Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

PHILHARMONICA. International Music Journal
Reference:

The study of works for voice and piano dedicated to Special military operation by future conductors of a military orchestra

Platonova Alina Aleksandrovna

ORCID: 0000-0001-8088-0797

PhD in Art History

Senior Lecturer, Military Institute (Military Conductors), Department 46 (piano), Prince Alexander Nevsky Military University of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation

107150, Russia, Moscow, Boitsovaya str., 18 building 14, sq. 31

alina_platonova@mail.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2453-613X.2024.4.70190

EDN:

UAOEQC

Received:

21-03-2024


Published:

10-12-2024


Abstract: The subject of the study are works for voice and piano, which are part of the collection "Voices of the Motherland", published following the results of the All-Russian creative competition of composers and poets for composing a patriotic song. The object of the study is the military-patriotic repertoire of the XX–XXI centuries. Special attention is paid to the issues of professional mastery of the skills of careful piano accompaniment by future military brass band conductors, namely: reading sheet music, feeling the balance between soloist and accompanist, understanding dynamic, articulatory, dramatic tasks, overcoming pianistic difficulties. Addressing the topic of military-patriotic songs by modern authors is becoming particularly relevant in our time, supporting the strength of the spirit of military personnel and civilians, preserving spiritual and moral values and contributing to the musical and aesthetic education of Russian citizens. The novelty of the research lies in the study of a new military-patriotic repertoire in the context of the development of piano accompaniment skills by future conductors of a military brass band. The studied methodological works of the luminaries of the national school of pianism, devoted to the problems of working in the accompaniment class, were used as a theoretical basis used in the analysis of the works of modern composers who compiled the collection "Voices of the Motherland". The updated repertoire created over the past few years, which included military songs by modern composers dedicated to a special military operation, enriched the existing methodological material of the department 46 (piano) Military Institute (military Conductors) The Military University made it possible to expand the thematic and imaginative spectrum, contributing to the introduction of acutely modern and topical topics into the program.


Keywords:

Piano, accompaniment, accompanist, Conductor, Vocal, Pianist, Military Brass Band, Repertoire, patriot, Musician

This article is automatically translated.

"War is all transitory, but music is eternal"

(k/f "Only old men go into battle")

The formation of interest in the history of the emergence and development of the genre of military song is an urgent task of modern musical art. The promotion of the values of Russian culture, ideals and goals of the Russian army is important for the civilian population and participants in a Special military operation. The problem of patriotic education of the generation never loses its relevance, especially becoming more acute in recent years. It is important to focus the interest of the younger generation on such concepts as love of the Motherland, ancestral traditions, and the revival of spirituality. The works of many scientists and teachers emphasized the importance of civic and patriotic education through music [3, 11, 12, 14]. For example, T.A. Kashtanova suggests focusing on the creative heritage of Russian and Soviet composers, which can form a sense of pride in the great culture and art of our country [10, p. 70], E.P. Gorchakov believes that "the formation of patriotic consciousness among modern youth is generally associated with the peculiarities of youth culture. Music is considered as a cultural code and therefore it directly affects the formation of national identity, patriotism, and national consciousness" [4, p. 185]. M.A. Khalilov notes: "Music has the ability to influence the value orientations of each person in a unique way" [15, p. 65]. K.S. Gritsenko and N.O. Podporinov emphasizes: "Music is of paramount importance in fostering a sense of patriotism – in particular, song as an effective means of influencing the sensual and value sphere of a person. Vocal works about military exploits, heroes and, of course, victory have a strong positive effect on patriotic feeling" [7, p. 216].

There are many songs on military-patriotic themes that have become truly popular, have earned great popularity and love: "Holy War" (music by A.V. Alexandrov, words by V. Lebedev-Kumach), "My Beloved" (music by M. Blanter, words by E. Dolmatovsky), "Random Waltz" (music by M. Fradkin, words by E. Dolmatovsky), "In the frontline forest" (music by M. Blanter, words by M. Isakovsky), "The Last Battle" (music and words by M. Nozhkin) and many others. These songs have a huge emotional impact, preserve the memory of the exploits of the people, promote national unification and support the strength of the spirit of the population.

The new age dictates new conditions and ways to foster patriotic feelings. One of these ways may be to address the topic of military-patriotic songs written in recent years in connection with a Special military operation. Following the results of the All-Russian creative competition of composers and poets for composing a patriotic song, with the support of the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation, a collection "Voices of the Motherland" was created, which included the 50 best works of authorship presented by the contestants. These include songs accompanied by piano, guitar, instrumental ensemble and orchestra, as well as choral compositions. The works from this collection can become an aid for the development and preservation of spiritual and moral values and the promotion of musical and aesthetic education of Russian citizens. Of course, the methodological potential of the collection is of interest to teachers of different levels of education: from music schools to secondary and higher educational institutions. The author shares his personal experience gained in the course of conducting Piano lessons with future conductors of a military orchestra, but assumes the universality of the application of the results obtained.

