Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Pedagogy and education
Reference:

Features of artistic and creative training in the field of industrial design in diverse universities of modern China

Syui Yun'

Graduate Student, Department of Art History and Pedagogy of Art, Herzen State Pedagogical University

191186, Russia, Saint Petersburg, Moika embark., 48, room 6, room 51

xuyun@rambler.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0676.2023.3.43824

EDN:

ZNBTVS

Received:

17-08-2023


Published:

05-10-2023


Abstract: The processes of modernization of the Chinese higher education system are changing the content of educational activities of educational institutions and emphasize the need to train specialists with the ability to think innovatively in industrial production. The author of this article focuses on the peculiarities of the organization of the educational process in the specialty industrial design in leading educational institutions of different profiles and the role of disciplines related to the formation of artistic abilities of students in it. The purpose of the research is to study the educational process in modern Chinese art and non-art universities and to identify those components of it that condition the training of a future specialist capable of productive professional activity in production conditions. The object of the research is the process of formation of professional knowledge and skills of future specialists in the field of industrial design in modern Chinese art and non-art universities. The subject of the study is a characteristic of the ratio of artistic and creative disciplines and other subjects during the preparation of students of the specialty "Industrial Design". The author of the work notes that educational institutions in China consider the ability to create sketches in different techniques, materials and stylistics as basic for future specialists, but drawing, composition and color theory are not taught in all universities as independent disciplines. At the same time, they are necessarily present in creative research projects as a mandatory component.


Keywords:

industrial design, art education, chinese education, chinese universities, design education, design, artistic design, sketch, design product, visual literacy

This article is automatically translated.

Industrial design is a relatively new field for manufacturing and education in China. After the country's accession to the WTO, industrial design began to play a key role in creating its own well-known brands and enterprises in the XXI century, the image and status of local products, developing brands taking into account cultural characteristics, increasing the competitiveness of enterprises and products in international and domestic markets, promoting sustainable development of society. The concept and methods of industrial design have spread to creative fields, becoming a means of optimizing the distribution of resources between them and production. A specialist in this field is in the eyes of people, as a rule, the owner of innovative thinking, which helps to create design products that are important for both economic growth and cultural development. Moreover, he must be equally well versed in the beauty of forms and technologies, which, of course, is extremely rare, since the path of professional formation in this profession is not stable and may consist of a variety of components and circumstances.

Currently, the concept of "industrial design" is not just the research and development of an original product intended for mass production, the design of its appearance, but also the mechanism of promotion on the market, advertising and everything that is somehow connected with the embodiment in reality. At the beginning of the XXI century, the Council of the International Association of Industrial Design Industrial Design of China defined the essence of the profession as follows: "In the case of mass-produced products, due to training, technical knowledge, experience and visual perception, new qualities and specifications are given to materials, construction, shape, colors, surface finishes and decorations, which is called industrial design" [1, p. 125]. In accordance with this concept, a training model was formed in China for such specialists who should know all aspects of inventing and creating product design, packaging, advertising, positioning, market development, etc. At the same time, the starting point for him can be both science and technology, and fine art, and ideally both together. Graduates of Chinese universities majoring in Industrial Design can be both engineers and design artists. Such a watershed creates certain difficulties, since it assumes the presence of two different training models within the same specialty. This situation is unique, and requires a scientific understanding of the features of the structure of the educational process, the interaction of artistic, technical and other disciplines in the formation of future specialists. It should be noted that the issue of the correlation of fine art, especially academic drawing and painting, and design training in the context of higher education is devoted to the works of Russian researchers, for example, such as T. V. Antropova [2], V. R. Viitman [3], A.V. Danilova [4], K. A. Platunov [5]., A.V. Strizhak [6] et al. The growing interest in Russia in the design options of the educational process in teaching industrial design, the role of the artistic and creative component in it determine the relevance of this publication. Its scientific novelty is due to the fact that for the first time it highlights the specifics of conducting fine art classes in the preparation of designers in universities of various profiles in modern China, where such subjects are closely intertwined with humanities and technical related to the interdisciplinary nature of the chosen specialty.

Education in the field of industrial design in China began its formation relatively late in the 1980s, but it developed rapidly and at the beginning of the new century became one of the most popular specialties in China. Before the "cultural revolution", a course was taught in universities, which was called "Design modeling of light industry". The first educational institutions to introduce it into the educational process were the Central Academy of Arts and Crafts (now the Academy of Fine Arts of Tsinghua University) and the Wuxi Institute of Light Industry (now Jiangnan University). In 1982, with the approval of the Ministry of Education, a specialty was created at Hunan University and the Wuxi Institute of Light Industry, within which industrial designers were trained. In the new century, due to the growth and improvement of the market economy, it began to develop even more rapidly. The National Commission for Development and Reforms has even developed a draft "Industrial Design Industry Development Strategy", in which clear goals for the development of industrial design were put forward. So, by 2030, China should become a world power in design innovation [1].

