Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Psychology and Psychotechnics
Reference:

The influence of combining professional and educational activities on the stress resistance of adult students

Zinatullina Azaliia Maratovna

ORCID: 0000-0001-9223-5074

Lecturer, Department of Scientific Basis of Extreme Psychology, Moscow State University of Psychology and Education

127051, Russia, Moscow, Sretenka str., 29

azaliazinatullina@mail.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0722.2023.3.43694

EDN:

UBKFBG

Received:

30-07-2023


Published:

06-08-2023


Abstract: In this article, the purpose of the research was to study the impact of combining professional and educational activities on the indicators of stress resistance of adult students in connection with the growing importance of higher education and a large number of competencies in the labor market in order to be a competitive person. Moreover, modern society is undergoing a number of changes that are reflected in various areas of life, which additionally affects the physical and psychological health of a person. Thus, 334 people took part in the study among the respondents: 187 students in the magistracy and 147 not studying at the moment. Techniques for determining stress resistance were used - a test for stress resistance according to the method of K. Schreiner and a test for stress resistance by Holmes and Rage, as well as a method for determining neuropsychic instability "Forecast". The results showed that students in the magistracy have lower stress resistance than adults who do not study, which indicates high workloads associated with the implementation of various types of employment at the same time. For example, many adult learners have families, minor children, dependent parents, other social activities, etc. Thus, the factor of combining professional and educational activities, indeed, affects the instability to stressful experiences, indicating the urgent need to develop adaptive skills of adult respondents.


Keywords:

stress, stress resistance, magistracy, training, higher education, health, adult, professional activity, employment, educational activity

This article is automatically translated.

Introduction

In the realities of today, higher education is becoming a necessary stage of personal and professional development of a person of the XXI century, especially given the transformational processes in the economy and the high importance of the growth of the influence of human capital on it [2]. The formation of science and the education system are strategically important directions of the Russian state, which is interested in achieving international prestige and authority in order to integrate into the world process [5]. A modern specialist in the framework of his profession cannot do without the implementation of professional development tasks, the acquisition of new knowledge and competencies, the improvement of existing skills, since the employer's requirements on the labor market for applicants are growing, and therefore the second and (or) additional higher education are part of the process of constant professionalization. Thus, when choosing the level of education, adult specialists often give preference to the master's degree institute, which offers training in a wide range of areas where it is possible to improve their qualifications in various types of activities over a two-year period of study [5].

At the same time, we can observe an increase in external stressful factors related to the socio-political and economic situation every day, which, in turn, can lead to various man-made, informational and environmental threats [4], which negatively affects the emotional and physical state of the individual. Moreover, the very fact of simultaneous combination of training and performance of work duties for adult learners contributes to intellectual overload and, as a result, high overstrain, which also affects the effectiveness of the activities carried out.

In connection with the above, the skill of stress tolerance in our time is one of the key personal characteristics of a modern person, which allows you to adapt to constantly changing conditions in a rapidly developing society. As A.B. Leonova notes, the issues of mental well-being, the disclosure of the motivation of specialists and ensuring productive work affect not only external stimuli and causes of stress, but also the search for adaptive capabilities and resources of the individual, thanks to which she can cope with difficult and critical situations, and in the works of G. Selye, who studied the phenomenon of "stress", it is the "mechanism of plastic adaptation of the subject to the requirements of the environment" that is laid down [6]. And an important criterion indicating successful individual adaptation to environmental conditions is physiological and mental health under various circumstances. And here it is advisable to talk about "eustress", when even with stressful events or experiences, an individual is able to maintain his well-being. But the reverse reaction will indicate "distress" when the adaptive resources of the body are not enough or they are exhausted to overcome the difficulties that arise.

