Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Culture and Art
Reference:

Interactive video installation "Millennials": convergent approach in education and Collective Performance

Magidovich Marina

ORCID: 0000-0003-0747-1078

Professor; Department of Theory and History of Culture; A.I.Herzen Russian State Pedagogical University

191186, Russia, Saint Petersburg, Malaya Posadskaya str., 26, room 304

maguidov@mail.ru
Iushchenko Uliana

independent researcher

198328, Russia, Saint Petersburg, 28 Valor street, sq. 20

ulya.yushchenko@mail.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0625.2024.8.71284

EDN:

PHOCMX

Received:

18-07-2024


Published:

02-08-2024


Abstract: The subject of the research is the development, creation and holding of a group immersive exhibition "Millennials", the authors and creators of which are a creative team consisting of a teacher and 15 students. The subject of the exhibition is the culture of childhood in Russia in the first decade of the 21st century. It was during these years that the childhood of the students took place, 13 of whom were born in 2002, and two in 1998 and 1999. The article presents the innovative experience of organizing and holding an immersive exhibition dedicated to the culture of childhood in Russia at the beginning of the XXI century, created by students of the final year of the bachelor's degree of A.I. Herzen Russian State Pedagogical University (direction "Cultural education", module: "Museum and theater pedagogy") in October 2023 - January 2024 under the guidance of the author of the article – M.L.Magidovich. The following approaches and methods of sociological surveys were used by the authors: case study, included observation, focused survey, anonymous questionnaire. In many ways, the study was based on the theory of cultural capital and social space of Pierre Bourdieu. The novelty of the study is determined by the artistic components of the exposition (concept, title, texts, sculptural objects, audio-visual content), the format of the exhibition (performative basis, theatricalization, interactivity), as well as the author's methodology and methodology for collecting and processing empirical data obtained during the development and holding of the exhibition. Among the main conclusions, one can note the revealed nostalgia for the own childhood of modern 20-year-olds, the dependence of generational cultural codes and the structure of everyday life in childhood on television content viewed in preschool and primary school age, problems of intergenerational communications associated with various spectator experiences in childhood. The format of the collective exhibition of students contributes not only to the growth of professional competence of future professionals, but can also become the basis for convergent research and the development of significant museum projects. The obtained research results can be used both in the artistic practice of contemporary art and in social and humanitarian studies of youth.


Keywords:

immersive, art education, art-pedagogics, exhibition, student, exhibition design, audiovisual installation, collective performance, Action research, childhood culture

This article is automatically translated.

Introduction

The article presents the materials and conclusions of a cultural study of the university art project "Children of the Noughties", which combines elements of a pedagogical experiment, collective performance and a theatrical immersive multimedia art exhibition created using the principles of multiscreen and interactivity by a creative team consisting of a group of students and a teacher. The exhibition project was developed and implemented by the second graduation of cultural educators who studied under the new module "Museum and Theater Pedagogy" at the turn of the Year of the teacher and mentor and the Year of the Family. The opening of the exhibition took place on 12/21/2023, in the space of the technopark of the Institute of Human Philosophy of the Herzen State Pedagogical University. Since the article does not involve watching a video, to create a visual image, we will briefly describe the opening of the exhibition.

Before the acting director of the institute Denis Vladimirovich Ignatiev cut the ribbon in front of the closed door of the exhibition, Anastasia Sokolova moved the audience to tears by reciting her own poem "Visiting Childhood" on a chair in front of the entrance, inspired by the preparation for the event:

"...You will find our childhood in the yard,

Where was the scary monster hiding in the mountain?

Where we were friends, believed, loved,

Did you bury the treasure, did you go camping?...".

Then the curators of the exhibition Anna Avimskaya and Ulyana Yushchenko talked about how the childhood of those born in the early years of our century differs from the childhood of other generations. Behind the closed door, the audience discovered a magical space similar to a music box or a kaleidoscope with flickering colored lights, where the characters Angela (Moskalenko) and Nastya (Temir-Bulatova), sitting on warm ottomans, offered treats from their childhood and showed how to play yo-yo and other children's fun of the early 2000s, who were on the table at the entrance. On the big TV of the late 1990s, the cartoon "Bratz: Fashionable Fairies" was broadcast. In the window opening, instead of a dark courtyard, children's images of singers, figure skaters, ballerinas, millionaires, prosecutors floated out – the dreams of children at the beginning of our century. Children's fears were hidden on the floor under the batteries in old boxes: spiders, monsters, etc. After enjoying lemonade and children's sweets, visitors actively filled out the once popular children's Questionnaire of a friend.

