Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Philosophy and Culture
Reference:

The Ideological Foundations of Chinese Traditional Landscape Painting Art

Lu Sa

Graduate student, Department of Art History and Pedagogy of Art, Herzen State Pedagogical University

191186, Russia, Saint Petersburg, nab. Sinks, 48, room 6, room 51

tkachenko.lnik@gmail.com
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0757.2022.10.38818

EDN:

CXLVXR

Received:

22-09-2022


Published:

05-11-2022


Abstract: The article analyzes the ideological foundations of the emergence and evolution of landscape in Chinese painting as an independent genre from the III to the XVIII century, before the rapid integration of Western European artistic traditions. Landscape painting is considered as an expression of the state of mind of Chinese artists, the prevailing philosophical ideas, in particular Taoism, the embodiment of literary images associated with the natural origin. Despite the attention of the scientific community to the development of images of nature in the art of ancient and modern China, there are few studies devoted to the causes and justification of certain processes that influenced the formation of the genre. The purpose of the study is to analyze the reasons for the appearance of images and motifs in the landscapes of Chinese artists in connection with the philosophical ideas of that time, cultural connotations in poetry and the principles of landscape art. The tasks include determining the most typical range of scenes and images in landscapes created from the III to XVIII centuries. The material is the work of Chinese artists who lived since the reign of the Wei Dynasty, during the heyday of landscapes in the era of the Tang Dynasty and up to the XVIII century. Of interest is the study of the mechanism of influence on the formation of figurative systems in Chinese landscape painting that developed in parallel poetry and landscape art.


Keywords:

chinese painting, Taoism, motive, literary plots, aesthetics, chinese philosophy, landscape, gardening and park art, the image of nature, medieval China

This article is automatically translated.

 In Chinese art studies, scientific works of various levels are very widely presented, analyzing the history and features of the landscape art of the country at various stages.

 

There are also works exploring the history of garden art, the authors of which consider the manifestations of its traditions in the works of Chinese painters. Especially often scientists seek to correlate pictorial images and poetic ones, which are associated with the description of glades, ponds and fruit trees in gardens and parks of the Celestial Empire. A similar situation is observed in Russian science. Among the most significant works in Russian, we will include the books of E.V. Zavadskaya, N.A. Vinogradova, O.N. Glukhareva, the dissertation of Ya.V. Yakovlevsky, as well as other authors who were attentive to the search for the ideological foundations of images in the works of Chinese artists of different periods. Meanwhile, philosophy and literature are traditionally considered as a source of inspiration for the masters of Chinese painting. At the same time, it is obvious that under the influence of the principles of organizing such garden and park spaces as a means of spiritual self-improvement, the picturesque landscape also changed.Fig. 1. Xi Yunren.

 

https://nimg.ws.126.net/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fdingyue.ws.126.net%2F2022%2F0417%2Fb30ddb6dj00rah2hm003jd200ku00eag00hh00bz.jpg&thumbnail=660x2147483647&quality=80&type=jpg

Reflection in the mirror water of the entrance to the Mermaid Palace. Beijing. Photo. 1949. A source:https://www.163.com/dy/article/H55Q00JN0514IU34.htmlThe history of the formation of the image of the garden in Chinese art began during the Qin and Han dynasties, when the great emperors tried to maintain stability and demonstrated their power through the pomp of architectural buildings [1, p. 13].

They built palaces, surrounded them with pavilions, planted rare plants, and also arranged cascading rockeries, ponds and other garden ventures. In terms of their scale and decorative design, these palaces surpassed all subsequent royal gardens and parks. Examples include the palaces of Qin Shi Huang and Weiyang Han Wudi, built in the II–I centuries BC on the territory of modern Shaanxi province. Judging by the very vague but expressive descriptions of that time, the gardens then looked more like hunting grounds with a large number of rare birds and animals, lush trees and luxuriously decorated gazebos.

The emperors built magnificent gardens not only out of love for nature and practical needs, but also out of interest in Taoist ideas about the natural principle. According to them, they sought to turn their home into a magical place on earth, hoping to achieve immortality through spiritual practice. Taoism advocated a "return to nature" both internally and externally, that is, a person had to establish the closest relationship with nature on the spiritual and material levels. The life of an individual reflected the rhythm corresponding to the constantly changing life forms of nature. For example, the Chinese artist of the Tang dynasty, Gu Kaizhi, painted paintings that reflected scenes with wildlife, into which he seemed to immerse his viewer. His contemporary Zong Bing was fond of rocks, believing that they both in painting and in reality symbolize a person's path to perfection in the darkness and danger of the world.

