Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Theoretical and Applied Economics
Reference:

Use of Internet Marketing Channels (on the Example of the Market of Translation Services in the City of Krasnoyarsk)

Skacheva Nina

Assistant Professor, Reshetnev Siberian State University of Science and Technology

660037, Russia, Krasnoyaskii krai, g. Krasnoyarsk, Prospekt imeni gazety «Krasnoyarskii rabochii», 31

Sollo_sk@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 
Drygina Inna

PhD in Pedagogy

Associate Professor, Reshetnev Siberian State University of Science and Technology

660037, Russia, Krasnoyarskii krai, g. Krasnoyarsk, Prospekt imeni gazety «Krasnoyarskii rabochii», 31

innadrygina@mail.ru

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8647.2022.3.38573

EDN:

UUOTLT

Received:

05-08-2022


Published:

15-09-2022


Abstract: The speed with which marketing is developing and changing is a difficult task for both individual marketing specialists and companies that have to compete with each other and with the global market all the time. The Internet becomes the main platform here and provides an opportunity to search for effective channels of interaction with the consumer of services. Channels of interaction should be constantly improved, focusing on consumers, their behavior, lifestyle. Service providers need to search, analyze, introduce new Internet channels or improve old ones for business development. At the same time, the number of channels used may vary depending on the business area. The translation business is one of the representative examples, as it is focused not only on the local, but also on the global market. The purpose of this article is to analyze the use of Internet marketing channels by translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk, to identify their diversity and the possibility of application in other areas of services. The object of the study is the market of translation services in the city of Krasnoyarsk, and the subject is the use of Internet marketing channels. The results of the analysis are presented to the heads of translation companies to select the most productive Internet marketing channels to promote their services on the market.


Keywords:

internet marketing, market, translation services, business, Internet, internet marketing channels, the company, digital marketing, development, consumer

This article is automatically translated.

There is an increase in the number of online and mobile users around the world. The age of the Internet and digitalization has come, where the Internet economy is growing rapidly every day. After the improvement of mobile technologies, as well as social networks, marketing began to function in a new, complex and constantly changing market environment. The Internet has become the main business platform and the most popular communication channel. Marketing today has become completely different and its traditional methods have become less effective. The creation of new rules of Internet marketing, both on the demand side and on the supply side, is the basis for the search and development of new marketing models. Thus, the purpose of this article is to analyze the use of Internet marketing channels by translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk, to identify their diversity and the possibility of application in other areas of services.

Internet marketing is a term that appeared at the end of the 20th century and its interpretation is constantly changing. Communication with consumers through the "Internet channel" [8] takes on various forms every day and requires an immediate response from the business. It is important to monitor all changes and take into account various approaches and strategies of Internet marketing, which are fundamental to the competitive advantage of a particular business. In terminology, the authors most often compare digital and Internet marketing. The two terms are similar, but not synonymous. Despite the fact that digital marketing is also known as Internet marketing, online marketing, web marketing [13], it is a general term suitable for a group of marketing processes that use all available digital channels and Internet technologies to promote goods and services. The growth in the use of this term is a direct result of the increase in the consumption of digital media and their impact on the business sphere around the world. At the same time, many authors claim that digital marketing and Internet marketing are different concepts [4, p. 29]. For us, digital marketing is also a concept that includes both online and offline digital technologies, while Internet marketing bases its activities only on the Internet. Some of the digital marketing channels are "SMS marketing, digital print advertising, television marketing, radio advertising, etc." [4, p. 29]. This is not the case for internet marketing, given that some of the digital marketing channels do not necessarily require an internet connection. In this article, we will focus on the analysis of Internet marketing from the point of view of new consumer behavior and the study of Internet marketing channels.

The beginning of Internet marketing research is associated with the advertising boom and the first versions of search engine optimization (SEO) in 1995 [11]. Today it is a general term for search engine optimization, social media marketing, advertising display on websites, search engine marketing and so on. Internet marketing is a subset of digital marketing. One of the "possibilities of using the Internet in the company's marketing complex" is "the formation of an Internet communication system" [2, p. 720]. The main means for the implementation of this communication are Internet channels. The Internet marketing channel is a "material and technical space designed to organize communication between the parties, transfer and exchange of information" [4, p. 31] The main channels of Internet marketing are: "website, search marketing, social media marketing, content marketing, email marketing, mobile marketing, media Internet advertising" [4, pp. 29-33].