Returning to adult students, we understand that the combination of the educational process and the implementation of professional activities, as well as the fulfillment of other life obligations (family, social, etc.) for many will be a stressful factor. It is also worth emphasizing that it is in adulthood that a person also faces a crisis of self-actualization in the context of his life path, when there is a restructuring of previously habitual stereotypes, attitudes, habits, views and values [9]. In other words, during the period of maturity, there are a huge number of life tasks and goals that require the development of stress tolerance skills and adaptive abilities from the individual.

Thus, the aim of the study was to study the influence of the factor of combining professional and educational activities on the stress resistance of adult students.

 

Materials and methods of research

1. Stress tolerance test according to the K method. Shriner, which includes 9 questions assessing stress resistance. The scale of this technique is the reverse: the higher the score, the lower the degree of regulation in stressful situations) [10].

2. The Holmes and Rage stress tolerance test, which includes 43 statements on the assessment of determining the level of individual stress load and stress resistance. The scale of this technique is the reverse: the lower the score, the greater the degree of resistance to stress [8].

3. The method of determining neuropsychiatric instability "Prognosis", consisting of 84 questions. The scales of this technique are straight: the lower the score, the higher the neuropsychic stability [7].

4. Methods of mathematical statistics: Student's t-criterion, one-factor analysis of variance Anova.

 

Selection

The empirical basis of the study was:

- 147 people who have higher education and carry out professional activities, but are not currently studying from 20 to 60 years old: 22 men and 125 women;

- 187 people who are studying for a master's degree and carry out professional activities from 20 to 60 years: 106 men and 81 women.

The characteristics of the sample are presented in Table 1.

 

Table 1. Characteristics of the empirical study sample

Group

Paul

 

Quantity

Middle age

Undergraduates who combine training with professional activity

Men

22

38,3

Women

125

35,6

Specialists who carry out only professional activities

Men

106

36,4

Women

81

47,2

 

Research results and their discussion

The results of a comparative analysis of the stress resistance of students and non-students of adult respondents are presented in Table 2.

 

Table 2. Comparative analysis of average indicators of stress resistance of students and non-students of men and women

Name of the group

Stress tolerance test by the method

To. Shriner (reverse scale)

t emf

p

Holmes and Rage Stress Tolerance Test (reverse scale)

t emf

p

The method of determining the neuropsychiatric instability "Prognosis"

t emf

p

Male students

4,9

2,9

0,01

736,0

4,5

0,01

26,3

2,5

0,05

Non-studying men

3,7

487,6

22,6

Women students

4,2

4,7

0,01

721,0

7,3

0,01

24,5

2,1

0,05

Non-studying women

2,7

384,3

22,1

 

Based on the data obtained, statistically significant differences were found in all methods for determining stress resistance in men and women. So, men who are not studying according to the stress tolerance test according to the K method. Shriners are resistant to stress (3.7 points at p ? 0.01), while men studying at the magistracy have a higher score, which indicates the need for them to use self-control methods if stressful situations arise (4.9 points at p? 0.01). In accordance with the Holmes and Rage stress tolerance test, non-students and male students have scores higher than the normative indicators, however, it is worth noting that the former are more comfortable with individual stress load (487.6 points at p ? 0.01) than male undergraduates (736.0 points at p? 0.01). Similar results were obtained using the method of determining neuropsychiatric instability "Prognosis": the scores of students (26.3 points at p < 0.05) and non-students (22.6 points at p < 0.05) of men indicate that there is a probability of nervous breakdowns, and in moments of extreme and difficult situations it increases. At the same time, we draw attention to the fact that after all, men who are not studying are more stable in their behavior, manifestation of character and feel better.

As for women, statistically significant differences were obtained by the K method. Schreiner's test – students with 4.2 points (at p? 0.01), non–students with 2.7 points (at p? 0.01); according to the Holmes and Rage test – students with 721.0 points (at p? 0.01), non-students with 384.3 points (at p? 0.01); according to the "Forecast" method - students have 24.5 points (at p? 0.01), non-students have 22.1 points (at p? 0.01). As we can see, women who do not study according to the first method are resistant to stress, unlike students. Almost 2 times non-trained women have a greater resistance to it, and they may face neuropsychiatric tension in difficult situations, but to a lesser extent.