The exhibition Children of the Noughties is a full-fledged artistic, educational and scientific project created as a model of working with students within the university environment, the purpose of which is to acquire professional competencies by participants, consolidate the knowledge gained during the passage of such disciplines as "Modern technologies in museum activities", "Methods and technologies of organizing exposition and exhibition space", "Museum Art Pedagogy", "Sociology of Museum and Theater audiences", etc.

According to the authors, the exhibition "Children of the Noughties", which has become a university project, can be implemented as a museum exhibition of contemporary art and transformed depending on the specifics of the space and the theme of the museum.

The relevance of the research is due to the performative and psychological turns in art and social sciences, the increased interest in art pedagogy and art therapy, as well as new requirements for modern museum and exhibition activities [1] and the educational environment of universities.

The subject of the research is an artistic and pedagogical experiment of the Institute of Human Philosophy of the Herzen State Pedagogical University in the form of a group immersive [11] exhibition "Children of the Noughties", the authors and creators of which are a creative team consisting of a teacher and 15 students. The subject of the exhibition itself was the culture of childhood in Russia in the first decade of the 21st century. It was during these years that the childhood of students took place, 13 of whom were born in the 2002's, and two in 1998 and 1999.

Having proposed the theme of the exhibition, indirectly dedicated to their own biography, the main exhibition statement was the self-presentation of the authors through the optics of nostalgia for childhood. The selection of the theme and the approval of the name of the exhibition took place collectively for about 2-3 weeks. The theme and title determined the further methodology of the development and the methodology of the creation and display of the exhibition.

Theoretical and methodological framework of the study

The teacher chose a convergent approach as the theoretical and methodological basis of the project, implying the absence of "interdisciplinary boundaries between scientific and technological knowledge" [8]. In addition, in order to obtain the factual data necessary for creating an exposition and their visualization, as well as as a managerial technology, the "Action research" method, widely used in foreign pedagogy, was used, the essence of which is to acquire competencies "by solving a certain problem that arose in the course of activity. Thus, through conducting research in action, the teacher makes changes to his teaching practice" [6]. In this case, the study goes through 5 main stages: "1. Definition of the problem. 2. Data collection. 3. Data analysis. 4. Activities based on the data obtained. 5. Reflection" [6, p.96].

The subject-environment approach was also chosen, which is actively used in modern higher school pedagogy, art therapy and art pedagogy, taking into account both the influence of the subject environment on personal development and the psychosomatic state of the subject, and the role of creating a comfortable, safe environment by students themselves in their self-realization and social activity [10].

The main approaches were determined by the research methods: formal descriptive and structural-typological methods of description and analysis of artistic and pedagogical experiment, as well as sociological methods of specific research: case study, included observation, focused survey, anonymous questionnaire. In the field of designing the exhibition space, the method of total performative audiovisual installation of the "black box" type was used. In many ways, the research was based on the theory of cultural capital and social space by Pierre Bourdieu.

Choosing the exhibition space as a socio-psychological problem

The selection and coordination of the premises for the exhibition revealed a number of social problems. Since the exhibition was developed by graduate students, they sought to use their own experience gained during three years of communication in the university space. In general, the following opinions were voiced by the participants:

1) The exhibition can only be placed within the premises of the department or the premises of the technopark assigned to it, due to fierce competition between various departments of the institute and the negative attitude of teachers of other departments towards them ("no one likes us", "they will scream if they see", etc.).

2) the redi of the premises proposed by the administration in the dean's office area, the students chose an open opening under the stairs. As it turned out later, almost none of the creators of the exhibition had their own room in childhood, or their parents did not allow the door to be closed in the children's room, so the room was chosen the smallest and most inconspicuous, contrary to the logic of the preservation of the exposition and its promotion.

