Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Litera
Reference:

The Siberian text of Russian literature in the assessment of Chinese critics

Shi Fuyui

PhD in Philology

Senior Lecturer, Institute of Russian Language, Dalian University of Foreign Languages

116000, China, Liaoning Province, Dalian, Liushunxi str., 6

sfy1989@foxmail.com
Other publications by this author
 

 
Li Syaoge

ORCID: 0000-0003-3002-6968

PhD in Philology

Senior Lecturer, Department of Russian Language, Inner Mongolia Normal University

010000, China, Inner Mongolia, Hohhot, Zhaowuda str., 81

lixiaoge89@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8698.2023.9.43965

EDN:

VHUBIT

Received:

31-08-2023


Published:

07-09-2023


Abstract: The article is devoted to the problem of studying the "Siberian text" of Russian literature through the eyes of Chinese critics. The object of the study is the analysis of the "Siberian text" in Chinese literary criticism. The subject of the study is the metaphorical images of Siberia analyzed by Chinese critics in the works of Russian writers of the XVII-XX centuries. The main purpose of the work is to determine the specifics of studying the "Siberian text" of Russian literature with a brief overview of the main directions of modern research by Chinese critics. In the work, along with general scientific methods of analysis, synthesis, analogy and generalization, the following research methods were used: descriptive method, comparative method and method of linguocultural interpretation. The results of the study show that Chinese literary critics pay close attention to the works of classical and new Siberian writers. The main conclusions of the study are the classical images of Siberia and the change in the image of Siberia, as well as the famous writers of various trends and their works are summarized. The scientific novelty of the research lies in the fact that for the first time new Chinese scientific achievements are involved in the research field – the assessments of Chinese researchers about the images of Siberia in Russian literature.


Keywords:

the image of Siberia, Siberian text, Siberian technique, Siberian plot, spatial-semiotic idea, Russian literature, Chinese criticism, the land of the dead, the original paradise, the space of the initiation rite

This article is automatically translated.

Introduction

The image of Siberia appeared in Russian literature more than three hundred years ago. The "Siberian Text" has been formed as a local text of Russian literature since the XVII century. Both geographically and nationally, Siberia is an entity that cannot be ignored. The problems of the correlation of culture and space, their interaction are extremely relevant both in the field of scientific research of various humanitarian disciplines (cultural studies, political science, history, philology, psychology, etc.), and in the field of direct practical human activity – be it the protection of cultural and natural heritage, foreign and domestic policy of states, international relations, social-economic development of various regions and countries [1, p. 10]. In connection with the further strengthening of Sino-Russian cooperation in the field of economic and cultural exchange, the understanding of the culture of Siberia is becoming especially timely, this is why the relevance of this work is due to the need to identify the cultural connotations of the "Siberian text", which are especially important for intercultural communication.

The study of the specifics of the "Siberian text" of Russian literature in Chinese criticism has great theoretical and practical significance. The theoretical significance of the research lies in the fact that it contributes to the general methodological and applied potential of studying the problems of interaction between culture and space, the practical significance lies in the possibility of using the results obtained in the educational process at universities.

In the course of the study , the following tasks were solved: Russian Russian literature: 1) to describe and systematize the various points of view of Chinese researchers on the "Siberian text" in Russian literature; 2) to characterize the symbolic field of the classical image of Siberia as the land of the dead, the original paradise, the space of the initiation rite; 3) to identify the dynamics of changes in the image of Siberia in the works of Russian writers of the XX century.

The theoretical basis of the research was the works devoted to the general issues of studying the geographical image (Zamyatin 2006), the mythologeme of Siberia (Tyupa 2002), the image of Siberia in the Russian literature of the XVII–XX century (Li Kun 2016; Li Chunyu 2022; Song Yuzhu 2019; Xu Le 2019; Zhang Shuming 2020), as well as an in-depth analysis of the Siberian images in the works of a certain author or group of authors (Liu Qiqi 2020; Sun Ting 2019; Xu Le 2019; Zhang Shuming 2016, 2018).

The image of Siberia in Russian literature in the Chinese academic environment

Being a regional literary creation with a unique aesthetic style, the "Siberian text" has a long history and constitutes a rich cultural heritage. Writers of different periods and schools created the geographical image of Siberia in different ways, arising from the interaction of geographical space and culture. The regional specificity of Siberia is determined by its natural, historical, ethnic, socio-economic and other characteristics. Chinese critic Zhang Shuming analyzed the works of Russian writers of the XVII–XIX centuries, proceeding from the logic of historical and cultural development, characterized the image of Siberia as the land of the dead, as the original paradise and as the space of the initiation rite [11, pp. 20-21].

The image of the land of the dead is connected with the geography of Siberia and the peculiarities of social policy: located in Asia, with harsh natural conditions, it is considered as a colony and a real place to punish criminals. The chronotopic image of Siberia in Russian classical literature represents it as a country of cold – winter – night (moon), that is, death in the mythological sense. At the same time, Siberia is a country of desolate and boundless (a symbol of cosmic eternity) space [2, p. 28]. This is described in the works of K. F. Ryleev "The Death of Ermak" (1822); N. A. Nekrasov "Russian Women" (1826); "The Life of Archpriest Avvakum, written by himself" (XVII century); A. N. Radishchev "Journey from St. Petersburg to Moscow" (1790); J. Kennan "Siberia and Exile" (1906), etc.

Contrary to the image of the land of death, Siberia is also associated with utopian ideas, being described in Russian literature as a primitive paradise [11, p. 23]. In M. V. Lomonosov's ode "On the day of the accession to the All-Russian throne of Her Majesty Empress Elizabeth Petrovna, 1747," Siberia appears to be a rich place full of gold, a wide variety of animals, endless forests and deep rivers. Researcher E. F. Gudkova called Siberia "belovodye" in the work "Nedorosl" by D. I. Fonvizin. The Petrashevites considered Siberia as a country of hope for the future of Russia due to the absence of serfdom and landlords on its territory.

The unique combination and interaction of geopolitical, cultural, historical and natural factors has led to the mythologization of Siberia as a region of liminal half-death, which opens up the problematic possibility of personal rebirth in a new quality and a corresponding renewal of life [2, p. 28].

The interpretation of Siberia as the space of the initiation rite can be divided into two stages. First, Siberia is a place where the soul of an exiled person is resurrected to complete a spiritual initiation rite. However, by the end of the 19th century, Siberia turned into a place where the soul of a person who voluntarily went to complete a spiritual initiation rite is resurrected [11, p. 24]. This function of Siberia is embodied in L. N. Tolstoy's novel "Resurrection", in F. M. Dostoevsky's works "The Brothers Karamazov" and "Crime and Punishment".

Zhang Shuming and Li Kun paid special attention to the story of V. P. Astafyev "Theft". The author describes the life of ordinary people experiencing hunger, poverty and hopelessness. In the story "Theft", the image of Siberia is embodied in the form of a small town called Kraesvetsk, that is, "the edge of the world", which contains the semantics of the typical remoteness of the northern space and isolation from the big world [9, p. 27]. The essence of Astafiev's creativity is the rebirth and resurrection of man [10, p. 186].

Chinese researcher Xu Le in his works focused on two images of Siberia – the land of death and the holy land of resurrection. The rebirth in the land of death of Siberia, in order to heal the collective trauma of the nation, should take place under the sacred banner of the Orthodox Church. This belief is hidden in the Siberian works of classical Russian writers such as Leskov, Korolenko, Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Chekhov, and their main characters will perform a spiritual resurrection from this land of death and gain the power to save the world [7, p. 168].

Further, Xu Le wrote a work devoted to A. P. Chekhov's essays "From Siberia", which demonstrate the broad consensus reached by the Russian scientific and literary communities and the tsarist government at the end of the XIX century regarding the geographical conquest and cultural absorption of Siberia. Russian Russian classics presented this unity in an artistic form with the intention to encourage the Russian nation to change its character and realize its "Divine mission" to lead the world [8, p. 37].

In addition, Xu Le focused on the style of Siberian writers after the October Revolution, which was very different from the decadence and idealism that prevailed at that time in the central regions of Russia. The harsh natural environment and social contradictions forced Siberian writers to develop a steady, bold, innovative, healthy, bright and energetic literary interest [6, p. 6]. Using the example of V. V. Ivanov's play "Armored Train 14-69", Xu Le showed the national and worldwide significance of the "Siberian text". On the one hand, this play inherits the national tradition of Russian literature and demonstrates the justice of the people's revolution. On the other hand, it shows the world significance of the Soviet revolution for Siberia with the help of an extensive epic painting, providing a living artistic proof of the socialist movement throughout the world in the XX century [6, p. 5].

Chinese critic Song Yuzhu investigated the ideological dynamics of state administrative policy in Siberia, hidden behind the symbols of the "Siberian text", in three dimensions: cultural-historical, religious and in the aspect of environmental ethics [5, p. 151].

The objective attractiveness of rich resources and the subjective desire of the tsar to seize them made the Siberian lands east of the Ural Mountains a great value for Russia and turned this region into a strategically important goal. During the development of Siberia, historical facts and personalities – the conqueror of Siberia Ermak Timofeevich and the process of colonization itself – were mythologized (for example, in the works of K. F. Ryleev "The Death of Ermak" (1822); I. I. Dmitriev "Ermak" (1794); P. P. Bazhov "Ermakov's Swans" (1940), etc.) The concept of cultural symbiosis came into conflict with the expansionist nature of imperial thought, the state sought to create an ideal cultural image with a colonial characteristic [5, p. 151].

The writers focused on the description of hard labor and suffering experienced by people in exile, and turned them into a religious experience of ascension to the Kingdom of heaven and renewal of faith, and also built the logic of "hard labor – resurrection" [5, p. 152] (for example, in the works of A. S. Pushkin "In the depths of Siberian ores" (1827); V. V. Yerofeyev's "Moscow-Petushki" (1970); "The Life of Archpriest Avvakum, written by himself"; F. M. Dostoevsky's "Crime and Punishment" (1866) and "Notes from the Dead House" (1861); G. Sh. Yakhina's "Zuleikha opens her eyes", (2014), etc.).

The village prose, which originated in the 1950s, is a unique phenomenon in Russian literature. The writers experienced the pain of "paradise lost", remembering their native village and striving for their spiritual homeland; they extolled nature, reflected on human nature, discussed issues of morality and environmental ethics [5, p. 168]. In the conditions of constant destruction of villages and villages, the appearance of industrial ruins, the main topic of discussion was what kind of survival status the Russian nation will retain in Siberia [5, p. 152]. Representative works are "The Usual Thing" (V. I. Belov, 1966), "Brothers and Sisters" (F. A. Abramov, 1958), "The Last Bow" (V. P. Astafyev, 1957-1992), "Tsar Fish" (V. P. Astafyev, 1972-1975), "Kalina Krasnaya" (V. M. Shukshin, 1973), "Characters" (V. M. Shukshin, 1973), "Conversations under a clear moon" (V. M. Shukshin, 1974), "From the life of Fyodor Kuzkin" (B. A. Mozhaev, 1966), "Men and women" (B. A. Mozhaev, 1977), "The Usvyat helmet-bearers" (E. I. Nosov, 1977), "The Last Term" (V. G. Rasputin, 1970), "Farewell to Mater" (V. G. Rasputin, 1976), etc.

Changes in the image of Siberia in the works of Russian writers of the XX century in the assessment of Chinese writers

According to D. N. Zamyatin, the geographical image, as a dynamically developing system, can describe the real space and reflect the gradual characteristics and unique forms of society. However, due to changes in the social and cultural context and living conditions of people, the geographical image itself and the combination of various geographical images often change [1, p. 180].

Chinese critic Li Chunyu analyzed the evolution of the image of Siberia based on the works of a group of writers of the second half of the XX century. Since the second half of the XX century, the image of Siberia as a whole has undergone changes from a "poetic homeland" to a "flood zone", in addition, in the creative concepts of writers of different periods there is a transition from "mythologism" to "neorealism" [3, p. 139].

Siberian representatives of "village prose", such as V. G. Rasputin, V. P. Astafyev, V. M. Shukshin, and neo-realist writers, such as R. V. Senchin, are filled with a sense of responsibility to their native land and awareness of their high mission. In their opinion, Siberia is no longer the land of the dead, the original paradise and the space of the initiation rite (as it was perceived by classical writers), but becomes the basis of national survival and development. Russian Russian culture is an eternal home that nourishes Russian civilization and carries Russian traditional culture and values.

Liu Qiqi analyzed the image of Siberia based on the novel by G. Sh . Yakhina's "Zuleikha opens her eyes" (2014), in which Siberia is a natural space rich in resources, forests and exotic animals; it is a place of exile where "special immigrants" are doomed to hard labor, and it is also a place where the heroine Zuleikha awakens her consciousness [4, p. 87].

Conclusion

In the history of the development of Russian literature, the image of Siberia has been one of the important themes in the works of many famous writers. In the works of the classics of the XIX century, Siberia is a country full of exotic customs, a land of exile and a space of death. At the same time, against this background, the main characters can get out of the crisis, regain faith and finally achieve salvation of the soul and resurrection of the spirit. Russian Russian writers such as V. G. Rasputin, V. P. Astafyev, V. M. Shukshin, D. S. Zakharov, A. A. Antipin, R. V. Senchin, Siberia has become the birthplace of dreams, the basis for the survival and development of the Russian nation and an eternal home that carries the Russian spirit and culture.

The Siberian Text shows the tradition of deep understanding of human nature by Russian literature, and also reflects the humanistic turn of the state will. Being a soft power of national culture, Russian literature contributes to the strengthening of Russia's influence throughout the world.

This article provides only a general overview of the research of modern Chinese scientists devoted to the "Siberian text"; these studies in China are at an initial stage and can be continued. Russian Russian scholars would find it interesting to study the formation and development of the "Siberian text" of Russian literature, to examine the images of the Siberian city and their paradigms in the works of various genres, as well as to study the originality of the image of the Siberian city in the works of Russian writers.

References
1. Zamyatin, D. N. (2006). Culture and Space: Modeling of Geographical Images. Moscow: Znak.
2. Tyupa, V. I. (2002). The Mythologeme of Siberia: on the Question of the "Siberian Text" of Russian literature. Siberian Philological Journal, 1, 27–35.
3. Li, Chunyu. (2022). Geographical Image in the Texts of Contemporary Siberian Writers. New Perspectives on World Literature, 3, 139–148. (李春钰. (2022). 当代西伯利亚文本中的地理形象—以西伯利亚作家群创作为例 // 外国文学动态研究).
4. Liu, Qiqi. (2020). Siberian Writing in the Novel "Zuleikha Opens Her Eyes". Journal of Yan'an Vocational & Technical College, 34(6), 85–87. (刘其琪. (2020). 小说《祖列依哈睁开了眼睛》中的西伯利亚书写 // 延安职业技术学院学报).
5. Song, Yuzhu. (2019). Poetic National Imagination: A Study of the Siberian Text in Russian Literature. Russian Studies, 1, 147–176. (宋羽竹. (2019). 诗意化的民族想象俄罗斯文学中的西伯利亚文本研究 // 俄罗斯研究).
6. Xu, Le. (2019). Nationalism and Internationalism in Siberian Soviet Literature: V. Ivanov’s "Armored train 14–69" as an Example. New Perspectives on World Literature, 2, 5–13. (徐乐. (2019). 西伯利亚苏维埃文学的民族性与世界性—以弗谢·伊凡诺夫的《铁甲车》为例 // 外国文学动态研究).
7. Xu, Le. (2019). Russian Literary Classics in the 19th century and Siberia – on the National and Global significance of Siberia. Study & Exploration, 10, 164–170. (徐乐. (2019). 19世纪俄国文学经典与西伯利亚—兼论西伯利亚的民族性与世界性意义 // 学习与探索).
8. Xu, Le. (2020). Chekhov’s "From Siberia": Writing Siberia into Russia. Foreign Literature Review, 2, 5–37. (徐乐. (2020). 契诃夫«寄自西伯利亚»: 将西伯利亚“写入”俄罗斯 // 外国文学评论).
9. Zhang, Shuming, & Li, Kun. (2016). Siberia Image in Astafiev’s "Theft". Journal of Hebei University: Philosophy and Social Science), 41(03), 26–29. (张淑明, 李坤. (2016). 阿斯塔菲耶夫《偷窃》中的西伯利亚形象 // 河北大学学报: 哲学社会科学版).
10. Zhang, Shuming. (2018). Siberia Image in Astafiev’s Creation. Chinese Language and Literature Study, 23(01), 185–195.. (张淑明. (2018). 阿斯塔菲耶夫创作中的西伯利亚形象 // 中国语言文学研究).
11. Zhang, Shuming. (2020). Image of Siberia in Russian Literature between 17th and 19th Century. Literature and Culture Studies, 3, 20–25. (张淑明. (2020). 17世纪至19世纪俄罗斯文学中的西伯利亚形象 // 文学与文化).

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Russian Russian literature in the Assessment of Chinese Critics, the article presented for consideration, proposed for publication in the journal "Litera", is undoubtedly relevant, due to the growing interest in the study of the Chinese language and culture in our country, as well as due to the fact that the features of the reception of Russian culture are one of the promising areas in modern philology and a vast area for research. The consideration of the specifics of the "Siberian text" of Russian literature in Chinese criticism is. The article examines the current problems of literary criticism through the prism of two different cultures. It should be noted that there is a relatively small number of studies on this topic in Russian literary criticism. The article is innovative, one of the first in Russian philology devoted to the study of such issues. The article presents a research methodology, the choice of which is quite adequate to the goals and objectives of the work. The author turns, among other things, to various methods to confirm the hypothesis put forward. Unfortunately, the author does not specify the volume of the selected language corpus, the sampling methodology and the principles of selection. This work was done professionally, in compliance with the basic canons of scientific research. The research was carried out in line with modern scientific approaches, the work consists of an introduction containing the formulation of the problem, the main part, traditionally beginning with a review of theoretical sources and scientific directions, a research and final one, which presents the conclusions obtained by the author. The theoretical conclusions are illustrated with language examples in Chinese and Russian. It should be noted that the conclusion requires strengthening, it does not fully reflect the tasks set by the author and does not contain prospects for further research in line with the stated issues. The bibliography of the article contains 11 sources, among which works in both Russian and Chinese are presented. Unfortunately, the article does not contain references to the fundamental works of Russian researchers, such as monographs, PhD and doctoral dissertations. The comments made are not significant and do not detract from the overall positive impression of the reviewed work. Typos, spelling and syntactic errors, inaccuracies in the text of the work were not found. The work is innovative, representing the author's vision of solving the issue under consideration and may have a logical continuation in further research. The theoretical significance of the research lies in the fact that it contributes to the general methodological and applied potential of studying the problems of interaction between culture and space. The practical significance of the research lies in the possibility of using its results in the teaching of university courses in literary studies, literary criticism, as well as courses in interdisciplinary research on the relationship between language and society. The article will undoubtedly be useful to a wide range of people, philologists, undergraduates and graduate students of specialized universities. The article "The Siberian text of Russian literature in the assessment of Chinese critics" can be recommended for publication in a scientific journal.