Thus, both male and female students, as we believe, due to the high loads associated with combining professional and educational activities, along with the fulfillment of a number of other social, family obligations, have lower stress tolerance, and therefore a one-factor analysis of variance Anova was subsequently conducted in order to identify the influence of the factor of combination two types of activity on the indicators of resistance to stress. The results are shown in Figures 1-3.

 

Figure 1. The effect of combining professional and educational activities on stress resistance (according to the method of K. Shriner's)

Note. 1 – students in the master's program; 2 – not students; current. effect : F(1, 331) = 17.042, p =,00005*.

 

Figure 2. The effect of combining professional and educational activities on stress tolerance (according to the Holmes and Rage test)

Note. 1 – students in the master's program; 2 – not students; current. effect : F(1, 331) = 60.501, p =,00000*.

 

Figure 3. The effect of combining professional and educational activities on neuropsychiatric instability (according to the "Forecast" method)

Note. 1 – students in the master's program; 2 – not students; current. effect : F(1, 331) = 3.9052, p =,04897*.

 

From the graphs presented in the form of figures, it can be seen that the combination of professional and educational activities really affects the indicators of stress resistance and neuropsychiatric instability. This may explain the fact that non-learning adults have more internal physical and mental resources to overcome various stressful events and situations. Moreover, you need to understand that studying in a master's degree is an additional intellectual load, and along with this, the following tasks appear simultaneously for students: 1) the need to resolve the issue of paying for master's degree in the absence of a sufficient number of budget places in accordance with the Order of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation dated 08/21/2020 No. 1076 "On approval of the Procedure for admission to higher education educational programs - bachelor's degree programs, specialty programs, master's degree programs"; 2) the implementation of scientific activities, so how to obtain a master's degree according to the Order of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation dated 22.03.2006 No. 62 "On the educational program of higher professional education for specialized training of masters" implies conducting high-quality scientific research [3]; 3) performing a large number of tasks that are part of independent work [1]; 4) in addition to educational activities in the master's program, students are required to undergo various types of practices that undergraduates should have time to attend along with employment, etc.

Despite the actual high importance for adult specialists of obtaining a master's degree, additional and (or) highly specialized education requires huge resources for advanced training, obtaining new knowledge and the formation of important professional competencies, therefore, thanks to the study, it was found out that today the question of the development of adaptive capabilities of adult learners within the framework of their development is acute. stress resistance.

 

Conclusions

The modern world is in constant development, which affects the economic, political, spiritual, social spheres of society, therefore, it is important for a person today to have various types of skills, abilities, knowledge, to be competitive, and therefore studying at a higher school is one of the necessary stages in the framework of professional development, formation and self-determination, which is the most safely provided there is such a personal quality as stress tolerance, because at the same time there is a high risk of information stress, intellectual and physical overload.

As the results of the study among adult respondents aged 20 to 60 years showed, the factor of combining master's degree studies and professional activity has a direct impact on stress resistance indicators. Thus, undergraduates are more prone to experiencing stress and neuropsychiatric breakdowns, unlike adult specialists engaged only in the implementation of work activities. All this makes us take into account the urgent need to develop stress tolerance, critical thinking skills and analytical thinking of an adult who aspires to be a full-fledged, physically and mentally healthy person.

 

Thanks. The author thanks the project manager, Doctor of Psychological Sciences, Professor T.N. Berezina.

