Ilikaev A., Fadeev K.V. —
Comparative analysis of current nuclear and military doctrines of Russia and the USA
// Law and Politics. – 2025. – ¹ 4.
– P. 123 - 142.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0706.2025.4.73952
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/lpmag/article_73952.html
Read the article
Abstract: The subject of this study is a comparative analysis of the current nuclear and military doctrines of Russia (2024) and the United States (2018). The purpose of the article is to identify the similarities and differences between the nuclear and military doctrines of the world's leading nuclear powers, as well as to formulate recommendations regarding Russia's nuclear and military doctrines in order to minimize the risk of nuclear war and effectively realize the national and state interests of the Russian Federation. The relevance of the work lies in the fact that after the adoption of the nuclear doctrine in 2024 there has been an escalation of the information war related to attempts to lower the threshold for the applicability of nuclear weapons and discredit the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. The practical significance of the research is expressed in the fact that its results can be used to study the problem of international security in conditions of increasing danger of nuclear war, as well as to develop and implement concrete steps to improve Russian doctrinal installations on nuclear and military security. The methodological basis of this study is an analysis of the regulatory framework, scientific literature and Internet resources related to the problem of nuclear and military policy of Russia and the United States, a comparative historical approach for analyzing the doctrinal attitudes of the nuclear policy of the Russian Federation and their adjustments with the corresponding doctrines of the United States. The novelty of the research lies in establishing similarities and differences between the nuclear and military doctrines of the world's leading nuclear powers, as well as in formulating recommendations regarding Russia's nuclear and military doctrines. In particular, it was found out that while the United States had already adopted the first nuclear doctrine in 1994, there was no similar document in Russia until 2020, despite the presence of sections on nuclear deterrence in the military doctrines of the Russian Federation. At the same time, while Russia has almost always been identified as a key adversary in the US nuclear doctrines, even the current Russian nuclear doctrine of 2024 does not mention the United States in the same capacity. There is only an increase in threats emanating from NATO. The authors of the article first of all propose to specify the sources of threats to Russia's nuclear security, which, first of all, are the United States and its closest NATO allies.
Ilikaev A. —
Realpolitik, noopolitik and cryptopolitik: on the issue of the Peculiarities of the Russian Foreign Policy Course at the present stage
// Law and Politics. – 2025. – ¹ 3.
– P. 30 - 64.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0706.2025.3.73477
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/lpmag/article_73477.html
Read the article
Abstract: The subject of this research is the analysis of the features of the Russian foreign policy course at the present stage through the prism of the concepts of realpolitik, noopolitik and cryptopolitik. Based on the subject of the article, the author makes : a general overview of Russia's foreign policy, an analysis of the terms realpolitik, noopolitik, cryptopolitik, highlighting the features of Russian foreign policy characterized by the above-mentioned terms. To solve these research tasks, the following media resources were used : TASS, Kommersant, Fontaka, the Levada Center, Forbes, Reuters, YouTube , etc. The methodological basis of this research consists of using the results of monitoring various media resources, political science literature on the issue. The author used an analysis of the current, rapidly changing political situation, which gives relevance and practical significance to this research. The novelty of this work lies in the study of the features of the modern Russian foreign policy, its conditioning factors. The author of the article consistently examines the prerequisites for the emergence of the current configuration of international relations since the entry of the Russian state as a sovereign player on the international political scene. This allows us not only to single out and use the terms noopolitik and cryptopolitik, which are still poorly developed in Russian political science, but also to fill them with new content in relation to the topic of the article, as well as to put forward a whole range of recommendations for adjusting the current Russian foreign policy, mainly against the background of its conduct in Ukraine. The author of the article analyzed the current, rapidly changing political situation, which, in his opinion, gives relevance and practical significance to this study.
Ilikaev A., Sharipov R.G. —
Parallels in the astral myths of the Turks and Finno-Ugrians: on the example of the mythologies of the Milky Way and the Polar Star
// Genesis: Historical research. – 2024. – ¹ 12.
– P. 119 - 142.