At this stage, the diagnostic value of the environment as a stimulus material was revealed, which made it possible to understand the psychosomatic state of students, to identify their anxiety. At the same time, the search for "one's place" in the university space led to the emergence of semantic images [9], the emergence of spatial metaphors of childhood, self-identification as creators [13]. There was an interiorization of the conceptual apparatus of P. Bourdieu's theory of the interaction of social and physical spaces [3]. Awareness of the reflection of social space in the allocation and assignment of university premises by staff helped participants to live the experience necessary for the design of museum exhibitions and the scenography of theatrical performances in the future.

The choice of the room, which took place in the form of a collective interventionist performance along the corridors of the university, largely contributed to the selection and approval of the performative nature and structure of the planned exposition. The support of the director of the institute, who provided advisory assistance during the discussions in the corridor, turned out to be important. The smallest auditorium of the techno park, designed for laboratory classes and resembling a 3x3x3 meter cube in size, was agreed with the administration.

The concept of the exhibition

At the next stage, based on the chosen room, a three-level vertical structure of the exposition based on universal mythological representations of the three worlds was proposed by the teacher (the author of the article) as the main concept of the exhibition space, and the group approved it. The lower world was supposed to contain images of children's fears, the middle one was supposed to represent the world of things surrounding the child in everyday and play culture, in the upper world it was supposed to represent the visualized dreams of children in 2003-2010. To form the exposition, an anonymous survey of the group was conducted, during which students were asked to recall and list their childhood fears, dreams, and favorite things. As a result, answers were received, among which were repeatedly repeated both universal (archetypal) and relevant statements related to the era and television content of the 2010s.:

Fears: darkness, height, spiders, an electric train, getting lost in a supermarket, evil heroes of television content: Maleficent, Night monsters, a spinning top bites the side, a girl from the horror movie "Bell", an Iron nanny from the TV series "Smeshariki", the program "Battle of psychics", etc.

Computers, Baby Born dolls, stuffed toys with cartoon characters, and a yo-yo game were named as favorite things. Chewing gums with tattoos and Huba Buba, Kinder Surprise, Albums and collections with stickers from cartoons, animation discs and TV shows of animated series, costumes for matinees, summer trips to the sea and to grandma's cottage.

The professions of flight attendants, dancers, singers were named as the childhood dreams of girls, young men in childhood wanted to become millionaires, prosecutors, surf and travel to different countries and galaxies. In addition, dreams of new tape recorders, animation discs, computers, etc. were sometimes mentioned.

After determining the approximate content of the exhibition, formed on the basis of the first survey, students were asked to fill out a questionnaire in which they had to specify: 1) the name of the exhibition; 2) the area of personal responsibility (sound design, poster design, video content, etc.); 3) exhibits for the exhibition, which each member of the group is ready to bring for display;4) draw a sketch of the exposition with the main sections of the exhibition.

According to the results of the second survey, the name of the exhibition "Children of the Noughties", proposed by Ivan Fadeev, was chosen by voting in several stages, and its format was determined as a total installation and the type of main exhibits. The mandatory components of the installation were named: a TV, discs and cassettes with animation, a desk with a children's table lamp in the form of a toy, a push-button mobile phone, a music listening area, board games, poster collections, a yo-yo game, it was also conventionally decided to create objects embodying personal fears and develop a videocontent that visualizes students' dreams.

Exhibition preparation / collective performance

One of the significant results identified during the preparation of the exhibition is the intergenerational gaps associated with the various cultural capital of childhood and the cultural codes of the teaching and student generations. Requests for explanations on decoding the names of memes mentioned by young people, heroes of children's games and films during the development of the project caused the need to think through special excursions and art mediation for the teaching staff. The preparation of the exhibition "Children of the Noughties" has become not only a space of intercultural communications and a research field for teachers and students, but also institutionalized as a collective performance, which, according to scientists, is distinguished by: "collectivity as a means and purpose of work, participation (involvement and complicity), procedural, communicative, identity of performer and character, heteronomy (hybridity)" [7, p.8].