In accordance with this course and in the conditions of reforming the entire educational system, universities and colleges needed to change the system of training such personnel [7, p. 45]. In recent years, many of them have received the right to award bachelor's, master's and doctorate degrees in the field of design, and thus a full-fledged system of design education has been created. The latter focuses on practice-oriented training. So, even in the Bauhaus education system, which Chinese universities are equal to, practical training was cultivated, in which students discovered and solved creative tasks through creative project activities. The training of specialists in China now includes mandatory mastery, for example, of skills such as creating sketches by hand or models using software, which are elements of one creative process. The methodology is also focused on the analysis and synthesis of information, the ability to verbally and in writing express their thoughts and ideas, the development of the ability to work in a team, etc.

In China, the conditions of each higher school are completely different, not to mention the difference in teaching between the Academy of Arts and, for example, a technical university. Moreover, China does not seek unification. Moreover, they see diversity as a way of development. Such a profession as industrial design often includes a variety of professional knowledge and requires long-term training, accumulation of practical experience mainly on their own. The question of how to give students the opportunity to use the limited time spent at the university to create a reasonable knowledge structure that meets the needs of social development has become an important topic in the theory and practice of vocational education in China. It is obvious that industrial designers both in my country and in Russia need not ready-made and firmly fixed knowledge and skills, but interdisciplinary cultural literacy, which includes drawing skills, or rather sketching, creating models, including their 3D visualization, interpersonal communication, a subtle sense of form and space, an understanding of, how to "bring" a product to market and much more.

The Chinese Academy of Arts at the Department of Industrial Design trains specialists in the design of transport, communications, furniture and toys. Students are introduced to such disciplines as "Drawing", "Professional painting", "Computer design", "Materials and Technologies", "Product structure", "Ergonomics of design", "Product Design", "Special Design", etc. There is no separate discipline related to drawing or painting, but sketching runs through all the objects with a red line. Sketches based on field observations are created when performing any creative project. At the same time, students are not required to have deep visual skills. The main thing is to feel the shape of the product, its connection with the spatial environment, function.

The Department of Industrial Design of the Academy of Arts and Design of Tsinghua University is an example of training such specialists in the environment of a multi-profile university. In the educational process, the emphasis is on practical training within the framework of creative projects in disciplines related to design. The training is divided into three levels: theoretical knowledge, basic skills and tools. Theoretical knowledge includes philosophy, psychology, design history, etc.; design and research methods; tools are mainly sketching, modeling, functional principles and other design possibilities. And here art and graphic training as an independent direction is not conducted, remaining at the level of basic drawing and working with color in line with certain educational projects. Teachers believe that design is not the creation of forms or decoration, but the solution of a problem in accordance with certain requirements. In their understanding, "purposeful action" within the framework of an educational creative task is design [8].

The Department of Industrial Design of Northwestern Polytechnic University in Shanxi Province specializes in the design of transport and mechanical equipment, research on the construction of production chains and everything that helps to "go to sea, fly in the air and travel." The complex and diverse field of study necessitated the training of specialists, both in the field of design in science and technology – the direction of training "Industrial Design", and in the field of art – "Product Design", which was previously referred to as "The Art of Design" [9]. Upon admission, all applicants pass an exam for knowledge of history and culture, but the second group also passes a creative test in the form of drawing and composition in painting. Students of both majors master basic drawing skills in their first year. At the same time, they take quite intensive and time-consuming courses in natural science and technology, higher mathematics, etc. They master theoretical material, which they consolidate with practice-oriented homework. In the second year, in addition to sketching, students get ideas about the theory of color, composition. However, students do not have credits for mastering these disciplines, which leads to a rather low interest in the subjects. In the subsequent period of study, mainly those related to engineering, computer design and modeling are taught. In order to encourage the desire for creative activity with a fairly small element of creativity in the curriculum, the university offers its students participation in reporting exhibitions, research projects, international cooperation and exchange programs.