A similar vision was reflected in poetry. So, the poet Tao Yuanming in "The Return", written at the beginning of the V century about the meaning of the garden, wrote the following: "When you return home, you realize that there is no idyll outside the house. Since you take your heart for a form, you are melancholic and lonely <...> The boat sails far away with a light nose, and the wind blows your clothes <...> Three paths are empty, but pine trees and chrysanthemums still remain. The garden is fun, and the door to it is always closed <...> Yun Wuxin comes out of the gazebo, and the birds fly away when they get tired. Jing Ying is about to enter, caressing the lonely pines" [2, p. 155].

https://nimg.ws.126.net/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fdingyue.ws.126.net%2F2022%2F0417%2F31e25203j00rah2ho001qd200bs00ehg00hh00lg.jpg&thumbnail=660x2147483647&quality=80&type=jpg

Fig. 2. Unknown master of the Ming Dynasty. An idea of the royal mountain garden of the Han Dynasty. Freer Museum of Art, Washington. Source: https://www.163.com/dy/article/H55Q00JN0514IU34.htmlDuring the Han Dynasty, a Rabbit garden appeared near the Yaohua Palace, owned by King Xiao of the Liang Kingdom.

According to the descriptions of this object, it was pitched around the Bailin Mountain with the Qilongxiu Cave, and also had a fish pond. It was decorated with rare trees, flowers and birds. Many of the constituent elements of this garden subsequently found their place in later Chinese garden and park ensembles. They also had caves and rocks, even if artificial in the form of grottoes, winding paths and waterways, dense forests and rich vegetation — all this created the effect of fabulousness. But the most important feature of these gardens was an artfully constructed rock garden, consisting mainly of stone blocks. So gradually Chinese gardeners focused on the transformation of natural landscapes and the creation of artificial ones.

The development of landscape art of that time also stemmed from the romantic views of Taoist philosophy. Artists played on this theme, trying to depict magnificent palaces and gardens. Their works are known from copies of masters from the later medieval Song and Ming dynasties. Some depicted marble platforms, intricate pavilions, towering pagodas, open terraces and other architectural elements, and placed them among lush trees and stones surrounded by white clouds. Due to the desire to create an image of a special fairy-tale place, their works did not fully reflect reality, but rather embodied an idealized image (Fig. 2).

https://nimg.ws.126.net/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fdingyue.ws.126.net%2F2022%2F0417%2F0dbfc81fj00rah2hn002pd200je00e7g00hh00cs.jpg&thumbnail=660x2147483647&quality=80&type=jpg

Fig. 3. Yang Wujiu. A zen room surrounded by trees and rocks and a garden wall. The beginning of the XII century. Freer Museum of Art, Washington. Source: https://www.163.com/dy/article/H55Q00JN0514IU34.htmlLater, Taoist scholars and artists began to lay out gardens around their homes, and they undoubtedly differed in scale and principles of organization from gardens built by wealthy aristocrats and rulers.

Private gardens were usually small and located in hard-to-reach places, for example, in the mountains or on the banks of rivers. Terraces on the mountains were planted with bamboo and plum trees, river banks with willows, and outside the house was lost behind fruit trees and plantings of chrysanthemums and peonies. The gardens were surrounded by fences made of bamboo branches. This contributed to a closer connection between man and nature, united people who lived surrounded by gardens, emphasized not power and strength, but rather the ingenuity that they sought to express in life and creativity.

Due to the fascination with private gardens, the theme of landscape painting is changing, as it switches to the image of protected areas. Thus, in a composition characteristic of that time, a copy of which was performed by Yang Wujiu in the XII century under the title "Zen room surrounded by trees and rocks and a garden wall", it is noticeable that the unknown author of the IV century moves away from idealization towards a sufficiently detailed image of a corner of nature transformed by man, in which the owner meditates. In an effort to repeat the principles of garden art, the artist leaves the space around the pavilion, bringing plants and rocks to the perimeter — symbols of the dangers of the real world (Fig. 3). Thereby they begin to play the role of framing, and a contrast is built: a light and almost empty center and a dark periphery saturated with shapes and spots.

