Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Culture and Art
Reference:

Exploring the origins and early development of Chinese military bands

Zhang Sho

PhD in Art History

Postgraduate Student, Department of History music, Dmitri Hvorostovsky Siberian State Academy of Arts

22 Lenin Street, Krasnoyarsk, 660049, Russia, Krasnoyarsk region

zhangshuosax@163.com

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0625.2024.5.70749

EDN:

EPIJJU

Received:

15-05-2024


Published:

02-06-2024


Abstract: Chinese military music plays a significant role in cultural and historical traditions, serving not only as a means of communication during war but also as a vital component of national identity. Studying military music reflects the changes in China's political structures, technological advancements, and international influences, providing deep insights into the socio-political history of China. By analyzing military music, we can trace the impact of cultural exchanges and interactions with other nations and cultures on Chinese musical traditions. This research explores the origins and early development of martial music in ancient China and how these bands reflected and influenced China's cultural traditions and socio-political history, revealing the evolution of martial music through various historical periods. It examines how these changes interacted with political structures, technological progress, and international influences. Employing historical documentary analysis and musicological research, the study investigates the multiple roles of military music in state ceremonies, public celebrations, and on the battlefield. The scientific novelty of this study lies in its systematic integration of musicology, history, and cultural studies to comprehensively understand the origins and early development of wind music in ancient China. It analyzes the evolution of national wind music and its roles in society from a multidimensional perspective, demonstrating how marching band music reflects and influences philosophical, religious, and cultural concepts throughout Chinese history. This approach not only deepens our understanding of specific aspects of Chinese musical culture but also contributes to a broader comprehension of music's influence on social processes and identity.


Keywords:

Military Music, Cultural Traditions, Socio-Political History, Confucian Thought, Evolution of Music, Ritual Functions, Cultural Exchange, Silk Road, Historical Documentary Analysis, Musicological Analysis

This article is automatically translated.

Introduction

Military music plays a significant role in the cultural and historical tradition of China, acting not only as a means of communication during military operations, but also as an important element of national identity. Studying military music allows for a deeper understanding of China's socio-political history, as it reflects changes in the political structure, technological progress and international influences. Analyzing military music, one can trace how cultural exchanges and interactions with other peoples and cultures influenced the Chinese musical tradition.[1]

Military bands have a long history that varies across cultures. In Russia, for example, they are often associated with marching music, which played an important role in the moral and psychological support of the troops.[2] In China, military bands not only accompanied ceremonial events, but also became an integral part of rituals and folk festivals, reflecting the philosophical, religious and cultural characteristics of the country. The study of the international development of military orchestras allows us to take a fresh look at the unique aspects of Chinese musical practice.

The main purpose of this study is to investigate the origin and early stages of the development of Chinese military bands, as well as to assess their impact on Chinese cultural traditions and identity. To achieve this goal, the following tasks were set: To analyze historical sources to identify the first mentions of Chinese military bands. To assess the development of military bands in various historical periods and their role in public and political life. To study the musical instruments that form the basis of military orchestras and the changes in their use depending on the historical context. To consider the influence of external cultures on the formation and development of Chinese military orchestras. Thus, the study not only deepens the understanding of specific aspects of Chinese musical culture, but also contributes to a broader understanding of the influence of music on social processes and identity.

Research methodology

The research methodology proposed in this paper is an interdisciplinary approach combining historical-documentary and musicological analysis. In particular, this methodology uses historical documentary research to track and analyze the origin and development of Chinese military music in various historical periods, and combines them with musicological analysis to study changes in the form, function and socio-cultural significance of this military music. This methodological approach is partly based on historical and analytical methods commonly used in previous studies, for example, based on Fan Qi's study[7] of the art of military music during the periods of Spring and Autumn and Warring States, which focuses on understanding through historical documents how cultural and political structures influenced the development of musical forms. In addition, by introducing a musicological analysis based on Zhang's analysis[12] on the creation of musical modes in ancient Chinese music, the article adds a specific study of music itself, including types of instruments, music structure and performance styles, which allows for a more complete understanding of the role and significance of music in history and culture. Thus, the methodology of the article is based on historical research, which has been analyzed in detail with the help of musicology, which made it possible to create a comprehensive research perspective that goes beyond documenting historical events and includes an assessment of the social and cultural influence of music. This interdisciplinary methodology allows us to explore how military music reflects and shapes social identity and cultural exchanges.

The historical roots of Chinese military bands

The history of Chinese military bands goes back to ancient times.[5] The records on "divination bones" and bronze products from the time of the Shang Dynasty (about 1600-1046 BC) contain the first mentions of the use of music in a military context. Musical instruments of that era, such as drums and bells, were used not only for signaling, but also to inspire troops and intimidate the enemy. These tools have played an important role in shaping military traditions and ceremonies, which have become an integral part of military strategy.

Figure 1. Four Tigers Bronze Bo,

Source: https://www.hnmuseum.com/zh-hans/zuixintuijie/W020220830409134897989

Figure 2. A copper drum from Chongyang

A source:http://www.hubei.gov.cn/jmct/gcww/202208/t20220830_4284951.shtml

During the reign of the Shang and Zhou dynasties, music occupied a central place in state and military rituals.[6] Musical accompaniment was a mandatory attribute during sacrifices and other ritual actions. During the Zhou Dynasty (about 1046-256 BC), music education became part of the mandatory training program for noble men, including military leaders, which emphasized the role of music in the cultural and moral education of the individual. Compositions that could influence the morale of troops and strengthen discipline were especially appreciated.

With the emergence and establishment of Confucian ideas, music acquired a new meaning in the context of social structure and state ideology. Confucius (551-479 BC) considered music to be an important means of education and self-improvement, as well as a tool for harmonizing society. In his teaching, music was associated with order and harmony, which was reflected in the military sphere. Military bands began to use music not only for military manipulation, but also as a means of training and educating soldiers, helping to strengthen loyalty and discipline.

Each of these aspects highlights not only the historical significance of music in China's military affairs, but also its deep relationship with the cultural and philosophical traditions of the country. Military bands thus become a mirror of the social structure and cultural priorities of various historical periods.

The development of military bands during the dynasties

The military bands of the Han Dynasty (206 BC – 220 AD) played a significant role in both ceremonial and combat life. They included a wide range of wind, string and percussion instruments such as metal timpani, wooden flutes and drums of various sizes.[3] This made it possible to create a multifaceted sound corresponding to the scale and significance of state events. The main functions of the orchestras covered signaling (announcing the beginning of important events), motivational (raising the morale of troops) and ceremonial tasks (accompanying state rituals), as well as coordinating the movements of troops on the battlefield. Rhythmic and marching melodies helped to maintain the formation and rhythm of the army's movement. During the Tang (618-907) and Song (960-1279) dynasties, Chinese culture was enriched by the influence of neighboring states, which was reflected in the composition of military bands. New instruments such as Persian drums and Indian flutes were introduced, enriching the sound of orchestras. The repertoire has expanded due to melodies popular in Central Asia, giving the music an exotic and diverse character.[10] The melodies became more complex and melodic, moving away from the strict marching rhythms of earlier periods. During the Ming (1368-1644) and Qing (1644-1912) dynasties, military bands were further structured, reflecting the increased centralization of power. Musical compositions of these times were strictly regulated, musical forms became more monumental and emphasized the greatness and power of the empire, being used to demonstrate power in the international arena and in diplomatic missions. Confucian philosophy continued to influence military music in China, considering music to be a means of educating the moral qualities of warriors. Musical compositions were supposed to promote harmony and order in society, which was reflected in the strict structure of musical compositions and attention to detail of performance. This influence is evident in the strict hierarchy and discipline of military bands, which became a reflection of Confucian ideals of order and harmony. These aspects show how cultural, political and philosophical changes have influenced the development of military music in China over various historical periods, each of which has left its own unique imprint on the musical practice of military orchestras.

Instruments and musical repertoire

Chinese military bands have traditionally used a wide range of musical instruments, which can be classified by type: brass, strings and percussion. Among the wind instruments, various flutes are particularly distinguished, such as didju () and sheng (?), which were used to produce high, shrill sounds characteristic of military signals. Stringed instruments included such as xie (?) and guzheng (), which were used in more solemn and calm moments. Percussion instruments such as drums and gongs were key to maintaining rhythm and coordination of movements during marches and battles.[13]

Over the course of history, the composition of orchestras has evolved, reflecting both internal cultural changes and external influences. For example, during the Tang Dynasty, the advent of Persian and Indian instruments such as drums and flutes greatly expanded the sound capabilities of orchestras.

The musical repertoire of military orchestras is closely related to their functions. During the ceremonies, compositions were performed that emphasized the status and power of the emperor, such as "King Qin breaks through the front line." During the Tang dynasty, "King Qin breaks through the front line" not only as music, but also as a tool of political propaganda designed to strengthen the legitimacy of government.[8] These compositions had pronounced marching rhythms and sublime melodies, emphasizing the greatness and power of the dynasty. In the context of combat, the repertoire of the orchestras included signal melodies that were used to coordinate tactical maneuvers, for example, "Attack" or "Retreat". The majestic and awe-inspiring nature of imperial power was reflected in complex phrasing and large-scale arrangements, and the emphasis on dramatic shifts and powerful blows emphasized the determination and impregnability of the empire. The scores of that time often used brass and bass drums to create loud and impressive sounds, symbolizing the strength and unity of the empire. The construction of melodies makes maximum use of the resonance of these instruments to create a majestic and solemn sound. An analysis of the notation of these works shows that the use of different intervals and rhythmic patterns reflects the need for military discipline and organization, which were important for military operations at that time.

562d58c941665

Figure 3. King Qin breaks through the front line

A source:https://www.qupu123.com/Mobile-view-id-335522.html

The symbolic significance of these compositions lies in their ability to influence the morale of soldiers, strengthen discipline and unity, as well as demonstrate the cultural identity of the nation. Foreign influences have had a significant impact on Chinese orchestral practice, especially during periods of active international contacts. An example is the period of the Tang Dynasty, when musical styles and instruments from Central Asia and Persia penetrated into China through the Silk Road. This has led to the enrichment of the musical language of military orchestras and the emergence of new genres and forms that have been adapted for ceremonial and military use. Thus, the study of instruments, musical repertoire and external influences allows for a deeper understanding of how changes in orchestral practice reflected broad socio-cultural processes in China.[11]

The socio-cultural significance of military bands

The music of military bands acted as a powerful tool to influence the emotional state of soldiers. During the Han Dynasty, music was used not only to coordinate actions on the battlefield, but also to maintain the morale of troops. The performance of battle hymns and marches helped to maintain a high level of morale of soldiers, especially at critical moments of battles. Research shows that music promotes the release of endorphins, which can reduce feelings of pain and fatigue.[9] For example, before the Battle of Kaohsiung in 202 BC, military bands performed motivating melodies, which, according to historians, significantly increased the morale of Liu Bang's troops.

Military bands were not only a means to wage war, but also a channel for cultural exchange. As the orchestras moved with the armies across various regions of China, they spread musical styles and instruments that were found in one area among the peoples of other regions. During the Tang Dynasty, when China was heavily influenced by foreign cultures, military orchestras adapted and incorporated elements of these cultures into their repertoire, such as the use of Central Asian stringed instruments. This contributed to the formation of a more global musical perception and understanding of cultural diversity.

Military conflicts inevitably influenced the development of musical practices of military orchestras.[4] During periods of war, for example, during the Mongol conquests, Chinese military orchestras encountered the musical traditions of the Mongols, which led to the exchange of musical techniques and instruments. This, in turn, led to the creation of new musical forms that were adapted for use in the Chinese military. For example, special marches were developed to coordinate cavalry attacks, which greatly improved the tactical effectiveness of cavalry on the battlefield.

These aspects illustrate the deep relationship between military bands and cultural, social, and military changes in Chinese society. Military bands not only accompanied military operations, but also actively participated in the formation of cultural identity, promoting cultural exchange and adaptation to new conditions as a result of military conflicts.

Conclusion

In the course of this study, the key aspects of the development of military orchestras in China, starting from ancient times and ending with the last dynasties, were considered. The main focus was on the evolution of musical instruments, changes in the musical repertoire and the impact of cultural and historical events on the practice of military orchestras. It was found that military bands not only helped to strengthen the morale and discipline of the troops, but also served as a bridge for cultural exchange and integration of various musical traditions.

Military bands have been of great importance in the history of China. They were not only a tool of military administration and communication, but also a means of spreading cultural ideals such as Confucian morality and state ideology. Orchestras contributed to the formation of national identity and unity, emphasizing the role of music as a universal language that could bring together different segments of the population and cultural groups. The music of military bands reflected not only technical and creative achievements, but also political changes in the country.Military bands have played an important role in China's social and cultural history, and studying military bands offers a unique perspective on Chinese history and culture. Continued research in this area promises to lead to new discoveries and a deeper understanding of the influence of music on social processes.

Further research in the field of military orchestras may include in-depth analysis of the impact of specific historical events (for example, wars and political changes) on the musical practice of orchestras. In addition, a promising area may be the study of the interaction of Chinese military orchestras with the musical traditions of other countries and cultures. This will allow us to gain a more complete understanding of the process of cultural exchange and assimilation in a global context. Finally, in the future, it may be possible to conduct an in-depth analysis of the various historical processes associated with national marching bands.

References
1. Gen-Ir, Wu G Yi Wu. (2009). Formation of musical culture in Ancient China. Izvestia of the Russian State Pedagogical University named after AI Herze, 89, 139-147.
2. Gorbunova, L Yu. (2019). Military music in the history of the Russian army. Scientific Bulletin of the Volsk Military Institute of Material Support: a military-scientific journal, 2, 188-192.
3. Dong, S. (2020). Visible Music in the Images of Ancient Chinese Statuettes of the Han and Tang Epochs. Vesnik Belaruskogo dzyarzhaunarstvennogo universtitet kultura i mastatsutstvau, 1, 143-148.
4. Yinghong, F, & Nifontova, O I. (2024). Transformation of traditional Chinese music under the influence of Western music in the Qing Dynasty. Scientific Result. Social and Humanities Research, 10(1), 31-138.
5. Miao, W. (2022). Chinese music of military themes as an object of research.
6. Fang, X, & Jichao, W. (2014). Ritual and ceremonial music in China: bronze items of the Shang and Zhou eras from Hubei Province and the uniqueness of Chinese culture. Society and State in China, 44(1), 74-95.
7. Fan, Qi. (2016). Research on military music art in the period of Spring and Fall and Warring States. Music Composition, 9, 131-133.
8. Jing, C. (2016). Functioning of the system of music education in China during the Tang Dynasty. Music Education and Science, 1(4), 14-17.
9. Qi, C. (2015). Art in the structure of Russian and Chinese palace art culture: a comparative analysis.
10. Jiang, Shanshan, & Zhou, Maojiang. (2015). Preliminary research on the development of Western-style military music in contemporary China.Modern Communications: second half of the month, 12, 76-77.
11. Chen, G. (2021). Historical aspects of the formation of music education in China. World of Science, Culture, Education, 4(89), 297-300.
12. Zhang, J. The way of creating ancient Chinese musical literature. Linnan Journal of Chinese Studies, 16(1), 5.
13. Yan, Y. (2018). Formation of the Chinese orchestra of traditional instruments of a new type in 1920-1930. Problems of interdependence of mysticism, pedagogy and theory and practice of education, 50, 165-180.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the research in the article submitted for publication in the journal Culture and Art ("Research on the origin and early development of Chinese military orchestras"), as presented in the title and emphasized in the goal setting, is the early period in the historical development of Chinese military orchestras; accordingly, the historical process of development of Chinese military orchestras is the object of the author's attention. The author consistently solves a set of scientific and cognitive tasks. The article analyzes historical sources with the first mentions of Chinese military bands. In particular, the author emphasized that the first mentions of military orchestras in the ancient history of China can be found on bronze products from the time of the Shang Dynasty (about 1600-1046 BC). Consistently revealing individual historical periods of the development of Chinese military orchestras, the author evaluates their role in public and political life, pays attention to the evolution of musical and instrumental composition of orchestras and changes in the use of musical instruments depending on the cultural and historical context. The author examines the influence of cultural exchange on the formation and development of Chinese military orchestras. In general, the study deepens the understanding of specific aspects of Chinese musical culture, contributes to a broader understanding of the influence of music on social processes and identity in Chinese history. Summarizing the scientific literature allowed the author to establish that "military orchestras not only contributed to strengthening the morality and discipline of the troops, but also served as a bridge for cultural exchange and integration of various musical traditions." The author's final conclusion that "military bands played a significant role in the socio-cultural history of China, and their study provides a unique perspective on understanding Chinese history and culture" is well-founded and deserves theoretical attention. Thus, the subject of the study was disclosed by the author at a theoretical level sufficient for publication in the journal Culture and Art. The author does not pay special attention to the research methodology, although it is quite obvious that the work is based on a summary of a brief review of the special scientific literature on the chosen topic. The strong side of the methodological support of the research is the strict logic of its general program: The narrative is subordinated to the logic of presenting the results of solving a previously described set of scientific and cognitive tasks to achieve a specific goal. In general, the work has the character of problematizing an interesting topic. The author has coped with the task of attracting theoretical attention to research on the origin and early development of Chinese military orchestras and quite reasonably concludes that "continued research in this area promises new discoveries and a deeper understanding of the influence of music on social processes." The author explains the relevance of the chosen topic by saying that military music plays a significant role in the cultural and historical tradition of China, acting as a means of communication during military operations and an important element of national identity. Therefore, "studying military music allows for a deeper understanding of China's socio-political history, as it reflects changes in the political structure, technological progress and international influences." The scientific novelty of the work, which consists primarily in the explication into the Russian historical and cultural discourse of the corpus of special scientific literature on the history of military orchestras in China, deserves trust. The author tried to maintain the scientific style of the text, but it is necessary to correct the style of design of references to sources in the text of the article: square brackets with references to sources in the text are part of the previous sentence, therefore, the dot in the sentence is not placed before the square bracket, but after it. The structure of the article follows the strict logic of presenting the results of scientific research. The bibliography reveals the problem area of the study at a minimum sufficient level. The reviewer recommends that the author actively include in future planned publications an assessment of the interest not only of Chinese scientists in the history of military bands, but also of theorists from different countries. The appeal to the opponents is minimal, but it is quite correct. The article is of interest to the readership of the magazine "Culture and Art" and after finalizing the design flaws found, it can be recommended for publication.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