It is possible to more fully identify and emphasize the specifics of Chinese design education in this aspect by comparing the data obtained with what other countries offer in the training of industrial designers, in particular in Russia. The People's Republic of China built its art education system based on the Russian-Soviet experience, however, since the late 1970s, it has been actively introducing technologies of Western design education. E.N. Koveshnikova identified and characterized a number of modern models of training future designers. She notes that during the preparation within the walls of universities, artistic and creative disciplines and technical ones can be combined mechanically; the former prevail, and the latter are considered as auxiliary; technical training prevails. The author especially notes, as the most optimal, the activities of design schools, which are common in Europe and the USA, striving to harmoniously combine the artistic and technical components, offering students participation in a variety of creative and research projects[1]. The attraction of Chinese universities of almost all profiles, from artistic academic to polytechnic, to the introduction of interdisciplinary projects in the educational process, apparently reflects the influence of this model on them and the understanding of their role in the formation of skills of individual creative activity.

The analysis of various educational institutions in China, where future specialists in the field of industrial design are trained, showed that the content of educational programs is dominated by material related to the design of products. At the same time, artistic, graphic and technical components are considered as auxiliary. At the same time, training in the first one is conducted indirectly within the framework of creatively-oriented subjects, where for the implementation of a particular educational task it is necessary to create a sketch, sketches, that is, visualization of the idea. Technical disciplines are taught at the level of basic familiarity with existing technologies, materials or available software for design.

It should be noted that a common place for universities of artistic and humanitarian profiles in relation to teaching industrial design is that the system of mentoring and graduation at the studio is actively used in the educational process [10, p. 149]. It is a consequence of direct borrowing from the experience of Western art education. The advantage lies in the fact that students' practical activities take place in specially organized spaces, as a rule, art workshops and with the advisory assistance of teachers who are artists and designers. Teaching based on instructions and examples is a tradition for such universities, although it reduces the degree of creative independence. In addition, the content of the studio work is closely related to the lecture materials, expands and complements them.

It is noteworthy that such a model is not cultivated in universities with a technical profile, since they are focused not on the creative component, but on the interaction of students with technology, so practical work is focused either on computer equipment or on production [11, p. 308]. At the same time, interaction with teachers is mineralized. Students receive introductory information from them, which is developed and expanded by them independently, as well as various training tasks related to design, modeling, prototyping, testing, etc. In the "design – science – art" system, the creative element becomes secondary. The ability to solve problems by meeting people's needs comes to the fore.

Modular training is an association of interrelated courses into several training modules that is relevant for universities of all profiles, contributing to their integration. Chinese universities are also characterized by an open and flexible system of elective courses that promote the stimulation of students' independence and the integration of knowledge in interdisciplinary or professional fields. For example, at the Department of Industrial Design of Zhejiang University, the management and teaching staff strive to combine technology and creative design, digital technologies and media. As a result, the industrial and artistic components are connected with each other and with other fields, including cultural studies and psychology. As a result, students are taught the synthesis of functions and forms. However, students, as a rule, do not have basic artistic training. For this reason, during the first years of their bachelor's degree, in parallel with engineering, economics, and human sciences, they master a module related to artistic design and sketching, where they learn to look for harmony between proportions, textures and textures, lines, colors, etc. Such mainly practical work allows you to form the ability to innovative thinking as the most important factor in the implementation of design ideas.

The analysis of the activities of a number of leading universities in the training of specialists in the field under consideration has shown that educational institutions in China, when preparing future industrial designers, somehow find time in the educational process for fine arts classes. For the most part, they are rather superficial and introductory in nature. As a rule, in the first two courses, students perform drawings from nature and by presentation, then master the basics of composition and color theory [12, p. 63]. Such classes are considered not only as mastering the basic tools for fixing ideas and ideas, but also as a means of studying objects, the environment, space and other factors that can influence the creation of a design product. Moreover, drawing allows you to choose the most suitable methods of expression and style for yourself. Sketches made by students should not only focus on the integrity of the spatial position and morphological characteristics of things, but also on their structure, that is, emphasize "industriality". Artistic and creative subjects are often intertwined with humanities and technical disciplines, which allows students to achieve an understanding of the interdisciplinary nature of industrial design. It should also be noted that a graduate of an art university with a diploma in industrial design is likely to be engaged in the design of interior items, accessories, clothing and other things close to the principles of artistic design. Technical universities focus their graduates more on various mechanisms and equipment.

In general, the artistic and creative component in the curriculum of both artistic and non-artistic universities engaged in training in the field of industrial design is presented both as separate disciplines and as a component integrated into other subjects. Moreover, taking into account the fact that Chinese design is gradually moving from the design of external objects, buildings, machinery, equipment to complex design services, discussions about the primacy of forms, style or materials, structures and equipment cease to be so important. The learning process includes more and more new disciplines related to research on demand, market factors, product promotion, etc. In the near future, the issue of including a creative approach and appropriate tools in them will become a priority. The general trend boils down to the fact that the skill of traditional drawing is gradually turning into only one of the means of implementing the plan, giving way to computer graphics and modeling.