The exhibition preparation process has become a platform for active communication between the participants of the exhibition process on the one hand and a dialogue between the student audience and teachers on the other. Being the creators of the exhibition project, the students simultaneously played the role of museum staff, artists and the public involved in art mediation and participatory practices aimed not at passive perception, but at the active role of the viewer in creating and transforming the exhibition space, involving attention to the visitor's motivation, psychological and cognitive needs [5]. At the same time, the collective performance for the preparation of the exhibition extended beyond the educational classes, involving students from other groups and parents in communication to collect objects and photographs.

The exhibition "Children of the Noughties" became an opportunity for students not only to declare themselves and their generational characteristics, as they stated when choosing a topic. Plunging into memories while searching for the material attributes of the exhibition, the students wanted to feel nostalgia, plunge into childhood, remember and preserve the historical facts of everyday culture of Russia at the beginning of our century, which was reflected in the annotation to the exhibition: "The performative video installation "Children of the Noughties" is a time machine that takes us to carefree days when every day we were looking forward to the release of a new episode of our favorite animated series on TV, collected our own collections of posters and stickers, and showed the most popular clips on MTV, which became the voice of our generation." (A fragment of the text of the annotation of the exhibition by A.Avimskaya and U.Yushchenko).

Identification with a common past contributed to the consolidation of the student group and the self-realization of each of its members, gave the opportunity to express themselves in a new capacity as a curator (Anna Avimskaya, Ulyana Yushchenko), sculptor (Elena Nemirova, Dmitry Pokrovsky, Elena Dibrova, Stepan Nemogai, Anastasia Smirnova), performance poet (Anastasia Sokolova), character and art mediator (Anastasia Temir-Bulatova, Angela Moskalenko, Ulyana Yushchenko), video editing director (Ivan Fadeev), exhibition architect (Ivan Fadeev, Anastasia Farafonova, Angela Moskalenko, Stepan Nemogai, Anastasia Smirnova, Anastasia Temir-Bulatova) and computer 3 D designer (Dmitry Pokrovsky, Anastasia Temir-Bulatova), exhibition designer (Arzu Aliyeva), lighting designer (Anastasia Sokolova, Dmitry Pokrovsky, Anastasia Smirnova), chief curator (Anastasia Sokolova) and graphic designer (Anna Avimskaya, Ivan Fadeev) or feel like workers at the installation and dismantling of the exhibition (Valery Tsvirov, Ivan Fadeev, Stepan Nemogai).

Enumerations of students' job responsibilities show the involvement of the same actors in different professional roles, which proves the performative characteristics of event preparation and exhibition holding, its participativeness and hybridity. According to the researcher and performer R.Osminkina, "modern collective performances are complex micro-laboratories of artistic, socio-cultural and everyday interaction within the framework of an undifferentiated life experience" [7, p.8].

Opening and holding of the exhibition

The choice of exhibits and the spatial solution of its exposition were discussed by students during face-to-face classes at the university, their main criterion was the mass character in the culture of Russia of the studied period. Legitimacy was determined by the recognition of a particular exhibition object by all project participants or at least 80% of the group. During the installation of the exhibition, the participants rejected "narrowly focused objects" and approved only generally recognized toys, magazines, and cartoons. Everyone offered a variant of what they could add from their personal belongings, and the group coordinated each element of the future exhibition. The general concept and organization of the space during the installation was taken together with the teacher.

The main elements of lighting and design were also provided with fashionable decorative "sunset" and children's zoomorphic lamps and textiles collected by students.

The preparation of the exhibition poster was also of a participatory nature. Expressive, but too expressive and harsh, in the opinion of classmates, the image of childhood proposed by I. Fadeev was replaced by a collage of children's photographs of the group members, the collection and approval of which took on a performative character, which can be explained by the spread of screen images and familiar network communications of students to the real physical space.

As Anna Avimskaya, the curator and author of the exhibition poster, recalls, "The idea of designing the poster for the exhibition came to us through a general brainstorming. Today, one of the trends in social networks and media is the publication of their own children's photos from the 1990s – 2000s, taken both on film and on digital cameras that appeared by the beginning and middle of the noughties. It has become incredibly interesting for people to retrospectively compare themselves from childhood with themselves today. In general, this trend should be attributed both to the popularity of universal nostalgia for childhood and to the trend of nostalgia for the period of the early and mid-noughties. This led to the idea of using our children's photos in the materials of the poster. Another question was how organically these photos would look as a whole, so it was decided to create a general collage of photos with the name of the exhibition on top of it. The font was also written manually, without using ready-made templates. This is an attempt to create a "careless" inscription, as if made by a child."

