Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Genesis: Historical research
Reference:

The Dynamics of Fertility and Mortality of the Turkic-speaking Population of the Tobolsk Province (based on the Material of the Muslim Metric Books "on the Note of those Born and Dead")

Fajzullina Guzel Chakhvarovna

ORCID: 0000-0002-2721-4063

Doctor of Philology

Senior Researcher, Tobolsk Complex Research Station, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences

626150, Russia, Tyumen region, Tobolsk, Academician Yuri Osipov, 15

utgus@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.25136/2409-868X.2022.11.39222

EDN:

QXWFRE

Received:

21-11-2022


Published:

02-12-2022


Abstract: The article is devoted to the analysis of the dynamics of fertility and mortality of the Turkic-speaking population of the Tobolsk province. The analysis of the materials was preceded by research work in the state archives of Tobolsk (National Archive of the Republic of Bashkortostan) and Tobolsk (State Budgetary Institution of the Tyumen region "State Archive in Tobolsk") to identify the necessary sources, as well as systematization of the received materials, transliteration and translation into Russian. The material of our research is the metric records of the Komarov mosque of the Bukhara parish of the Tobolsk district of the Tobolsk province from 1835 to 1862 (with the exception of 1853). The novelty of the work is seen in the use of unexplored materials in the Old Tatar language – Muslim metric books "on the note of those born, on marriages, divorces and death" written on Arabic graphics. The study of the dynamics of fertility and mortality based on the material of mosque books will reveal the main demographic trends in the XIX century among the Turkic-speaking population of the Tobolsk province. The author comes to the conclusion that the observed: 1) excess of fertility over mortality, 2) excess of infant mortality over adult mortality, 3) a tendency to decrease the mortality rate by the end of the calendar year, 4) excess mortality (in some years) from epidemiological diseases (measles, smallpox, dysentery, rubella, etc.).


Keywords:

birth rate, mortality, Turkic-speaking population, old-yasak Tatars, Siberian Bukharians, quitrents, Tobolsk province, metric records, Old Tatar language, demography

This article is automatically translated.

Introduction. The relevance of the study is due to both the object of study – the Turkic–speaking population of the Tobolsk province, and the source – Muslim metric records of the XIX - early XX centuries.

In historiography, the names of the following scientists are known, in whose works Siberian Tatars (including Siberian Bukharians) become the object of historical, ethnographic and linguistic research: G. F. Miller, S. Patkanov, M. B. Lavryashina, S. N. Korusenko, G.H. Fayzullina, E.H. Kadirova, M. V. Ulyanova, D. O. Imekina, Z. A. Tychinskykh, V. V. Poddubikov, B. A. Tkhorenko, V. G. Volkov, S. A. Likshina, R. R. Zamaletdinov, Galiullina G.R., Khadieva G.K., Mukhametgalieva Z.M., Dubrovina M.E. and others [1-12]. Statistical data on Siberian Tatars are updated in such documents as revision tales, the 1897 population census (then processed by Patkanov S. Statistical data showing the tribal composition of the population of Siberia, the language and genera of the gentiles (based on data from a special development of the 1897 census material). Vol. 2. St. Petersburg, 1911. 432 p.), "Review of the Tobolsk province..." etc. However, these documents give only general ideas about the quantitative composition of the Turkic-speaking population, while the dynamics of fertility and mortality remain beyond the scope of study.

Back in the XIX century, the value of metric records in conducting demographic research was emphasized. Thus, the doctor P. Vershinin, a researcher of infant mortality in Verny (1875-1884), notes: "In Russia, so far, the only material on the issue of population movement is the church-metric books compiled by our clergy. These books, despite their weak merits with respect to the accuracy of some data, can still have the value of approximately correct statistical material, and therefore any study on the issue of population movement based on data borrowed from metric records, although only approximately correct, nevertheless deserves practical significance. in the sense of "grounds and guidelines for improving the living conditions of the population." And where, finally, can we find more accurate figures than those that are collected bit by bit by our clergy" [14, p. 3].