References
1. He Renke (2010). History of industrial design, pp. 123–127. Beijing: Higher Education Publishing House.
2. Antropova T. V. (2013) Fundamentals of industrial design ": the relevance of the course in teaching students of engineering and technical areas. Prospects for the development of science and education: Collection of scientific papers based on the materials of the International Scientific and Practical conference: in 7 parts, Moscow, November 29, 2013. AR-Consult LLC, Volume Part I. (pp. 94–95). Moscow: AR-Consult Limited Liability Company.
3. Viitman V. R. (2016) Specialization "Industrial Design" and figurative component in the process of teaching students. Philological Sciences. Questions of theory and practice, 6-2(60), 187–190.
4. Danilova A. V. (2018) To the question of the methodology of teaching special painting at the department of industrial design in SPGHPA them. A. L. Stieglitz. Design and artistic creation: theory, methodology and practice: Proceedings of the second international scientific and practical conference, St. Petersburg, October 11–12, 2018. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg State University of Industrial Technologies and Design, pp. 512–515.
5. Platunov K. A. (2018) Psychological features of the process of activating the mental activity of students in the direction of preparation "industrial design" in the design classes. Innovations and modern technologies in the fashion industry: Proceedings of the National Scientific and Practical Conference, Novosibirsk, 15 May 2018. Novosibirsk: Amirit Limited Liability Company, pp. 133–134.
6. Strizhak A. V. (2021) Innovative methods in teaching bachelors of specialization "Industrial design" using bionic shaping. Innovations in the field of industrial design: Collection of materials of a scientific and practical seminar, Moscow, September 30, 2020. Moscow: Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education "Russian State University named after A.N. Kosygin (Technology. Design. Art)”, pp. 53–58.
7. Sun Yuejuan, Fang Rujian, Shen Honglei, Jiang Changyong, Jiang Wei (2016). An applied study of experimental teaching in engineering design courses. Journal of the Changzhou Institute of Technology, 10, 45-51.
8. Professor Zhang Lei, Director of the Department of Industrial Design, talks about design problems. (2021). Academy of Fine Arts website, Tsinghua University. Retrieved from https://www.ad.tsinghua.edu.cn/info/1205/25813.htm
9. About the Department of Industrial Design and the specialty "Industrial Design". (2021). Website of the Northwestern Polytechnic University. Retrieved from https://jidian.nwpu.edu.cn/info/1015/1576.htm
10. Wang Yan (2015). An Analysis of Teaching Methods for a Sketching Course in Industrial Design. Journal of the Suzhou Institute of Education, 25(6), 146–150.
11. Shen Fa, & Zhang Fuchang (2001). On the Characteristics of Industrial Design Education in Engineering Colleges. Journal of Wuxi Light Industry University (Social Science Edition), 3, 306-308.
12. Meng Yan (2014). Exploring Teaching Design Sketches in Industrial Design. New West (theoretical edition), 30(13), 59-67.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the study is the pedagogical features of artistic and creative training in the field of industrial design in modern Chinese universities. The research methodology is based on a combination of theoretical and empirical approaches using methods of analysis, generalization of pedagogical experience, comparison, synthesis. The relevance of the research is determined by the growth of intercultural interaction in the modern world and, accordingly, the need to study and compare the experience of universities in different countries, including in the field of professional training of industrial designers in the People's Republic of China. The scientific novelty has not been explicitly highlighted by the author and, apparently, is related to the conclusions that in the preparation of future industrial designers, fine art classes are introductory in nature. Artistic and creative subjects are intertwined with humanities and technical subjects, which contributes to students' understanding of the interdisciplinary nature of industrial design. The learning process also includes more and more disciplines related to research on demand, market factors, product promotion, etc. The article is written in Russian literary language. The style of presentation is scientific. The structure of the manuscript includes the following sections (not highlighted in separate paragraphs, not titled): Introduction (industrial design as a sphere of production and education in China, the concept and methods of industrial design, the definition of the Council of the International Association of Industrial Design of China, engineers and design artists, two models of learning within one specialty, the ratio of fine art and design- training in the context of higher education), Industrial design education in China (course "Light Industry Modeling Design", Central Academy of Arts and Crafts, Wuxi Institute of Light Industry, Hunan University, "Industrial Design Industry Development Strategy", design education system, practice-oriented training, Bauhaus training system, solving creative tasks through design activities, diversity as a path of development, interdisciplinary cultural literacy), Experience of Chinese universities in the field of industrial design (Chinese Academy of Arts, Academy of Arts and Design of Tsinghua University, Northwestern Polytechnic University), Analysis of educational programs (prevalence of product design, auxiliary character of artistic, graphic and technical components, training within the framework of creatively oriented subjects, mentoring and graduation system in the studio, modular