Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Man and Culture
Reference:

Shoulder Ornaments in the local version of the Moksha Women's Costume.

Shigurova Tat'yana Alekseevna

Professor of the Department of Cultural Research and Library Information Resrouces at N. P. Ogarev's Mordovia State University

430010, Russia, Mordovia region, Saransk, Serova str., 3

shigurova_tatyana@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8744.2022.4.38641

EDN:

TQCFKB

Received:

16-08-2022


Published:

23-08-2022


Abstract: The article fills in the missing knowledge in science about the shoulder element of the kavlalks (armpits) of the traditional women's costume of the mid-nineteenth century of the villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of the Insarsky district of the Penza province, presents a complete description of its constructive and decorative specifics and the names of the details of the decoration in comparison with similar elements in the Mordovian costume and in comparison with the correspondences in the costumes of the peoples of the Middle Volga region. The materials of the archive of the Russian Geographical Society (hereinafter referred to as the SBI "RGO") are investigated as the main sources. Along with general scientific methods, systematic, comparative-historical and art criticism approaches were also used. The novelty of the work is due to the study of the original decoration of the local version of Moksha clothing, previously not mentioned by researchers. It is established that the existence of the shoulder decoration until the middle of the nineteenth century reflects the complex ethnogenetic processes in the Oka-Sur interfluve of the XVI – XVIII centuries. The technical, technological, artistic and stylistic features of the element of the Moksha women's costume reveal an affinity with the decoration of the ozhanuchka, preserved until the twentieth century in the Erzya women's costume of the Temnikovsky district of the Tambov province. The scientific contribution is determined by enriching the classification of Mordovian costume jewelry with a unique variant of the strap-type decor, known only to the Mordovian people.


Keywords:

traditional women's costume, the Mordovian people, mordva-moksha, mordva-erzya, protection of cultural heritage, shoulder decoration, ethnogenetic processes, decorative finishing, the strap shape of the decoration, origin

This article is automatically translated.

 

The traditional female costume of the Mordovian people of the mid-nineteenth century reflects a close connection not only with the peculiarities of peasant life, labor and economic activity of the carrier, but is a source of information about the complex ethnic history and processes of ethnogenesis. According to researchers, the semantic content of the "continuity of ethno-cultural traditions", ethno-cultural interactions is concentrated in the traditional jewelry of the Mordovian, Mari and Chuvash peoples [8, p. 1]. The abundance of jewelry of the women's costume of the Mordovian people of the XIX century, "amazes with the variety of materials and forms", being divided into head, bevel, breast, neck, wrist jewelry, waist, dorsal cross-shoulder [3, p. 138].

In the structure of clothing, the shoulder belt is especially important. According to R. V. Zakharzhevskaya, "the human body by nature itself is divided into sections, the shapes of which suggest certain placements of the covers" [9, p. 260]. The shoulder belt, which performs an important supporting function, is most often used as a basis for fixing clothes on the human body. In the costume of the peoples of the world, shoulder-length elements of clothing are known. The earliest existence of shoulder accessories was found in the Assyrian costume (the history of Assyria – from the XIV century BC – 605 BC): "A fringed baldric is an indispensable detail of royal and priestly vestments, which served as a badge of distinction in the costume of noble Assyrians: wide and long – for high officials, narrower and the short one is for the royal servants" [13, p. 22]. Shoulder elements were widely distributed from the XVI century in the male court costume, the secular noble costume of the European nobility, in the ceremonial costume of Russian nobles, in the military clothing of European peoples, for example, in the costume of Russian archers.

The purpose of this article is the historical reconstruction of an element of material culture, previously unknown in science, complementing the cartography of the traditional clothing of the Mordovian people with the shoulder decoration kavlalks (armpits); introduction of new terminology into scientific circulation; comparison of the details of the decoration that existed in the Moksha women's costume of the mid–nineteenth century with similar decorations in other local versions of the clothing of the Mordovian people; definition technical and technological features of the shape of the shoulder decoration, the aesthetic specifics of its decorative decoration, as well as the origins of its appearance.

The relevance of the study is determined by the absence in scientific publications of the XX – early XXI century of information about the existence of the cross-shoulder decoration kavlalks and information about its specifics. Until now, there have been no studies comprehensively characterizing the features of jewelry of the local version of the women's costume of the villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of Insar county and analyzing in detail the cross-shouldered women's jewelry kavlalks, its functions and decor. 