DOI: 10.25136/2409-868X.2024.12.72533
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/hr/article_72533.html
Read the article
Abstract: The subject of this article is a comparison of the astral mythology of the Turks and Finno-Ugrians using the example of key mythologems-astronomers of the Milky Way and the Polar Star. The main research method was the analysis of the available ethnographic literature on the astral mythology of the Turks and Finno-Ugric peoples. As we have found out, the eschatological myth of the dog stars (wolves), which are tied with ropes to the Pole Star, is very popular among the Turks. The comparison of the Milky Way with the "road of birds" was known to the Turks and Finno-Ugrians, but, according to experts, it arose mainly among the Uralic peoples. Nevertheless, we assumed that the basis of the myth of the emergence of the "bird's road" as a path of migratory birds most likely originated in the Ural-Volga region. The comparison of the Milky Way with a "ski trail" (or just a trail in the sky) was common among the Finno-Ugrians. It probably went back to the Siberian myth of the heavenly hunt. The likening of the Milky Way to snow, rather, as we see it, has a Turkic origin. In our opinion, the comparison of the Polar Star with the "nail" was preceded by the mythologeme of the "world pillar", celebrated by all Turks and Finno-Ugrians. The original mythologeme of the "world pillar" among the Turks was the idea of a Golden Pillar. In addition, the Turks, as specialized cattle breeders, were characterized by the idea of the Polar Star as a hitching post. The peculiarity of the Finno-Ugric names of the Polar Star is that they can directly relate to a bird sitting on top of a world pillar, or even a star goddess.
Ilikaev A. —
The problem of the authenticity and divine status of the image of heavenly virgins in Mari mythology
// Genesis: Historical research. – 2024. – ¹ 11.
– P. 1 - 11.
DOI: 10.25136/2409-868X.2024.11.72216
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/hr/article_72216.html
Read the article
Abstract: The subject of this article is the question of the authenticity, as well as the divine status of celestial maidens in Mari mythology. The images of celestial maidens (for example, Yumyndyr – the Daughter of Heaven/ God) in Mari mythology are archetypal. In addition, images of celestial maidens are found in the mythology of the Finns, Karelians, Komi and Mordvins. So, Komi is the famous daughter of the sun Zaran, Mordvins – Castorgo and Vecorgo, the daughters of the goddess Ange-Patiai. Among the heavenly maidens, in addition to Yumyndyr, Mari can be noted Piambar, Yymyndyr, Yuktalche, Pampalche, etc. Nevertheless, some researchers doubt the authenticity of the image of Yumyndyr in view of the fact that it is supposedly the only proper mythological image in Mari mythology. However, Mari still has a real myth about Piambar, the daughter of Kugo Yumo. In addition, images of celestial maidens are present in many Mari fairy tales, songs, and spells. The materials indicate that Yumyndyr and similar characters act as archaic deities who have retained their connection with the aquatic environment, the cult of ancestors, as well as their magical and protective functions. As a local deity, the goddess Piambar is still revered by some Mari groups. Thus, the divine status of celestial maidens in Mari mythology is complex and contradictory. On the one hand, the images of heavenly virgins are common and popular in folklore, incantation magic, on the other hand, they are modestly represented in rituals and prayers. However, in our opinion, this does not allow us to assert that the heavenly virgins in Mari mythology became only a "reduced" version of the former goddesses. Rather, we are talking about the complex evolution of images from matrix-centered deities to folklore, fairy-tale and local characters.
Ilikaev A. —
Myths about Yumynudyr ("heavenly maiden") in Mari mythology and Ritual: an attempt at a source and structural analysis
// History magazine - researches. – 2024. – ¹ 6.