training), Conclusion (conclusions), Bibliography. The content generally corresponds to the title. At the same time, it seems advisable to compare the experience of Chinese universities in the field of professional training of industrial designers with other countries, academic schools in the field under study (including, for example, Russian ones). Otherwise, in general, it remains unclear what the specifics of Chinese design education are in this aspect, what are its causes, etc. The bibliography includes 12 sources of domestic and foreign authors – scientific articles, materials of scientific events, Internet resources, etc. Bibliographic descriptions of some sources require adjustments in accordance with GOST and editorial requirements, for example: 2. Antropova, T. V. Fundamentals of industrial design": the relevance of the course in teaching students of engineering and technical fields / T. V. Antropova, A. P. Antropova // Prospects for the development of science and education : a collection of scientific papers based on the materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference. – Moscow : AR-Consult, 2013. – Part I. – pp. 94-95. 6. Strizhak, A.V. Innovative methods in teaching bachelors of specialization "Industrial design" using bionic shaping / A.V. Strizhak // Innovations in the field of industrial design : a collection of materials of a scientific and practical seminar (Moscow, September 30, 2020). – Moscow : Kosygin Russian State University, 2021. – pp. 53-58. 8. Professor Zhang Lei, Director of the Department of Industrial Design, talks about design problems. Website of the Academy of Fine Arts, Tsinghua University, 2021. (????????????????????. ?????????). – Access mode: https://www.ad.tsinghua.edu.cn/info/1205/25813.htm Appeal to opponents (T. V. Antropova, A. P. Antropova, V. R. Viitman, O. A. Kazakova, N. G. Viitman, A.V. Danilova, K. A. Platunov, A.V. Strizhak, He Zhenke, Sun Yuejuan, Fan Zhujian, Shen Honglei, Jiang Changyong, Jiang Wei, Wang Yan, Shen Fa, Zhang Fuchang, Meng Yan, etc.) takes place. In general, the material is of interest to the readership and after revision, the manuscript can be published in the journal Pedagogy and Enlightenment.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The object of research in the manuscript submitted for review is artistic and creative training in the field of industrial design in China as a professional and pedagogical process, while the subject is actually its main essential and specific features. The relevance of the research is due to the high importance of industrial design as a phenomenon that transcends art in its purest form. It is known that in industry, manufacturing, design is closely related to ergonomics, and therefore to the convenience of using certain things, and therefore their popularity and competitiveness. Thus, the issues of industrial design and training of relevant specialists lie, among other things, in the economic plane. Another aspect of the relevance of the work is the increase and intensification of international relations of various levels and contents between Russia and China. At the same time, the issues of industrial design in the scientific and journalistic field are considered relatively rarely, so we can talk about the elements of novelty in the presented work. The work is completely theoretical in nature, and the only research method is descriptive and narrative analysis, which is the minimum (threshold) level for scientific publication. Practical issues in the text are considered not at the level of concretization, analysis and systematization of individual didactic units (forms, methods, tools, techniques, knowledge, skills, competencies, etc.), but at the level of maximum generalization, review of pedagogical experience. The study would undoubtedly benefit if the specified experience were generalized precisely at the above level, and was reflected in the form of lists of features, specific features, trends, etc.. In a solid format, this information is "dissolved" in a text array. A rather detailed historical digression into the formation of the system of training industrial designers in China deserves attention. The article is written in a language that generally corresponds to the norms of scientific style. The list of references meets the requirements and finds a real meaningful reflection on the pages of the work. From a meaningful point of view, the publication may be of interest to a fairly wide audience, namely those interested in comparative pedagogy, art pedagogy and Oriental culture in general. There are a number of comments on the work. From a structural point of view, the article is made in the form of a single solid text, which is more typical of journalistic material. Scientific research, even of a small volume, is usually divided into content-related parts. The final part is made not in the form of postulates reflecting the main essence of the scientific work carried out, but in the form of a description of common problems and issues of design development and teaching. Despite the substantial list of sources, the text does not contain an overview of the authors and the vectors of their research, at least at the level of the main contribution to the studied problems. The article is very vague about the subject of research in the classical scientific and pedagogical understanding of this term. The author touches on too wide a range of aspects of design training from managerial to methodological – this article also somewhat resembles journalistic material. These remarks impoverish the study from a meaningful point of view, but do not negate the understanding that, in general, it meets the minimum generally accepted requirements for scientific journal articles, and can thus be published in a peer-reviewed publication.