The author of the pre-revolutionary work "Experience on the laws of mortality in Russia and on the distribution of the Orthodox population by age" V. Ya. Bunyakovsky writes: "The method of death lists essentially consists of extracting from the metric books a very significant number of testimonies about the deceased, which are first distributed by age" [15, p. 7].

At the same time, researchers point out that the source is only church metric books. For example, E. Anuchin notes: "When starting to draw up a mortality map, we, of necessity, took into account only one Orthodox population of the region on the grounds that for the population of other faiths we did not have any data that we could rely on without a large margin of error" [16, p. 303].

Consequently, metric records, firstly, are the only source for studying the dynamics of fertility and mortality in the pre-revolutionary period, and secondly, Muslim metric records are an unexplored source both from the point of view of history and philology.

The main part. Muslim metric books "on the note of those born, on marriages, divorces and death", written in the Old Tatar language (on Arabic graphics), were kept from 1828 until the beginning of the XX century by decree "On the introduction of metric books on the Orenburg Spiritual Mohammedan Administration".

The material of our research is the metric records of the Komarovskaya mosque of Tobolsk province from 1835 to 1862 (with the exception of 1853), extracted from the archival funds of Ufa (NARB) and Tobolsk (GBUTO GA in Tobolsk). These records were transliterated and translated into Russian by scientists of the Ibragimov Institute of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Tatarstan – E.H. Kadirova and Tyumen State University – G.H. Fayzullina and L.H. Faizova [17]. The materials obtained by the researchers are used in our article. The mosque books of the Komarovsky parish recorded information about the inhabitants of two villages – Komarovsky and Arapovsky proper. Komarovsky were part of only Bukhara volost, Arapovsky – Bukhara and Vagay.

According to the census of 1897, indigenous Turks (Tobolsk Tatars-foreigners; 17,817 people), Siberian Bukharians (3,380 people) and Tatars (peasants; 1,392 people) lived in the Tobolsk district from among the Muslim population. It should be noted that the majority of the Turkic-speaking population lived in rural areas. Accommodation is recorded in the city of Tobolsk: 1% of Tatars are foreigners, 2% of Bukharans and 14.5% of Tatars are peasants.

In 1897, 10 Russians (only men), 236 Siberian Bukharans (107 men and 129 women), 8 indigenous Turks (4 men) lived in Komarovsky yurts. and 4 wives); in Arapov yurts – 20 Siberian Bukharians (8 men and 12 women), 99 indigenous Turks (41 men and 58 women) and 59 Tatars (30 men and 29 women). Table 1 shows the population by yurts [18-21].

 

Name of the village1868-69

18931897

1903

1912

Komarovsky

243

295

257

266

281

Arapovsky

110

165

178

206

277

Total:

353

460

435

472

558

 

Let's consider the statistical data presented in Komarov mosque books. Figure 1 graphically shows the dynamics of fertility and mortality. During the period under review, only 489 people were born, including 252 males (51.5%) and 237 females (48.5%). Only 448 people died, including 216 males (48.2%) and 232 females (51.8%). These graphs have points of intersection, while the fertility curve retains a certain relative amplitude and is ascending, while the mortality graph is characterized by both maximum (1842 – 39 people) and minimum (1836 – 3 people) indicators.

 

Fig. 1. Dynamics of fertility and mortality

 

 

In the book "on the note of those born" in 324 cases (66.2%) Komarov yurts are indicated, in 163 cases (33.4%) – Arapov yurts and 2 – Kyrkyrali (0.4%). The geography of the burial of the deceased is wider: the villages of Tobolsk county – Komarovsky (315 people – 70.3%), Arapovsky (124 people – 27.7%), Sauskansky (2 people – 0.45%), Pushnyatsky (1 person - 0.22%), Epanchinsky (1 person - 0.22%), Abalaksky (2 people – 0.45 %); other counties or provinces – Yanka of Tyumen County (1 person – 0.22%), Kurtai of Kainsky county (1 person – 0.22%), Chur...ichka (written illegibly) Tomsk province (1 person – 0.22%). The reasons for the burial in these or other villages are not specified. Probably, the person died during his stay or residence in the village of Komarovsky (or Arapovsky), where the local imam witnessed the death.