Due to the small size of the exhibition space and the image of a children's room filled with wonders and fears from childhood, the design of the exhibition was planned and implemented in the format of a total installation "black box" [2] using the principles of multi-screen [12, pp.121-127]. A darkened room was also necessary for the projection of videos containing children's photos and the drawings of the participants depicting their dreams and dreams in the early years of their lives. The interactive nature of the exhibition was enhanced by the opportunity to listen to the hits of the 2000s, which, in the words of A.Avimskaya, became "the favorite songs of our childhood."

One of the important tasks of the project was a lively dialogue between students and teachers, especially important was the seminar and art mediation at the exhibition held for teachers of the Department of Art and Design of Murmansk Arctic University.

In conclusion, we can note the heuristic potential and pedagogical significance of such projects. The refocusing of cultural optics on art criticism, psychological, pedagogical and sociological aspects carried out in the course of the study made it possible to identify the performative basis of the studied case, to determine the artistic form and design of the exhibition component of the project. The socio-psychological monitoring conducted during the preparation of the exhibition in the form of focused surveys and discussions, as a rule, acquired the characteristics of art mediation, stimulating creativity, imagination and agency of members of the creative team, contributed to the self-identification of the group as a collective author and performer of a creative idea, taking into account the contribution and significance of each.

Conclusions:

1) Students are interested in modern forms of exhibition statements aimed at dialogue and discussion, actively strive to develop participatory artistic practices aimed at self-realization and agency.

2) Nostalgia for early childhood can be recognized as one of the characteristics of student youth, which can be explained by the feeling of insecurity of twenty-year-old students, the desire to distance themselves from situations associated with risks and uncertainty before graduating from university.

3) Cultural representations and the worldview of young generations are largely shaped by media content in childhood, which is often underestimated and little studied in cultural studies and art studies.

4) The dependence of generational cultural codes and the structure of everyday life on television content viewed in preschool and primary school age by modern youth can cause problems of interpretation of images and meanings in intergenerational communication related to the various spectator experiences of teachers and students.

5) The organization of an exhibition project in the form of a collective educational performance contributes not only to the growth of professional competence of future professionals, but can also become the basis for convergent research and development of significant museum projects.

6) The organization of collective student art exhibitions by future cultural educators contributes to the consolidation of the studied material in a number of socio-humanitarian and artistic disciplines. Along with professional competencies, such practices contribute to the acquisition of personal, general cultural and other competencies, which must be studied in research on higher education pedagogy.

7) The primary conclusions obtained in the course of a sociological study aimed at obtaining data on cultural memory and ideas of modern youth about the early years of the 21st century require additional measurements and can be used in further research in the field of microsociology, modern history, biographical research, etc.

8)The conducted artistic and pedagogical experiment has shown the effectiveness of combining a convergent approach with the method of "research in action" (Action research) and can be recommended when organizing and conducting interactive events by a creative team consisting of students and teachers in higher education and museum pedagogy when working with the public.