The website is the starting point for an online marketing campaign and communication with customers [6]. This is a "place" in the digital space, "owned" by the company, where you can find all the information about it and its products. At the same time, special attention should be paid to the process of designing a website, where there should be unique and attractive content for the target audience.

Search Engine Marketing is a tool to increase the visibility of a company's website and increase the effectiveness of the company's online promotion. It uses paid advertising links (for example, on the Google Adwords platform) and search engine optimization (for example, in Google, Bing, Yahoo systems), in particular to speed up website traffic. The goal is to attract as many target users as possible, as well as increase website traffic and company awareness [6].

Social media marketing is "an innovative tool that is used to create very strong connections with customers in virtual networks" [10, p. 273]. Social media platforms consist of large and diverse customer communities. These groups have great power in exchanging information about the company and its products, expressing personal opinions, evaluating their experience, which can be both positive and negative. Social networking websites help to improve communication with all users, and each site requires different approaches, methods and marketing strategies. Therefore, "social networks provide great opportunities to achieve maximum results with minimal investment" [9, p. 36].

Content marketing is "a strategic marketing approach aimed at creating and distributing valuable, relevant and consistent content to attract and retain a certain audience and stimulate business" [7, p. 8]. Content marketing should be presented in the form of information that is described in simple words for the consumer "without superlatives, and carry the attributes of authenticity, purposefulness and relevance" [10, p. 273].

Email marketing is a direct way of personal and individual communication with new and old customers. It helps to attract more customers and get direct feedback to measure efficiency. Companies using email marketing are cost-effective, personalized, mass, targeted, approved by consumers, who are usually consciously registered in the company's email list, easily tracked, etc. However, it is important to avoid sending a large amount of spam to consumers, information that is not relevant, but is aimed simply to to remind consumers of the existence of the company [8, pp. 265-274].

Mobile marketing has become a necessity in business in the last few years, given that "the degree of consumer interaction with mobile devices is so comprehensive that no business can ignore it," and this implies that "all marketing should be optimized for mobile devices" [8, p. 266]. "Manufacturers of goods and services are actively implementing customer relationship management systems, realizing the importance and prospects of automating sales business processes" [3]. Therefore, the possibility of mobile marketing for the company is to create fully personalized information for customers, depending on their location, time, activity, etc., and tracking data about a person through a mobile device and an application installed on it.

Media advertising is focused on the use of visual elements such as images, videos, animation to increase brand awareness and image and, finally, sales of goods and services [4, p. 30].

Internet marketing channels can be represented as an "Internet Marketing Tree". The main parts of the tree are deep roots, a strong trunk and branches. The basis of everything is created by the website, and the branches determine the order in the use of Internet marketing channels [12].

Internet marketing requires an integrated approach and the use of all channels that are available in the online space with their regular analysis and updating.

Alexander Grubor and Olia Yaksha write that when planning the company's Internet marketing strategy, it is necessary to "focus on the rational and emotional benefits for the company, on products or services in each channel" and point out the main elements that should be taken into account when drafting the company's Internet marketing strategy [8, p. 270]:

  • every company should have its own website;
  • The company's website should be optimized for desktop computers, iOS phones, Android and tablets;
  • blogging is a great tool for keeping in touch with customers (blog section on the website);
  • communication should be built taking into account the different interests of several target audiences;
  • all marketing messages in each medium must be carefully integrated;
  • public profiles of all employees should correspond to the image and interests of the organization;
  • the design of all messages is a very important part of communication and attracting attention;
  • communication via video and live broadcasts is effective in online communication;
  • highlight and distinguish business from competitors with a unique message;
  • interaction with customers through social networks is a necessity;
  • track the interests of customers and constantly adapt.

In order to analyze the current state of the use of Internet marketing channels of translation companies in Krasnoyarsk, we conducted an expert survey among the directors of translation companies in the city.