Let's consider the dynamics of child and adult mortality. In Federal Law No. 124-FZ of 24.07.1998 (as amended on 11.06.2021) "On the basic guarantees of the rights of the child in the Russian Federation", a child is understood as "a person until he reaches the age of 18 (majority)" [FZ]. In pediatrics, a system of gradation of children by age is generally accepted (the basis for the periodization of childhood is the scheme of N.P. Gundobin and the decision of the WHO Committee of Experts from 1977), in which the following groups of the extrauterine period are distinguished:

1) from birth to the 28th day of life - newborns;

2) from the 1st to the 12th month – infants, infants;

3) from 1 year to 3 years – nursery age, early childhood;

4) from 3 to 7 years – preschool age, middle childhood;

5) from 7 to 12 years – primary school age, older childhood;

6) from 12 to 16 years – high school age, adolescence, adolescence;

7) from 16 to 20 years – adolescence, the period of social maturation [22].

Following the researcher P. Vershinin, "for the convenience of comparing the mortality of children and adults," we will consider two groups: those who died at the age of birth and up to 15 years (children) and those who died over the age of 15 (adults) [14, p. 3].

During the entire period, 246 children (54.9%) and 202 adults (45.1%) died. Figure 2 shows the dynamics of child and adult mortality by year. The peak of infant mortality occurred in 1838 and 1842, adult mortality – in 1842 and 1843. In 1838, the causes of infant death were indicated: jaundice (1 person), suffocation (6 people), smallpox (5 people), consumption (1 person), tumor (1 person), fever (3 people), the influence of evil spirits (2 people); in 1842 – abdominal disease (2 people), suffocation (4 people), rubella (4 people aged 2-3 years from January 20 to February 7), asthma (8 people), tumor (2 people), consumption (2 people). Among the causes of death of adults for the designated two years, asthma and consumption are more common than others.

 

Fig. 2. Dynamics of child and adult mortality by year

 

 

P. Vershinin draws attention to the ubiquity of this problem: "Excessive, almost total extinction of children in comparison with older ages is observed everywhere, not only in Russia, but also in Western Europe, although on a smaller scale" [14, p. 1].

Figure 3 shows a graph of child and adult mortality by month. These curves are descending. The highest point of the child mortality chart is January, the lowest is December; the highest point of the adult mortality chart is April, the lowest is November. Consequently, despite the fact that child mortality exceeds adult mortality, the same trend is observed – the mortality rate decreases by the end of the year.

 

Fig. 3. Dynamics of child and adult mortality over the entire period by month

 

 

Figure 4 shows a graph of infant mortality by age, from which it can be seen that the most dangerous ages are the first month of life and the period from 1 to 3 years. Common causes of death are epidemiological diseases: measles, smallpox, dysentery, rubella, etc. From the age of 4, the schedule goes to the maximum reduction in the level of death.

 

Fig. 4. Dynamics of child mortality by age

 

 

Conclusion. When analyzing the dynamics of the birth rate and mortality of the Turkic-speaking population of Tobolsk province (old-country Tatars, Siberian Bukharans, trespassers) during the period under review, there is, firstly, an excess of fertility over mortality (489 people were born, 448 people died), secondly, an excess of infant mortality over adult mortality (54.9% / 45.1%), thirdly, the tendency to decrease the mortality rate by the end of the calendar year, and fourthly, the excess of mortality (in some years) from epidemiological diseases (measles, smallpox, dysentery, rubella, etc.).

The study of the causes of both child and adult mortality is an urgent task for individual scientific research, while there is a prospect in studying this problem in a comparative aspect with data on related and unrelated peoples who lived on the territory of the Tobolsk province. Some arguments about this can be found in the work of E. Anuchin "Climate of Tobolsk": "The average life for a Russian is less than for a Tatar. The mortality rate among the children of Tatars is not as high as among the children of Russians. Tatars reach the highest ages much less often than Russians" [16, p. 333].

Thus, the analysis of the Muslim metric books "on the note of births, deaths" allows us to identify the dynamics of the birth rate and mortality of the Turkic-speaking population of the Tobolsk province, as well as to reconstruct the epidemiological situation in Western Siberia.

