Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Taxes and Taxation
Reference:

Bartashevich S.V. The Legal Right of a Taxpayer to Decrease the Tax Burden: Theoretical Grounds and Legal Registration

Abstract: The subject tax rights, in particular, the legal right of a taxpayer to apply for decreasing the tax burden, still remain understudied categories in the tax law. In this article Bartashevich inscribes actions undertaken by taxpayers to economize tax liabilities as the model of the subjective right of a taxpayer. The definition of such a right, contents, structure and limits thereof constitute the object of the research in the present article. The subject of the research is the problems of the theoretical justification and legal registration of the taxpayers' right to decrease the tax burden by all ways allowed by the law. The author also analyzes the role, meaning and forms of the execution of subjective rights by taxpayers in terms of the regulation of tax relations. Bartashevich describes the essence of taxpayers' subjective rights as a form of individuals' public rights as well as a structure-forming element of tax relations. Special attention is paid to peculiarities of legal authorities in the structure of subjective tax rights determined by their sectoral affiliation. The author of the article also analyzes the current status of the legal registration of taxpayers' subjective rights and gives his critical evaluation of associated legal provisions as well as makes suggestions on how to improve them. The author provides theoretical grounds for the subjective right of a taxpayer to decrease the tax burden and offers his own definition of such a right concluding that the basis for the legal behavior of taxpayers with reference to decreasing the tax burden consists of subjective rights lestablished by taxation rules and laws as well as rights that are not mentioned thereby. 


Keywords:

subjective right, tax burden, taxpayer, tax authority, legal relation, behavior, permissibility, legal authority, taxation, tax