The paper attempts to solve the problem of filling gaps in knowledge about the unique complex of the traditional costume of Moksha women of the Insar district of the Penza province of the mid-XIX century, including the original cross-shoulder decoration kavlalks, which did not survive until the beginning of the twentieth century, and therefore is still not known to specialists. The study of the artifact will be useful for the reconstruction of the technical and technological specifics and functions of the shoulder decoration.

The conclusions of the work are based on the application of general scientific methods, as well as the interpretation of written sources of the archive of the SBI "RGO", which is an invaluable historical and ethnographic heritage, which has not yet been published. The analysis of the detailed answers of the clergyman Peter Sektorov to the well-known IRGO questionnaire completed in the 1850s is supplemented by the reliance on systematic, comparative-historical and art criticism approaches, which ultimately contribute to the identification of the form, manner of wearing, location and functions of decoration, and in addition, the features of manufacturing and decoration.The decorations of the traditional Mordovian costume have attracted the attention of researchers since the end of the XVIII century, but for the first time mention in the scientific literature about the shoulder straps of the neck (around the arm) and about the eponymous complex back decoration is found in the work of N. I. Sprygina, published in 1928.

The author reports on the use of two pairs of box-patsat towels with decorated ends as waist clothing on the sides of a woman in the costume of erzi in the north-western part of Temnikovsky district: "The second pair of box-patsat is outweighed by the shoulder straps. The decoration of the ozhanuchka consists of a strip of brocade sewn on a solid bast frame and sheathed with shells and coins on the edges, suspended on the back with straps made of shells and beads or made of woolen braid; from this strip, with the help of a braid, a square of kumach descends to the lower part of the back, in the upper part also having a rigid base and decorated with ribbons, copper rattles, tokens, chain and shells" [14, p.38]. Thus, we find that N. I. Sprygina distinguishes a complex strap-shaped accessory that performs the function of fixing side towels and back decoration on the wearer's body. The author also mentions another form of shoulder jewelry that existed in the Moksha women's costume of Ruzaevsky and part of the Bednodemyanovsky counties in the form of a sling – kichkr (curve) – "a strip of beads, copper chains, coins and copper buttons along the edge, worn obliquely over the shoulder and on the side connected by a pendant of chains and beads" [Ibid, p . 41].

In the first post-war decade of the second half of the twentieth century, a thorough study of the traditional clothing of the Mordovian people was continued. V. P. Yezhova considered a local variant of shoulder jewelry in the costume of the Tengushevskaya erzi: "The Ozhanuchka represents red woolen straps worn on the shoulders and crossed on the back, on which cowry shells and beads are tightly sewn" [7, p. 151]. In addition, she noted the mandatory availability of additional towel pendants with ribbons sewn on them, which were thrown over the straps in the armpit area; described in detail the complex set of back ornaments of the Erzya woman. N. I. Hagen-Thorn characterizes the shoulder decoration of the women's costume of the peoples of the Volga region as "a sling over the shoulder, ... worn on the left shoulder under the right arm", considering its spread among many peoples as a sign of cultural community [5, p. 99]. However, she did not mention the presence of a sling in a Mordovian suit. V. N. Belitzer in the book "Folk clothes of the Mordvins" reported on the cross-shouldered paired decoration of the Mordvins-moksha: a sling in the form of paired closed ovals kichkor (curve) (Stary Drakino village, Alkino Narovchatsky district of Penza province)

and kreskal (crosses) (village Kochetovka of Narovchatsky district, Shadym of Insarsky district of Penza province), as well as about the existence of similar in the villages of Furnaces and Sleds of Nizhny Novgorod province. They wore jewelry on both shoulders, crossing each other on the chest (see: [3, p.126]). According to V. N. Belitzer, the decoration of the ozhanuchka appeared "in the Tengushevskaya mordvins-erzi under the influence of the neighboring more numerous mordvins-moksha" [Ibid., p. 126].

Bandages were recorded by researchers in the female costume of many peoples of the Volga region: Tatars "khasite", Chuvash (tevet), Mari (arshchyash, kyshke vui), southern Udmurts (b utmar, kalo butmar, Kamali, butmar-Kamali) [10, p. 283; 15, p. 230-236].

In the formal typological classification of ornaments of the peoples of the Volga region, developed by A. Zadneprovskaya, shoulder ornaments are allocated to the 3rd department. Here, the shoulder straps and back ornaments are combined; in fact, all the Mordovian shoulder ornaments known to her, ozha nuchka, kreskal, kichkor, are designated by the concept of "shoulder sling" (see: [8, p. 8]). It should be noted that in the solid edition of the encyclopedia "Mordovia" there is also information about the shoulder ornaments of the Mordovian people, which "are mainly inherent in moksha (kichkor, kreskal, chresty) and erze of the Tengushevsky district (ozha nuchka)" (see: [11, p. 431]). The Museum ethnographic collection of the I. D. Voronin Moscow Art Museum, replenished with samples of the decorative and applied heritage of Mordovia, which were collected for a long time by the museum staff, has a collection of negatives by M. E. Evseviev, transferred to the museum in the 30s of the twentieth century after the death of the scientist.