Taoist ideas about nature and its relationship with man have undoubtedly had a great influence on the development of gardens and parks in China, as well as on their images in poetry and painting. However, Buddhism, which developed side by side with these ideas, also had an impact on the art of landscape. In China, starting from the IV–V centuries, Buddhist monasteries and temples began to be actively built, usually located in picturesque places, which pushed the founders and residents of these monasteries to organize garden spaces. One of the most famous was Bailian, founded by Hui Yuan in the city of Lushan, Jiangxi province. The followers of the teaching gathered in the large garden, who, returning to their native lands, created a semblance of this landscape — the so-called Lushan gardens.

Buddhism encouraged people to dive deeper into the world of nature, which, in turn, became a source of inspiration for painting and garden art. This development became more noticeable during the Song and Ming dynasties, when the Chinese transformed Indian religion with the help of local traditions and philosophical thought. This had a decisive influence on painting and, as a result, on garden art. Rich Chinese who turned to religion began bequeathing gardens to Buddhist monasteries before their death in order to preserve their "privileges" when they die and go to another world. This phenomenon was very common. In the book describing the history of the origin of Buddhism "Luoyang Jialang Ji" (), which was published in 547, a detailed description of Zhang Lun's garden is given: "The beauty of garden mountains and ponds is inaccessible to any king. The owner erected Jingyang Mountain, which was similar to a natural one. Deep streams and ravines are connected together. A tall forest giant tree is enough to cover the sun and moon. Hanging branches and rhizomes expel wind and smoke from the pavilions. The road, cut by stones, seems winding. A person comes here who is happy in the mountains and wilds and travels so as not to return back" [3, p. 39-40]. This description is rather vague, but it captures some characteristic elements of the basic layout of the garden, such as paths, ponds and rock gardens, which gave the garden a picturesque effect.

No less famous is the garden of the same time called Jingu, the first mention of which dates back to the IV century. It belonged to Shi Chong, one of the richest people in China of that period. It was this garden that became the object of attention of a number of artists whose works have come down to us. However, these works still belong to the Ming Dynasty. So, there is a painting by the artist Qiu Ying, who turned to the image of this garden, but the emphasis was not on reflecting the peculiarities of the organization of space, but on embodying the image of joyful holidays in the midst of architecture of small forms and graceful beauties, one of which was the legendary inhabitant of the garden — "Green Pearl". If we summarize the available artistic material of that period, it turns out that most of the scrolls and paintings showed, first of all, secular pavilions or monastic monasteries, usually located on mountain platforms or in valleys.

Compared with the lavishly decorated palace garden and park complexes, such gardens looked more modest, but began to appear more often in painting. Due to their proximity to the wild, they were more closely connected with the need to live naturally and simply — poetry, painting, and garden art reflected this desire. Among the poems describing secluded pavilions and gardens, the lines written by the poet Xie Lingyun "Help in planting a garden of Tiannan trees" are still well known, which describe the specifics of the garden's location: "A garden under a clear sky attracts the wind from afar. The meditation room faces north, and the open gate faces the south river. Hibiscus stands like a column in front of the window ..." [4, p. 69]. Obviously, this little secret garden faced the mountains to the north and faced the river to the south. Only hibiscus was mentioned in the poem of plants, but there were undoubtedly chrysanthemums and bamboo groves, as well as other trees whose branches shaded the pavilions. It is noteworthy that with the development of such gardens, separate images of garden plants appeared in Chinese painting, primarily flowers and bamboo — the main motifs of the "flowers and birds" genre. Small spaces encouraged owners to pay more attention to details, making them objects for admiring [5, p. 23]. One of the first artists who turned to this motif was probably Xu Chunxi, who painted elegant flowers and leaves with colored ink over silk and thin rice paper, introducing insects and poetic lines into the composition. At the same time, he left the space around him unpainted (Fig. 4).

https://nimg.ws.126.net/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fdingyue.ws.126.net%2F2022%2F0417%2F13a6697cj00rah2ho001jd200fo00ckg00hh00e0.jpg&thumbnail=660x2147483647&quality=80&type=jpg

