Translate this page:
Nota Bene. Books, journals, publishing technologies.
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate ☒
Library
 Your profile
Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Back to contents

Philosophy and Culture
Reference:

Iferov R.G., Titlin L.I. Comparative analysis of Anekāntavāda and antinomian monodualism

Abstract: The subject of this research is the two philosophical concepts that belong to distant from each other philosophical movements: Anekāntavāda of Jainism and antinomian monodualism. The object of this research is the logical-philosophical aspect of these concepts. The authors carefully examine such aspects of the topic as the foundations for comparison of the reviewed concepts and their common features. The article demonstrates that Anekāntavāda and antinomian monodualism are the nonclassical modal multivocal logical-philosophical systems.  This is why they can be subjected to a comparative analysis. Special attention is given to the causes of the determined correlations between Anekāntavāda and antinomian monodualism. The main common feature of Anekāntavāda and antinomian monodualism, which unites them with each other and counterpoise to majority of the Western logical-philosophical systems, is the principle of irreducibility of opinions. On various ontological bases, particularly platonic and dharmic, originates one and the same pattern that produces similar logical-philosophical systems. This pattern is based on the gnoseological intuition of irreducibility of opinions, generating from intuition of the endless multiplicity of the universe. The gnoseological intuition of multiplicity demonstrates independence form the ontological basis characteristic to one or another philosophical system. The mental pattern, realized in form of the considered logical-philosophical systems, will be greatly demanded in the modern post-globalization era, which on one side is characterized by the global unification, and on the other – by escalation of the local conflicts. This research is one of the few that compares the Russian with one of the Eastern philosophies; the philosophy of Frank with one of the movements of Hindu philosophy; as well as one of the first to compares the Jainism with one of the directions of Russian philosophy.


Keywords:

comparative analisis, comparative philosophy, logical-philosophical systems, comparative studies, antinomian monodualism, Anekāntavāda, modal logic, multivocal logic, nonclassical logic, religious philosophy

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p.
2. Shaha S. M. Anekanta and the Problem of Meaning in “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 106 – 114
3. Tatia N. Anekanta, Syadvada and Saptabhangi in “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 115 – 144
4. E. B. The Anekanta Theory of Existence in “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 145 – 161
5. Bhattacharya H. M. The Anekantavada of the Jainas in “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 162 – 166
6. Padmarajiah Y. J. Anekantavada, Nayavada and Syadvada in “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 167 – 226
7. Sanghvi S. Anekantavada: The Principal Jaina Contribution of Logic in “Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 227 – 241
8. E. B. Anekantavada or the Theory of Manyfoldness: The Most Consistent Form of Realism in“Encyclopaedia of Jainism“ by .Nagendra Kr Singh, Indo-European Jain Research Foundation, Anmol Publications . PVT. LTD., 2001. 8330 p. pp. 242 – 257
9. Mookerjee Satkari dr. “The jaina philosophy of non – absolutism. A critical study of anekantavada”, Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi – Varanasi – Patna. 1978. 300 p.
10. Terent'ev A.A, Shokhin V.K. st. «Filosofiya dzhaynizma» v kn.: Lysenko V.G., . Terent'ev A.A, Shokhin V.K. «Rannyaya buddiyskaya filosofiya. Filosofiya . dzhaynizma», M.: Izd.f. «Vost.lit.» 1994. 383 s.
11. Shokhin V. K. «Shkoly indiyskoy filosofii: Period formirovaniya (IV v. do n.e. – II . v. n.e.)/ In-t filosofii. M. Vost.lit., 2004. 415 s.
12. Barlingay S.S. “A modern introduction to indian logic”, National Publishing House, 23, . Ansari road, Darya Ganj, New Delhi – 110002, second revised and enlarged edition, . 1976.
13. Zheleznova N.A. «Uchenie Kundakundy v filosofsko – religioznoy traditsii . dzhaynizma» In-t vostokovedeniya, M.: Vost.lit, 2005. 343 s.
14. Kanaeva N.A. «Problema vyvodnogo znaniya v Indii»/Zabolotnykh E.L. «Logiko – epistemologicheskie vozzreniya Dignagi i ego ideynykh preemnikov», M.: Vost.lit., 2002. 326 s.
15. The study of Patanjali. By Surendranath Dasgupta, M. A., professor, Cwittagong College. Griffith memorial prize. 1915. University of Calcutta. 1920. 207 p.
16. Routledge (Firm), Ed. Craig “Concise Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy” Routledge . 2000.
17. Ganeri Jonardon “Philosophy in Classical India: the Proper Work of Reason” Routlege 2001.
18. Billington Ray “Understanding Eastern Philosophy” Routledge 1997.
19. Plott John C. “Global History of Philosophy: the Patristic – Sutra Period” Motilal . Banarsidass Publ 2000.
20. Padmarajiah Y.J. “A Comparative Study of the Jaina Theories of Reality and Knowledge” rep. Motilal Banarsidass Publ 1986.
21. Dundas Paul “The Jains” Routledge 2002. 368 p.
22. Gier Nicolas F. “Spiritual Titanism: Indian, Chinese, and Western perspectives” SUNY Press 2000. 302 p.
23. Filosofiya: Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar'. — M.: Gardariki. Pod redaktsiey A.A. Ivina. 2004. http://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/enc_philosophy/1302. data obrashcheniya 07.02.15.
24. Filosofskaya Entsiklopediya. V 5-kh t. — M.: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. Pod red. F. V. Konstantinova. 1960—1970. T. 5.
25. Khintikka Ya. Logiko-epistemologicheskie issledovaniya. Sbornik izbrannykh statey. – M., Progress. 1980. 448 s.
26. Slovar' po logike. — M.: Tumanit, izd. tsentr VLADOS. A. A. Ivin, A. L. Nikiforov. 1997. 384 s.
27. Frank S. L. Predmet znaniya. Ob osnovakh i predelakh otvlechennogo znaniya. V knige: Predmet znaniya. Dusha cheloveka. – Mn.: Kharvest, M.: AST, 2000. 992 s.
28. Frank S. L. Nepostizhimoe. Ontologicheskoe vvedenie v filosofiyu religii. V: Chelovek i Bog. – Mn., BPTs (BEMP), Kharvest, 2009. – 528 s.
29. Shiller F. Nashi chelovecheskie istiny. (F.C.S. Schiller. Our Human Truths. – New York: Columbia University Press, 1939.) – M.: Moskovskaya shkola politicheskikh issledovaniy. 2003. – 344 s
Nota Bene
 
For authors
 
Other
 
Our sites
© 1998 – 2024 Nota Bene. Publishing Technologies. NB-Media Ltd.