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Alekseev S. S. Obshchaya teoriya prava. T. II / S. S. Alekseev.-M.: Yuridicheskaya literatura, 1982.-360 s.
2. Alekseev S. S. Obshchie dozvoleniya i obshchie zaprety v sovetskom prave / Pod red. Plekhanova L. A.-M.: Yuridicheskaya literatura, 1989.-288 s.
3. Arkhipov S. I. Sub'ekt prava: teoreticheskoe issledovanie / S. I. Arkhipov.-SPb: Yuridicheskiy Tsentr Press, 2004.-469 s.
4. Bartashevich S. V. Nalogovoe bremya kak pravovaya kategoriya // Nalogi i nalogooblozhenie.-2010.-¹6.-S. 37-44.
5. Valiev Yu. K. Metod razresheniya v administrativnom prave: Avtoref. … kand. yurid. nauk. M.: MU MVD RF, 2009.-27 s.
6. Variychuk E. K. K voprosu o sootnoshenii sub'ektivnykh prav i zakonnykh interesov v nalogovom prave // Finansovoe pravo.-2009.-¹8.-S. 22-26.
7. Vakhitov R. R. Khartiya nalogoplatel'shchika uluchshaet vzaimootnoshenie storon v nalogovykh otnosheniyakh // Nalogoved.-2005.-¹4.-S. 64.
8. Vinnitskiy D. V. Sub'ekty nalogovogo prava // D. V. Vinnitskiy.-M.: Norma. 2000.-192 s.
9. Vrublevskiy E. Bezdeystvie i prichinnost' // Pravovedenie.-1971.-¹1.-S. 69-72.
10. Gavrilyuk R. A. Nalog kak pravoobyazannost' pravodeesposobnogo chlena grazhdanskogo obshchestva // Nalogi i nalogooblozhenie.-2005.-¹2.-S. 47-49.
11. Durdenevskiy V. N. Sub'ektivnoe pravo i ego osnovnoe razdelenie // Pravovedenie.-1994.-¹3.-S. 78-95.
12. Zelentsov A. B. Administrativno-pravovoy spor: voprosy teorii / A. B. Zelentsov.-2 izd.-M.: Izd-vo RUDN, 2009.-692 s.
13. Ioffe O. S. Pravootnoshenie po sovetskomu grazhdanskomu pravu / O. S. Ioffe.-L.: Izd-vo LGU, 1949.-144 s.
14. Ioffe O. S., Shargorodskiy S. D. Voprosy teorii prava / O. S. Ioffe, S. D. Shargorodskiy.-M.: Gosyurizdat, 1962.-381 s.
15. Kudryavtsev V. N. Pravovoe povedenie: norma i patologiya / V. N. Kudryavtsev.-M.: Nauka, 1982.-287 s.
16. Kucheryavenko N. P. Kurs nalogovogo prava. T. 2 / N. P. Kucheryavenko.-Khar'kov: Legas, 2004.-600 s.
17. Mal'ko A. V., Subochev V. V. Zakonnye interesy kak pravovaya kategoriya / A. V. Mal'ko, V. V. Subochev.-SPb: Yuridicheskiy tsentr Press, 2004.-359 s.
18. Motovilovker E. Ya. Teoriya regulyativnogo i okhranitel'nogo prava / E. Ya. Motovilovker.-Voronezh: Izd-vo Voronezhskogo universiteta, 1990.-218 s.
19. Nalogovoe pravo / Pod red. S. G. Pepelyaeva.-M.: ID FBK-Press, 2000.-608 s.
20. Pepelyaev S. G. Grazhdanin kak sub'ekt finansovo-pravovykh otnosheniy: Avtoref. … kand. yurid. nauk. M.: MGU, 1991. 25 s.
21. Petrov G. I. Sovetskie administrativnye pravootnosheniya / G. I. Petrov.-L.: LGU, 1972.-159 s.
22. Rukavishnikova I. V. Metod finansovogo prava: Avtoref. … dokt. yurid. nauk. Saratov: Saratovskaya gosudarstvennaya akademiya prava, 2004.-50 s.
23. Rusyaev N. A. Pravovoe regulirovanie nalogovoy optimizatsii v Rossii i Germanii: Avtoref. … kand. yurid. nauk. M.: RAP, 2008.-24 s.
24. Sarkisov A. K. Konflikty v sfere nalogovykh otnosheniy: teoriya i praktika pravovogo razresheniya: Avtoref. … dokt. yurid. nauk. M.: VGNA MF RF, 2006.-56 s.
25. Sinitsyn S. A. Sub'ektivnye publichnye prava: k razrabotke voprosa o ponyatii i sisteme // Advokat.-2016.-¹7.-S. 20-37.
26. Smirnykh S. E. Sub'ektivnye prava nalogoplatel'shchikov v teorii i na praktike / S. E. Smirnykh.-M.: Volters Kluver, 2009.-176 s.
27. Smit A. Issledovanie o prirode i prichinakh bogatstva narodov.-M.: Izd-vo sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoy literatury, 1962.-677 s.
28. Tolstoy Yu. K. K teorii pravootnosheniya / Yu. K. Tolstoy.-L.: LGU, 1959.-87 s.
29. Khalfina R. O. Obshchee uchenie o pravootnoshenii / R. O. Khalfina.-M.: Yuridicheskaya literatura, 1974.-352 s.
30. Chibinev V. M. Problemy sootnosheniya ponyatiy «obyazannost'» i «obyazatel'stvo» v nalogovom prave // Nalogi.-2006.-¹3.-S. 39-51.
31. Shaukenov A. T. Nekotorye polozheniya teorii nalogovogo pravoprityazaniya // Nalogi i nalogooblozhenie.-2008.-¹4.-S. 34-38.
32. Yurmashev R. S. Osobennosti ob'ektivnoy storony sostavov nalogovykh pravonarusheniy // Finansovoe pravo.-2005.-¹4.-S. 44-48.
33. Yadrikhinskiy S. A. Mekhanizm obespecheniya ispolneniya obyazannosti po uplate nalogov: problemy teorii i praktiki / Otv. red. E. Yu. Gracheva.-M.: Norma, Infra-M, 2015.-144 s
34. Bartashevich S.V. Effektivnost' sudebnykh doktrin protivodeystviya izbezhaniyu nalogooblozheniya kak kriteriy otsenki ekonomicheskoy bezopasnosti Rossii // Natsional'naya bezopasnost' / nota bene. - 2014. - 4. - C. 560 - 573. DOI: 10.7256/2073-8560.2014.4.10708.
35. Shcherbakova L.V. K diskussii ob obyazatel'stvennoy kontseptsii nalogovogo pravootnosheniya v sovremennoy natsional'noy doktrine // Administrativnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo. - 2011. - 11. - C. 43 - 53.