References
1. Balash, A.N. (2022). Informal museology. Museum and museum practices in modern culture: Museum and museum practices in modern culture. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg State Institute of Culture.
2. Bishop, K. (2017). Black box, white cube: fifty shades of gray? Art magazine, 103, 13-49. Retrieved from https://moscowartmagazine.com/issue/64/article/1349
3. Bourdieu, P. (2007). Physical and social spaces: Penetration and appropriation. Sociology of social space. Trans. from French. Responsible editor N. Shmatko, 49-63. Moscow: Aletheya.
4. Zharmukhambet, M.E., & Kalakova, G.K. (2019). Action research as a tool for increasing the professional competence of a teacher; research in action as a tool for increasing the professional competence of a teacher. Economics and Society, 6(61). Retrieved from https://www.iupr.ru/_files/ugd/b06fdc_e31f6b0232874cd9855109ab4dbf6364.pdf?index=true
5. Kopelyanskaya, N. A. (2012). Instead of a preface. Museum as an educational space: game, dialogue, culture of participation, 2-4. Moscow: Museum solutions.
6. Krotova, A.S., & Adaspaeva, N.M. (2016). "Action research" as a strategy for increasing the effectiveness of a modern teacher’s own activities. European research, 1(12), 95-98. Retrieved from https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_25409731_92971169.pdf
7. Osminkin, R.S. (2020). Collective forms of artistic performance in Russia at the beginning of the 21st century. Abstract of the dissertation for the degree of candidate. arts. St. Petersburg: Russian State Pedagogical University named after A.I. Herzen.
8. Feshchenko, T.S., & Shestakova L.A. (2017). Convergent approach in school education-new opportunities for the future. MNIZH, 11-2(65). Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.23670/IRJ.2017.65.127
9. Kharitonov, E.M. (2008). Khoruzhaya S.V. Imagery of meaning and the meaning of the image in culture. Cultural life of the South of Russia, 3. Retrieved from https://kjur.kgik1966.ru/arhiv
10. Kharlanova, E.N. (2009). Subject-environmental approach as a theoretical and methodological strategy for studying the development of social activity of future specialists. MNKO, 6(18), 134-137. Retrieved from http://amnko.ru/index.php/russian/journals/
11. Evalle, V.D. (2019). Interactivity and immersion in the media environment. On the problem of delimiting concepts. Artistic culture, 3, 247-271. doi:10.24411/2226-0072-2019-00033
12. Evalle, V.D. (2023). Phenomenon of poly-screen. Moscow: Kanon+ ROOI "Rehabilitation".
13. Kopytin, A.I. (Ed). (2019). Ecological and environmental approaches in art therapy. Moscow: Kogito-Center.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The article "Interactive video installation "Children of the Noughties": convergent approach in education & collective Performance" is submitted for review. The work is a review of theoretical research and an analysis of the methodological approach used. The subject of the study. The work is aimed at conducting an artistic and pedagogical experiment on the basis of the Institute of Human Philosophy of the Herzen State Pedagogical University in the form of a group immersive exhibition "Children of the Noughties". The authors and creators were a creative team consisting of a teacher and students. The main purpose of the exhibition was the culture of childhood in Russia in the first decade of the 21st century. This is the period when the students spent their childhood. Since the theme of the exhibition was indirectly devoted to the biography of students, the main exhibition statement was the self-presentation of the authors through the optics of nostalgia for childhood. Research methodology. The author analyzed a number of scientific research papers that considered the problem raised. The following approaches of scientists were presented: - a convergent approach, implying the absence of interdisciplinary boundaries between scientific and technological knowledge; - research method in action: problem definition, data collection, data analysis; activity based on the received data; reflection; - the subject-environment approach, actively used in modern higher school pedagogy, art therapy and art pedagogy; the theory of cultural capital and social space by Pierre Bourdieu. The main research methods are: formal descriptive and structural-typological methods of describing and analyzing an artistic and pedagogical experiment, sociological methods of specific research: case study, included observation, focused survey, anonymous questionnaire; the method of total performative audio-musical installation of the "black box" type. The relevance of research. The problem raised in the article is significant. The author notes that the relevance of the research is due to the performative and psychological turns in art and social sciences, the increased interest in art pedagogy and art therapy, as well as new requirements for modern museum and exhibition activities and the educational environment of universities. It is important to introduce a convergent approach in the educational space. The scientific novelty of the research. The work carried out allowed the author to focus on finding effective approaches in the higher education system aimed at self-realization and self-development of modern students. Style, structure, content. The style of presentation corresponds to publications of this level. The language of the work is scientific. The structure of the work is traced, the author highlights the main semantic parts. There is logic in the work. The volume and content of the article meets the requirements for works of this level. This made it possible to fully disclose the subject of the study stated in the title of the article. The introductory section substantiates the significance of the event – the interactive video installation "Children of the Noughties". The author highlights the relevance, subject and features of this educational event. The main part defines the theoretical and methodological framework of the study, describes the features of the organization and conduct of interactive events. The author pays special attention to the choice of the exhibition space, the concept of the exposition, the preparation and implementation of the exhibition. At the end of the article, the author made a number of significant conclusions, which were formulated taking into account the results obtained during the sociological research. The bibliography of the article includes 11 domestic sources, there are no publications for the last three years. The list contains mainly articles and abstracts. In addition, there is also an abstract of the dissertation, monographs and educational publications. Sources are not designed correctly and uniformly in all positions (for example, 2, 5, etc.). Appeal to opponents. Recommendations: 1) to issue a bibliographic list in accordance with the requirements; 2) the theoretical analysis is incomplete, since insufficient attention has been paid to research works over the past 3-5 years; 3) it is necessary to develop recommendations for higher education institutions on the use of a convergent approach in education and interactive events involving a creative team consisting of teachers and students 4) demonstrate the effectiveness of the implementation of the proposed methodology by providing statistical results; 5) review the work for descriptions (for example, directoa) and syntactic inaccuracies. Conclusions. The problems of the topic are of undoubted relevance, theoretical and practical value; it will be of interest to specialists who deal with the problems of implementing a convergent approach/ collective performance in education. The author presented one of the approaches to its implementation: the use of an interactive video installation "Children of the Noughties". The article may be recommended for publication. At the same time, it is important to take into account the highlighted recommendations, analyze, among other things, modern developments and make appropriate changes. This will make it possible to submit scientific, methodological and research work to the editorial board, which is characterized by scientific novelty and practical significance.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the research in the presented article is an interactive video installation "Children of the Noughties" within the framework of a convergent approach in education and collective performance. The convergent approach, the subject-environment approach, the method of categorization, the "method of research in action" (Action research), "formal descriptive and structural typological methods of description and analysis of artistic and pedagogical experiment, as well as sociological methods of specific research were used in this article.-study, included observation, focused survey, anonymous questionnaire. In the field of designing the exhibition space, the method of total performative audio-musical installation of the "black box" type was used. The relevance of the article is beyond doubt, since video installation is one of the directions of modern art, and the experience of the A.I. Herzen Russian State Pedagogical University described by the author of using the video installation "Children of the Noughties" in the educational process is unique and innovative. The scientific novelty of the research lies in an in-depth analysis using the author's methodology and a detailed description of the interactive video installation "Children of the Noughties" within the framework of a convergent approach in education and collective performance. In general, the article is written in the language of scientific style with the competent use in the text of the study of the presentation of various positions of scientists to the problem under study and the use of scientific terminology characterizing the subject of the study, however, there are some paragraphs in the text of the article, they are presented descriptively and narratively, but unscientifically. The structure is designed taking into account the basic requirements for writing scientific articles, the structure of this study can be distinguished such elements as the introductory part (with the definition of relevance and the subject of the study), the definition of the theoretical and methodological framework of the study, the main part (the choice of the exhibition space as a socio-psychological problem, the concept of the exposition, the preparation of the exhibition / collective performance, opening and holding of the exhibition), conclusions and bibliography. The content of the article reflects its structure. In particular, the author's emphasis on the fact that "the process of preparing the exhibition has become a platform for active communication between participants in the exhibition process on the one hand and a dialogue between the student audience and teachers on the other. Being the creators of the exhibition project, the students simultaneously played the role of museum staff, artists and the public involved in art mediation and participatory practices aimed not at passive perception, but at the active role of the viewer in creating and transforming the exhibition space, involving attention to the visitor's motivation, psychological and cognitive needs [5]. At the same time, the collective performance for the preparation of the exhibition extended beyond the training sessions, involving students from other groups and parents in communication to collect objects and photographs." The bibliography contains 13 sources, including domestic periodicals and non-periodicals. The article describes various positions and points of view of scientists characterizing the features of video installation in contemporary art. The article contains an appeal to various scientific works and sources devoted to this topic, which is included in the circle of scientific interests of researchers dealing with this issue. The presented study contains conclusions concerning the subject area of the study. In particular, it is noted that "the conducted artistic and pedagogical experiment has shown the effectiveness of combining a convergent approach with the method of "research in action" (Action research) and can be recommended when organizing and conducting interactive events by a creative team consisting of students and teachers in higher education and museum pedagogy when working with the public." The materials of this study are intended for a wide range of readers, they can be interesting and used by scientists for scientific purposes, teaching staff in the educational process, employees of ministries, departments and organizations responsible for culture and art, employees of theaters and museums, specialists in working with students, cultural scientists, art historians, psychologists, sociologists, by analysts and experts. As disadvantages of this study, it should be noted that there are typos and technical errors in the text of the article. Special attention should be paid to the title of the article, where an error was made in the word "video installation", the word is written together. In addition, it would be advisable to abandon the "&" sign in the title of the article and replace it with an analog in Russian. The structural elements of the article, which undoubtedly make up its content, should be outlined more concisely and concisely, and the text of the article should be supplemented with an introduction and a generalizing conclusion and not limited only to the conclusions of the research. Some paragraphs of the article, especially those from which the article begins, are written descriptively, narratively, and unscientifically, therefore it is necessary to pay attention to the style of presentation of the text. These shortcomings do not reduce the scientific and practical significance of the study itself, but they must be promptly eliminated and the article sent for revision.

Third Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

In the journal Culture and Art, the author presented his article "Interactive video installation "Children of the Noughties": a convergent approach in education and collective performance", which presents the materials and conclusions of a cultural study of the university art project "Children of the Noughties", which combines elements of a pedagogical experiment, collective performance and a theatrical immersive multimedia art exhibition. The author proceeds from the study of this issue from the fact that the exhibition "Children of the Noughties" is a full-fledged artistic, educational and scientific project created as a model of working with students within the university environment, the purpose of which is to acquire professional competencies by participants, consolidate the knowledge gained during the passage of such disciplines as "Modern technologies in museum activities", "Methods and technologies of the organization of the exposition and exhibition space", "Museum art pedagogy", "Sociology of museum and theater audience", etc. Therefore, the practical significance lies in the fact that the concept of this project can be recommended when organizing and conducting interactive events by a creative team consisting of students and teachers in higher education and museum pedagogy when working with the public. Unfortunately, the article lacks a theoretical component, which should contain a bibliographic analysis, an analysis of the scientific validity of the problem. The theoretical basis was the provisions of the works of such researchers as Bourdieu P., Osminkin R.S., Feshchenko T.S., Shestakova L.A. and others. The scientific novelty lies in the description of the experiment, the result of which was the exhibition project "Children of the Noughties". The purpose of this study is to describe and analyze the stages of preparation and implementation of an exhibition project created using the principles of multiscreen and interactivity by a creative team consisting of a group of students and a teacher. The subject of the research is an artistic and pedagogical experiment of the Institute of Human Philosophy of the Herzen State Pedagogical University in the form of a group immersive exhibition "Children of the Noughties", the authors and creators of which are a creative team consisting of a teacher and 15 students. The convergent and subject-environment approach was chosen by the head teacher as the theoretical and methodological basis of the project. These approaches allowed the author to define research methods: formal descriptive and structural-typological methods of describing and analyzing artistic and pedagogical experiment, as well as sociological methods of specific research: case study, included observation, focused survey, anonymous questionnaire. In the field of designing the exhibition space, the method of total performative audiovisual installation of the "black box" type was used. In the study, the author relies on the theory of cultural capital and social space by Pierre Bourdieu. The empirical basis of the research was an exhibition project developed and implemented by the second graduate of cultural educators who studied under the new module "Museum and Theater Pedagogy" at the turn of the Year of Teacher and Mentor and the Year of Family. In the article, the author provides a detailed description of the stages of preparation and implementation by students under the guidance of a teacher of an exhibition and art educational project: selection and coordination of premises for the exhibition, development of the concept of the exhibition, the process of preparing the exhibition, the degree of involvement of student participants, design and opening of the exhibition. The author presents the conclusions he made based on the results of this experiment. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing a topic for analysis, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of the process of formation and application of a certain technique in art education is of undoubted theoretical and practical cultural interest and can serve as a source of further research. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. An adequate choice of methodological base also contributes to this. The bibliographic list of the study consists of 13 sources, which seems clearly sufficient for generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the studied problem. The text of the article is designed mainly in a scientific style, but needs correction, as it contains minor errors and typos. The author fulfilled his goal, received certain scientific results that allowed him to summarize the material. It should be stated that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication after these shortcomings have been eliminated.