Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Law and Politics
Reference:

Shchedrina Yu.V. State policy in the area of ensuring independence of judges in Russia

Abstract: The subject of this research is the state policy on correction of legislation in the area of judicial independence of the state (crown and peace) courts during 1905-1917. Analysis is conducted on the normative legal acts that regulate the organizational legal (irremovability of judges and special order of prosecution, incompatibility of posts, independence of court from the branches of administrative power) and social law guarantees of independence (high salaries) of judges of state courts in the aforementioned period, as well as the evolution of views of the legislator in their development and enactment. The author concludes that the Revolution events of 1905 I the subsequent modernization of the political system of the Russian Empire required yet another correction in the mechanism of guarantees of independence of judges. Analysis of the legislation, normative acts and legal practice allows the author to argue the established thesis on the attempt of the government to decisively end the independence of judges. It is substantiated that the legislation of this period was characterized by the conscious refusal of the government to limit the most important guarantees, clarification of some of them (incompatibility of posts due to realization of the norms of the October 17, 1905 Manifesto on formation of political parties) and certain expansion of the ties with the judicial reform of 1912.


Keywords:

Highest disciplinary presence, Ministry of Justice, State Duma, I. Scheglovitov, P. Stolypin, Incompatibility of posts, Irremovability of judged, Independence of judges, Judicial Reform, Court charter


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Vremennye pravila ob ustroistve mirovykh sudebnykh ustanovlenii v guberniyakh: Vilenskoi, Kovenskoi, Grodnenskoi, Kievskoi, Volynskoi, Podol'skoi, Minskoi, Vitebskoi i Mogilevskoi, vpred' do vvedeniya zemskikh uchrezhdenii: Vysochaishe utverzhdennye ot 23 iyunya 1871 g. // PSZ RI. T. XLVI. ¹ 49750.
2. Vysochaishe utverzhdennye vremennye pravila ob ustroistve mirovykh sudebnykh ustanovlenii v guberniyakh Orenburgskoi i Astrakhanskoi vpred' do vvedeniya v sikh guberniyakh zemskikh uchrezhdenii ot 2 maya 1878 g. // PSZ RI. Sobr. II. T. LIII. ¹ 58457.
3. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii. F. 1838. Op. 1. D. 3136.
4. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Kurskoi oblasti. F. 32. Op. 1. D. 7865.
5. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Kurskoi oblasti. F. 795. Op. 1. D. 35.
6. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Kurskoi oblasti. F. 795. Op. 1. D. 212.
7. Gosudarstvennaya Duma. 1906-1917. Stenograficheskie otchety. T. III. M.: Pravovaya kul'tura, 1995. 344 s.
8. Lazarenko A. N. Ocherk osnovnykh nachal nauki sudoustroistva Rossii i glavneishikh zapadnoevropeiskikh gosudarstv za pyat'desyat let. Pg.: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1914. 91 s.
9. O vvedenii sudebnykh ustavov 20 noyabrya 1864 g. v deistvie v Stavropol'skoi gubernii: Imennyi, dannyi [Senatu] ukaz ot 9 dekabrya 1867 g. // PSZ RI. Sobr. II. T. XLII. ¹ 45261.
10. O preobrazovanii mestnogo suda: Vysochaishe utverzhdennyi odobrennyi Gosudarstvennym sovetom i Gosudarstvennoi dumoi zakon ot 15 iyunya 1912 g. // PSZ RI. Sobr. III. T. XXXII. Ch. 1. ¹ 37328.
11. O rasprostranenii deistviya Vysochaishe utverzhdennogo 19 avgusta 1879 goda Polozheniya Komiteta ministrov, o zameshchenii dolzhnostei po zemskim i gorodskim uchrezhdeniyam i na zameshchenie vsekh voobshche dolzhnostei po mirovym sudebnym ustanovleniyam, isklyuchaya lish' samikh mirovykh sudei: Vysochaishe utverzhdennoe polozhenie Komiteta ministrov ot 26 sentyabrya 1879 g., raspublikovannoe 23 oktyabrya // PSZ RI. Sobr. II. T. LIV. ¹ 60045.
12. Ob uvelichenii soderzhaniya chinam sudebnogo vedomstva: Zakon, Vysochaishe utverzhdennyi odobrennyi Gosudarstvennym Sovetom i Gosudarstvennoi Dumoi ot 3 iyulya 1908 g. // PSZ RI. Sobr. 3-e. T. XXVIII. ¹ 30655.
13. Ob usovershenstvovanii gosudarstvennogo poryadka: Manifest ot 17 oktyabrya 1905 g. // PSZ RI. Sobr. III. T. XXV. ¹ 26803
14. Osnovnye gosudarstvennye zakony: Vysochaishe utverzhdennye 23 aprelya 1906 g.// PSZ RI. Sobr. III. Tom XXV. 1905. Otdelenie I. ¹ 27805.
15. Pravo.1907. ¹ 1.
16. Pravo. 1907. ¹ 3.
17. Pravo. 1907. ¹ 5.
18. Pravo. 1907. ¹ 14.
19. Pravo. 1907. ¹ 15.
20. Pravo. 1908. ¹ 6.
21. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi istoricheskii arkhiv. F. 1276. Op. 2. D. 77.
22. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi istoricheskii arkhiv. F. 1278. Op. 2. D. 3471.
23. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi istoricheskii arkhiv. F. 1362. Op. 1. D. 570.
24. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi istoricheskii arkhiv. F. 1544. Op. 1. D. 23.
25. Sbornik opredelenii Soedinennogo Prisutstviya i Obshchego sobraniya pervogo i kassatsionnykh departamentov (1902-1912 gg.) i Vysshego distsiplinarnogo prisutstviya (1885-1912 gg.) Pravitel'stvuyushchego Senata.-SPB: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1913. 450 s.
26. Sbornik rechei Petra Arkad'evicha Stolypina, proiznesennykh v zasedaniyakh Gosudarstvennogo Soveta i Gosudarstvennoi Dumy (1906-1911). SPb.: Tip. V. V. Logacheva, 1911. 131 s.
27. Svod zakonov Rossiiskoi imperii. T. XVI. SPb, 1913.
28. Svod osnovnykh gosudarstvennykh zakonov // Svod zakonov Rossiiskoi imperii. T. 1. SPb., 1913
29. Uchrezhdenie upravleniya Kavkazskogo kraya: Vysochaishe uchrezhdennoe 26 aprelya 1883 g. // PSZ RI. Sobr. III. T. III. ¹ 1522.
30. Shchedrina Yu. V. Kadrovye polnomochiya gubernatorov v sfere sudebnogo upravleniya v Rossii v 1860-kh – seredine 1880-kh gg. (k voprosu o nezavisimosti sudei) // Administrativnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo. 2012. ¹ 11. S. 44-53.