References
1. Balikoeva, M.I., & Rubaeva, V.P. (2016). Organization of independent work of undergraduates in a foreign language in the framework of professionally oriented education. Internet magazine "World of Science", 4(3). Retrieved from http://mir-nauki.com/PDF/18PDMN316.pdf
2. Demidko, E.V., & Thirnadtsatko, O.A. (2020). Features and opportunities of the institute of magistracy in the system of higher education. Modern problems of science and education, 5. Retrieved from https://science-education.ru/ru/article/view?id=30160
3. Ivashchenko, T.N. (2015). The role of the institute of magistracy in the system of Russian education. Vestnik gosudarstvennogo i munitsipal'nogo upravleniya, 4, 75-79.
4. Karabuschenko, N.B., & Stefanishina, M.V. (2018) Peculiarities of overcoming stress by psychology students. Bulletin of the Orenburg State University, 2(214), 77-83.
5. Kuzmina, M.A. (2017). Formation of the second stage of higher education as a factor in improving the quality of education. Regional authorities, local government and civil society: interaction mechanisms: Collection of scientific papers, Saratov, January 26, 2017. Saratov: Volga Institute of Management named after P.A. Stolypin-branch of the Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Professional Education "Russian Academy of National Economy and Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation", 36-38.
6. Leonova, A.B. (2016). Complex psychological technologies of stress management and assessment of individual stress resistance: an experience of integrating various research paradigms. Bulletin of the Moscow University, 3, 63-72.
7. Prokhorov, A.O. (Ed.). (2004). Workshop on the psychology of states: textbook. allowance. St. Petersburg: Speech.
8. Raigorodsky, D.Ya. (Ed.). (2002). Practical psychodiagnostics: Methods and tests: [Textbook. allowance]. Samara: BAHRAKH-M (GUP IPK Ulyan. Press House).
9. Sapogova, E.E. (2013). Existential psychology of adulthood. Moscow: Meaning.
10. Schreiner, K. (1993). How to relieve stress: 30 ways to improve your well-being in 3 minutes: Per. from English. Christian Schreiner; [Foreword. Yu.V. Pakhomov]. Moscow: Progress: Ed. firm "Univers".

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The object of research in the proposed article is adult education as a pedagogical process.The subject is the effect of combining academic and professional activities on the stress tolerance of the subject. The relevance of the work is undoubtedly due to the fact that an extremely small number of adults can afford to study and not work. At the same time, as a rule, it is professional activity that acts as the main source of stress. From a methodological point of view, the article has a pronounced practical character, while the main research method is a comparative experiment. Mathematical methods of psychological research are actively used, which allow us to talk about the validity of the results. The methodological tools have been selected reasonably and correspond to the objectives of the article. The work is done in a language that fully complies with the norms of scientific style. The list of references meets the requirements and finds a real meaningful reflection in the text. The article may be of interest to a very wide audience interested in and exploring andragogical issues, given that relatively little attention is paid to adult education in the publication space in comparison with the education of, for example, schoolchildren or bachelors. The only fundamental disadvantage of this work, in our opinion, is the actual absence of a theoretical part in it. From a structural point of view, the theory is presented in the format of a preamble, which rather reveals and emphasizes relevance than offers an analysis of a scientific nature. In the work with the proposed title, the following issues are expected to be disclosed in the theoretical part. An overview of existing research and the vectors that the authors adhere to in the problem field under consideration. The analysis of the social, psychological and pedagogical characteristics of the adult contingent that determine the impact of academic activity on the psychological sphere. Analysis of the positive impact of academic interactions (as an opportunity to escape from the work routine) and identification of conditions for maximizing this influence. Given that the concept of "adult" is extremely extensible, perhaps a sample consisting, for example, only of undergraduates, or limited to 20-40 years old, would be more successful. Nevertheless, at the age of 20 and 60, the social situation is very different, and therefore the attitude towards education and the influence of the process of these social relations on the human psyche. Conclusions about the development of stress tolerance are staged, the conclusion would benefit if the author indicated specific ways of psychological and pedagogical work in this direction. The presented remarks are given rather in the order of designating future potential research vectors, taking into account the real social significance of the issues raised by the author. They do not negate the scientific value and high quality of the text. The article fully complies with the basic structural and substantive requirements for works of this kind, and can be published in a peer-reviewed journal in the psychological and pedagogical field.