The album of photographs published for the 140th anniversary of the educator-educator of the Mordovian people M. E. Evsevyev contains unique pictorial sources on which the existence of shoulder ornaments in the Mordovians is recorded (see: [6, p. 146]).

Photo 1. A bride among young people. Tambov province, Temnikovsky district.

 

 

The discovered written information of the NGO "RGO" must be compared with the pictorial materials of the scientist, educator M. E. Evseviev. In addition, there was an opportunity to see the abundance of women's jewelry in visual sources posted on the Internet, where the beginning of the archaeological study of the pagan burial ground of the village of Levzha of the XVII - XVIII centuries was recorded, the excavations of which were carried out in the summer of 2021.

        The strap shape of the shoulder decoration and the shape of the sling. The uniqueness of the local version of the traditional female costume of the Moksha population living in the villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of the Penza province, the study of which was initiated by the author of the article earlier (see: [18, pp. 91-105]), is most convincingly represented in the decorative decoration, independently made by the wearer of the clothing.

The materials used were home-made fabrics, hand-spun and dyed woolen threads, as well as ribbons, braid, beads, buttons and other products sold in the markets. An addition to the specifics of the folk clothing of these villages is the previously unknown shoulder decoration kavlalks:"the complete outfit of young women and adult girls also includes a kavlalks, shaped like an axis of a figure, decorated with many buttons, many small horizontal buttons and multicolored, which is worn on the shoulders" [2, L. 4].

The location of an additional technologically complex accessory in the shoulder area of the suit, combined with an abundance of breast jewelry, confirms a person's understanding of the importance of highlighting it as a compositional center of the female image and attracting the attention of others.  The shoulder girdle in the structure of clothing carries the greatest load, determined by a variety of techniques for securing body coverings: throwing (skins, fabrics), tying with something. The objective properties of the material (strength, reliability, strength) from which the accessory was made – rope, braided cord, determined the requirement of culture in additional retention of the cover, additional protection of the body from cold, wind, and, consequently, providing favorable conditions for human life.    First of all, it is necessary to pay attention to the fact that in the costume of Mordovian women there were two forms of shoulder ornaments, differing in cut, location on the camp, functional purpose and decorative design.

The forms of jewelry can be defined as a sling and straps, this is how they were designated at the first mention of N. I. Sprygina. We believe that clarifying the meaning of these concepts quite reasonably fixes the functional difference of accessories.

The form of the decoration of the sling corresponds to the description in dictionaries as – "Belt, ribbon over the shoulder" [16, p. 501]; or – "a strip of expensive fabric, loosely thrown over clothes. At first they wore a sling over one shoulder, slung diagonally on the opposite side and tied with a bow, then they began to put a sling over the body and tie a bow on the sides" [1, p. 280].In the Moksha women's costume, a sling, as defined by N. I. Sprygina, is "a strip of beads, copper chains, coins and copper buttons along the edge, worn obliquely over the shoulder and on the side connected by a pendant of chains and beads" [14, p. 41]. This definition corresponds in form, manner and place of wearing, decorative transformations to the ornaments of Moksha women kreskal, kichkor. Sometimes Moksha women wore two sashes at the same time, which crossed in front and served as an additional source of decoration, voicing the costume.

https://ic.pics.livejournal.com/purgine/20421851/44937/44937_900.jpg

Photo 2. Mordva-moksha. Penza province. Insarsky county. Kon XIX – beginning . XX century .

The second form of shoulder decoration, which is defined by N. I. Sprygina as straps, corresponds to the description in dictionaries: "A wide belt, a strip of fabric or a rope thrown over the shoulder for pulling or carrying weights" [16, p. 337]; "a belt or braid over the shoulder, with which they carry (pull) somethingsomething heavy, or just some object, a bag.." [1, p. 236]. Such a form of decoration (we see it on the central figure of the bride, in the photographs presented by M. E. Evseviev) was characteristic of the women's costume of erzi Temnikovsky district. The decoration, called ozha nuchka, was a complex basis for additional fastening of side towels and a back element (decoration) on the body (see: photo 3. The bride among young people. Tambov province, Temnikovsky district, S. Standrovo. [6, p. 143].

https://sun9-63.userapi.com/impg/GrXdfEpSbtp2mjSwSKBN8XOMkNIsubHPuuwbWA/j9X14sH-POo.jpg?size=744x1080&quality=96&sign=298697de1dc7d7edd9e65d8cb22cd68e&type=album

 

In the villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of the Penza province of Sectorov, a similar form of accessory was found, called kavlalks, consisting of two straps: "the handle ... has the shape of an arc" [2, L. 4]. The straps (according to Sectorov, handles in the shape of an arc) were connected on the back, like the straps of a modern backpack. The rings of this outfit were distinguished by their strength, they were made of a wide hemp braid, known for its resistance to deformation, capable of performing the function of fastening, binding, which ensured the formation of the costume, complemented its capabilities. Two rings of braid were placed on the shoulders of the wearer, they were sewn in the back area, which formed the shape of a cross on the back. In the women's costume of Insar county, kavlalks straps were also used to wear towel-shaped pendants. Thus, the technology of creation, the functional purpose of ozha nuchka and kavlalks has a single character, which fundamentally distinguishes the straps from the sling. Features of the shoulder strap-shaped decoration to avlalks.

           The form to avlalx is determined by the functional necessity of the thing, which additionally continues the formation of the local complex.

The activity of the masters was determined and directed by the consciousness of a person who perceives the world around him in accordance with the final values aimed at achieving and preserving life, freedom, happiness, love, characteristic of all people. The side towel elements of the suit served as additional protection of the body from the adverse effects of the external environment, performing a utilitarian function of preserving the health and life of a woman. The ethnic identity of the complex is expressed by the uniqueness of the combination of various ornaments: breast, waist, shoulder, partially having analogies in the sets of other local variants of the Mordovian (Moksha and Erzya) people.

First of all, it is necessary to take into account the preservation of details and features in traditional clothing that are associated with peasant life, the specifics of labor activity in the conditions of subsistence farming. Circumstances of living in the forest-steppe zone of the Oksko-Sursky  The Volga region required daily physical activity from men and women. Shoulder straps were widely used to carry cargo. Pre-revolutionary photographs captured peasants of the Middle Volga region, going on foot on a long journey, on a pilgrimage, to the market, carrying their luggage attached to cross-shoulder straps. The Mordovian woman repeatedly appeared in photographs of the turn of the XIX – early XX century, which convinces her of her active participation in public life, free movement on the territory of the Volga region without any restrictions, and the use of costume accessories. To transform the means of carrying cargo, widespread in Russia, into the basis of shoulder jewelry, additional reasons were needed to actualize the value of the clothing element in culture, but it is important to note the utilitarian purpose of this form of accessory.

 

 

https://museum.diveevo.info/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/museum.diveevo.info-7-2.jpg

Photo 4. Pilgrims going to Sarov. onethousandninehundredfour

 

https://museum.diveevo.info/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/museum.diveevo.info-3-1.jpg

Photo 5. The wanderer in the Seraphim-Diveyevsky monastery. 1904 Another reason for the existence of shoulder straps in a suit was the fastening 

  in the camp of sleeveless clothing. The theory of the study of the costume highlights the shoulder support constructive belt as the basis for fixing clothes on the human body. An additional protection of the human body in the harsh climate of the Middle Volga region was the layering of clothing, which included sleeveless elements or with short sleeves, which did not restrict freedom of movement, allowed us to engage in active economic activity, which we observe among the population of Temnikovsky county  Tambov province. In the local version of the women's costume, a women's shirt with short sleeves, additionally fastened on the shoulders "nangun panar" (upper shirt) and a vest "sermav shubeyka" (a painted vest made of printed canvas) have been preserved here. In addition, it is known that jewelry was attached to the shoulder straps on the back in the area of the shoulder blades and lower back. Belt decorations were a separate element of the costume. Researchers of the Mordovian costume noted the similarity of the ozh nuchka "even in details with ... the decoration of murom" [12, p. 63], therefore, it can be argued that the origins of the ozh nuchka decoration are in the distant past.The only difference between the jewelry of ozha nuchka and kavlalks is the absence of P. Sektorov's references to the back details of the jewelry that existed in the costume of Moksha women of Insar district.

But it is possible that the back detail was overlooked by the clergyman or by the nineteenth century it had already been lost here. It is known that in other Moksha villages of Insarsky, Krasnoslobodsky counties up to the middle of the twentieth century, women wore back ornaments, for example, ftala pulo (brush behind), kopor tsekane (back brush), parkhti kotf (brocade fabric), etc. from ribbons, buttons, sequins, cowry shells, beads, tokens. Since there is no information about them in the studied written communications of P. Sektorov, we do not mention them in this work.

The revealed proximity of the elements of the costume of ozha nuchka and kavlalks is explained by the historical processes of mass migration of the Mordvins in the south-east direction. The Moksha villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of the Insarsky district of the Penza province were founded no later than the XVII century by peasants from under Temnikov, who owned these lands on the rights of hunting grounds and onboard "grooming": "South of Perkhlyai ... were the possessions of the Mordvins of Temnikovsky district, where the Moksha settlements of Suzgarye, Levzha, Mordovian Pishlya were subsequently formed" [4, p. 44]. The rapid population growth was associated with the continued influx of the Erzya population from Temnikov (Bayevo, Norovatovo, Shiromasovo, Shoksha), from Arzamas to the south, where the southern border of the Russian state was being strengthened during this period, serif features appeared (see: [18, pp. 93-95]).

The original name of the jewelry kavlalks translates as "armpits" (see: [17, p. 52]); it has a clear internal form, since it concretizes the semantics of the name of the jewelry by indicating the location of its wearing in the shoulder area around the arm. In addition, the term clearly expresses the idea of culture about the features of the space that a person focuses on: the habitable and mastered concept of the bottom (alo, alks). The simplest qualitative spatial reference points of the bottom (alo, alks) and the top (vyare, prya) are a necessary contrast in the picture of the world of the Mordovian people, objectively characterizing its qualities. The spatial representations of the Mordovian people were most often expressed in terminology related to the definitions of the territory closest to human life (elements of clothing, a hut, a yard, the structure of a rural settlement).

Thanks to kavlalks, additional vertical directions appear in the suit, created by attaching brushes and paired towels to the straps,. As a result, a volume is created that increases the real dimensions of a woman, which reveals the specifics of ideas about the individual values of an idealized female image corresponding to the national character. The handmade product of the Mordovian people enriches the aesthetic expressiveness of the traditional costume, deliberately complicating the visual impression of the wearer created by the movements of the brushes and fringes. P. Sectors showed amazing attention for a man, recording in detail and comprehensively the features of the decoration: "On the back side of both kavlalks rings, 2 red brushes are visible and 1 green between them.  And under the arms and the front side of 1 red. The most extreme brushes have both rings to the front, with one orange. From each red brush consists of 4 tinsel threads, in the green ones – orange, 4 more red paper threads, and on each brush it is made from one woolen thread of another with a corolla-colored brush" [2, L. 4]. The scrupulously made clarifications of the author of the text allow us, two centuries later, to carry out not only a theoretical understanding, but also a practical reconstruction of the unique Mordovian decoration, which did not survive until the twentieth century (unfortunately, even the memory of it was lost until visual sources were discovered). The combination of individual brushes and fringe under the woman's hand during her movement created a rhythmic swaying that attracted the eyes of others: "... a woolen fringe of 4 black lobes and 2 red threads was sewn near the green brush at the ends of the hanging arc. And thus, from this fringe and green tassels, as it were, one brush is formed, which, during the dress of a girl or a woman in kavlalks, is visible under her hand" [Ibid., l. 5].

The desire to attract the attention of others to a young woman by aesthetic means is explained by her important role in ethnoculture. The combination of real living conditions and the way of life of the people demanded from the woman (wife, mother, mistress of the house) daily strenuous physical and spiritual activity, good health, endurance, responsibility, high moral qualities. It should be recalled that a woman in Mordovian society, along with a man, participated in family and social customs and rituals, she was assigned to perform separate social and family religious rituals.

  The abundance of expressive means used for making kavlalks was represented, in addition to brushes and fringes of multicolored threads, by cowry shells, beads, buttons, tinsel purchased on the market, which eventually became a sign of the high status of the wearer of the costume. Considerable financial resources were needed to purchase various materials on the market. So, for example, according to P. Sektorov, "no less than 4000 are sewn on a good kavlalks, which are valued by the muzzle with more than 2 rubles in silver" [2, L. 5]. The shells were tightly sewn onto the hemp braid not only on the back in the area of the shoulder blades, but also under the arms: "The shells of the neck and brush serve as an ornament for the back side of the muscles under the arms and are slightly visible from the front" [2, L. 4]. The peculiarity of the kavlalks decor was manifested in the alternation of sewn tassels made of multicolored threads and shells connected in pairs: "Up to 5 woolen brushes are sewn to each ring and with round handles (lengths of one and a half vershka, others of a quarter vershka), wrapped with tinsel threads and in 5 places with a thin woolen red cord, on each handle it is sewn on the side the edges have 4 edges (in 2 places, 2 edges with pointed tips together) and at the ends of two edges, one small, copper, smooth button" [Ibid., l. 4]. The created image of a woman's costume undoubtedly corresponded to the ideal of the idea of beauty in this culture. The meaning and types of clothing elements, a variety of jewelry complemented each other.

Thus, we explain the existence of the accessory of the kavlalks strap form in the Moksha women's costume of the villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of the Insar district of the Penza province by the influence of a similar decoration of the ozhanuchka in the costume of the Erzya women who migrated in the XVI – XVII centuries from the Temnikovsky district. The functions, cut, location in the suit, decorative design using brushes, cowry shells, beads coincide. The similarity is confirmed by all the most important technical and artistic-stylistic properties of jewelry. Decorative design, the use of a variety of materials (brushes and fringes of multicolored threads, cowry shells, beads and buttons purchased on the market, tinsel and braid) emphasized the high status of women. The aesthetic function of the decoration explains its spread in the festive version of the costume.

As mentioned above, written evidence of the resettlement of the Erzya population in the XVI – XVII centuries in the south-east direction convince of the possibility of preserving many elements of traditional Erzya clothing in the new territory of residence. They turned out to be in demand, they remained (at least) until the middle of the nineteenth century, although they received a new Moksha name, which is confirmed by written sources of the SBI RGO. Archaeological excavations in 2021 of the pagan burial ground of the XVIII century of the village of Levzha recorded an abundance of cowry shells, beads in the area of both hands and in the shoulder area, which were the place of wearing kavlalks. The analysis of the features of the local version of the traditional women's costume and shoulder jewelry testifies to the complexity of the ethnogenetic processes taking place in the Oksko-Sursky interfluve of the XVI – XVIII centuries.

A comparative study of shoulder strap jewelry and shoulder straps in the costume of the peoples of the Middle Volga region will reveal the fundamental typological difference between them from each other. The originality of the local version of the Moksha clothing, the amazing diversity of the results of the creative activity of the Mordovian woman speaks of the undoubted importance for cultural institutions of further study of the unique heritage of the Mordvins (Moksha and erzi): here lies the untapped potential for the development of museum, exhibition and tourism practices.

References
1. Andreeva R. P. Encyclopedia of fashion. – St. Petersburg: Publishing house "Litera", 1997. – 416 p.
2. ARGO section 53, op. 1, d. 48. – About the peoples of European Russia. P. Sectors. Ethnographic information about the Mordvins. 1855 12 l .
3. Belitzer V. N. Folk clothes of the Mordvins. – M.: Nauka, 1973. 215 p.
4. Voronin I. D. Favorites. / Editorial board: V. A. Yurchenkov (Chairman), E. V. Glazkova, T. M. Guseva, etc.; Research Institute Humanit. Sciences under the Government of the Republic of Mordovia. – Saransk, 2005. – 432 p.
5. Hagen-Thorn N. Women's clothing of the peoples of the Volga region (materials for ethnogenesis). Cheboksary: Chuvash State Publishing House, 1960-228 p.
6. Evsevyev M. E.: the life of Mordvins in photographs. The end of the XIX – the beginning of the XX century / [comp. A. S. Luzgin, N. F.Mokshin, T. A. Shigurova]. 2nd ed., supplement and revision. – Saransk: Mordovia Publishing House, 2017. – 248 p.
7. Yezhova V. P. Ethnographic characteristics of the clothes of the Mordovian population of the Tengushevsky district of the MASSR // Uchen. zap. Mordovia. ped. in-ta. – Saransk, 1956. Issue 4. – pp. 135-154.
8. Zadneprovskaya A. Yu. Traditional ornaments of the peoples of the Middle Volga region (the second half of the XIX – the first quarter of the XX century.): Abstract. dis. on the job. learned. step. Candidate of Historical Sciences: (07.00.07) / Russian Academy of Sciences, Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography. Peter the Great. – St. Petersburg, 1992. – 27 p.
9. Zakharzhevskaya R. V. The history of costume: From antiquity to modernity. 3rd ed., supplement – M.: RIPOLL classic, 2005. – 288 p.
10. Kozlova K. I. Essays on the ethnic history of the Mari people. – M.: Publishing House of Moscow. un-ta, 1978. – 345 p.
11. Kornishina G. A. Decorations // Mordovia: Encyclopedia: In 2 vols. / [Chief editor: Chief editor A. I. Sukharev et al.]. – Saransk: Mordovia Publishing House, Vol. 2: – M-Ya. 2004. – 699 p .
12. Martianov V. N. Mordovian folk embroidery. – Saransk: Mordovia Publishing House, 1991. – 120 p.
13. Modern encyclopedia "Avanta +". Fashion and style. – M.: Avanta+, 2002. – 480 p.
14. Sprygina N. I. Clothes of Mordvins-moksha of Krasnoslobodsky and Bednodemyanovsky counties of Penza province. – Penza, 1928. Issue 3. – 47 p.
15. Suslova S. V., Mukhamedova R. G. Folk costume of the Tatars of the Volga region and the Urals (mid-XIX – early XX century). Historical and ethnographic atlas of the Tatar people. – Kazan 2000. – 312 p.
16. Explanatory dictionary of the Russian language: 80,000 words and phraseological expressions. – M.: LLC "ITI Technologies", 2006. – 944 p.
17. Tsygankin D. V., Mosin M. V. Etymologiyan vasks. – Saransk: Publishing House of Mordovians. un-ta, 2015. – 228 p.
18. Shigurova T. A. Female costume of the Mordvins-moksha of the Insarsky district of the Penza province of the XIX century: local features // Man and culture. – 2021. – No. 4. – pp. 91-105.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The issues of preserving the identity of cultural values and attributes are traditionally quite actively studied in modern science. Interest in such a situation is usually represented by generalizations that allow us to judge not only the originality of a particular cultural reality, but also the importance they have for the development of personality, cultural dynamics, etc. Meanwhile, the author turns in his research to shoulder jewelry and limits the locus of his work to the Moksha women's costume. I believe that despite the rather narrow space for study, nevertheless, the author can count on obtaining heuristically significant results, since based on ideas about specific decorations, it is actually possible to conclude about certain trends in the formation and development of ethnocultural specificity at the regional level, which in turn will reflect the features of cultural regionalism. As for the content of the article submitted for review, first of all, its clear structuring is revealed here, which makes it possible to trace the logic of scientific research. In addition, in the introductory remarks, the author outlined the necessary attributes of scientific research, described the relevance, purpose, scientific novelty, etc. At the same time, neither the title of the work nor the introduction describes the problem of research, and the jewelry itself is, as we understand it, not a problem, but only an object for study. In this case, the author will have to finalize the article. Meanwhile, the novelty also raises questions: it is noteworthy that the author formulated the following provision in the novelty: "for the first time, an attempt was made to analyze and interpret a written source from the archive of the SBI "RGO", which is an invaluable historical and ethnographic heritage that has not yet been published ...". It is reasonable to ask: what is being studied and what is being reconstructed; if we are talking about a written source, then this is only an indirect way of understanding the jewelry mentioned in it, if we consider this source as an independent subject for study, then the jewelry itself seems to "dissolve" in this document, etc. The author should decide: The novelty of his work is related to a specific artifact or to a secondary analysis of a document that is valuable for understanding the role of the artifact in question in cultural development. In this sense, the course of the author's logic is clearly violated, and the "novelty" itself does not look at all like novelty, but rather like the definition of the boundaries of the subject area of research. The undoubted advantage of the work should be recognized as the analysis of scientific discourse on the topic of research – here the author showed himself on the good side, having studied many sources, summarizing them, highlighted the main aspects or directions of research of the problems identified in the article. However, along the way, I would like to say that "the degree of elaboration of the topic" is a phrase more suitable for a dissertation than for a scientific article, the same can be noted about other parts of the so-called "introductory remarks" - you need to get rid of formulations by the type of dissertation and present a whole text that would indicate the proper the level of the research culture of the author of the article. Undoubtedly, the illustrations became the decoration of the article – they all fit the place and fully demonstrate the author's ideas, but also the very features of the jewelry in question and the overall female costume. However, the inscriptions to the drawings should be considered unsuccessful, and somewhere they are completely absent: it is desirable that the author associate the inscriptions with the features of jewelry or costume, so that the reader immediately draws attention to the originality of the outfit. And it's certainly not good to end the article with a skeleton, especially since it's not entirely clear what this has to do with it, if the article is about jewelry. In general, the article has the potential for publication, but needs to be finalized.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The author presented his article "Shoulder ornaments in the local version of the Moksha women's costume" to the magazine "Man and Culture", which examines the traditional women's folk costume as a sample of decorative and applied art, a marker of folk culture. In his research, the author proceeds from the fact that the traditional female costume of the Mordovian people of the mid-nineteenth century reflects a close connection not only with the peculiarities of peasant life, labor and economic activity of the bearer, but is a source of information about the complex ethnic history and processes of ethnogenesis. In the structure of clothing, according to the author, the shoulder girdle is especially important, which performs an important supporting function and is most often used as a basis for fixing clothes on the human body. The relevance and scientific novelty of the study is determined by the lack of information in scientific publications of the XX – early XXI century about the existence of the kavlalks shoulder ornament and information about its specifics. Until now, there have been no studies comprehensively characterizing the features of jewelry of the local version of the women's costume of the villages of Levzha, Perkhlyai, Suzgarye of Insar district and analyzing in detail the cross-shouldered women's jewelry kavlalks, its functions and decor. The purpose of this study is the historical reconstruction of an element of material culture, previously unknown in science, complementing the cartography of the traditional clothing of the Mordovian people with the shoulder decoration kavlalks (armpits); introducing new terminology into scientific circulation; comparing the details of the decoration that existed in the Moksha women's costume of the mid-nineteenth century with similar decorations in other local versions of the clothing of the Mordovian people; determining the technical and technological features of the shape of the shoulder decoration, the aesthetic specifics of its decorative decoration, as well as the origins of its appearance. As a methodological basis, the author uses an integrated approach that includes comparative, historical and art criticism analysis, as well as a method for studying scientific and authentic sources. The conclusions of the work are based on the application of general scientific methods, as well as the interpretation of written sources of the archive of the SBI "RGO", the analysis of the detailed answers of the priest Peter Sektorov to the questionnaire of the IRGO filled out in the 1850s, which are an invaluable historical and ethnographic heritage. In the work, the author attempts to solve the problem of filling gaps in knowledge about the unique complex of the traditional costume of Moksha women of the Insar district of the Penza province in the middle of the XIX century, including the original cross-shoulder decoration kavlalks, which did not survive until the beginning of the twentieth century, and therefore is still unknown to specialists. The practical significance of studying the artifact lies in the possibility of reconstructing the technical and technological specifics and functions of the shoulder decoration. In studying the degree of elaboration of the problem, the author has done a thorough bibliographic analysis of scientific works and ethnographic empirical material collected by members of the Russian Geographical Society in different time periods devoted to the study of traditions of wearing and decorative design of elements of folk costume by representatives of the Mordovian people. All conclusions and theses are supported by citation material. The theoretical basis of the article was the works of N.I. Sprygina, V.P. Yezhova, N.I. Hagen-Thorn, V.N. Belitzer, M.E. Evseviev and others. The empirical basis of the study is also samples of the decorative and applied heritage of Mordovia from the museum ethnographic collection of the I. D. Voronin Moscow Museum of Fine Arts, women's jewelry from the pagan burial ground of the village of Levzha of the XVII - XVIII centuries, the excavations of which were carried out in the summer of 2021. To achieve this goal, the author identifies a problematic field of research, expressed in a detailed description and functional and artistic analysis of the basic elements of the shoulder area of a Mordvinian-moksha female costume, the features of their decoration, combination, wearing, depending on the place of residence, age, social, financial situation, time of year, nature of the situation. The author notes that in the costume of Mordovian women there were two forms of shoulder ornaments, differing in cut, location on the camp, functional purpose and decorative design. The shapes of the jewelry can be defined as a sling and straps. This item of clothing had not only a decorative, but also a utilitarian function. The advantage of the article is the careful study by the author of such a previously unknown element of the Moksha women's folk costume as the kavlalks shoulder ornament. In the article, the author pays attention to the study of both the appearance of the decoration, its decorative elements, and its internal semantics, which contain the ideas of the Mordovian peoples about the general picture of the world. At the end of the study, the author concluded about the complexity of the ethnogenetic processes that took place in the Oksko-Sursky interfluve of the XVI – XVIII centuries, about the interdependence of the intercultural interaction of various peoples of the Volga region and the common elements and features of the decoration of folk costume. The author concludes that the analysis of the elements of women's costume demonstrates the complex processes associated with the formation of the Mordovian ethnic group, its interaction with other nationalities and the relationship of the transformation of clothing and jewelry elements with the socio-economic development of the region. So, it seems that the author in his material touched upon issues important for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing for analysis an urgent topic, consideration of which in scientific research discourse helps in some way to change the established approaches or directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The author states that the folk costume is a unique ethnic and geographical marker of a certain people, and its study is of undoubted cultural, scientific and practical importance. The author has received interesting material for further research, interpretation and reflection. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure. The bibliography allowed the author to outline the scientific discourse on the issue under consideration, 18 sources were used. Without a doubt, the author fulfilled his goal, received certain scientific results that made it possible to summarize the material. This was facilitated by an adequate choice of the appropriate methodological framework. It should be noted that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication.