Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Urban Studies
Reference:

The heritage of industrial fringe belts in the logic of a modern city development

Logunova Elena Nikolaevna

Assistant at the Urban Design and Planning Department, Institute of Architecture and Design, Siberian Federal University

660018, Russia, Krasnoyarsk Territory, Krasnoyarsk, Svobodny Avenue, 82, art. 6

el.lgnv@yandex.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2310-8673.2023.2.40793

EDN:

STEWZC

Received:

19-05-2023


Published:

31-05-2023


Abstract: Modern urban development strategies are aimed at rationalizing land use, which leads to the search for inefficiently used territories, which include industrial conversion heritage - sites of liquidated production enterprises, modernized transport hubs. The object of the study is industrial fringe belts as a structural component of the city plan. The author considers the processes of formation of industrial fringe belts as a result of natural urban growth and their transformation in the dynamics of the development of a modern city. The analysis of the formation of industrial fringe belts in the planning structure of domestic and foreign cities is carried out. The international experience and legislative aspects of reconstruction of industrial and conversion heritage in the structure of a modern city are considered. The study summarizes theoretical views on the degraded industrial conversion territories. The main directions of transformation of industrial and conversion heritage in the structure of fringe belts are presented. Depending on the availability of valuable buildings and the size of the site, reconstruction may involve both the introduction of a new function with the preservation of architectural volume, and the total demolition of the existing buildings and the formation of a new spatial solution. The functional and spatial features of the fringe belt sites are described. The necessity of identifying the sites of industrial fringe belts as a single interconnected system for a more comprehensive assessment of the potential for the transformation of industrial-conversion territories is substantiated.


Keywords:

urban fringe belts, industrial-conversion territories, reconstruction, urban morphology, urban heritage, modern city, theory and practice, rationalization of land use, urban planning structure, urban planning

This article is automatically translated.

Domestic urban planning is focused on the development and reconstruction of existing settlements instead of new construction. Since the beginning of the XXI century, urban development programs have been adopted aimed at achieving the compactness of cities, compacting their development and unlocking the potential of the existing urban fabric, taking into account modern requirements.  This leads to an inventory and search for irrationally functioning urban lands. According to Rosstat research, more than 60% of urban areas are used inefficiently, and the total number of stagnant urban areas is more than 950 [1]. According to the estimates of the European Environment Agency (EEA), about three million inexpediently exploited sites have been identified in European settlements [2]. At the same time, their reconstruction and re-profiling is more economically justified than the development of new territories due to their advantageous location along transport arteries and the availability of developed infrastructure.The periods of the origin and prosperity of industrial activity have left a particularly vivid trace in the structure of modern cities in the form of an interlace of industrial and residential areas.

Subsequent modernization at the end of the XX-beginning of the XXI centuries, the liquidation of production facilities or their removal outside the city limits provoked the search for ways of large-scale transformation of the urban fabric, achieving spatial and functional connectivity and reintegration of industrial conversion territories into the city plan.

The researchers note the need for a special attitude to degrading industrial conversion territories and making informed decisions on their renovation and the purpose of rational land use.For this kind of unprofitable spaces, various definitions are used that characterize their insufficient functioning efficiency. Spanish architect and theorist I. de Sola-Morales describes unused areas in the structure of the city as an "indefinite landscape" (from the French "terrain vague", "vague" has meanings as "indefinite and at the same time" "unoccupied", "free") – voids in urban space, spontaneously derived from economic, social processes of the city. The transformation of such places, as the architect believes, should not be immediate and should be guided by methods of forced assignment of functional content, but should be carried out gradually and based on the analysis of adjacent territories and identification of the needs of urban space [3]. H. Armstrong introduces the concept of "landscapes of contempt" (from the English "landscapes of contempt"), based on from the general attitude of designers and residents to urban areas that have fallen into disrepair. In her opinion, the presence of voids in the urban fabric is an important component of it, which on the one hand makes it possible to identify problems of urban planning, on the other hand, provides a resource for compacting urban development, and their reorganization requires deliberate decisions [4]. R. Tranchik identifies "lost spaces" as part of American cities (from the English lost spaces) – unused territories of the city, without clear boundaries, which do not make any positive contribution to the life of the city, violate the connectivity of its territories, while having the potential for transformation. The lost spaces, in addition to inactive public spaces, also include non-functioning port zones, railway stations, territories of former military institutions and sites of industrial enterprises outside the city [5]. I. V. Kukina defines zones of obsolescence and marginalization as failures of the urban fabric and emphasizes that they arise as a result of the fact that "the city...is a consequence of reflexive projects "according to the law", which lead to the formation of independent rules, laws, norms, processes, random, subjective and unregulated" [6, p. 68].

 

Urban marginal beltsIn the foreign theory of urban morphology, the historical and geographical approach to the study of the existing urban fabric allowed us to justify the appearance of specific marginal belts (from the English "urban fringe belts") in the structure of the city, including, among other things, industrial conversion.

It is established that at each stage of the development of the planning structure of cities, marginal territories are formed spontaneously and chaotically, encircling urban development [7-10]. The conditions of occurrence are reflected in their spatial and functional structure as a whole: peripheral territories, as a rule, have an intricate street and road network and a pattern of land surveying sites, low density of development, extensive types of land use, such as communal storage and industrial, recreational facilities, territories of gardens and vegetable gardens, sports, religious and public institutions. In the future, with the expansion of the city, new buildings appear on undeveloped lands, crossing the established periphery, since morphological characteristics and the structure of land use make it difficult to integrate it into the territories that have developed according to project plans and cause the complexity of the outskirts to transform [11]. Thus, previously marginal areas are included in the internal structure of the city, forming a single system, heterogeneous in plan and functions and remain unchanged for a long time as a characteristic imprint of the previous stages of urban development, regardless of the design decisions made in the master plans. The appearance of marginal belts is associated with fixation lines – barriers to the development of the city (river valleys, terrain features, city walls, railways and highways, economic cycles, industrial enterprises and complexes) [12]. Depending on the depth of the city's history, several marginal belts can be found in its plan, which reflect its functional profile of a particular historical period. Examples are the green rings of boulevards on the site of fortifications around historical centers, a system of religious sites that were once located on the border of cities, as well as green belts created to curb the expansion of urban development, Periods of industrialization and the development of rail transport affected the particularly extensive nature of the outskirts of cities, which later entered the city limits. In the structure of a modern city, industrial and industrial marginal belts disrupt transport and functional connections, and the physical characteristics of the sections of marginal belts that have lost their primary functional purpose directly affect their inclusion in the processes of the city's vital activity.

The system of distinctive industrial-conversion territories is observed in the structure of cities of various cultural contexts. For example, in the plan of the city of Nantes (France), the industrial marginal belt of the XVIII-XIX centuries stands out, in the plan of Istanbul (Turkey) – the middle of the XX century; in Chicago (USA) – the industrial-industrial marginal belt of the XX century.

 Analysis of the formation of industrial marginal zones and their transformation in the structure of a modern city

In the international practice of urban planning, the transformation of industrial and conversion heritage is carried out mainly locally, without taking into account the patterns of origin of such territories and neighboring ones.

Depending on the availability of valuable buildings and the size of the site, reconstruction may involve both the introduction of a new function with the preservation of architectural volume, and the total demolition of the existing buildings and the formation of a new spatial solution. The main trends in the reorganization of industrial conversion territories are their conversion into office and business centers, residential buildings, cultural facilities [13-17].

Three industrial and industrial marginal zones have been identified in Krasnoyarsk. The first marginal belt of the second half of the XIX century borders on the central core of the city, it includes communal storage enterprises, a steam locomotive repair plant (EVRZ) based on railway workshops, the territory of the former Krasnoyarsk Combine harvester plant. The next industrial-industrial marginal belt of the first half of the XX century has a linear character, its formation is associated with the construction of a railway bridge over the river. The Yenisei (1899) and the tracing of the Trans-Siberian Railway on the right bank, where by 1927 a brick factory, a sawmill, sawmills, a backwater harbor appeared. This marginal belt was gradually compacted by large industrial enterprises in connection with the first stage of industrialization of Krasnoyarsk, then during the evacuation of production facilities during the Great Patriotic War and in the postwar period. On the left bank, the marginal belt of the first half of the XX century has a fragmentary outline and was formed from the west, near the Nikolaevsky cemetery (1908), a slaughterhouse and a sausage factory (in 1939 united into a meat processing plant). By the beginning of the 1950s: in its structure, a site was allocated for the Krasnoyarsk TV factory "Iskra". The third industrial-industrial marginal belt of the second half of the XX century was fragmentally formed on the left bank and is associated with the second stage of industrialization of the city. It includes an aluminum plant and a branch from the Trans-Siberian Railway to ensure its production processes. Along the dead-end branch of the railway and the Northern Highway, commercial and communal storage and manufacturing enterprises are concentrated.

To date, the processes of transformation of industrial conversion territories of various scales have been noted.The buildings of the TV factory and the plant of photosensitive materials "Kvant" have been re-equipped with shopping and entertainment complexes TC "On Svobodny" and TC "Kvant".  Radical changes have occurred at the site of the Krasnoyarsk Combine Plant, where, after the liquidation of production, a multi-apartment residential development of the Novoostrovsky district appears. The existing street and road network, the presence of valuable architectural objects determines the parameters of the new district, which are tied to the existing context. In addition, in the structure of the marginal belt of the second half of the XIX century, it is proposed to build a business complex Krasnoyarsk City. Reconstruction is observed at the sites of the Krasnoyarsk Woodworking Plant and Shipbuilding Plant in connection with their liquidation or transfer outside the city. Residential development of the Southern Coast, Quiet Dawns and the Platinum Arena sports stadium appears in these territories in preparation for the Winter Universiade 2019. The loss of the former function made it possible to place a large sports facility in the inner structure of the city in transport accessibility. Such significant changes will affect the territories of the Krasnoyarsk oil depot and shipyard, areas of which, according to the projects, are allocated for residential development.

Similar decisions are made in other cities of the Russian Federation. Thus, there are several industrial marginal zones in the structure of Moscow, the size of which is increasing from the central core to the periphery, which is associated with the development and increase in the scale of production activities. The most extensive territories are occupied by the industrial-industrial marginal belt of the late XIX-first half of the XX centuries. The impetus for its active development was the construction of the Moscow District Railway in 1908, traced through forests, swamps, agricultural lands and industrial sites adjacent to the city. In the future, the city border was established along the line of the Moscow District Railway, and numerous industrial facilities continued to concentrate along it during the following five-year plans. In the second half of the XX century, with the development of mass housing construction, the development crossed significant territories of the industrial-industrial marginal belt of the late XIX-first half of the XX centuries. (Figure 1).

 

Fig.1. Industrial-industrial marginal belt of the late XIX-first half of the XX centuries: on the left – on the plan of 1925, the location of industrial enterprises on the outskirts of Moscow is recorded; on the right – sections of the industrial-industrial marginal belt in the structure of the modern city (Sources: retromap.ru , yandex.ru/maps )

 

Currently, after the removal or liquidation of industrial enterprises, the railway tracks laid near the historical part of the city made it possible to organize a system of railway passenger transport – the Moscow Central Ring integrated with the metro, as well as transport hubs. Industrial conversion territories have become a resource for the appearance of such objects as the Moscow City business center (on the site of the Dorogomilovsky quarries), the ZIL residential district (on the site of the Likhachev Plant), the Arma business quarter (on the site of the Moscow Gas Plant), etc. Under the program "Redevelopment of the industrial zone", transformation is provided industrial enterprises of the industrial-industrial marginal belt of the late XIX-first half of the XX centuries, "Upper boilers", "Varshavskoe highway", "Grayvoronovo", "Hammer and Sickle", "Western Port", the territory of the Riga cargo yard.

In addition, the isolated specifics of the functioning of enterprises allowed the preservation of buildings with historical and cultural value.

Industrial conversion territories are a resource for the formation of a polycentric structure of the city, the placement of necessary social and public facilities in transport and pedestrian accessibility. The status of a new facility often has a local or regional level, less often – state or international. For example, in London (Great Britain), the industrial and industrial marginal zone of the second half of the XIX-early XX centuries. on the territory of the world's largest port and the adjacent Docklands area, during the change of the city's profile from an industrial center to a financial one, a special economic zone "Isle of Dogs" was organized and a business and residential area was built.

In the city of Lille, once the industrial capital of France, the reorganization of the industrial and conversion heritage in the marginal zone of the XVIII–XIX centuries allowed to revive the economic potential of the city after the closure of the city-forming textile industries in the second half of the 1960s. During the point reconstruction in the 1980s, some production areas were adapted to new functions, mainly related to the service sector. The location of the sections along the railway line and the modernization of urban transport ensured the accessibility of previously isolated territories. The site in the eastern part of the marginal belt, favorably located relative to transport links, underwent the largest transformations, where the Eurolille project was implemented (master plan development - OMA company). As a result of the reconstruction of the railway tracks for the movement of high-speed trains connecting Lille with other European cities, international business, office, shopping centers and residential development have concentrated in the adjacent territories. The former peripheral territories have become an administrative and financial area of international importance (Figure 2).

 

Fig. 2. The formation of the industrial-industrial marginal belt of the XVIII-XIX centuries. Lille.

From left to right: the outskirts of the city on the 1880 plan, the marginal belt is included in the urban development, the 1967 plan, aerial photography of 2022, the Eurolille project implementation site is highlighted in red (Sources: cartes-livres-anciens.com , www.historicpictoric.com , yandex.ru/maps )

 

An example of a more comprehensive transformation of the industrial and conversion heritage is the Green Rays of Milan project. On the outskirts of Milan, as the main industrial hub of Italy in the XIX-first half of the XX centuries, large production facilities of various profiles were concentrated: from the production of fabrics to automobiles, as well as a large number of chemical industry enterprises. This was clearly reflected in the modern plan of the city in the form of an industrial-industrial marginal belt of the XIX-first half of the XX centuries.

At the beginning of the XXI century, with the withdrawal of all enterprises from the city limits, a thorough analysis of empty plots was carried out and the concept of "Green Rays of Milan" was proposed. According to the designers, the territories of the industrial-industrial marginal belt of the XIX-first half of the XX centuries and the marginal belt of the XXI century are connected into a single system by radial linear spaces from the city center to the suburbs. In this system, the territories of former industrial enterprises are nodal elements and are compacted by public and residential buildings.To date, the Portello Park project has been implemented at the Alfa Romeo plant site (authors: Charles Jenks, Andreas Kipar, LAND Bureau, 2000-2013). In the territories of the Porta Nuova station, which has lost relevance due to the construction of Garibaldi station, business complexes and residential quarters have been erected (LAND Milano, 2004-2017). On the site of the Falck steel mill (author of the master plan Renzo Piano, 2005-present), the project provides for the preservation and conversion of several objects of industrial architecture, the placement of a park and residential development.

 

Legislative aspects of the transformation of industrial and conversion heritage

Separately, it is worth highlighting the approach to the transformation of industrial-conversion heritage from the point of view of legislation, which implies a more holistic view of solving the problems of these territories. In Berlin (Germany) in the last decades of the XX century, one of the large-scale processes of liquidation of industrial enterprises took place. At the same time, the city authorities decided not to abandon production facilities within the city, the total area of which was 4,500 hectares, but to preserve the original purpose with the reorientation of production activities, which, of course, is of strategic importance for any city, at least to streamline traffic flows. In order to avoid widespread repurposing of sites that have lost their industrial function for office and business development, about 1,700 hectares have been reserved in the urban development plan since 1992. to accommodate high-tech industries, educational and research centers with priority for small businesses and environmentally friendly technologies. About 2,900 hectares in the structure of the city have already been transformed into actively functioning industrial enterprises. [18-19]. In the USA at the beginning of the 1990s, the concept of "brownfields" was legally established in order to comprehensively solve the problems of industrial conversion territories, implying degraded, previously developed territories that are not used according to their potential [20]. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) The program "Brownfields Initiative" was adopted. The purpose of the program is the restoration and reuse of such territories. Nevertheless, these legislative decisions do not consider the commonality of the emergence and interconnectedness of such territories. In addition, the spatial characteristics of the sites are not taken into account, which to a greater extent affect the possibilities of reconstruction of industrial conversion territories and the degree of their integration into the surrounding context.

 

ConclusionAnalysis of the theoretical basis and practical experience of reconstruction of industrial conversion territories shows that their transformation is carried out mainly locally and is not interconnected, without taking into account the historical stages of the formation of the city and considering these sites as an integral structural part of the urban fabric, which is assumed by the theory of marginal belts.

The study of the mechanisms and laws of the formation of marginal belts, their features and influence on the subsequent stages of the development of the city allows us to explain the physical composition of the existing planning structure and more reasonably and realistically predict the possibilities of its development and reorganization. In this regard, it is relevant to identify industrial and industrial marginal belts as an integral interconnected structure, which will allow to assess to a greater extent the urban development potential of industrial conversion territories and the conditions for their integration into the surrounding space of a modern city.

References
1. Shvidkovskii, D. O. (2022). Spatial development of Russia: history and the present day. Academia. Architecture and construction, 3, 5–13.
2. Gertsberg, L. (2022). Sustainable cities. Formation of urban planning premises. Academia. Architecture and construction, 3, 69–76. doi: 10.22337/2077-9038-2022-4-123-129
3. De Solà-Morales, I. (1995). Terrain vague. England: Cambridge.
4. Armstrong, H. (2006). Time, Dereliction and Beauty: an Argument for «Landscapes of Contempt». The Landscape Architect, IFLA Conference Papers, 116-127.
5. Trancik, R. (1986). Finding lost space: theories of urban design. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Company.
6. Kukina, I. V. (2014). Tendencies of urban agglomerations development. Foreign experience. Krasnoyarsk: Siberian Federal University.
7. Whitehand, J.W.R. (1994). Development Cycles and Urban Landscapes. Geography, 99, 3-17.
8. Oliveira, V., Yaygin, M. A. (2022). The concept of the morphological region: developments and prospects. Urban Morphology, 24(1), 35–52.
9. Ünlü, T. (2022). Large-scale urban development and the possibility of new models in fringe-belt studies: the question of the ‘umbrella fringe belt’. Urban Morphology, 26(2), 189–193.
10. Kubat, A. S., Çalışkan, E. K. (2022) Tracking Morphological Agencies in the Alienated Fringe Belt Plots of Istanbul. International Journal of Architecture and Planning, 10 (2), 711-734.
11. Conzen, M. P., Gu, K., Whitehand, J. W. R. (2012). Comparing Traditional Urban Form in China and Europe: A Fringe-Belt Approach. Urban Geography, 33 (1), 22-45.
12. Conzen, M.R.G. (1969). Alnwick, Northumberland: A Study in Town-Plan Analysis. London: Institute of British Geographers.
13. Sapkova, A. N. (2022). Renovation of industrial facilities in Moscow. Electronic Science.
14. Panteleeva, M. S., Kosenko, A. O. (2023) Industrial park as a promising form of redevelopment of industrial zones in Moscow. Territories development, 1 (31), 86-96. doi: 10.32324/2412-8945-2023-1-86-96
15. Razumova, P.S., Finogenov, A.I. (2021). Renovation of historical textile enterprises as one of the mechanisms for sustainable cities development in Central Russia. Innovations and investments, 5, 203-208.
16. Vlasova, M. F., Leonova, L. B. (2021). Redevelopment of industrial zones in large cities to create a comfortable urban environment in Russia. Construction Economics, 5 (71), 15-26.
17. Gomozov, V. I. (2022). Reconstruction of the "Gray Belt" of St. Petersburg: the problem of the formation of the street network. Innovations and investments, 7, 90-93.
18. Titov, S.A., Biriukov, A.P. (2015). European experience of industrial districts redevelopment programs in megacities. Fundamental research, 11-3, 605-610.
19. Osipov, V. S., Oborin, M. S. (2018). Foreign experience in the development of new territories. Intellect. Innovation. Investments, 7. 44-50.
20. Kabatskaia, L. N. (2020). Foreign experience of legal regulation of liquidation of accumulated environmental damage. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 1, 114-128.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

In the journal Urbanistics, the author presented his article "The legacy of industrial and industrial marginal zones in the logic of modern city development", in which a study of options for changing industrial zones of large cities of the world was conducted. The author proceeds in studying this issue from the fact that modern urban planning is focused on the development and reconstruction of existing settlements instead of new construction. Since the beginning of the XXI century, urban development programs have been adopted aimed at achieving the compactness of cities, compacting their buildings and unlocking the potential of the existing urban fabric, taking into account modern requirements. According to the author, their reconstruction and redevelopment is economically more justified than the development of new territories due to their advantageous location along transport arteries and the availability of developed infrastructure. The relevance of the study is due to the need to identify industrial and industrial marginal belts as an integral interconnected structure, which will allow to assess to a greater extent the urban planning potential of industrial conversion territories and the conditions for their integration into the surrounding space of a modern city. The purpose of the article is to analyze the theoretical basis and practical experience of reconstruction of industrial conversion territories. This analysis constitutes the scientific novelty of the study. The methodological basis was general scientific methods of analysis and synthesis, socio-cultural and descriptive analysis. The theoretical justification is the works of domestic and foreign scientists and practitioners devoted to the problems of research. The empirical basis is the existing projects and renovation programs of unused industrial and industrial marginal zones in such large cities as Moscow, Krasnoyarsk, London, Lille, Milan. After analyzing the scientific validity of the studied issues, the author notes that most researchers come to the general conclusion about the need for special treatment of degrading industrial conversion territories and making informed decisions on their renovation and the purpose of rational land use. For such unprofitable spaces, the author identifies various definitions characterizing their insufficient functioning efficiency: "uncertain landscape", "landscapes of contempt", "lost spaces", "zones of obsolescence and marginalization". Based on the provisions of the theory of urban morphology and the historical and geographical approach to the study of the existing urban fabric, the author substantiates the appearance of specific marginal belts. Depending on the depth of the city's history in its plan, the article identifies several marginal belts that reflect its functional profile of a particular historical period: green rings of boulevards on the site of fortifications around historical centers, a system of religious sites once located on the border of cities, as well as green belts created to curb urban sprawl buildings. According to the author, in the international practice of urban planning, the transformation of industrial and conversion heritage is carried out mainly locally, without taking into account the patterns of origin of such territories and neighboring ones. Depending on the availability of valuable buildings and the size of the site, the author describes or assumes reconstruction both by introducing a new function while preserving the architectural volume, and by completely demolishing the existing buildings and forming a new spatial solution. As the main trends in the reorganization of industrial conversion territories, the author notes their conversion into office and business centers, residential buildings, cultural facilities. The author supports this position by describing and analyzing the programs and processes of renovation of former industrial suburbs in cities such as Moscow, Krasnoyarsk, London, Lille, Milan. Separately, the author highlights an approach to the transformation of industrial conversion heritage from the point of view of legislation, which implies a more holistic view of solving the problems of these territories. From the author's point of view, the legislative decisions studied by him do not consider the commonality of the emergence and interconnectedness of such territories. In addition, the spatial characteristics of the sites are not taken into account, which have a greater impact on the possibilities of reconstruction of industrial conversion areas and the degree of their integration into the surrounding context. The author sees one of the solutions to these problems in studying the mechanisms and laws of the formation of marginal belts, their features and influence on the subsequent stages of city development, which will explain the physical composition of the existing planning structure and more reasonably and realistically predict the possibilities of its development and reorganization. After conducting the research, the author concludes by presenting the conclusions on the studied materials. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing a topic for analysis, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the scientific complex analysis and planning of the transformation of industrial and industrial zones of urban space is of undoubted theoretical and practical cultural interest and can serve as a source of further research. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material, which is also facilitated by an adequate choice of an appropriate methodological base. The bibliographic list of the study consists of 20 sources, including foreign ones, which seems sufficient for generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the studied problem. The author fulfilled his goal, obtained certain results that made it possible to summarize the material. It should be noted that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication.