Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Politics and Society
Reference:

The Image of BRICS in Latin American Media (Cases of Argentina and Mexico)

Kleshchenko Liudmila Leonidovna

ORCID: 0000-0002-4172-6583

PhD in Politics

Senior lecturer, Department of Political Science, The Herzen State Pedagogical University of Russia

191186, Russia, g. Saint Petersburg, nab. R. Moiki, 48, korp. 20, kab. 201

ludmila.popova2011@yandex.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0684.2022.3.39211

EDN:

KCIRDU

Received:

20-11-2022


Published:

30-12-2022


Abstract: The subject of the study is the image of BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media. In the modern world, the role of multilateral institutions, including the BRICS group, is increasing. In 2022, Argentina applied to join the BRICS. In the context of the restructuring of the entire architecture of the system of international relations, the development of cooperation with the "Global South", as the leader of which the BRICS is positioned, seems extremely relevant for many countries of the world. In turn, such cooperation is impossible without the formation and strengthening of a positive image of BRICS in developing countries, among which Latin American states play an important role. The research is based on a constructivist methodology, according to which the image of the state or other political actor is a social construct created discursively. The purpose of the article is to identify the specifics of the image of the BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media. The chronological framework of the study includes the period from 2014 to 2022. Research method: content analysis. The author comes to the following conclusions. Firstly, the image of BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media is mostly positive. In addition to informational messages, they publish analytical materials in which BRICS is considered as one of the influential actors in global politics. Secondly, the range of opinions and assessments of BRICS in the sources is heterogeneous, which speaks, first of all, about the pluralism of Latin American media. The sources considered pay great attention to Brazil as the only Latin American country that is part of the BRICS, and Argentina as the only Spanish-speaking country that is preparing to become a member of the BRICS.


Keywords:

Latin America, BRICS, multilateral institutions, international organizations, mass media, Latin American media, Argentina, Mexico, image, the image of BRICS

This article is automatically translated.

 

IntroductionIn the modern world, not only States, but also various multilateral institutions, both intergovernmental and non—governmental, are becoming actors in world politics.

 

Trans—regional integration is becoming a new phenomenon - the development of integration interaction between countries belonging to different regions, which has become possible due to the gradual decline in the role of the geographical factor in politics and economics. One example of a trans-regional association is the BRICS, a partnership of Brazil, Russia, India, China and the Republic of South Africa, the largest developing economies in the world. International meetings in the BRIC format, which began in 2006, were held as part of four countries, in 2010 South Africa joined the association, and its modern name was formed. The competence of the BRICS and the range of issues discussed at the meetings of the association is extremely wide and includes various aspects of existing global problems.

The BRICS countries have significant demographic, political, and economic potential. The expert community expresses opinions on the prospect of the transformation of BRICS into the basis of a new world order (BRICS as the basis of a new world order: what are the prospects? URL: https://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-and-comments/analytics/briks-kak-osnova-novogo-miroporyadka-kakovy-perspektivy/). In the context of the restructuring of the entire architecture of the system of international relations taking place in the modern world: the emergence of new global players, the formation of a multipolar world, the destruction of existing financial and economic ties, for Russia's foreign policy, the development of cooperation with the "Global South", as the leader of which the BRICS is positioned, seems extremely relevant. In turn, such cooperation is impossible without the formation and strengthening of a positive image of the BRICS in general and Russia in particular in developing countries, among which Latin American states play an important role. The BRICS Union, whose identity was originally built around the idea of economic growth, is currently at the stage of constructing a new identity, which can be based on the idea of criticizing the Western-centric world order, which is attractive to the population of many countries of the world that have suffered from the costs of neoliberal globalization. In 2022, Argentina applied to join the BRICS, which shows the relevance of this institution for the region.

The study of international institutions in general and international organizations in particular is conducted within the framework of political science, theory of international relations, jurisprudence and other sciences. For this study, the authors involved works on the history and theory of international institutions, which form an idea of the signs, functions, and features of international institutions at the present stage of development: Keohane R. [1], Gilligan M. J., Jones L. [2]

Among the array of political science literature, it is necessary to highlight the works of specialists devoted to international organizations in general: Archer S. [3], Barnett M. N., Finnemore M. [4], Clubbers J. [5] and BRICS in particular: Korshunov S.A. [6], Lipovataya M.S. [7], Popova N.V. [8], The development of the countries ... [9], which analyzed the prospects for the expansion of the BRICS, the main parameters of the BRICS member states, the role of Russia in the BRICS.

The methodological basis of this research is the works devoted to the role of subjective factors in international relations: Wendt A. [10], as well as scientific works on imagology: San K., Pasvan A. K., Tislau M. [11], since they consider the problems of studying the image of international organizations.

Of great importance for this study are the works devoted to the image of the BRICS [12], as well as the image of the BRICS countries [13].

Also, the sources of this research are the works of domestic Latin American scholars devoted to the analysis of political processes in the countries of the studied region, in particular, such aspects of the topic as integration processes, their prerequisites and driving forces [14, 15], the processes of democratization in the region [16, 17], the state of the American subsystem of international relations as a whole [18], the role of Latin American States in the world economy and politics [19, 20, 21, 22].

The research is based on a constructivist methodology, according to which the image and image of the state or other political actor is a social construct created discursively. The purpose of the article is to identify the specifics of the image of the BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media. The chronological framework of the study includes the period from 2014 to 2022. Research method: content analysis.

 

The image of BRICS in the Argentine media One of the features of the media sphere of Argentina is the process of monopolization of the media market, a significant role in this process is played by the media holding "Grupo Clar?n S.A.", which is generally characterized by a skeptical attitude towards the policies of ex-presidents N. Kirchner and K. Kirchner [23, p. 28].

 

The daily newspaper Clar?n has been published in Buenos Aires since 1945 and has an online version.

The online version of the newspaper Clar?n contains both news and analytical materials about BRICS. News reports include reports on events held within the framework of the BRICS, agreements concluded, prospects for Argentina's accession to the BRICS, as well as Argentina's bilateral relations with China or Brazil. The prospects of Argentina's membership in the BRICS, as the publication notes, can bring certain benefits to the country (first of all, access to loans from the BRICS Development Bank). In addition, such membership is seen as an alternative to strengthening the influence of the United States in Latin America and in the world as a whole.

There are also materials where BRICS is mentioned in the context of the prospects of a "New Cold War", including as a possible alternative to the North Atlantic Alliance (NATO). As possible challenges for the Latin American region in the light of the restructuring of the system of international relations, the periphery due to the food and energy crises is called (URL: https://www.clarin.com/opinion/brics-g7-otan-dilemas-sur-global_0_LHBaEAwKCF.html ).

The article "Soviet Heritage in Latin America" is noteworthy, where the Russian presence in the region is criticized. The author notes the strengthening of anti-colonial and anti-Western rhetoric on the part of Russian leaders, which resonates on the continent, where anti-Americanism is traditionally quite widespread. Russia's allies on the continent are labeled as populist and authoritarian regimes, the author notes with regret that no Latin American country has joined the sanctions against Russia. The article mentions BRICS in the context of criticism of Argentina's initiatives to develop cooperation with Russia. The author expresses fears of a decline in the role of Latin America in the world market with an increase in China's imports of raw materials from Russia (URL: https://www.clarin.com/opinion/herencia-sovietica-america-latina_0_ixQ8Pckhvc.html ).

In other materials of the publication, Argentina's policy towards Russia is criticized as insufficiently consistent, and Argentina's non-alignment with anti-Russian sanctions is condemned (URL: https://www.clarin.com/politica/condenar-china-rusia-reclamos-unidos-incomodan-gobierno_0_6njPkIC4pl.html).

The next Argentine edition, La Prensa, also publishes news reports on BRICS events. The slogan of the newspaper is "Freedom, Progress and Civilization". It is the oldest media in Argentina, was founded in 1969. Here the BRICS theme is more often mentioned in connection with the initiatives of Argentine President A. Fernandez, which are generally evaluated more positively. The President's statements on the prospects of Argentina's membership in the BRICS are given (URL: https://www.laprensa.com.ar/517257-Alberto-Fernandez-pidio-la-incorporacion-de-la-Argentina-al-BRICS.note.aspx).

A number of materials contain information about the initiatives of the elected but not yet inaugurated President of Brazil, L. da Silva, which are also evaluated positively. In contrast to the foreign policy initiatives of politicians such as J. Bolsonaro and M. Macri, who, on the contrary, are criticized. The prospects for Argentina's accession to the BRICS are assessed as more favorable if Lula wins the Brazilian presidential election. 

BRICS is also becoming the subject of articles on the potential strengthening of relations between Argentina and Brazil after the change of power in the latter. The role of BRICS in La Prensa materials is often characterized as a pole, an alternative to NATO, an association of states opposed to American unilateralism and for building a multipolar world (URL: https://www.laprensa.com.ar/520978-La-situacion-actual-en-Ucrania.note.aspx ). The publication also considers Russia's foreign policy in this vein. There is a similarity in the approaches of Argentina and BRICS to economic and political development issues. The importance of Argentina's access to new sources of financing in the event of the country's accession to the BRICS is also noted. Argentina's entry into BRICS is also mentioned in connection with the difficulties of this country in interacting with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), as well as in connection with the foreign policy activities of A. Fernandez in other regions of the world (URL: https://www.laprensa.com.ar/517117-Alberto-Fernandez-La-Argentina-no-es-ese-pais-sin-destino-que-algunos-quieren-plantearnos.note.aspx).

Another popular publication, Diario Popular, contains fewer mentions of BRICS in quantitative terms, but also covers all significant events and processes: India's support for Argentina's entry into BRICS, BRICS Summits, Argentina's participation in BRICS Summits, the development of Argentina's relations with BRICS member countries. This is a local publication, widely distributed in the south of the country, existing since 1974. In Diario Popular, more attention is paid to the figure of the Vice President of Argentina, K. Kirchner, in connection with the BRICS issues, Kirchner's statements on the topic are often mentioned. For example, the criticism of the former President of Argentina of a skeptical position on the development of BRICS in the British media (URL: https://www.diariopopular.com.ar/politica/cristina-respondio-ingles-criticas-del-financial-times-al-brics-n236621 ) or an assessment of the economic situation in the country (URL: https://www.diariopopular.com.ar/politica/cristina-los-brics-la-argentina-no-va-entrar-default-n197651). Diario Popular also mentions the possible benefits of Argentina joining the BRICS, in particular, it is noted that "joining the bloc will facilitate access to loans and foreign investment due to the possibility of increasing direct investment from member countries" (URL:  https://www.diariopopular.com.ar/economia/dos-escenarios-un-eventual-crecimiento-n197238).

Thus, the BRICS theme is significant for the Argentine media. During the period under review, the media paid great attention to such problems as Argentina's interaction with BRICS and member countries, as well as the prospects for Argentina's entry into this institution. At the same time, the context and tone of appeals to the topic of BRICS in the media under consideration are different: for a publication opposed to the government, an appeal to the BRICS issue is often accompanied by criticism of the president's foreign policy for passivity or inconsistency. Loyalist media, on the contrary, highly appreciate the foreign policy initiatives of A. Fernandez, emphasize his personal role in foreign policy processes and events, including those related to BRICS. At the same time, opposition publications do not dispute the possible dividends from Argentina's accession to the BRICS.

 

The image of BRICS in Mexican mediaMexico's media has also been affected by the trend of monopolization: Grupo Televisa controls a significant part of the country's television broadcasting.

 

In the field of print media, there is relative pluralism here, publications of various political orientations are presented. However, the peculiarity of the position of the media in the political system of Mexico is the influence of transnational organized crime on this sphere. Mexico, according to the International Federation of Journalists, is the most dangerous country for journalists (Informe anual de la FIP. URL: https://www.ifj.org/es/centro-de-medios/noticias/detalle/category/health-and-safety/article/ifj-annual-killed-list-mexico-remains-deadliest-country-in-the-world.html). The sources of the study were four Mexican publications characterized by a wide audience coverage and various political and ideological orientations.

The daily La Jornada was founded in 1984, and has had an online version since 1995. La Jornada sympathizes with the left forces, publishes materials of left—wing theorists and thinkers, as well as political figures (among the authors of the publication are Noam Kholmsky, Fidel Castro). La Jornada publishes reviews of the most important events on the development of BRICS, which note the importance of this format of cooperation and its high role in global political processes (for example: "BRICS is an important mechanism for cooperation between developing countries, as well as a platform for South-South cooperation. Since its creation 16 years ago, BRICS has become an active, stabilizing and constructive force at the global level, whose influence and attractiveness are growing every day." URL: https://www.jornada.com.mx/pages/diariodelpueblo-el-ano-brics-de-china-2022/). It is noted that the election of Lula da Silva as President of Brazil in 2022 will be a new impetus for the development of the BRICS format (URL: https://www.jornada.com.mx/notas/2022/11/13/politica/bajo-la-lupa-brics-acelera-el-paso-de-la-multipolaridad-soberanista-mas-de-12-paises-en-fila deespera/?from=homeonline&block=ultimasnoticias). Individual areas of BRICS activity are also covered: investment, trade, ecology (combating climate change), as well as BRICS are mentioned in the context of Russia's foreign policy in other regions of the world.

In general, La Jornada contains materials containing an optimistic view of the prospects for the development of BRICS and the accession of new members to the group, the possible strengthening of BRICS against the background of a decrease in the influence of the G7.

El Universal (Mexico) is the largest Mexican daily publication, whose history dates back to 1916. Analytical and news articles about BRICS are published here. In the author's columns, you can find materials where the contradictions of the BRICS are noted, such as the rivalry between India and China (https://www.eluniversal.com.mx/opinion/jorge-lomonaco/palos-de-ciego-reflexiones-para-un-verano-caliente ) or insufficiently effective cooperation of the BRICS countries in the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic (https://www.eluniversal.com.mx/opinion/latinoamerica21/el-aislamiento-de-brasil-en-la-lucha-contra-el-covid-19).

BRICS is mentioned by El Universal in the context of the following topics: China-Mexico relations, Russia-Mexico relations, the election race in Brazil, political processes in South Africa, Russian foreign policy (including Russia's alleged interference in the 2018 Mexican elections), and BRICS appears as a potential counterweight to the G7 in global politics. BRICS is also mentioned when describing the agenda of Russian-Mexican cooperation, and as a possible negotiating platform for the leaders of the countries.

El Heraldo de M?xico also has a large audience. Existing since 1965 , the publication was resumed after a break in 2017 . It is released daily in the capital of Mexico, has an online version. Currently, the publication is dominated by a pro-government orientation. In addition to news materials about BRICS events, El Heraldo de Mexico mentions that the President of Mexico rejected the trade agreement with BRICS, considering it insufficiently profitable in light of the preservation of the traditional economic partnership with the United States (URL: https://heraldodemexico.com.mx/nacional/2022/8/3/amlo-descarta-tratado-comercial-de-mexico-con-el-brics-427387.html). BRICS is also mentioned in the context of the "New Cold War" and the economic rivalry between the United States and China, as well as the fight against the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Animal Politico is the largest online publication about politics, popular among young people. The number of daily updates here is significantly less than in the online versions of the previously named sources. Nevertheless, it is noteworthy that the BRICS issues are almost not covered here — the latest news about BRICS dates back to 2016.

Thus, for the Mexican media, the BRICS issue is quite significant, the largest publications pay attention to it. The appeal to the BRICS issues is often associated with such a context as relations with the BRICS member states and the influence of political processes in these countries on the BRICS union. Ideological and political differences are manifested in the fact that neoconservative-neoliberal publications are more restrained in relation to the BRICS than the left.

 

ConclusionLet's summarize the results.

 

Using the example of the sources considered, it can be concluded that the image of the BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media is predominantly positive. In addition to informational messages, they publish analytical materials in which BRICS is considered as one of the influential actors in global politics. At the same time, the range of opinions and assessments of the BRICS in the sources is heterogeneous, critical assessments are also presented. It should be noted that there are popular media for which the BRICS theme is not significant, which speaks, first of all, about the pluralism of Latin American media. The sources considered pay great attention to Brazil as the only Latin American country that is part of the BRICS, and Argentina as the only Spanish-speaking country that is preparing to become a member of the BRICS.

References
1. Keohane R. O. (2017) International institutions: Two approaches. International Organization. Routledge, 171-188.
2. Gilligan M. J., Johns L. (2012) Formal models of international institutions. Annual Review of Political Science. V. 15, 1, 221-243.
3. Archer C. (2014) International organizations. London, Routledge.
4. Barnett M. N., Finnemore M. (1999) The politics, power, and pathologies of international organizations. International organization. V. 53, 4, 699-732.
5. Klabbers J. (2022) International organizations are here to stay. Journal of International Analytics. V. 13, 1, 12-23.
6. Korshunov S.A. (2013) BRICS unification and Russian-Chinese relations. Diss. Candidate of Political Sciences. Moscow, 145.
7. Lipovataya M.S. (2018) Political forecasting of the development of the BRICS Association, Diss. Candidate of Political Sciences. Moscow, 254.
8. Popova N.V. (2021) Russia in the BRICS Union: Value and Scientific and technological dimension (political science analysis), Diss. Candidate of Political Sciences., Moscow, 328.
9. Development of the BRICS countries in the global space. Lebedeva Ya. O., Gusarova S. A., Sorvirov B.V. M.: INFRA-M.
10. Wendt A. (2012) Social theory of international politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11. Sun Q., Paswan A. K., Tieslau M. (2016) Country resources, country image, and exports: country branding and international marketing implications. Journal of Global marketing. V. 29, 4, 233-246.
12. Evgenieva T.V. (2019) Images of the BRICS countries in the context of the geopolitical self-identification of Russians. In the collection: Trajectories of Russia's Political Development: institutions, projects, actors. materials of the All-Russian scientific conference RAPN with international participation. Moscow Pedagogical State University. Moscow, 139-140.
13. Belokonev S.Yu., Evgenieva T.V., Titov V.V., Usmanova Z.R. (2019) Analysis of ideas about Russia's BRICS partner countries in the political consciousness of Russian citizens. Bulletin of MGIMO University. 3 (66), 111-130.
14. Glinkin A.N., Lavut A.A., Nutenko L.Ya., Bulavin V.I. (2004) South American integration and Russia. M.:-ILA RAS. Analytical notebooks of ILA RAS, issue 13, 2004.
15. Razumovsky D.V. (2015) Latin American iteration goes out into the world. Prospects for Russia. World Economy and International Relations, 8, 82-91.
16. Latin America: Electoral Processes and Political Panorama. (2015) Ed. Z.V. Ivanovsky. M.: ILA RAS, 2015.
17. Andreev A.S. (2021) Processes of "democratic transit" in Latin America at the end of the XX— beginning of the XXI century and the left forces of the region. Latin American Historical Almanac, 29, 126-146.
18. Davydov V.M. (2016) Determination of the development of Latin-Caribbean America. Coupling of global and regional issues. Moscow: ILA RAS.
19. Latin America in the system of international economic relations. (2020) (Ed. Simonova L.N.). – M.: ILA RAS, 2020. – 487 p.
20. Yakovlev P.P. (2020) Global puzzles: Iberoamerica in a changing world. Moscow: ILA RAS, 2020.
21. Latin America at the turning point of global and regional trends. (2017) Ed. V.P. Sudarev, L.N. Simonova. Moscow: ILA RAS.
22. Martynov B.F. (2015) "West" and "non-West": past, present... the future? Moscow: ILA RAS, 2015.
23. Kleshchenko L.L., Morayta I.A. (2019) Corruption in Argentina: socio-political aspects. Latin America. No. 8. pp. 23-34.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The reviewed manuscript of the article "The image of BRICS in Latin American media (on the example of Argentina and Mexico)" is devoted to an interesting topic of representation of international political processes and institutions in the media of various states. The relevance of such a study is beyond doubt, since we are talking about the role of a significant BRICS transregional group in the media mirror of states, firstly, the developing world; secondly, the "global South", thirdly, different cases – both a potential participant in the BRICS format (Argentina) and the countries of the Latin American region which tends rather to interact with the United States (Mexico). The analysis of the BRICS group is extremely important, since this forum still has significant demographic, political, and economic potential and represents a platform for working out concepts of the future world order. The purpose of the article is to identify the specifics of the image of the BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media. The chronological framework has been defined for 2014-2022, which seems extremely interesting and relevant, since we are not talking about the first period of intensive development of BRICS cooperation, but the period when there was a rollback to the "right" in Latin America, and the policies of left-wing governments began to be considered critically. The author bases his research on a theoretical basis and reviews the scientific literature devoted to the problems of research. The literature review section lists really significant works by Russian and foreign authors. The author also correctly argues for a theoretical approach, as which, of course, constructivism should be chosen. The author uses the correct terminology, draws attention to his use of modern concepts (such as transregionalism). The approach to the selection and analysis of media is correct, since the author reveals the ideological orientation of a particular media before analyzing the subject. This allows us to give a more balanced assessment, analytically correct. The text is logical, structured correctly, well-read, and there are no serious inaccuracies in it. The author's conclusions are justified. The author shows that the image of the BRICS in the Argentine and Mexican media is predominantly positive. The Group is regarded as one of the influential actors in global politics. The author's conclusion about the heterogeneity of critical assessments is important. In the context of Argentina's potential accession to the BRICS, the conclusions can serve as a basis for scientific discussion and other studies. It would be interesting to analyze the media of other major states in the region, such as Chile and Venezuela. Of course, it would be interesting to look at the image of BRICS in the media of Brazil itself – a participant in the BRICS format – however, this is probably the basis of another scientific study. The article may be of interest to both BRICS and Latin American specialists – scientists and students. The article can be recommended for publication without making changes to it.