For our research, the main issue was the qualitative collection of information. The rejection of the quantitative approach is due to the fact that mass collection of information is not needed to analyze the Internet marketing of translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk. The survey covers one city and the number of translation companies in it is not sufficient to collect quantitative results. With a qualitative approach to the study, the method of expert interviews among the heads of three large translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk was used. In addition to the interview method, general scientific research methods such as analysis and synthesis, deduction and induction were used in the work.

The expert interview with the respondents of the city of Krasnoyarsk was carried out in a strictly prescribed sequence, since clear questions were determined and prepared in advance according to the purpose of the study, based on the information provided above about Internet channels and the main points for building the company's Internet marketing strategy.

Translation services are the provision of services for interpretation and translation of any subject, including highly specialized. Both individuals and companies with foreign partners apply for such services. During the period of major international sports, cultural and other events, such services are in great demand.

Let's present an analysis of the results of our interview with respondents. First of all, the Internet channels used by translation companies were identified: all companies use a website, search marketing and online media advertising, two thirds - content marketing, social media marketing, email marketing and mobile marketing.

Based on the marketing tree [12], the company's website is of primary importance. According to the respondents' answers, all companies have their own website and try to actively use it. Analyzing the target audience on websites and blogs, we came to the conclusion that the target audience of websites is represented not only by individuals, but also by large industrial enterprises of the city and the region. The sites are optimized for desktop computers, iOS phones, Android and tablets. At the same time, the question "Do you keep a blog to keep in touch with clients (blog section on the website)?" received an ambiguous answer, since only one third of all translation companies use such opportunities.

The next question was related to the personal profiles of the company's employees. According to respondents, only managers maintain personal profiles on social networks in accordance with the interests of the company. Employees do not associate personal and professional interests in public networks, without using the capabilities of this Internet marketing channel to promote translation services of the company they work for.

The result of the answers to the question about the design of messages showed that the respondents had not previously thought about the special design of messages on the website or blog. Respondent 2 indicated that "often the sending of messages and the posting of information is spontaneous and purposeful work in this direction is not carried out. There is no special person in the company whose duties would include preparing and posting information on the website. This is usually done by the head of the company himself or the manager at his order."

All respondents noted that they do not use the visual design of messages to communicate and attract consumers' attention to the company.  

When answering the question "Do companies use live broadcasts in online communication to promote their services?" two-thirds of respondents answered no. One of the companies used live broadcasts during the Winter Universiade in Krasnoyarsk in 2019, as it actively participated in providing translation services to participants and guests of the Universiade. The experience gained during this period was widely used in social networks and on the website page. This helped the company to actively declare itself not only in the region, but also abroad, and attract new customers in the future. However, according to respondent 1, later this company no longer used this Internet marketing channel.

The business in the field of translation services has its own specific features for each company, someone specializes more in interpretation, someone in writing. The industries in which translators work differ. Not all companies have the ability to notarize documents. Therefore, a person who is looking for a partner to receive a translation service, sometimes it is not easy to find the company that will be useful to him. Young people are often among the clients of translation services and interaction through social networks is important for them. However, the question of the use of social networks also did not receive a unanimous response among the respondents surveyed. Two-thirds of companies actively use the VKontakte network to advertise their services and note its advantage. Recently, one of the companies began to master the Telegram channel. Perhaps this is due to the specifics of this type of service. But, nevertheless, in the near future, all respondents expect to use the capabilities of social networks to promote their services.

Negative answers were received to the question "Are the interests of customers monitored in the company and with what?". At the same time, respondents noted that this question allows them to think about the importance of analyzing the interests of clients for the development of the translation services market. The competition for the client is big today and is growing every day, which forces companies to look for new marketing channels and use the already proven ones more actively.

Thus, having conducted the expert interview described by us with the heads of large translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk and analyzing their answers, we can note the problems that have emerged today in the use of Internet marketing channels in the translation services market. Firstly, translation companies have their own website, use social networks that can automatically collect data about consumers. For example, in the VKontakte social network, the system examines not only the user's location data, but also personal profile information, interests, requests and hobbies. Even the geometries in the photos posted by the user are taken into account" [1, p. 31].  

Secondly, company executives use separate Internet marketing channels, and this does not always bring the desired result. Here, a person specially trained in this field should be engaged in the promotion of services, and the staff of translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk is often limited and does not allow having a separate employee dealing with this issue. At the same time, the expansion of the staff can pay off quite quickly due to the active use of the possibilities of various Internet marketing channels to promote the company's services. It is necessary to develop all possible channels for promoting their services on the Internet and use them in an integrated manner and to interest all employees of the company to work in this direction, to show the possibilities of using, including personal profiles to promote services.

Thirdly, the lack of corporate design of messages on the Internet has a negative impact on attracting attention to the company. The company should be recognizable always and everywhere.  It is necessary to develop not only the company's logo, but also the style of address and actively use it in various Internet marketing channels.

The results of the analysis were presented to the heads of translation companies. We believe that they will help develop a successful Internet marketing strategy and improve the promotion of services. In the future, it is planned to monitor these companies for the use of various Internet marketing channels for the development of translation business in the city of Krasnoyarsk.  

The analysis of the use of Internet marketing channels was carried out on the example of companies providing translation services. However, the findings can be universal and relevant for any small and medium-sized businesses that require the promotion of services and the staff of companies is small.

References
1. Karpova, M. K. (2020) Hyperlocal targeting as an innovative advertising tool. Science. Society. State, No. 2 (30), pp. 29-37
2. Ketova, N. P. (2019) Internet marketing as an effective tool for the development of modern companies and increasing their marketing competence. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship, 20(3), pp. 717-729. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332346314_Internet-marketing_kak_effektivnyj_instrument_razvitia_sovremennyh_kompanij_i_povysenia_ih_marketingovoj_kompetentnosti
3. Skorobogatykh, I. I. (2016) Transformation of the role and model of marketing and marketing research in the information age. Modern management: Problems and prospects: St. Petersburg, V.2. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301204810_Transformacia_roli_i_modeli_marketinga_i_marketingovyh_issledovanij_v_informacionnuu_epohu
4. Shevchenko, D. A. (2019). Digital marketing: an overview of channels and tools. Practical marketing, 10 (272), pp. 29-37.
5. Grubor, A. (2018). Internet marketing as a business necessity. Interdisciplinary Description of Complex Systems, 16(2), 265-274
6. Shaltoni, A.M. (2017). From websites to social media: exploring the adoption of internet marketing in emerging'industrial markets. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, 32(7), 1009-1019
7. Atshaya, S. (2016). Digital Marketing vs. Internet Marketing: A Detailed Study. International Journal of Novel Research in Marketing Management and Economics, 3(1), 29-33
8. Jones, A.T. (2013). Internet marketing – 2013. GetSmarter, Cape Town,
9. Chris, A. (2017). Digital Marketing VS Internet Marketing. What is the latest trend.
10. Jan, A. (2014). Social Media Is Nothing but a Public Relation Tool. The International Journal of Business & Management, 2(12), 272-277
11. Ilić, D. (2014). The importance of marketing innovation in new economy. Singidunum Journal of Applied Sciences, 11(1), 34-42
12. Content Marketing Institute: Benchmarks (2015). North America: Budgets, and Trends. Retrieved from http://contentmarketinginstitute.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/2015_B2B_Research.pdf
13. Robinson, M. (2016). MainlineMedia: The Internet Marketing Tree. Retrieved from https://www.mainlinemedia.com/blog/2015/12/the-internet-marketing-tree-update/