References
1. Miller G. F. Description of cities, fortresses, prisons, settlements, villages, villages, islands, rivers, small rivers, lakes and other sights on the Irtysh River and near it up from the city of Tobolsk. Journey from Tobolsk to Tyumen // History of Siberia. Primary sources. Siberia 18th century in the travel descriptions of G. F. Miller. Novosibirsk: Siberian Chronograph. 1996. S. 14.
2. Lavryashina M. B., Ulyanova M. V., Imekina D. O., Tychinskykh Z. A., Poddubikov V. V., Tkhorenko B. A., Volkov V. G., Likshina S. A. Siberian tatars: unique indigenous people of Western Siberia // Advances in Sociology Research. 2021. No. 35. Pp. 125-148.
3. Fayzullina G. Ch., Kadirova E. Kh., Maslovskaya L. Z. Names of diseases in the written language of the Siberian Tatars of the 19th - early 20th centuries (based on the mosque books of the Tobolsk province) // Siberian Journal of Philology. 2021. No. 4. S. 229-240.
4. Galiullina G. R., Khadieva G. K., Mukhametgalieva Z. M., Dubrovina M. E. Phraseological units as means of expressing the emotivity in the Tatar language // Revista entrelinguas. 2021. Vol. 7. No. 1. Pp. 154-161.
5. Zamaletdinov R. R., Faizullina G. C. Nominations of person with name-food components in tatar national dialects of Tyumen region // International Journal of Humanities and Cultural Studies. 2016. Pp 218.
6. Faizullina G. Zh., Kadirova E. Kh. Metric records of 19th - early 20th centuries as historical and linguistic sources // Tatarica. 2021. No. 2 (17). pp. 7-24.
7. Galiullina G. R., Kuzmina K. K., Kajumova Z. M., Kamalıeva A. M. Genetic layers of tatar cosmonyms // International Journal of Society, Culture and Language. 2020. V. 8. No. 3. Pp. 19-27.
8. Zamaletdinov R. R., Fajzullina G. C. General name as cultural code of siberian tatars // International Journal of Criminology and Sociology. 2020. Vol. 9. Pp. 1129-1133.
9. Ermakova E. N., Prokopova M. V., Fayzullina G. Ch. Ethnonyms Bukharians and Sarts in the ethnonymy of the Tobolsk province of the 19th – early 20th centuries // Tomsk Journal of Linguistic and Anthropological Research. 2022. No. 1 (35). pp. 19-32.
10. Faizullina N. I., Zamaletdinov R. R., Fattakhova N. N. Metaphor analysis in the Russian riddle as a secondary nomination source // Journal of Research in Applied Linguistics. 2020. V. 11. No. SpecialIssue. pp. 82-89.
11. Gabdrakhmanova F. H., Zamaletdinova G. F., Zamaletdinov R. R. Linguoculturemes yarashu and nikakh in the tatar linguistic world image // International Journal of Society, Culture and Language. 2020. V. 8. No. 3. Pp. 10-18.
12. Kuzmina K., Galiullina G., Kajumova Z., Kamalieva A. Allusive proper names in the 13th century poem "Kissa-i Yusuf" by Kul Gali // Utopia y Praxis Latinoamericana. 2020. Vol. 25. No. Extra 7. Pp. 224-230.
13. Prokopova M. V., Fayzullina G. Ch., Ermakova E. N. The image of “another people” in the mythology of the Urals and Western Siberia // Ethnospace of Western Siberia: modern language situation. Collection of abstracts of the reports of the participants of the International Scientific Forum. Kirov, 2021. S. 224-233.
14. Vershinin P. Experience of statistical study of child mortality in the city of Verny (1875-1884). Moscow: Mosk. lips. Zemstvo, 1888. 43 p.
15. Bunyakovsky V. Ya. Experience on the laws of mortality in Russia and on the distribution of the Orthodox population by age. St. Petersburg: Imperial Academy of Sciences, 1865. 195 p.
16. Anuchin E. Climate of Tobolsk. Tobolsk, 1896.
17. Fayzullina G. Ch., Kadirova E. Kh., Faizova L. Kh. Komarovo mosque books of the Tobolsk province of the 19th – early 20th centuries. Kazan: Fatherland, 2022. 335 p.
18. List of populated places. According to the information of 1868-1869. St. Petersburg: Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, 1871. 196 p.
19. Volosts and populated places in 1893. St. Petersburg: Edition of the Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, 1894.
20. List of populated areas of the Tobolsk province / Comp. lips. stat. com. by order of Mr. Tob. Governor, according to information, delivered. parish rule in 1903 and verified. from the census material. Tobolsk: Lip. type., 1904. 341 p.
21. List of populated areas of the Tobolsk province. Edition of the Tobolsk Provincial Statistical Committee. Tobolsk: Provincial Printing House, 1912.
22. Zhmurov VA Psychiatry of children and adolescents. Moscow: Medical Literature, 2016. 552 p.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Review of the article "Dynamics of fertility and mortality of the Turkic-speaking population of Tobolsk province (based on the material of Muslim metric books "on the note of those born, deaths")". The subject of the study is demographic processes (fertility and mortality) among the Turkic-speaking population of Tobolsk province from 1828 to the beginning of the twentieth century based on the material of Muslim metric books. Research methodologies have been compiled by general scientific and special historical methods. Historical-comparative and historical-genetic methods were used. A systematic approach was used, taking into account the specific historical situation for almost a century of consideration of birth and mortality among the Tobolsk Tatars. The relevance of the study is due to the very formulation of the question and the subject of the study on such an original, objective and rather poorly represented in scientific research on this topic - Muslim metric books. Metric Muslim books have not been preserved in all regions of Muslim residence in the Russian Empire, and therefore their analysis and introduction into scientific circulation is relevant and interesting. In addition, the study of the birth rate and mortality of the Turkic-speaking population of Tobolsk province in the XIX- early XX century is interesting from the point of view of analyzing demographic processes among this population group in the twentieth century and this will contribute to the study of demographic processes in different chronological periods. The scientific novelty of the reviewed article is obvious and it lies in the fact that demographic processes (fertility and mortality) among Muslims of the Tobolsk province are studied on Muslim metric records, which have so far been practically not investigated and have not been introduced into scientific circulation. The style of the article is scientific, written in a clear and understandable language and will be available to a wide range of readers, not just specialists. The structure of the work is aimed at ensuring that the reader understands the topic and the questions posed by the author of the reviewed work are resolved. The article consists of an introduction, which reveals the relevance of the topic under consideration, gives a fairly detailed description of metric records (in what language they were written, how they were formed, on what graphic basis (Latin, Cyrillic or Arabic graphics), in addition, a list of works with their characteristics is given, in which the issues were considered to one extent or another, concerning the Tobolsk Muslims. All this indicates that the author of the reviewed work knows the topic well and understands it deeply. The work consists of an introduction, a main part and a conclusion. The bibliography of the work consists of 22 works, including works on the topic in English, prepared by Russian researchers on the topic under study and related topics. The appeal to the opponents is not specifically put, but the text of the work, the work done by the author on the topic and the bibliography show that the opponents will find answers to questions if they arise, According to the reviewer in the article, all the tasks set by the author of the work have been completed and the purpose of the article has been achieved. The author's conclusions are objective and they follow from the work done. In conclusion, the author notes that the analysis of the dynamics of the birth rate and mortality of the Turkic-speaking population of Tobolsk province (Old Country Tatars, Siberian Bukharians, tolls) shows that during the study period there is an excess of fertility over mortality, in addition, child mortality is higher than adult mortality, there is a decrease in mortality by the end of the calendar year. His conclusion is also interesting that in some years there was an excess of child mortality from epidemiological diseases (measles, smallpox, dysentery, rubella, etc. It is also important to conclude that "the study of the causes of both child and adult mortality is an urgent task for individual scientific research, while there is a prospect in studying this problem in a comparative aspect with data on related and unrelated peoples living in the territory of the Tobolsk province." The article is written on an urgent scientific topic, has all the signs of scientific novelty, will be of interest to both specialists and a wide range of readers and is recommended for publication in the journal Genesis: Historical Research.