The program of the Piano discipline of the Military Institute (military conductors) The Military University provides for the study of topic No. 6 "Accompaniments". The teaching material for cadets is piano parts of pieces for military brass band instruments and chamber vocal works. In classes on this topic, students gain the skill of accompanying vocal and instrumental compositions. The musical material is an educational and methodological manual of a military-patriotic orientation. In addition to the famous songs of the Great Patriotic War, which became classics, works from the collection "Voices of the Motherland" are used during classes, and can also serve later for concert performance, including those organized in conditions of their own.

S.L. Dzhioev, relying on the works of prominent researchers in the field of conducting, comes to the following conclusion: "Science recognizes the fact that there are specifics in the training of leaders of military orchestras. This specificity is determined by the functions of a military orchestra, such as: musical accompaniment of military drill, the performance of military rituals and ceremonies, educational and recreational functions" [8, p. 4-5]. One of the components of this specificity is the education of the orchestra members with whom the military conductor works, a sense of patriotism, military duty, honor, and conscientious performance of official duties.

For the harmonious development and formation of a military orchestra conductor, it is important to master a lot of necessary competencies, the most important of which is ensemble interaction in the process of performing a musical composition. The best help in the course of mastering this skill is the ability to competently and carefully accompany the soloist, fostering a sense of balance, overcoming pianistic difficulties associated with a quick understanding of dynamic, articulatory, dramatic tasks, the ability to read accurately and fluently from a sheet, simplifying the texture if necessary. E.M. Shenderovich directly points to the relationship and kinship of the functions of the concertmaster and conductor: "The accompanist needs a musical scope, a vision of the whole work, the form, the score consisting of three lines" [16, p. 12]. These problems can be solved by referring to the collection "Voices of the Motherland", which simultaneously allows the cadet to familiarize himself with the relevant, modern, patriotic repertoire.

The skill of fluent and accurate reading from a sheet plays a huge role in the activities of a musician of any specialization. It is equally important for the formation of the future conductor of the military brass band. E.M. Shenderovich emphasized: "This is an organic component of the overall musical and performing potential, and without this skill, no pianist (and not only a pianist) will be able to become a major musician-artist" [16, p. 61].

It is no coincidence that in individual lessons in the discipline of "Piano" at the Military Institute (military conductors), the problem is highlighted in a separate topic No. 2 "Reading from a sheet" and a sufficient number of academic hours are devoted to working on it. Often, this skill is poorly developed among students due to insufficient practice. Therefore, when developing the ability to read musical text from a sheet, it is important to teach how to perceive the material holistically, grasping it visually in large fragments, without breaking it into component parts in the form of individual notes or chords. The same way we perceive a literary text without dividing it into letters or syllables. Works for voice accompanied by piano are an invaluable help for the development of this skill, because the concertmaster often has at least three musical stands in front of his eyes and the most important task of the accompanist is to cover not only the material of his part, but also the soloist's part, otherwise the ensemble will not work. Therefore, at the initial stage of work, it is useful to choose texturally not very saturated essays, so as not to overload the student with an abundance of tasks. For example, these can be the songs "We are going to make peace" (words and music by A. Boyko), "About Russia" (words by V. Shchepetkov, music by A. Saversky), "I Believe in Russia" (words by V. Paevskaya, music by V. Saltanova), "Prayer (Song Waiting)" (words and music by N. Kapitanova), "I love you, country!" (words and music by S. Goryainov).

When playing from a sheet of paper, it is important to teach the student so that all his attention is focused on the three lines of music, and not only on the piano part. At the same time, the task should be performed not mechanically, but analyzing and thinking carefully, trying not to stop and reproduce the figurative and artistic idea of the composer. E.M. Shenderovich recommends at the initial stage of work to play the soloist's line with the right hand, and the bass line with the left, in order to gradually learn how to harmoniously fill the fabric with the figures of the right hand part. Why do you need to learn to cover the soloist's part at the same time? In order to be able to anticipate and anticipate his performing intentions related to agogy, dynamics and phrasing, the instructions of which are often written out in the soloist's part. As an example, the song "We are going to make peace" (words and music by A. Boyko) is suitable for working on this task, in which the piano part is presented in the form of long, stretching chords that allow you to cover the soloist's part without compromising the accompaniment.

Another useful exercise that E.M. Shenderovich advises for use in practice is reducing the texture to a chord vertical, that is, their reduction. It is useful to carry out such work in the songs "Prayer (Song of the Waiting One)" (words and music by N. Kapitanova), "I love you, country!" (words and music by S. Goryainov).

The main conditions for the development of the skill of reading from a sheet should be systematic and consistent. It is no coincidence that the outstanding musician I. Hoffman explained: "You need to play a lot from the sheet, and as quickly as possible, at least at first some inaccuracies crept in. With fast reading, you will develop the ability of the eye, as they say, to "grasp", and this, in turn, will make it easier for you to read the details" [6, p. 177].

In the process of working on the musical texture in accompaniments, it is necessary, first of all, to understand the axiom: the soloist is the leader, because he sets out the melody, which is the basis of the thematic material. V.N. Biktashev tirelessly emphasizes: "The main task of the concertmaster ... is not to interfere with the soloist! What does it mean not to interfere with the melody?… And what is a melody? The soul, the meaning of music, the main thing for which music in the vast majority of cases exists at all. Melody is the queen, melody is the face! Melody, if it is in the texture of a musical work, is its main element" [1, p. 11]. For example, in the song "About Russia" (words by V. Sakladova, music by A. Tadinov), after a fairly transparent and understandable accompaniment in the verse, the chorus follows, with a more saturated texture at the piano: arpeggiated right-hand figuration passes into the left-hand part, and accentuated chords are added instead. It is important to explain to the student that the musical text is often conditional, and the accents prescribed by the author, which require strict observance, nevertheless should not interrupt the main presentation of the material from the soloist. That is, these chords should be played with an emotional, semantic accent rather than a dynamic one, directly corresponding to the poetic text set forth by the vocalist. We encounter a similar situation in the song "Dmitry Donskoy" (words and music by M. Panisheva, arranged by I. Nokhrin): In the chorus, in order to convey the strong-willed, persistent image of Prince Donskoy and his most important goal of rallying and reuniting the Russian people against the Tatar-Mongol yoke, the vocalist's part is duplicated in octave doubling in the right hand, emphasizing the importance of the content. The accompanist, embodying the required decisive and strong image, should not forget about his subordinate and auxiliary function in relation to the soloist, without interfering with excessive forced sound production.

In many works there are polyphonic fragments saturated with undertones or independent melodic lines. In such cases, the student should be explained about the importance of independent lines, the ability to trace them, to tone them, but, again, not to the detriment of the vocalist's part, strictly observing the rule of priority of his musical material. For example, in the song "Our City" (words by V. Tolmachev, music by V. Cherny), in parallel with the presentation of the main melody, the vocalist has an independent theme in the right-hand part. Since it begins in the third octave, which does not differ in strong sonority, it will not be difficult to correctly build a balance in an ensemble with a soloist. However, the concertmaster faces another, no less important musical task – to photograph and tone this sub-voice in such a way that it does not fall apart into separate sounds, but lines up into a beautiful, soulful melody. Another example of a polyphonic presentation of the material can be the song "Oh, Motherland!" (words by R. Gamzatov, music by G. Kambarova). In this composition, in the chorus of the piano part, the moving figures represent independent melodic lines that help the soloist convey an enthusiastic, excited patriotic mood, as if finishing the unsaid.

In the course of further work on texture differentiation, teachers in classes with cadets should pay special attention to working on the bass line, its independence, understanding of the basic principles, intonation. There are often cases when the importance of this line is not given due attention, as a result of which the performance is deprived of a well-built balance, volume of sound, logic. V.N. Biktashev laments: "Oh, long-suffering, unrecognized, undisclosed, unvoiced bass! After all, he is essentially the foundation that carries the whole mass of musical texture on his shoulders, he is a support and a reliable haven in all the endless transformations, transformations, modulations and other cataclysms that can only occur in music!" [1, p. 22]. Explaining the fundamental nature of the bass voice, it is necessary in every possible way to protect the novice accompanist from forced, rude or formal, straightforward sound production, calling for instrumental analogies in the work, comparing the sound with double basses, bassoons, tubas – to work tirelessly on the required carcass. As examples of the pedagogical repertoire, one can cite the songs "About Russia!" (words by V. Shchepetkov, music by A. Saversky), "Only a cross is on him out of armor" (words by A. Shagin, music by O. Trunnikov). In the work "Prayer of a Soldier" (words by N. Balynskaya, music by P. Sergienko) and in the chorus of the song "Mother of Russia" (words by E. Kovalyuk, music by A. Yakush), the bass melody acquires special significance, introducing an element of polyphony, independence of the lower voice, which must be emphasized and worked out. Special attention should be paid to the problem of proper pedalization. Often, having learned how to use the lagging function of the right pedal, novice concertgoers leave it unchanged throughout the work. For example, in the chorus of the song "Mother of Russia" (words by E. Kovalyuk, music by A. Yakush), the rhythm and texture of the material change – the chord presentation turns into a gradual movement of the bass voice according to the sounds of arpeggios, abundantly supplied with non-chord sounds. At the same time, in the right-hand part, the vocal two-voice is duplicated by double notes. Many inexperienced performers continue to use a lagging pedal, similar to a couplet accompaniment, replacing a well-toned finger legato with an imaginary coloring and shading of the melody, outlined in double notes, with a pedal. The result is mud and cacophony. It is important to teach the figures in the right and left hands separately, carefully observing the vocalization and phrasing without the slightest attempt to press the pedal. And only then use it very carefully, strictly controlling the substitution and removal.

The next layer of texture that needs to be aligned with the overall vertical is harmonic filling. It can be diverse and multivariate in terms of rhythm and method of presentation: from "chord columns" (V.N. Biktashev's term), to arpeggiated or gamma-like sequences richly saturated with non-chord sounds. And here it is important to remind the student of the rule of priority of the soloist. The song "I believe in Russia!" (words by V. Paevskaya, music by V. Saltanova) can serve as an illustration of the presentation of the material using the so-called "chord pillars". In this work, it is important to ensure that the novice accompanist does not play these chords exactly like pillars, but tries to combine them into one musical phrase, thought, intoning each sound. It is useful to draw a parallel with the instruments of a symphonic or brass orchestra, the sound of which does not fade away, unlike the piano, but dynamically or phraseologically develops.

Often poorly learned harmonic filling is played heavily, clumsily and interferes with the presentation of the vocal part. Therefore, it is important to teach a novice concertmaster to properly treat his duties, to take a responsible approach to learning his part. For example, in the song "Prayer (Song of the Waiting One)" (words and music by N. Kapitanova) in the chorus, the chord accompaniment alternates with arpeggiated figurations, which are not very convenient at first glance. Here everything is solved by a well-chosen fingering and a responsible attitude to learning these fragments. In the song "Nikolai Masalov" (words and music by Elena Yatsenko), the piano part is replete with various technical elements: scale-like passages, rehearsals, constant changes of trioles to dotted lines. These figures also require competent and painstaking teaching.

Often in the works there is a peculiar, sometimes complex rhythm that carries a certain image, or shows a characteristic genre illustrating this image. For example, the song "Dedication" (words by F. Farisova, music by M. Khairullina) tells about the struggle for the eternal values of life and love. The author does not have the Hamlet question "To be or not to be?", her credo is "Of course to be!". Reflecting a persistent and strong-willed character, the accompaniment is set out in the spirit of perpetuum mobile, transmitting the energy and pulse of life, alternating with repetitive ostinate chords. V.N. Biktashev rightly emphasizes: "Rhythmic function is unthinkable without rhythmic discipline and metrical constancy" [1, p. 22]. In this work, it is important to convey motor skills and toccatarity due to the iron observance of the rhythmic structure, as well as the tenacity and clarity of the fingers. To do this, the chord presentation of the material should be played with a stroke as close as possible to a sharp, dry staccato, despite the absence of this indication, because we use the stroke depending on the figurative and artistic task of the work. Another example of the ostinate model of accompaniment can be the song "Only the cross is on it from the armor" (words by A. Shagin, music by O. Trunnikov). In this composition, the terse tremolo, which later turns into a chordal one, conveys the excitement and tension of the situation in which the unprotected lone fighter found himself. A complex combination of syncopated and dotted rhythms of the piano part in the song "Captain Russia" (words and music by Yu. Ryzhova) helps the soloist embody the image of an intrepid and brave hero, the savior of Russia, confidently averting misfortune.

Of course, solo fragments of the piano part play a huge role in creating and embodying the image, helping the soloist to express the emotional subtext, finishing what sometimes cannot be expressed in words. In the Musical Encyclopedia, the role of piano accompaniment is characterized as follows: "In instrumental and vocal music of the XIX-XX centuries, accompaniment often performs new expressive functions: it "completes" the unspoken soloist, emphasizes and deepens the psychological and dramatic content of music, creates an illustrative and pictorial background. It often turns from a simple accompaniment into an equivalent part of the ensemble..." [13, p. 80]. An introduction is important, introducing the composition into the artistic world, setting up the soloist and the listener in a certain way. For example, the song "About Russia" (words by V. Shchepetkov, music by A. Saversky) is preceded by an expressive introduction symbolizing the breadth and scale of the country. The texture is rich, but not dense – the chord presentation in the right hand and the iridescence of arpeggios in the left hands embody this image. At the end of the song, again, the piano continues the climax started by the soloist: The texture is compacted with richer chords, and arpeggiated figures soar upwards. Often, the expressive functions of the accompaniment are not limited to the first bars of the introduction: "Piano "performances" often alternate with the vocal line of the romance, somewhere shading, somewhere complementing, somewhere contrasting with it, in other words, revealing the subtext of the vocal work" [16, p. 30]. For example, in the song "Dmitry Donskoy" (words and music by M. Panisheva, arranged by I. Nokhrin), there is a small fragment in the piano part before the chorus, which has a calling character. To understand the image, it is useful for students to draw an analogy with the intonation and sound of a trumpet, which was a signaling instrument. In the song "Mothers of Russia" (words by E. Kovalyuk, music by A. Yakush), the piano playing precedes the chorus, rearranging the performers and listeners from the seriousness of the minor verse, telling about the duty of sons to defend the Motherland, to a major, bright, life-affirming way.

In the introduction to the work "Golden-Domed Russia" (words by E. Nikiforova, music by V. Kippor), the piano part is presented in a variety and richly: wide arpeggios in the left, covering a wide range, together with powerful, majestic chords in the right hand create a solemn image filled with love for the Motherland. In the chorus, as if painting a picture of Russia, illustrating the soloist's words about bells, the accompaniment changes, becoming saturated with octaves and chords located at opposite ends of the keyboard. Later in the course of development, piano playing leads to modulation from D minor to the distant key of E flat minor, introducing new color, increasing the emotional degree. Throughout the composition, the piano plays an important role, in fact, the concertmaster here turns from an accompanist into an ensemble player. However, despite this, students should be constantly reminded of the most important rule, which is the constant priority of the solo part.

When working on the works, it is important for future military brass band conductors to explain the relationship between concepts such as tessitura and dynamics: any dynamic indication should first of all be correlated with the technical capabilities of the vocalist. At the same time, it is important to remember that these indications of the power of sound are, first of all, an indication of character and carry a semantic function. For example, in the song "I will not betray you, Donbass!" (words and music by E. Karavanskaya) in the chorus, the indication f is set in both parts. However, it is obvious that the concertmaster must match the scale of his sound with the capabilities of the vocalist in order not to drown it out. In the song "Oh, Motherland!" (words by R. Gamzatov, music by G. Kambarova) in the vocal and piano parts, we again find a similar indication of mp and again try to correlate the balance in such a way that the soloists (this work was written for a vocal duo) find it convenient to present their material in the middle register, which, as is known, less sonorous than the extreme ones. In some works of the collection "Voices of the Motherland" (for example, "Mother of Russia" (words by E. Kovalyuk, music by A. Yakush) or "Prayer (Song of the Waiting One)" (words and music by N. Kapitanova), the dynamics are not exposed by the authors, which implies a certain performing freedom. It is important to try to avoid dynamic monotony, especially when repeating verses and choruses, and to start from the poetic text and artistic tasks.

An important aspect in working with future conductors is the development of orchestral thinking. On the one hand, there are no difficulties in solving this issue, since the cadets own one or more wind instruments. On the other hand, sometimes there are some problems associated with the lack of technical ability to embody the desired timbre in view of not very good command of the piano, or a poorly developed representation of the timbre or the peculiarities of sound production on the instruments of the string-bowed group of a symphony orchestra. In the above examples, the author has made small attempts to draw parallels with some orchestral instruments. Such work can be carried out further, limited only by the imagination of the performer.

These judgments are advisory in nature, because, as you know, interpretation can be multivariate. V.N. Biktashev exclaims: "I am convinced that in beautiful, perfect music, Music with a capital letter, written by brilliant and outstanding masters, there is never one single correct way to perform, understand, interpret and express it. There are always many such ways, and this makes music more beautiful, more diverse, and more unpredictable" [1, p. 6]. However, there are immutable rules and axioms applicable to works written in any genre or style that require familiarization and painstaking study. These are the immutable truths of some of the issues raised in this work that arise for novice concertgoers: the primacy of the soloist's part, the developed skill of holistic coverage of musical material together with a vocal line when reading from a sheet, competent differentiation of texture and a correctly built vertical balance, with a verified and toned horizontal (sub-voices and independent voices in polyphonic presentation), harmonic and rhythmic figurations performed without prejudice to the melody, solo fragments of the piano part that complement the artistic image created by the soloist, the relationship between the concepts of vocal tessitura and the dynamics of the work, the development of orchestral thinking.

During the years of the Special Military Operation, many songs and poems have been composed, which, as well as during the Great Patriotic War, serve as a means of maintaining morale and morale. At the Piano Department of the Military Institute (military Conductors) The updated repertoire of the Military University, including military songs by modern composers dedicated to a Special military operation, enriched the existing methodological material, allowed expanding the thematic and imaginative range of works, contributing to the introduction of acutely modern and topical topics into the program. The social function of music in the life of society consists in the possibility of mastering national and general cultural values by the people through the use of the entire pedagogical arsenal inherent in the musical art for the education of a harmoniously developed personality: it is important to carefully study the military-patriotic works of the past, which have become classics of this genre, it is no less important to turn to a new repertoire, close in subject and time to a modern person.

References
1. Biktashev, V.N. (2014). Art of the accompanist. Fundamentals of Performing Skills. St. Petersburg: "Union of Artists".
2"Voices of the Motherland" (2023). Computer addiction: A collection of songs for various performing compositions. Issue 1. In O. Pashinina Editor. Retrieved from https://old.golosa-rodiny.ru/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/golosa_rodiny_sbornik_21.12.2023.pdf
3. Vaseva, T.S. (2022). Creativity of D.B. Kabalevsky as an element of patriotic education of children and youth. In: Musical culture of the 21st century: theory, performance, education. Materials of the III International Scientific and Practical Conference (pp. 90-92). Kazan.
4. Gorchakov, E.P. (2023). The role of music in the formation of the patriotic consciousness of youth. In: Sustainable development strategies: social, economic and legal aspects. Materials of the II All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference with international participationv (pp. 181-185). Cheboksary.
5. Gottlieb, A. (1971). Fundamentals of Ensemble Technology. Moscow: Music.
6. Hoffmann, I. (1961). Piano playing. She answers questions about piano playing. Moscow.
7. Gritsenko, K.S., & Podporinova, N.O. (2023). The influence of a military-patriotic song on the education of young people. In: Science of the young-2023. Collection of articles of the II International Research Competition (pp. 215-220). Petrozavodsk.
8. Dzhioev, S.L. (2021). On the specifics of training a military conductor. Modern problems of science and education, 2, 30 p. Moscow: Publishing House Academy of Natural Sciences LLC.
9. Ivanova, O.V. (2021). Military-patriotic song as an element of upbringing and introduction to domestic traditions. In S.M. Nizamutdinova Editor, Modern problems of higher education. theory and practice: Current problems of creative education during a pandemic. Special issue (pp. 90-92). Moscow.
10. Kashtanova, T.A. (2023). Patriotic education of youth through music. Scientific works of Moscow Humanitarian University, 2, 67-71.
11. Mizina, L.V. (2022). Formation of patriotism among students of the music department in the performing class. Didact, 2(10), 56-59.
12. Morozova, E.V. (2022). Music as a means of civil-patriotic education. In E.Ya. Arshansky Editor, The world of childhood in the modern educational space. Collection of articles by students, undergraduates, postgraduates (pp. 367-369).
13Encyclopedia of Music. (1973). In Yu.V. Keldysh Editor.
14. Tomilina, E.N. (2022). Music as a means of patriotic education. In: Psychology and pedagogy of the XXI century: topical issues, achievements and innovations. Collection of articles of the III All-Russian student scientific and practical conference with international participation (pp. 720-724). Orekhovo-Zuevo.
15. Khalilov, M.A. (2023). Pedagogical potential of musical art in the process of formation of patriotic feelings of personality. Man. Society. Society, 6, 62-72.
16. Shenderovich, E.M. (1996). In the concertmaster class. Reflections of the teacher. Moscow: Music.
17. Shenderovich, E.M. (1987). On overcoming pianistic difficulties in claviers. Accompanist's tips. Moscow: Music.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the research in the article submitted for publication in the journal "Culture and Art" ("The study of works for voice and piano dedicated to self-defense by future conductors of a military orchestra") is, apparently, the didactic potential of the collection of patriotic songs "Voices of the Motherland", created following the results of the All-Russian creative competition of composers and poets, published in 2023 in electronic form (https://old.golosa-rodiny.ru/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/golosa_rodiny_sbornik_21.12.2023.pdf ) on the website of the contest "Voices of the Motherland" (https://golosa-rodiny.ru/contest-2023/music-collection-2023 /). The value of the collection (its didactic potential), according to the author, is very limited. The author sees this potential exclusively in use in classes for the development of cadets of the Military Institute (military conductors) Military University of the theme No. 6 "Accompaniments" according to the program of the discipline "Piano". In any case, this is indicated by the author's specific recommendations developed on the basis of Soviet-era methodologies. If we accept the didactic potential of the collection as the subject of research, then the collection itself is an object of research, and the highly specialized aspect chosen by the author indirectly indicates the purpose of the presented research. The reviewer notes that the genre of a scientific article requires unambiguity in determining the author's research program: the reader of a scientific journal should not, as the reviewer has to, speculate for the author on the methodological support of the scientific search results presented in the article. The reviewer also draws attention to the relevant question that arises about the compliance of the submitted article with the subject of the scientific journal "Culture and Art". After all, the thematic section of the magazine does not provide for the problems of musical pedagogy. From the magazines of NB-Media LLC, it rather corresponds to the content of the article "PHILHARMONICA. International Music Journal" and then on condition that the author, when finalizing the article, justifies the broader scope of the results presented by him: should patriotic songs be studied exclusively by military conductors, and exclusively during their military training (for example, in secondary schools in peacetime, are they not needed)? On the other hand, if we consider the published first issue of the collection "Voices of the Motherland" not only in musical and pedagogical terms, but emphasizing its importance as a cultural event, then readers of the magazine "Culture and Art" may also be interested in the presented article. However, such an angle will require more work to finalize the article (The published collection of songs should be considered in comparison with other cultural events of this kind: for example, how often are repertoire song collections published with the support of the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation? In the USSR, such work was systematic and educational institutions of any level, as well as creative amateur groups, and simply lovers of songwriting did not know a shortage in such musical literature. Is it really necessary today for such a systematic work?). Depending on the direction of revision of the article, the title should also be adjusted. According to the reviewer, speculation on the topic of self-defense in the field of popularization of the patriotic song repertoire is unnecessary, since it is ethically ambiguous (does no one really need a patriotic repertoire in peacetime?). In this regard, it should be noted that from a formal point of view, certain requirements are imposed on the title of a scientific article: it will be easier for scientists to navigate the content of the article if the title reflects the scientific problem, the subject and the object of research. Regardless of the angle chosen by the author to finalize the article, the reviewer draws attention to the fact that insinuations (falsifications of facts) are unacceptable in the scientific text. So, for example, the author ranks several songs by composers who were contemporaries of the Great Victory: "The Holy War" (music by A.V. Alexandrov, words by V. Lebedev-Kumach), "My Beloved" (music by M. Blanter, words by E. Dolmatovsky), "Random Waltz" (music by M. Fradkin, words E. Dolmatovsky), "In the frontline forest" (music by M. Blanter, words by M. Isakovsky), "The Last Battle" (music and words by M. Nozhkin), "At an unnamed height" (music by M. Blanter, words by M. Matusovsky)." Of course, the author's idea that "they became truly popular, gaining great popularity and love" is not in doubt. However, firstly, is the repertoire of popularly beloved songs of the wartime so limited: why not disclose this list with the common abbreviation "etc."? Secondly, the presented list is heterogeneous: 1) "My Beloved" by M. Blanter was composed to the words of E. Dolmatovsky in 1939 on the events related to the expansion of the western borders of the USSR, but became popular only after E. Dolmatovsky finalized the poetic text in early 1941, when the citizens of the USSR did not yet know about the upcoming trials of the Great Patriotic War; 2) M. Blanter's song to the words M. Matusovsky's "At an Unnamed Height" was composed in 1964, which, of course, does not detract from its patriotic significance, but already represents an understanding of the heroism of the Soviet people in the last war. And of course, these two songs should not be placed in the repertoire of concerts, which, according to the author, "served as an important means of maintaining public opinion against the fascist occupiers": in the first case, there were no occupiers yet, and in the second — there were no more. In addition, the reviewer objects to giving the heroic and dangerous cultural and educational work of Soviet artists during the Great Patriotic War a political and technological function as a means of "maintaining public opinion against the fascist occupiers": there was simply no need for such a function, the war was Patriotic, and in the opinion of the Patriarch of Moscow it was also Sacred. Giving unusual functions to the cultural enlightenment of the Soviet era, especially during the Great Patriotic War, coupled with the heterogeneity of the list of military songs, constitutes an insinuation that undermines the credibility of the author's text. Thus, until the author completes the article and specifically indicates what subject he is studying and why, it is difficult to judge the possibility of its publication in a scientific journal. The methodology of the study, as is obvious from the above, needs to be improved. It is extremely necessary to clearly define the subject and object of research, to finalize the research program as a whole (purpose, objectives, methods, etc.). If there is any specificity in the development of professional skills of military conductors that distinguishes the methodological support of the educational process at a Military University from the general problem field of music pedagogy, then this must be justified. So far, the author's idea as a whole looks wrong: as if the patriotic songs of the first issue of the musical collection "Voices of the Motherland" are needed exclusively by military conductors exclusively during their military training solely to master the skills of piano accompaniment. And this is not so, because it contradicts common sense. The relevance of the chosen topic is ensured by the author's reference to new empirical material (a recently published songbook). Scientific novelty, if present in the presented results, is extremely limited by the narrow purpose of the study. The methodological value of the article, in this sense, is insignificant.
The style of the text is generally scientific, although there are some violations in the ratio of special and ordinary vocabulary (for example: "War, in whatever era it was waged, has always been a terrible and strong shock and test for all parties directly or indirectly involved in this process" — in this context, war should not be identified with the process; the author's conclusion is that "At the piano Department of the Military Institute (military conductors) The updated repertoire of the Military University, including military songs by modern composers dedicated to a Special military operation, enriched the existing methodological material, allowed to expand the thematic and imaginative range of works, contributing to the introduction of acutely modern and topical topics into the program, relevant for performance at concerts, competitions, and festivals," is not correct in relation to soldiers on the front line: the guys are dying there, and the piano department of the Military Institute (military conductors) is delighted with the music collection, as if the methodological material of the department has not been updated since the Great Patriotic War). The structure of the article generally corresponds to the logic of presenting the results of scientific research, but the content of the introductory and final parts of the article, as noted above, should be methodically strengthened. The bibliography reflects the problematic field of research extremely poorly: in addition to the analyzed music collection, there is no scientific literature from the list for the last 3-5 years, and 7 sources are not enough to comply with editorial requirements (see https://nbpublish.com/camag/info_106.html ). At the end of the list, the author turned to the editorial board: "Please specify what exactly is incorrectly framed?". Answering this question, the reviewer points out that according to GOST, using a combination of a dot, a space and a dash, all significant sections of the description are separated. The shortening of the description allows for the absence of a dash, but then in all cases it should not be. This is the main and most common mistake (in all points). In addition, the description of the empirical source (Collection) is incorrect: see GOST for the description of electronic publications on the Internet. There is no appeal to opponents, the author is not included in theoretical discussions. According to the reviewer, the interest for the readership of the magazine "Culture and Art" in the article as presented is extremely limited. If the author intends to finalize the article in the direction of increasing its applied value for music pedagogy, then it is advisable to send it to a specialized scientific journal, for example, "PHILHARMONICA. International Music Journal».

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Review of the article "The study of works for voice and piano dedicated to a special military operation by future conductors of a military orchestra" Relevance of the research topic and its correspondence to the specialization of the journal "PHILHARMONICA. International Music Journal" does not raise doubts in connection with modern trends in socio-political development, which determine the priorities of modern musical art. The subject of the study is the peculiarities and promotion of the values of Russian culture, ideals and goals of the Russian army, which are important for the civilian population and participants in a Special military operation. The analysis of such categories as "patriotic education", "patriotic consciousness", "youth culture", "value orientations", "military patriotic songs", "military brass band", etc. is presented as a problem field of research. The works of military-patriotic themes have been identified and analyzed in detail. The advantage of the work is the key, end-to-end leading ideas about the development of orchestral thinking, rules and axioms applicable to works written in any genre or style, requiring familiarization and painstaking study. Of interest are the issues raised in this work that face novice concertmasters: the primacy of the soloist's part, the developed skill of holistic coverage of musical material together with a vocal line when reading from a sheet, competent differentiation of texture and a correctly built vertical balance, with a verified and toned horizontal, harmonic and rhythmic figuration, solo fragments of the piano part, complementing the artistic image created by the soloist, the relationship between the concepts of vocal tessitura and the dynamics of the work, the development of orchestral thinking. The article presents a detailed analysis of the works that serve as a means of maintaining morale and morale. The methodology of the reviewed work is based on a comparative approach. The article uses such research methods as comparative, structural, functional, semantic analysis, synthesis of the obtained results, analogy and comparison, deduction, design. The article implements in sufficient detail the systematization and generalization of data related to the analysis of the social function of music in the life of society, which consists in the possibility of mastering national and general cultural values by the people through the use of the entire pedagogical arsenal inherent in the musical art for the education of a harmoniously developed personality. The article has a scientific novelty related to the design and development of the role of music in the formation of patriotic consciousness of young people. The structure of the article meets the requirements for scientific publications. A detailed qualitative analysis of the obtained results of the study of military-patriotic works of the past, which have become classics of this genre, is presented. The content of the article, which explores creativity as an element of patriotic education, corresponds to its title. The style of presentation of the material meets the requirements for scientific publications. The bibliography corresponds to the content of the article and is presented by 17 domestic literary sources. The results of the study substantiate the importance of the study of military-patriotic songs in the education of young people. The article, which presents the results of a study of the specifics of military conductor training, arouses readers' interest and can be recommended for publication.