Fig 4. Unknown author of the Ming Dynasty. Woodcut based on a painting by Xu Chunxi of the IV century. Private collection. Source: https://www.163.com/dy/article/H55Q00JN0514IU34.html

In the VI century, when the capital of the state was in Nanjing, artistic activity associated with the reflection of feelings and emotions began to prevail, and landscape finally stood out as an independent genre. This happened due to the fact that the painting perfectly conveyed the changing mood of nature and its observer. Thus, the works of the artist Wang Wei, both in the field of poetry and painting, fully reflected this feature. Judging by the available copies of the works of painters of that time, the masters preferred to paint small scenes with huts covered with thatched roofs, in which hermits lived; open pavilions on the banks of mountain rivers, lost between trees at the foot of the mountains; ponds with water flowers in the middle of the forest. In addition, small orchards or groves of gnarled pines or bamboo swaying in the wind were depicted. The artist Zhang Senyao, who worked at the beginning of the VI century, was particularly successful in creating such images. He painted hermit huts that were located on the shores of lakes or rivers, where willows and other trees provided shade and there was enough space for flowers and trees.

During the reign of the Northern Song and Ming dynasties, images of open pavilions erected on a small plot of land protruding from the water became fashionable. Another option is that at the foot of the mountain, the painters painted several small pavilions surrounded by rocks and dense bamboo forests. These motifs are closely related to the trend that prevailed in medieval gardens and was expressed in the creation of secluded corners. Such views are shown in paintings by Zhao Danyan, Li Wei and other authors. For example, Yan Buzhi's ink drawing depicts a garden with a low hut and a thatched roof in the center, and trees and other plants around it. At the same time, endless expanses with mountain peaks overgrown with pine and bamboo forests can be seen behind the garden wall. A hut in the middle of mountains and endless distances is a place of secluded peace in a raging world.

Around this period, the work of Xu Shichang was painted, depicting a pavilion built by the water. The stream flows to the foot of the mountain, and there you can see a small plot with a garden surrounded by a fence. Bamboo groves and blossoming plums lean towards the fence, and tall pines and willows are located on the left and right. Behind — endless mountain peaks, lost in the fog. It is noteworthy that such an organization of landscape composition was typical for artists of the Southern Song Dynasty, in particular for the Ma Xia art school.

File:Sheng Mou 001.jpg

Fig. 5. Sheng Mao. Autumn boat trip on the river. 1361. National Museum, Beijing. Source: https://wiki5.ru/wiki/Sheng_MaoIn the Ming era, Mao Sheng worked, who created the scroll "Autumn Boat Trip on the River".

It is noticeable in it that the author has become more attentive to details, trying to show even the species of plants, their uniqueness (Fig. 5). Moreover, it is plants that become key in his work. The artist's painting "Assembly in the Orchid Pavilion" shows depicts a literary gathering of forty-one scientists who celebrate the annual Spring Cleansing Festival in the "Orchid Pavilion". During this event, cultural figures were engaged in composing poems. Cups of wine lying on large leaves floated on the surface of the water, and if a scientist could not find a rhyme or put a verse together, he had to drink a drink. The celebration became more fun as getting the bowls became more risky.

The first paintings, including the image of the orchid pavilion, date back to the IX century. Many centuries later, the same figures of men and several boys sitting along the stream and examining the scroll are written on the scroll of Mao Sheng. However, they are placed in a conditionally empty space, while the plants are "taken out" by the master to the periphery. They serve as a kind of framing of the scene. This corresponds to the principles of building a Chinese garden of that time. The influence of Western art affects the more detailed drawing of plants and in the desire to fill the entire plane of the scroll with the depicted objects.

https://www.wm-painting.ru/plugins/p17_image_gallery/images/9/2634.jpg

Fig. 6. Chen Hongshou. Drinking wine in the garden. 1649.Shanghai Museum, Shanghai.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chen_Hongshou#/media/File:Chen_Hongshou,_Drinking_Wine_in_the_Garden.jpgFollowing Mao Sheng, many Chinese painters turned to the theme of the meeting in the orchid pavilion.

For example, the Chinese artist Chen Hongshou tries to convey in his works his emotional state and feelings about the decline of the Ming Dynasty and the Manchu conquest that rooted the Qing Dynasty. His scrolls combine elegant lines with decorative flowers and plants. Chen Hongshou depicted both human figures and birds, flowers, landscapes. His painting is distinguished by its decorative manner and stylizations.

The scroll "Drinking wine in the garden" was written in the middle of the XVII century and conveyed a scene with a scientist drinking wine among banana trees against a background of rocky stones. He holds his glass high and sits looking into the distance. The master strives to convey the spirit of the past through antique dishes and costumes. Meanwhile, the organization of the garden corresponds to modern principles for it. In those days, gardens were organized so that they seemed as natural and open as possible with obligatory stone slides and other structures laid out of this natural material. Wanting to emphasize the "air", the master shifts the thickets of banana trees to the left edge, placing figures, masonry and plants so as to balance the composition (Fig. 6). The color scheme is moderate. Dark lines outlining the outlines of figures and natural objects are complemented by small spots of green, red and blue. This underlines the desire of the artist, who followed the ideas of Confucius, to renounce the world within a safe garden.

In the era of the Qing Dynasty, first of all, in the gardens of the provinces of Guangxi and Guangdong, architecture of small forms began to develop in the form of gazebos, lanterns, bridges, etc. Thanks to this, Chinese artists received new motifs in their arsenal. The most famous artist of the XVII–XVIII centuries is considered to be Len Mei, who combined the western and eastern style of creating works. He painted the secluded corners of the great imperial park. As a rule, it was a lake surrounded by hills and trees. He conveyed them in a rather saturated color scheme [6, p. 176]. During the Qing Dynasty, miniature landscapes were also popular, mainly with images of private gardens in southern China [7]. An example is the "Garden of the Wu Family" by an unknown author.

File:Leng Mei - Figures - Leaves 24 and 25.jpg

Fig. 8. LEng Mei. Figures. XVIII century

National Palace Museum, Taipei. Source: https://wiki5.ru/wiki/Leng_Mei

At the turn of XVII–XVIII centuries there were many artists who were active in the field of landscape. One of them was len Mei from Shandong province. In the beginning of his career he was a pupil of the artist and astronomer Jiao of Benjina. During the reign of the Kangxi became a court painter. The artist became famous for his works depicting people, including ladies and beautiful women. He imagined them in their scrolls not only inside the Palace interiors, but in the midst of gardens. Unlike predecessors, who had rarely entered the architectural motifs in the landscape, the wizard made a bet. Moreover, he very boldly used a colorful palette, achieving a contrast and bold combinations.

Concluding the analysis of the landscapes of Chinese artists in the context of the development trends of landscape art, note, that the motives which they are elected, largely due to the level and nature of development of philosophical and religious thought that is associated with the awareness of the connection between man and nature. Thus, the greatest impact on the composition of landscape as a genre, which has taken origins in the fifth century, had Taoism, who saw in nature is the path to spiritual perfection. After that the nature has become a major preoccupation of poets and writers, many of whom were supplemented their poetic images of spectacular. The latest on the dawn of the genre at first reflected the wild and transformed by human nature, but in the idealized way. Then with the development of landscape art of the attention focused on the man-made motifs garden plants and architecture of small forms. First, to focus the attention of painters were part of the Imperial parks and gardens of the nobility, which led to a desire to cover them in integrity, panoramically. Hence, complex compositions and scenes. From the VI century began to develop a small, private gardens, and then the master of landscape began to focus on separate from the world and pleasant gardens, the impenetrable wall surrounding owners. At the same time began to develop the genre images of floral compositions, many of which were the result of observation of the growth and flowering of the plants in the garden. Later with the development of garden architecture artists began to focus on the image of the pavilions and other buildings, among which are surrounded by trees, the various events.

Thus, the landscape painting in China has undergone many transformations, as the manner of the painters themselves, and one of the main factors that stimulate these processes were philosophical ideas about the connection of man and nature, as well as the success of the Chinese in the creation of gardens and parks.

References
1. Yanshao, Lu. (2006). Discussion of landscape painting. Shanghai People's Publishing House of Fine Arts, 2006, pp. 12-13.
2. Fuguan, S. (1980). Various conversations about Chinese art. Essays of Xu Fuguan — memorizing thoughts. Taiwan Times Culture Publishing Co., Ltd, pð. 154–159.
3. Wu-chan, Ch. (2008). The Complete History of Chinese painting. Beijing, 278 ð.
4. Qi, J. (2015). Artistic commonality of Chinese garden design and Chinese painting. Beauty and time: creativity (part 1). ðð. 69–70.
5. Changlin, S. (2006). On the question of the images of gardens in landscape painting. Fine Arts Magazine. ðð. 23–25
6. Dee, Ch. (2012). The evolution of Russian gardens, landscape gardening techniques and their influence. Beijing Forestry University. ðð. 174-176.
7. Fukuyama, F. (2004). The End of History and the Last Man. Moscow, NPP “Ermak”, 588 p

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Addressing the topic of the ideological and artistic originality of the genre system is not new in the science of art and culture, however, when it comes to the specifics of a particular ethno-national culture or art, as, for example, in this case, traditional Chinese art, then the study of ways to preserve identity and originality becomes important. From this point of view, the research perspective proposed by the author fits perfectly into such a "rule", therefore it is quite logical that this material can be supported. Meanwhile, turning to the content of the article, we can see that the author first of all focuses on the fact that the basis of the formation and development of the genre system of landscape is a philosophical reflection on the harmony of man with nature – of course, this "trend" is traditional for China and for Eastern culture and art in general. If the author is going to develop this topic, then he has the right to do so – moreover, it would hardly be possible to consider this issue outside the philosophy of the East and the wisdom of China, since the worldview and worldview of an Oriental person lies in harmony with nature, and the genre of landscape should naturally "grasp" this harmony, fill it with form and content, reflect key (or typical) features. I believe that the author partly focused on this aspect of the study as well and at the same time presented his own author's vision of the problem. So, first of all, in order to focus further on the omissions and advantages of the article, we note here a large number of errors (or typos): the author should be careful to edit the material in order to eliminate such an obvious flaw. Here are just some cases: it was an independent and most important genre (?) of fine art ...; the spirit of nature, which, according to the Chinese, was present ... (?); similar views led to the creation (?) a new genre... etc. I urge the author to proofread the text. Meanwhile, the content of the work contains rather curious generalizations related to the cultural and historical process and the development of Chinese philosophical thought - the author skillfully operates with historical facts, coordinates them with each other, analyzes the role of Chinese wisdom in understanding art, its nature, as well as its connection with man – it seems that the author correctly caught the main refrain research and throughout the entire material maintains adherence to the logic of scientific research, which, of course, is the advantage of this article. It should also be emphasized that the addition of illustrations to the text undoubtedly helps to better understand the material, and in addition, visually assess the validity of the generalizations proposed by the author. All the illustrations are quite appropriate, quite curious. The "dynastic" approach, which is often used in cases with the study of Chinese issues in its broad sense, quite "works" in this case as well – the author starts from the history of dynasties to show how the development of philosophical and religious movements was "superimposed" on the search for a genre system in Chinese art - and this should be recognized as quite logical Because the author has designated as the subject of his research precisely the ideological foundations of the origin of landscape as a genre. Thus, here we observe methodological certainty in the disclosure of the topic. The article also gives an assessment of works on the theory of painting, and also traces the relationship between Chinese poetry and painting in their development. I believe that the author has full knowledge of the information, the article contains elements of novelty in the final results, the topic seems to be sufficiently disclosed. On this basis, after a small revision in terms of eliminating language errors, the article can be recommended for publication.