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the study. Based on the title of the submitted materials, the content should be devoted to the study of Internet marketing in the market of translation services. It is important to note that in the introductory part of the article, the author narrows the geography to the Krasnoyarsk Territory (it seems that in the title it is necessary to note the region in which the issues raised were considered). Unfortunately, the content of the article only partially corresponds to the stated topic, since it considers only certain aspects. Research methodology. In general, the content of the presented materials does not indicate the use of any scientific methodology. The relevance of the study of Internet marketing issues in the market of translation services is beyond doubt, because this is one of the actively developing areas of activity and the development of author's recommendations for solving existing problems meets the existing requests from citizens and small businesses. Scientific novelty. Given the fact that the text of the article lists well-known facts, it is not possible to conclude that there are elements of scientific novelty. When finalizing the article, the author is recommended to pay attention to identifying existing problems (as stated in the research goal set by the author) and developing author's recommendations for their solution. At the same time, in order to expand the potential interested audience, it is also recommended to identify those offers that may be interesting for marketing in the sector of any services. Style, structure, content. The style of presentation is partly scientific. The structure of the article does not allow us to achieve this goal, because it does not contribute to identifying problems and offering author's recommendations for their solution. Speaking of the content, it, for the most part, either contains well-known acts or unreasonable expressions. For example, the author claims that "translation companies have their own website, but they are not actively using it." Which companies did the author analyze? Which companies do they use? What are the criteria for sufficient usage activity? The author also concludes that "some company executives use separate Internet marketing channels, and this does not bring the desired result." Which specific "some" leaders are we talking about? What specific "separate" Internet marketing channels are we talking about? Familiarization with the article allows us to conclude that the goal set in the first paragraph has not been achieved, because not only has the current state of marketing models of translation companies not been assessed, but the names, content and specifics of these models have not been indicated. Moreover, it was not possible to find in the text the problems identified by the author and the proposals prepared in accordance with them for the development of an Internet marketing strategy, as also stated in the introductory part of the article. Bibliography. The author has practically not analyzed the sources on the issues discussed in the article. It should be emphasized separately that the bibliographic list of sources does not include 2019-2022. Moreover, the author has absolutely not studied the domestic literature, despite the fact that the scientific community is actively discussing issues related to the digitalization of marketing. Appeal to opponents. Despite the presence of references to the sources used from the list of references, it was not possible to identify any scientific discussion. The author is recommended to discuss the results obtained with the results of studies conducted by other authors. This will significantly improve the quality of these materials, contributing to their transformation into a scientific article. Conclusions, the interest of the readership. The chosen research topic is of interest to a limited number of people, but only when finalizing the material. Qualitative refinement of materials can also expand the range of potential stakeholders by unifying individual procedures in the service sector.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The reviewed article is devoted to the study of the development of Internet marketing in the market of translation services. The research methodology is based on the results of an expert survey among the directors of translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk, the study of literary sources, materials of Internet resources on the topic of the work. The authors of the article rightly attribute the relevance of the study to the fact that the creation of new rules for Internet marketing, both on the demand side and on the supply side, is the basis for the search and development of new marketing models. The scientific novelty of the presented research, according to the reviewer, lies in the results obtained from the analysis of the use of Internet marketing channels by translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk, identifying their diversity and the possibility of application in other areas of services. The article considers Internet marketing as a subset of digital marketing. The authors compared the concepts of "digital marketing" and "Internet marketing", traced the connection of the latter with the advertising boom and the first versions of search engine optimization. Topical issues of social media marketing and content marketing, e-mail marketing are highlighted, Internet marketing channels are presented in the form of an "Internet Marketing Tree". The results of the survey of heads of translation companies are reflected, which showed that all companies use a website, search marketing and online media advertising, two thirds - content marketing, social media marketing, email marketing and mobile marketing, two thirds of companies actively use the VKontakte network to advertise their services and celebrate it the advantage. The publication reflects the responses of respondents to the questions formulated in the questionnaire. The authors have identified achievements and problems in the field of using Internet marketing channels in the market of translation services. Among the positive aspects, the study by translation companies of not only user location data, but also personal profile information, interests, requests and hobbies of clients, and geomatics in photos posted by users was noted. The reserves include the expansion of the staff of translation companies in the city of Krasnoyarsk at the expense of a separate employee dealing with Internet marketing issues, as well as the lack of corporate design of messages on the Internet. The bibliographic list includes 13 sources in Russian and English, to which the text contains address links indicating the presence of an appeal to opponents in the publication. The reviewed article is not without flaws: it is not properly structured with the allocation of such sections generally accepted in modern scientific publications as introduction, research materials and methods, results and their discussion, conclusion. The topic of the article is relevant, reflects the results of the research, contains elements of increment of scientific knowledge, is of practical interest, corresponds to the topic of the journal "Theoretical and Applied Economics" and is recommended for publication.