In the embassy itself, many employees were of North Caucasian origin, among whom were the already mentioned Aziz Meker, Zeki Bey and others. This led to the fact that some of the embassy staff complained that the Turkish Embassy in Moscow had turned into a "Circassian clique" maintaining active communication with the North Caucasus [9].

In October 1920, Bekir-seven Kundukh arrived for official negotiations in the RSFSR. During the negotiations, his partner, the head of the NKID of the RSFSR, G.V. Chicherin, noted the unhealthy interest of the Bekir-seven in the problems of the North Caucasus. The Turkish Foreign Minister also tried to hold personal talks with the government of the RSFSR. He offered to grant independence to Ossetia in exchange for Turkey ceding the territory around Lake Van to Armenia. Bekir-sami's behavior caused considerable discontent in Ankara. This fact, as well as a number of other reasons, led to his resignation in March 1921 [5].

After initialing the Soviet-Turkish treaty of friendship and mutual assistance, Bekir-seven went on a "tour" of the North Caucasus, where he met with anti-Bolshevik groups in Chechnya, Ingushetia and Ossetia, which irritated the Soviet authorities. At the same time, he continued to play a double game, during the same period he wrote to G.V. Chicherin that it would be nice to create a Soviet republic in the North Caucasus, which would become part of the greater Soviet federation. And before returning to Ankara in January 1921, in Tiflis, he met with the Foreign Minister of the Mountainous Republic, G. Bammat [14].

During this period, the Muhajirs tried to establish parallel contacts with the Bolsheviks in order to achieve their goals, in turn, the Turkish authorities wanted to use the North Caucasus as a bargaining chip that could be given for a certain price, primarily by increasing the assistance from the Bolsheviks to the Kemalists [15].

The political activity of representatives of the Muhajir diaspora in relation to the Mountainous Republic has met with some criticism from the public. Thus, a comment was published in one of the Turkish newspapers, in which it was noted that Caucasians, of course, should worry and have the right to think about the problems of their homeland, but should not forget about their duty to Turkey [5].

On January 20, 1921, after the end of the active phase of the Civil War in Russia, in particular in the Caucasus, the Mountain Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic was formed as part of the RSFSR, which became the first officially recognized mountain state entity. The Gorskaya ASSR was an association of national districts. Thus, the project developed in the Political Platform of the Union of United Highlanders of the North Caucasus and Dagestan dated May 7, 1917, received actual implementation. This project satisfied the interests of Russia, the highlanders themselves, Turkey, as well as a significant part of the Muhajirs living in Turkey.

 

Conclusion

 

At the beginning of the XX century, the Muhajir diaspora had a significant influence on the life of Ottoman society. At the same time, for the North Caucasians, as representatives of the diaspora, the "myth" of the homeland played an important role, to which they will definitely return and be released. In addition, representatives of the diaspora also had a strong "Ottoman" identity built around Islam.

Since the beginning of the First World War, the diaspora has tried to influence the situation in the Caucasus in the hope of undermining the rear of the Russian Empire. Nevertheless, until 1917, the real impact of the diaspora on the situation in the Caucasus was extremely low.

The situation changed after the February Revolution in Russia in 1917 and the formation of the Mountain Republic, which united the highlanders of the North Caucasus. This caused an immediate response from the diaspora, which began to provide various possible assistance to the new state formation within revolutionary Russia, moreover, diaspora organizations called for "... recognition of the Caucasian Confederation as part of the Russian Union Republic ...". In addition, the situation in the Caucasus was immediately taken advantage of by the Ottoman special services, which, through officers of Circassian origin, tried to establish contacts with the highlanders.

However, the aggravation of the revolutionary situation in Russia and the beginning of an immediate armed conflict led to the proclamation of full independence of the Mountain Republic, which was immediately supported by the countries of the Quadruple Alliance, not without the support of the North Caucasian diaspora.

The defeat of the countries of the Quadruple Alliance, in particular the Ottoman Empire, in the First World War became the ground for attempts by the Mountain Republic and the Muhajirs to start looking for contacts and support in the Entente countries, which, in turn, were not interested in real support for the Highlanders, supporting the "whites" in Russia against the "reds".

Against the background of the conflicts between Russia and Turkey, directly or indirectly with the war, the two countries began the process of political rapprochement. The "Caucasian" issue also played an important role in bilateral relations. The Bolsheviks sought to preserve the North Caucasus as part of Russia, and for Turkey, this issue became a subject of bargaining in bilateral relations. Moreover, Circassians were in charge of relations with Russia in the Turkish diplomatic department. At the same time, as the political situation in the Turkish Republic stabilized, the Circassians began to fade into the background, which was connected both with the internal policy of the Turkish state and with the role of the diaspora itself, which, in implementing its foreign policy towards the RSFSR, began to promote its personal interests, as evidenced, for example, by the negotiations of Bekir Sami- Bey Kundukh with G.V. Chicherin on granting independence to Ossetia in exchange for the territory around Lake Van.

References
1. Asan, H. (2021) Kırım-Kafkasya Muhacirlerinin Karşılaştığı Sorunlar: Diyarbakır ve Çevresi Şneği [Problems Faced by Crimean-Caucasian Muhajirs: The Case of Diyarbakır and Surroundings]. Insan ve Toplum Bilimleri Araştırmaları Dergisi, 2, 1941-1954.
2. Shavlaeva, T.M. (2019). Economic activity of Chechen muhajirs in the first years of deportation. American Scientific Journal, 28, 9-12.
3. Chochiev, G. (2007). On the History of the North Caucasian Diaspora in Turkey. Iran & the Caucasus, 2(11), 213-226.
4. Garsaev, L.M., Garasaev, H.-A.M., Magomedova, R.M., & Huseynova, I. S. (2021). Famous state and military figures of Turkey of Chechen origin. Education and Law, 8, 420-425.
5. Gingeras, R. (2011). The Sons of Two Fatherlands: Turkey and the North Caucasian Diaspora 1914-1923. European Journal of Turkish Studies Social Sciences on Contemporary Turkey Complete List. Retrieved from http://journals.openedition.org/ejts/4424
6. Badaev, S.-E.S. (2008). The Chechen Diaspora in the Middle and Near East: history and modernity: a monograph. Nalchik: Republican Polygraph Combine named after the Revolution of 1905.
7. Matveev, V.A. (2011). "The Circassian question": modern interpretations and realities of the epoch. Research on applied and urgent ethnology, Moscow, IEA RAS.
8. Celikpala, M. (2006). From Immigrants to Diaspora: Influence of the North Caucasian Diaspora in Turkey. Middle Eastern Studies, 3(42), 423-446.
9. Chochiev, G.V. (2014). Turkey, the Caucasus and the North Caucasian Diaspora during and after the First World War. The Caucasus during the First World War: heroics and everyday life: a collection of articles. Vladikavkaz: CPI SOIGSI VNC RAS and RSO-A, 21-35.
10. Yershov, V.F. (2012) North Caucasian abroad of the 1920s-1930s in Turkey, Western Europe and the USA: evolution and socio-cultural specificity. Archives and Society: scientific and educational journal, 22, 121-133.
11. Chochiev, G.V. (2014). Kavkazooriented activity of the Circassian political elite in Turkey in 1918-1921. Diploma, 4(42), 205-208.
12. Kambiev, A.M. (2022). Abdul-Majid Chermoyev - the first head of the Mountain Republic during the Civil War in the North Caucasus. Trends in the development of science and education, 81-1, 21-23.
13. Gülseven, A. A. (2021) Failed Independence Movement in the Context of the Great Powers Competition: The North Caucasian Struggle for Independence (1917-1920). Nevşehir Hacı Bektaş Veli Üiversitesi SBE Dergisi, 11(1), 245-259.
14. Chochiev, G.V. (2014). British document on the Caucasian-oriented activities of the Circassian political elite in Turkey after the First World War. Journal for Scientists, 11(95), 106-109.
15. Tsvetkova, T. (2021). The North Caucasian Diaspora Factor in the Soviet-Turkish Relations (1919-1921). Journal of Caucasian Studies, 12(6), 259-294.
16. Sultan, M. (1991) The Jihad of Said Shamil and Sultan Murad for the liberation of the Caucasus. Central Asian Survey, 10(1-2), 181-187.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