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the study, the ideological foundations of the origin of landscape as a genre in traditional Chinese art, as defined in the title, is revealed by the author on the example of an analysis of paintings significant for the history of landscape in the works of Chinese artists. The author traces three main historical stages of the development of the genre traditional for Chinese painting in the III-XVIII centuries, defining the features of each of them based on the evolution of the style and content of the scrolls. "The origin of landscape as a genre in traditional Chinese art," thus, according to the author, has been going on for 15 centuries. Such a historical period allows us to talk not only about the "origin", but also about the evolution of the genre. There is an obvious significant logical error in the formulation of the subject of the study. In fact, the author substantiates the logic of the historical process of the development of the traditional genre, which is reflected in the formulations of the main conclusion ("One of the main factors of such processes were philosophical ideas about the connection between nature and man, the synthesis of poetry and painting, as well as success in creating gardens and parks"). The work highlights the most important ideological foundations of the originality of the landscape genre in traditional Chinese art: the philosophy of contemplation and poetry, which are presented not at the stage of origin, but in the logic of the evolution of style due to the development of philosophy, poetry and architecture. Accordingly, when finalizing the article, attention should be paid to the differentiation of the object (it may be a historical process over the course of 15 centuries, or maybe more, since Lao Tzu and Xie He are mentioned) and the subject of the study. The scientific problem to which the study is devoted is also unclear. For Chinese and Russian art criticism, the three stages of the development of the Chinese landscape indicated by the author are textbook. The syncretism of philosophy, painting and poetry, as the main characteristic of the Chinese tradition, is also a banality. The "ideological foundations" stated by the author are intriguing, but they are not reflected in the final conclusions: what ideas underlie the traditional Chinese landscape and whether the author saw something beyond what is already known in science about these ideas has remained unknown to the reader. Thus, the subject of the study is not formulated logically and is not disclosed by the author. The research methodology is subordinated to a step-by-step historical narrative that reveals the logic of the historical process of development of the traditional genre of Chinese painting. To do this, the author applies elements of stylistic and iconographic analysis. However, for what purpose the reconstruction of the logic of the evolution of the genre is carried out remains a mystery, since the subject stated in the title ("ideological foundations") is only touched upon in passing. When finalizing the article, it is necessary to clearly specify the research program (problem, goal, tasks, methods necessary for solving problems), then the final conclusions will reflect the achievement of a certain research goal. The relevance of the topic addressed by the author is quite high due to the increased interest in Chinese culture around the world and in Russia. However, the author has not clearly formulated the scientific problem to which he seeks to contribute. Therefore, regarding the development of science (be it art history or cultural studies), the author's intentions are not entirely clear. The scientific novelty of the work remains in doubt due to the fact that the subject of the study is not clearly defined and has not been disclosed. The style generally corresponds to the scientific one (although years and centuries could be shortened, as is customary in the scientific style). The structure of the article does not fully correspond to the logic of presenting the results of scientific research: there is no goal setting in the management, the conclusion does not correspond to the subject and problem of the study indicated in the title. There are comments on the content of the text: there are numerous typos that significantly complicate the reading of the author's thoughts ("the most important genres of fine art ...", "they differed significantly ...", "At that time ...", "plants " were taken out by "masters to the periphery ...", "mandatory stone slides ...", "Motifs that they chose the artist ...") — the text, accordingly, needs proofreading and proofreading. The bibliography poorly reflects the problem area of research (there is no review of scientific papers over the past 5 years). The appeal to opponents is generally correct, although it is exclusively complementary. There is no scientific criticism in the work. The author has yet to win the interest of the readership of the journal "Philosophy and Culture" by finalizing the article taking into account the comments of the reviewer. The strength of the reviewed work is an interesting topic of the ideological content of the traditional Chinese landscape, for the analysis of which the techniques of semantic, stylistic and iconographic analysis are used. The author should correct the text so that the elements of scientific novelty (i.e. the main result of the research) become obvious, as well as the way of their discovery.

Third Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

In the journal "Philosophy and Culture" the author presented his article "Landscape art as a factor of changes in the images of Chinese landscape painting", which conducted a study of the origin and development of the landscape genre in China and the factors that determined the uniqueness of the content and expressive means. The author proceeds in studying this issue from the fact that philosophy and literature are traditionally considered by art historians as a source of inspiration for the masters of Chinese painting. At the same time, the author attributes the art of organizing garden and park spaces to the means of spiritual self-improvement and factors influencing the formation of a unique Chinese picturesque landscape. The relevance of the study is determined by the fact that the originality of Chinese art is currently attracting great attention from many researchers and amateurs from around the world. The scientific novelty of the research is a scientific approach to the consideration of numerous factors that have determined the unique style of the Chinese landscape. The methodological basis of the study was an integrated approach containing historical, socio-cultural and artistic analysis. The author writes in the article that the theoretical basis of the research is the works of E.V. Zavadskaya, N.A. Vinogradova, O.N. Glukhareva, etc., however, these works are not included in the bibliographic list of the article. The empirical basis of the study was the landscapes of Chinese artists of various historical periods. Accordingly, the purpose of this study is to analyze the specifics of the change in the artistic concept and form of the Chinese landscape in development, as well as the factors that determined this change. Having studied the degree of scientific elaboration of the problem, the author concludes that Chinese art studies have a very wide range of scientific works of various levels analyzing the history and features of the country's landscape art at various stages. There are also works exploring the history of garden art, the authors of which consider the manifestations of its traditions in the works of Chinese painters. Especially often, scientists strive to correlate pictorial images and poetic ones, which are associated with the description of glades, ponds and fruit trees in gardens and parks of the Celestial Empire. A similar situation is observed by the author in Russian science. After conducting a historical analysis, the author notes that landscape art was the basis for the development of the landscape genre in China. Its history is quite long, the beginning dates back to the era of the Qin and Han dynasties of the III century AD. Ancient palace gardens and parks, as the author notes, were designed under the influence of the ideas of Taoism and Buddhism, which preached the unity of man and nature, man had to establish the closest relations with nature on the spiritual and material levels. The life of an individual reflected the rhythm corresponding to the constantly changing life forms of nature. These works of art, as the author states, had not only an aesthetic, but also a sacred function. The emperors built magnificent gardens not only out of love for nature and practical needs, but also out of interest in Taoist ideas about the natural principle. According to them, they sought to turn their home into a magical place on earth, hoping to achieve immortality through spiritual practice. Gardens and parks were decorated with rare trees, flowers and birds. They also had caves and rocks, even if artificial in the form of grottoes, winding trails and waterways, dense forests and rich vegetation — all this created the effect of fabulousness. The development of landscape art at that time also stemmed from the romantic views of Taoist philosophy. Artists played up this theme, trying to depict magnificent palaces and gardens. Buddhism encouraged people to dive deeper into the world of nature, which in turn became a source of inspiration for painting and garden art. According to the author of the article, in the VI century AD, artistic activity associated with the reflection of feelings and emotions began to prevail, and landscape stood out as an independent genre. This happened due to the fact that the painting perfectly conveyed the changing mood of nature and its observer. Analyzing the landscapes of such artists as Sheng Mao, Chen Hongshou, Leng Mei, the author notes that under the influence of Taoist and Buddhist traditions, landscape painters sought not only to accurately convey the image of gardens and parks and to display their inner experiences and impressions of contemplation of unique artistic objects in paintings. Analyzing the dynamics of the development of the landscape genre, the author sums up the following: the motives of landscapes were largely determined by the level and nature of the development of philosophical and religious thought associated with the awareness of the connection between man and nature. Thus, Taoism, which saw in nature the path to spiritual perfection, had the greatest influence on the formation of landscape as a genre that took its origins in the fifth century. After that, nature became one of the main objects of attention of poets and writers, many of whom complemented their poetic images with picturesque ones. Then, with the development of landscape art, attention focused on man-made motifs, garden plants and architecture of small forms. Since the sixth century, small private gardens began to develop, after which the masters of landscape began to focus on isolated and cozy gardens that surrounded the owners with an impregnable wall. At the same time, the genre of depicting floral compositions began to develop, many of which were the result of observing the growth and flowering of plants in the garden. Later, with the development of garden architecture, artists began to focus on the depiction of pavilions and other buildings, among which various events took place surrounded by trees. After conducting the research, the author presents the conclusions on the studied materials, noting that landscape painting in China has undergone many transformations, as well as the manner of the painters themselves, and one of the main factors stimulating these processes were philosophical ideas about the connection between nature and man. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing for analysis a topic, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of the mutual influence of artistic culture and religious and philosophical views, as well as the facts of the manifestation of such mutual influence in the subjects of artistic culture, is of undoubted theoretical and practical cultural interest and can serve as a source of further research. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. An adequate choice of methodological base also contributes to this. The bibliographic list of the study consists of 7 sources, which seems insufficient for generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the studied problem. The author should add to the list of works indicated by him in the text of the article. The author fulfilled his goal, obtained certain scientific results that allowed him to summarize the material. However, there is an actual error in the text of the article. It should be stated that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication after the specified flaw has been eliminated.