– P. 275 - 294.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0609.2024.6.72829
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/hsmag/article_72829.html
Read the article
Abstract: The subject of the article is the sources and content of myths about Yumynudyr ("heavenly maiden") in Mari mythology and ritual. The article is a continuation of a previously published work that examined the reliability of information about this key image of Mari mythology, as well as the problem of its divine status.The purpose of the research is a source-based and structural analysis of the myths about the Yuminudyr in order to reconstruct the main semantic links of the original tradition, as well as systematize data on the cult of the "heavenly maiden". To achieve this goal, it was necessary not only to identify the sources of the Yumynudyr myth, but also to identify the most significant thematic and plot motifs in the existing texts, to analyze the rituals associated with Yumynudyr and the image of Piambar close to her. In the course of solving the tasks set, the author of the article used a number of methods: source studies, structural analysis. In addition to analyzing ethnographic literature and folklore collections, field research materials were also used to supplement and clarify existing information about the Yumynudyr. The novelty of the research is the systematization of all information available in the literature about Yumynudyr, the analysis of the little-known myth of May, the daughter of the Mari goddess Shochyn Ava, as well as a comprehensive analysis of texts mentioning the "heavenly virgin", "daughter of God". This made it possible to continue the most promising research of a specialist on the topic, Yu.A. Kaliev, to identify the seven main links of the legend of Yumynudyr, to arrange them in a logical and chronological (according to a hypothetical macro plot) sequence. In addition, based on the field material being introduced into scientific circulation, the accuracy of the details previously recorded by the researchers on the issue of interest to us was confirmed, as well as a more meaningful and systematic and consistent examination of the cult of the "heavenly virgin" for the first time in ethnographic science: to highlight the most significant holidays, rituals associated with the images of Yumynudyr and Piambar.
Ilikaev A., Sharipov R.G. —
Parallels in lunar myths of the Turks, Mongolian peoples
and Eastern Finno-Ugrians
// History magazine - researches. – 2023. – ¹ 5.
– P. 26 - 41.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0609.2023.5.43977
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/hsmag/article_43977.html
Read the article
Abstract: Parallels in lunar myths of the Turks (ancient Turks), Mongolian peoples and Eastern Finno-Ugric peoples (Mordvins, Mari, Komi, Udmurts) are the subject of this research. So far, lunar motifs in beliefs of these ethnic groups have not been specially compared with each other. In the article, the authors make an attempt based on a comparative analysis of mythological images and plots, and specifically, lunar myths which are essentially universal for all peoples of the world, to provide additional arguments in favor of confirming the hypothesis of V.V. Napolskikh about the existence of a special North Asian community of the Northern Eurasian peoples mythologies.
Based on the review analysis and the research, the authors have come to the following conclusions. Firstly, the moon deity in myths of the Turks, Mongolian peoples and Eastern Finno-Ugrians is a predominantly male deity having a close link with the underworld and the image of the death god. Secondly, the mythologeme about the origin of the moon from the water is another specific Ural-Altai element. Thirdly, in the mythology of the Turks, Mongolian peoples and Eastern Finno-Ugrians, the deities of the moon, most likely, go back to totems in the form of birds (primarily waterfowl), a bull, probably more related to the water element.
Thus, the assumption of V.V. Napolsky about the existence of a North Asian mythological union receives additional support.
Ilikaev A. —
Myths about the world creation from an egg of Baltic-Finnish peoples in comparison with cosmogonomic myths of Mary and Udmurts
// History magazine - researches. – 2023. – ¹ 2.
– P. 140 - 153.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0609.2023.2.40547
URL: https://en.e-notabene.ru/hsmag/article_40547.html
Read the article
Abstract: The subject of this study is the motives of the myth of creation from an egg among Mari and Udmurts. Until now, the myth of the world creation from an egg (MCE) has been noted in the tradition of the Baltic-Finnish peoples, as well as the Mordvins and Komi. An analysis of Mari cosmogonic myths and folk songs reveals two mythological motives related to MCE: 1) a cuckoo builds a nest on an oak tree with six branches; 2) a duck (goose) breeds five, six, seven, twelve chicks right on the water (the top of the grass growing in the river middle).
The main conclusions of the study are the following provisions. The image of a duck of the Eastern Mari is not so popular and is replaced by the images of a cuckoo and a swan. A wagtail and an ermine are also mentioned in the Mari folklore which finds parallels in Ainu and Nenets myths. Udmurt variants of folk songs include the mythologem of a duck (goose) with ducklings. The myth of a creator eagle and two ducks was perhaps characteristic not only of the Finns, Hungarians and North American Indians but also of the Mari. The Udmurt myth of creation is characterized by the presence, in addition to Inmar and Shaitan, of a cancer which finds a parallel in the Buryat cosmogonic myth. The motif of primordial ice and frozen primordial earth was probably widespread in the traditions of Izhora, Mari, part of the Bashkirs who were descendants of the Finno-Ugric peoples, Nganasan. And, thus, this motif was apparently present in the Proto-Uralic mythology.