When the process of expansion of the Moscow state to the east began in the second half of the XVI century, the emerging Russian state gradually transformed into a multiethnic state in which ethnic groups differing in language, culture, economic structure and temperament lived together in the spaces of 1/6 of the part. Russian President Vladimir Putin rightly notes that "Russia was born as a single centralized state, as a multinational and as a multi-confessional state, in fact, from a young age, everything was absorbed with mother's milk." At the same time, for a number of reasons, the diasporas of various Russian peoples are widely represented abroad, which makes it important to study the role of diasporas in neighboring countries. These circumstances determine the relevance of the article submitted for review, the subject of which is the role of the North Caucasian diaspora in the Ottoman Empire (muhajirs) in bilateral relations between Russia and Turkey in 1917-1921. The author aims to examine the situation of the Muhajir diaspora in the Ottoman Empire at the beginning of the First World War, to trace the influence of the First World War and the North Caucasian diaspora in the Ottoman Empire, to determine the role of the North Caucasian diaspora in the events of the Russian Civil War in the North Caucasus after the end of the First World War. The work is based on the principles of analysis and synthesis, reliability, objectivity, the methodological basis of the research is a systematic approach, which is based on the consideration of the object as an integral complex of interrelated elements. The author also uses a comparative method. The scientific novelty of the article lies in the very formulation of the topic: the author seeks to characterize the influence of the North Caucasian diaspora on the life of the Ottoman Empire, and then Turkey during the crucial period of 1914-1921. Scientific novelty is also determined by the involvement of documents from the Manuscript Fund of the Institute of IAE of the DNC RAS. Considering the bibliographic list of the article, its scale and versatility should be noted as a positive point: in total, the list of references includes 16 different sources and studies. The undoubted advantage of the reviewed article is the attraction of foreign literature, including in English and Turkish. Among the works attracted by the author, we will point to the works of S.S. Badaev, G.V. Chochiev, V.F. Ershov, which focus on various aspects of the study of the North Caucasian diaspora in the Middle East. Note that the bibliography is important both from a scientific and educational point of view: after reading the text, readers can turn to other materials on its topic. In general, in our opinion, the integrated use of various sources and research contributed to the solution of the tasks facing the author. The style of writing the article can be attributed to a scientific one, at the same time understandable not only to specialists, but also to a wide readership, to everyone who is interested in both the North Caucasus in general and the North Caucasian diaspora in particular. The appeal to the opponents is presented at the level of the collected information received by the author during the work on the topic of the article. The structure of the work is characterized by a certain logic and consistency, it can be distinguished by an introduction, the main part, and conclusion. At the beginning, the author defines the relevance of the topic, shows that the North Caucasian diaspora in the Ottoman Empire believed in the "myth" of the homeland, to which they will definitely return and liberate." Although during the First World War the diaspora tried to influence the situation in the Caucasus in the hope of undermining the rear of the Russian Empire, in reality its influence in the region was low. The author draws attention to the fact that the creation of the Mountain ASSR as part of the RSFSR satisfied the interests of "Russia, the highlanders themselves, Turkey, as well as a significant part of the muhajirs living in Turkey." It is noteworthy that the Turks jealously looked at the actions of the North Caucasian diaspora, believing that it should not forget its duty to Turkey. The main conclusion of the article is that the "Caucasian question" played an important role in the relations between Russia and the Ottoman Empire, as well as Russia and Turkey, while they were also influenced by the North Caucasian diaspora. The article submitted for review is devoted to an urgent topic, will arouse readers' interest, and its materials can be used both in lecture courses on the history of Russia and in various special courses. At the same time, there are comments on the article: 1) The title of the article should be adjusted to make it more readable. 2) It is necessary to proofread the text, eliminating some typos ("Moreover, Circassians were in charge of relations with Russia in the Turkish diplomatic department"). 3) The author writes in the text "The Great Socialist October Revolution", "The First World War", which needs to be corrected. After correcting these comments, the article can be recommended for publication in the journal "Conflictology / nota bene".

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Review of the article "The role of the North Caucasian Diaspora in bilateral relations between Russia and Turkey in 1917-1921." The subject of the study is the role of the North Caucasian Diaspora in bilateral relations between Russia and Turkey in 1917-1921. Research methodology. Unfortunately, the author(s) did not disclose their own research methodology, but from the text of the article it can be understood that the author, in addition to traditional scientific research methods, used special historical methods: historical-genetic, historical-problematic and historical-chronological. In addition, the work uses a systematic approach. The relevance of the topic is due to the increased role of the North Caucasian diaspora in Turkey at the beginning of the 20th century, their active participation in the Young Turks movement, the involvement of foreign Caucasian organizations in political events in southern Russia after the February bourgeois Revolution and during the civil war, as well as their participation in bilateral relations between Turkey and Russia in 1917-1921. The relevance is also due to the fact that in the 1990s, public organizations of the Caucasian diasporas in Turkey and other foreign countries increasingly began to participate in political events in the republics of the North Caucasus, the formation of international public organizations of the North Caucasian peoples and their desire to be actors in international relations and the formation of irredentist sentiments in the South of Russia during certain periods. Scientific novelty is determined by the formulation of the problem and objectives of the study. Style, structure, content. The style of the article is scientific with descriptive elements. The structure of the work consists of the following sections: The situation of the Muhajir diaspora in the Ottoman Empire at the beginning of the First World War (1914); The First World War and the North Caucasian Diaspora in the Ottoman Empire; the North Caucasus and the Diaspora in the context of the revolutionary events of 1917 in Russia; The role of the North Caucasian diaspora in the events of the Russian Civil War in the North Caucasus after the end of the First World War; The factor of the North Caucasus and the Diaspora in the bilateral relations of the RSFSR and the Turkish Republic against the background of the end of the Civil War in Russia in 1920-1921; Conclusion. In the section "The situation of the Muhajir diaspora in the Ottoman Empire at the beginning of the First World War", the author writes about how the Chechen diaspora was formed in the Ottoman Empire and the stages of its formation. The question arises why the author identifies the Chechen diaspora and not the North Caucasian diaspora as a whole in the first section, there is no answer to this question in the article. The following is a narrative about the situation of the North Caucasian diaspora in the Ottoman Empire, its integration into the Ottoman elite and the formation of public organizations of North Caucasians. The author notes that the North Caucasian diaspora in the Ottoman Empire was dual in its identity, on the one hand they retained the Caucasian identity and the idea of a common homeland and the goal of achieving its independence, as well as the Ottoman identity and the idea of the Ottoman Empire as a new, albeit temporary home. In the first section, its content, due to the fact that the author writes about the formation of the Chechen diaspora, does not quite correspond to its content. In the second section "World War I and the North Caucasian Diaspora in the Ottoman Empire", the North Caucasian Diaspora creates a public organization Committee of the Peoples of the Caucasus (KNK), (it includes representatives of the North Caucasus and Transcaucasia), in 2016, after the withdrawal of representatives of Transcaucasia, the organization receives a new name Committee of Political Emigrants of the North Caucasus (KPESK). Since the creation of the organization, its goal has been to achieve the independence of the Caucasus from Russia and the creation of a pan-Caucasian confederate state. The section "The North Caucasus and the Diaspora in the context of the revolutionary events of 1917 in Russia" shows how the events in Russia were perceived in the diaspora, and also reveals what tasks the public organizations of the North Caucasians set themselves and how they were perceived by the Ottoman Empire, each of them had its own goals. The North Caucasians used the Ottoman opportunities to create their goal - the creation of an independent North Caucasian state, and the Ottoman Empire to achieve its goal – the creation of a buffer state between Russia and the Ottoman Empire in the Caucasus. The next section examines the role of the North Caucasian diaspora in the events of the Civil War after the end of the First World War. The section contains a lot of interesting materials about the period under study. The section "The factor of the North Caucasus and the Diaspora in bilateral relations between the RSFSR and the Turkish Republic against the background of the end of the Civil War in Russia in 1920-1921" shows the change in relations between Russia and Turkey and the signing of a bilateral agreement, and the creation of the Gorskaya Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic within the RSFSR to a certain extent satisfied all parties, including descendants Muhajirov in Turkey, because "the GASSR was an association of national districts" and corresponded to the project developed in the Political Platform of the Union of United Highlanders of the North Caucasus and Dagestan dated May 7, 1917." In conclusion, the author draws reasonable conclusions. The bibliography of the work consists of 16 different sources on the research topic (these are the works of Russian and foreign researchers) and the bibliography made it possible to achieve the purpose of the study and its objectives. The bibliography is designed according to the requirements of the journal Appeal to opponents The appeal to opponents is carried out at a good level, and it is manifested in the work done by the author, conclusions and in the bibliography. Conclusions, the interest of the readership. The work will be interesting for specialists and a wide range of readers interested in the North Caucasian diaspora (descendants of muhajirs in Turkey).