Library
|
Your profile |
Law and Politics
Reference:
Savchin, M.V. (2013). Constitutional conforming interpretation of laws
and supremacy of the Constitution. Law and Politics, 13, 1779–1785. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=52113
Savchin, M.V. Constitutional conforming interpretation of laws and supremacy of the ConstitutionAbstract: The article is devoted to the specific features of constitutional conforming interpretation of the Constitution, based on systemic quality of law, harmonious and united character of the legal system. Conforming interpretation is a method for guaranteeing legal certainty, and it is one of the methods for overcoming gaps and conflicts in legislation. The basis of constitutional conforming interpretation is the idea of guarantees of implementation of constitutional norms as a directly applicable and efficient order, as well as polyvariety of application of constitutional provisions in the situation of lack of legal certainty. These factors are key to application of law and other normative acts only in those cases, when they meet constitutionality requirements. Based on comparative legal analysis, the author provides characteristic features of structure of constitutional conforming interpretation, which is defined by the object of legal regulation, administrative and judicial practice. The author formulates key approaches to overcoming legislative gaps and conflicts, which fail to meet the requirements of legal certainty, and they should be overcame by application of the norms of current legislation, which conform to constitutional values, norms, and principles. Keywords: supremacy of the Constitution, supremacy of law, conflict of laws, constitutional jurisprudence, constitutional justice, constitutional conforming interpretation, constitutionality, legal regulation, gap in the legislation, interpretation of the Constitution.
This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article
References
1. Birmontene T., Yarashyunas E., Spruogis E. General'nyi doklad XIV Kongressa Konferentsii evropeiskikh konstitutsionnykh sudov // Konstitutsionnoe pravosudie: Vestnik Konferentsii organov konstitutsionnogo kontrolya stran molodoi demokratii. Vypusk 2 (40) – 3 (41), 2008. Erevan : Tsentr konstitutsionnogo prava Respubliki Armeniya, 2008. S. 70 – 245.
2. Vei S. Printsipi konstitutsіinoї іnterpretatsії і samoobmezhennya konstitutsіinogo suddі // Vіsnik Konstitutsіinogo Sudu Ukraїni. 2002. № 2. S. 57—59. 3. Velikii tlumachnii slovnik suchasnoї ukraїns'koї movi / Uklad. і golov. red. V.T. Busel.K.; Іrpіn' : VTF «Perun», 2002. 1440 s. 4. Gadzhiev G.A. Konstitutsionnyi printsip samostoyatel'nosti sudebnoi vlasti v Rossiiskoi Federatsii // Zhurnal rossiiskogo prava. № 2003. № 1. 5. Geberle P. Zagal'nі problemi konstitutsіinogo prava ta yurisdiktsії konstitutsіinogo sudu na materіalі «nіmets'koї modelі» і z poglyadu na Ukraїnu // Vіsnik Konstitutsіinogo Sudu Ukraїni. 2001. №6. S.59-72. 6. Gosudarstvennoe pravo Germanii. Sokrashch. perevod s nem. v 2-kh t. / Pod red. V.A. Tumanova. T. 2. M. : IGP RAN, 1994. 320 s. 7. Klyain Khans Kh. Yurisdiktsiya konstitutsionnogo suda i struktura konstitutsii. Ot pravovogo gosudarstva k konstitutsionnomu gosudarstvu // Gosudarstvo i pravo. 1999. № 8. S. 111-112. 8.Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii № 29-P ot 20 dekabrya 2011 goda po delu o kompensatsii zatrat aviakompanii // http://www.rg.ru/2012/01/11/ks-avia-dok.html. 9. Reshenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Ukrainy № 4-rp/2020 ot 4 fevralya 2010 goda // http://ccu.gov.ua/uk/doccatalog/list?currDir=94600 (na ukr. yazyke) 10. Reshenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Ukrainy № 11-rp/2010 ot 6 aprelya 2010 goda // http://ccu.gov.ua/uk/doccatalog/list?currDir=106790 (na ukr. yazyke). 11. Rizhkov G. Printsip pravovoї derzhavi v Osnovnomu Zakonі (Konstitutsії) FRN і sudova praktika Federal'nogo Konstitutsіinogo Sudu FRN. K. : Knigi dlya bіznesu, 2008. 112 s. 12. Savchin M. Priroda aktіv Konstitutsіinogo Sudu Ukraїni: teoretiko-metodologіchnі aspekti // Vіsnik Konstitutsіinogo Sudu Ukraїni. 2007. №5. S.71-78. 13. Slovnik іnshomovnikh slіv: 23 000 slіv ta termіnologіchnikh slovospoluchen' / Uklad. V.O. Pustovіt ta іn. K. : Dovіra, 2000. 1018 s. 14. Strizhak A.A., Ribalko Ya.V., Savchin M.V.Zakon Ukraїni «Pro Konstitutsіinii Sud Ukraїni»: nauk.-prakt. koment.; za zag. red. A.A. Strizhaka. K.: Іn Yure, 2009. 328 s. 15. Tikhii V. Ofіtsіine tlumachennya Konstitutsії ta zakonіv Ukraїni Konstitutsіinim Sudom Ukraїni // Vіsnik Konstitutsіinogo Sudu Ukraїni. 1998. № 4. S. 38 – 45. 16. Todyka Yu.N. Tolkovanie Konstitutsii i zakonov Ukrainy: teoriya i praktika: Monografiya. Kh. : Fakt, 2001. 328 s. 17. Shevchuk S. Osnovi konstitutsіinoї yurisprudentsії. K. : Ukraїns'kii tsentr pravnichikh studіi, 2001. 294 s. 18. Shevchuk S. Sudova pravotvorchіst'. Svіtovii dosvіd і perspektivi v Ukraїnі. K. : Referat, 2006. 640 s. 19. Fіlosofіya prav lyudini / Za red. Sh. Ґosepata ta Ґ. Lomanna. K. : Nіka-Tsentr, 2008. 317 s. 20. Decision of Constitutional Conceil of French Republic 92-308 DC of 2 September 1992 // http://www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr/conseil-constitutionnel/root/bank_mm/anglais/a92308dc.pdf 21. Deutsches Staatsrecht. Ein Studienbuch von Reinhold Zippelius und Thomas Würtenberger. 31. Auflage des von Theodor Maunz begründeten Werkes. München : Verlag C.H. Beck München, 2005. 561 s. 22. Nales Pl. US 48/95 26.03.1996 roku o interpretace zakona v souladu s ustavnymi zakony a mezinarodnymi smlouvami dle ul. 10 Ustavy // http://nalus.usoud.cz/Search/ResultDetail.aspx?id=27983&pos=4&cnt=12&typ=result |