In the journal "Culture and Art", the author presented his article "Research on the origin and early development of Chinese military orchestras", which provides an overview of the stages of formation of methods of performing and applying military music in ancient China. The author proceeds in studying this issue from the fact that military music plays an important role in the cultural and historical tradition of China, acting not only as a means of communication during military operations, but also as an important element of national identity. The study of military music allowed the author to better understand the socio-political history of China, as it reflects changes in the political structure, technological progress and international influences. In China, military bands not only accompanied ceremonial events, but also became an integral part of rituals and folk festivals, reflecting the philosophical, religious and cultural characteristics of the country. The relevance of the research is due to the fact that the analysis of the formation of the military musical genre allows us to trace the influence of cultural exchanges and interactions with other peoples and cultures on the Chinese musical tradition and take a fresh look at the unique aspects of Chinese musical practice. The purpose of the article is to study the origin and early stages of the development of Chinese military bands, as well as to assess their impact on Chinese cultural traditions and identity. To achieve this goal, the author set the following tasks: analysis of historical sources to identify the first mentions of Chinese military orchestras; assessment of the development of military orchestras in various historical periods and their role in public and political life; study of musical instruments that form the basis of military orchestras and changes in their use depending on the historical context; consideration of the influence of external cultures on the formation and development of Chinese military bands. The methodological basis was made up of an integrated approach that included both general scientific methods of analysis and synthesis, as well as historical, musicological and socio-cultural analysis. The theoretical basis was the works of such foreign and Russian researchers as Nifontova O.I., Fan Qi, Jing Ch. and others . The empirical material was samples of ancient Chinese musical instruments and notations of military musical works. Unfortunately, the author has not analyzed the scientific validity of the problem, and it is difficult to conclude from the text of the article about the scientific novelty and practical significance of the study. As the author states, the first mentions of the use of music in a military context date back to about 1600-1046 BC. Musical instruments of that era, such as drums and bells, were used not only for signaling, but also to inspire troops and intimidate the enemy. These tools have played an important role in shaping military traditions and ceremonies, which have become an integral part of military strategy. The author examines the relationship between military music and Confucian ideas in the context of social structure and state ideology. Confucius (551-479 BC) considered music to be an important means of education and self-improvement, as well as a tool for harmonizing society. In the teachings of Confucius, music was associated with order and harmony, which was reflected in the military sphere, as military orchestras began to use music not only for military manipulation, but also as a means of training and educating soldiers, contributing to strengthening loyalty and discipline. Noting the socio-cultural factors, the author makes the assumption that military orchestras were not only a means of waging war, but also a channel of cultural exchange. As the orchestras moved with the armies across various regions of China, they spread musical styles and instruments that were found in one area among the peoples of other regions. Using the example of the Tang Dynasty, when China was strongly influenced by foreign cultures, the author shows that military orchestras adapted and included elements of these cultures in their repertoire, such as the use of Central Asian stringed instruments, which contributed to the formation of a more global musical perception and understanding of cultural diversity. In conclusion, the author presents a conclusion on the conducted research, which contains all the key provisions of the presented material. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing a topic for analysis, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of the process of formation and formation of cultural art trends of certain peoples is of undoubted theoretical and practical cultural interest and can serve as a source of further research. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. This is also facilitated by an adequate choice of an appropriate methodological framework. The bibliography of the study consisted of 13 sources, including foreign ones, which seems sufficient for generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the subject under study. It seems that the author has fulfilled his goal, received certain scientific results that made it possible to summarize the material. It should be noted that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication.