|
Culture and Art
Reference:
Abbasov I.B., Du I.
Design concept of the exhibition space of the Henan State Museum (China)
// Culture and Art.
2023. ¹ 6.
P. 56-76.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0625.2023.6.38496 EDN: SHSFJJ URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=38496
Design concept of the exhibition space of the Henan State Museum (China)
Abbasov Iftikhar Balakishi
ORCID: 0000-0003-4805-8714
Doctor of Technical Science
Professor of the Department of Engineering Graphics and Computer Design at Southern Federal University, Engineering-Technological Academy
347905, Russia, Rostovskaya oblast', g. Taganrog, ul. Chekhova, 22
|
iftikhar_abbasov@mail.ru
|
|
|
Other publications by this author |
|
|
Du Ifei
Master's Degree Student, Department of Engineering Graphics and Computer Design, Southern Federal University, Engineering-Technological Academy
347928, Russia, Rostovskaya oblast', g. Taganrog, ul. Chekhova, 22
|
igkd@sfedu.ru
|
|
|
|
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0625.2023.6.38496
EDN: SHSFJJ
Received:
23-07-2022
Published:
05-07-2023
Abstract:
The Henan Museum is one of the first museums in China which requires modernization of its design. This work is devoted to the development of a new design concept for the Henan Museum space, the hall of musical instruments of the Great Silk Road, in order to develop recommendations for further brand promotion in the field of tourist attractiveness and the development of the local economy. The object of the study is the museum of Henan Province, China, the subject is the influence of the museum brand on the popularization of ancient Chinese culture. The analysis of some Asian museums is given, the stages of the museum's formation are described, the elements of rebranding are developed: logo, booklet, poster, website, advertising products of the museum. The concept of the design of the exhibition hall "Musical Instruments of the Great Silk Road" was proposed, visualizations were made and a video flight of the hall was created, with a visual representation of the exhibits for remote access and viewing. A situational approach to the organization of the environment was used when developing the design of the museum space. The scientific novelty and theoretical significance of the research lies in the rebranding of the Museum of Culture, in the development of a new concept for the design of the exhibition hall of the museum space of the Henan Museum. Some modern trends in the development of museum space design on the example of domestic and foreign museums are discussed.
Keywords:
the museum, history of the museum, stages of formation, design concept, museum space, the brand of the museum, logo, booklet, computer model, rendering
This article is automatically translated.
Relevance of the study A museum is a place that spreads culture and demonstrates it to people in a unique way. Museum space is a way of reflecting the culture of society within a single space. The museum space is created with the help of certain exposition techniques, materials, designed to reveal the meaning, the message of the exposition [1],[2]. In general, this space unites not only the architectural basis, but also the visual shell of museum expositions. The components of the museum space include their digital support in the form of a website, a virtual tour for remote access. The design of the museum space is one of the most important ways to attract visitors. Moreover, the design of the museum space can bring a unique artistic atmosphere to the museum so that the museum continues to develop. The design of the museum is based on the demonstration of cultural relics and samples in a certain space. Thanks to further intelligent planning and special design of the space, cultural relics can be more closely integrated with the environment, creating a more accessible cultural atmosphere. The main object of maintenance of the museum space are visitors, tourists. It is necessary to create a functionally convenient environment for tourists to visit, attracting their attention as much as possible, arousing the desire to explore cultural relics, exhibits. The museum is also a public place where people receive cultural education and spend leisure time, but some exhibition spaces still have problems meeting the needs of the masses, which leads to a gradual decrease in the number of visitors [3]. Currently, there are many museums in China that use corporate image as part of their brand. In such conditions, it is necessary to actively develop all aspects of the museum brand to meet the needs of museums in modern society [4]. In this work, the key area of research is the introduction of brand culture in the Henan Province State Museum, a museum with a long history should keep up with the times. Purpose, objectives of the study This work is devoted to the development of a new design concept for the Henan Museum space, the hall of musical instruments of the Great Silk Road, in order to develop recommendations for further brand promotion in the field of tourist attractiveness and the development of the local economy. The object of the study is the museum of Henan Province, China, the subject is the influence of the museum's brand on the popularization of ancient Chinese culture. To achieve this goal, it is necessary: to analyze the current state of the brand of some Asian museums of history and culture, to determine the features of the development of the museum of Henan Province, to identify historical aspects of the existence of the culture of the Great Silk Road, to identify and develop components of a new design concept for the museum space of Henan province on the example of the hall Musical Instruments of the Great Silk Road. As part of the new design concept, it is planned to create a museum logo, advertising, printing products, design and modeling of the exhibition hall of Musical instruments of the Great Silk Road. The scientific hypothesis of the study suggests that the updated brand of the museum, created on the basis of modern technological requirements, will promote and popularize the history and culture of China. This paper mainly considers methods of analysis and synthesis based on historical data and information obtained from professional literature. The following research methods are used in the work: historical approach, logical approach, system analysis. A situational approach to the organization of the environment was used when developing the design of the museum space. Based on stylistic and comparative analysis, the components of the brand of some similar museums in Southeast Asia are described. The scientific novelty and theoretical significance of the research lies in the analysis of the brand of the South Asian museums of history and culture in order to rebrand this museum, in the development of the project of the original design concept of the hall of the exhibition space of the Henan Museum. Henan Provincial Museum Henan Province is located in the central part of China with its capital in the city of Zhengzhou. Henan is located at the junction of the coastal open area, central and western regions and is an important transport hub in China. As of the end of 2021, the permanent population of Henan Province was 98.83 million people. Located in the middle and lower reaches of the Yellow River, Henan Province is one of the birthplaces of ancient Chinese civilization [5]. Crafts such as agriculture, animal husbandry and pottery originated here during the Paligan culture period about eight thousand years ago. During the Middle and late Longshan culture, more than four thousand years ago, the Central Plains entered the era of combined use of stone and bronze products. More than 20 orthodox dynasties, such as the Xia Dynasty and the Shang Dynasty, successively founded or moved their capital to Henan. Henan is home to four of the eight ancient capitals of China, namely Luoyang, the ancient capital of the thirteen dynasties, Kaifeng, the ancient capital of the eight dynasties, Anyang, the ancient capital of the seven dynasties Zhengzhou, the ancient capital of Xia and Shang. Historical stages of the creation of the Henan Provincial Museum
Founded in 1927, the Henan Museum is one of the oldest and largest museums in China. The museum is located in the city of Zhengzhou, with a built-up area of 55 thousand square meters [6],[7]. In 2009, it was selected as the first batch of national museums built jointly by central and local authorities. Currently, the Henan Museum houses a collection of more than 170,000 cultural relics, the most distinctive of which are prehistoric cultural relics, Shang and Zhou bronzes, ceramics, jade and stone carvings of past dynasties. The choice of this particular Chinese museum is due to the fact that one of the authors of the article is a native of this province, and this work will help popularize the culture of his native land. Most of the cultural relics were obtained in the early twentieth century from archaeological excavations in Shangqiu, Luoyang, Anyang, Kaifeng, Sichuan, Sanmenxia, Huixian, Xinzheng. Among the collections there are more than 5,000 copies of first-class national cultural relics of high historical, cultural and artistic value, and some collections are known as national treasures. During the anti-Japanese War, some of the valuable cultural relics from the Henan Museum were preserved in the Taiwan Historical Museum. From 1930 to 1937 was a period of unprecedented development for the Henan Museum, the collections contained the most numerous and exquisite historical relics with local characteristics of Henan. In 1948, the People's Liberation Army of China liberated the ancient capital of Kaifeng. The Party and the government attached great importance to cultural education and cultural events, and the museum began to flourish again. In 1961, the Henan Museum was moved from Kaifeng to Zhengzhou, the provincial capital, with the best exhibition center. However, when the museum was organized and carried out various activities, an unprecedented cultural revolution began. During the 10 years of the Cultural Revolution, the work of the museum was paralyzed, and its activities were abandoned, later the museum gradually began to recover, and entered a new period of historical development. Especially in the 1980s, the popularity of the museum continued to grow, with the deepening of the reforms of the 1990s and openness, international cultural exchanges and the rapid development of tourism further contributed to the development of national museums. The main building of the main exhibition hall of the Henan Museum resembles the ancient observatory of the Yuan Dynasty (the earliest surviving observatory in China, located in Denfeng, Henan (Fig.1, left). The museum is interpreted as a "Pyramid with a crown", the crown has the shape of a rectangular vessel, symbolizing the Central Plains of China (Fig. 1, right). The main hall has blue transparent windows from top to bottom and a transparent glass belt, which looks very majestic [8]. Fig.1. The Observatory of the ancient Yuan Dynasty (Denfeng, Henan) and the modern building of the Henan Museum Exhibition activities of the museum At the beginning of the creation of the Henan Museum, great importance was attached to the collection of cultural relics. However, due to lack of experience, the work of the museum was random, often they simply collected rare collections, and the collections themselves were quite complex: the good and the bad were mixed. It is particularly worth noting that the museum also took the initiative to conduct several field excavations and received a large number of excavated cultural relics. Collections have become not only numerous, but also high-quality and valuable. Such as a square pot with a lotus and a tap, a nine-handed ruyi jade in Denfeng County (Fig.2). It is thanks to the large number of cultural relics that it has significantly increased its status in the national museum circle, and has also been highly appreciated abroad. Fig.2. Cultural relics in the museum, exhibition hall "Ancient jade of Henan province" The period from 1977 to 1997 can be called the 20th anniversary of the great development of the Henan Museum, the exhibition work was carried out vividly and gradually established itself as a museum of national cultural relics. Over the past ten years, with the constant deepening of work with cultural relics, long-preserved cultural relics have finally been exhibited again. Departments of culture of various regions and cities have collected a large number of beautiful cultural relics. These exquisite relics, such as pearls encrusted on the land of the Central Plains, emit a sparkling radiance and certainly attract countless tourists from China and abroad with their endless charm [9],[10]. The Henan Provincial Museum is not only a place for collecting cultural relics, cultural enlightenment, but also an important place for scientific research [11]. Between 1931 and 1938, the Henan Museum published more than 100 volumes of catalogues and research papers on cultural relics. In 1977, with the support of the Henan Provincial Museum, the first provincial-level cultural magazine "Henan Cultural Newsletter" was published. Gradually, academic journals with local features and unique styles have been formed, which attract more and more attention from cultural and museum circles. Next, we will consider as an analogue some museums of Southeast Asia of historical and cultural profile. Historical Museums of Southeast Asia
Ten major specialized museums of Southeast Asian countries were selected for comparison and analysis. Tables were compiled with the logo, exterior, interior, brand carriers, and corporate colors of these museums. Figures 3, 4 show comparative data of these two museums. 1. The Tokyo National Museum of Japan is located in the northern part of Ueno Park in Tokyo, founded in 1938, 87 items of Chinese treasures, 634 items of important cultural relics are in trust here. 2. The National Museum of Nature and Science is the largest natural history museum in Japan. Located in Ueno Park in Tokyo, founded in 1871, the collection fund consists of more than 89,000 exhibits. 3. The National Museum of Korea is the largest historical and art museum and cultural center in the Republic of Korea, founded in 1945, located in the capital city of Seoul, the collection fund consists of 220,000 exhibits. 4. The Seoul Historical Museum is located in one of the northern districts of Seoul – Jeongnogu, established in 2002. 5. The National Museum of Bangkok is the Central National Museum of Thailand, the largest museum in Southeast Asia, founded in 1874. The museum has a collection of works of Thai art and history.
Fig.3. Museums of Southeast Asia, part I 6. Siam Museum – located on Sanamchai Street in Bangkok, Thailand, established in 2007. 7. The National Museum of Singapore is the oldest museum in Singapore. The history of this institution begins in 1849, it is one of the sections of the library of the Singapore Institute. 8. The National Museum of Malaysia, founded in 1963 in Kuala Lumpur in a building that looks like a traditional Malay house. 9. The Asian Civilizations Museum is a Singapore museum that tells about the historical roots of the country through a description of the culture of Asian peoples over the past five thousand years. The collection fund consists of 1,500 historical and cultural artifacts. 10. The National Museum of Indonesia is the central museum of the history and Culture of Indonesia in Jakarta. Founded in 1778, the collection fund consists of 140,000 exhibits.
Fig.4. Museums of Southeast Asia, part II Regarding the brand analysis of these museums, we are mainly interested in the logo (brand name), brand carriers and corporate colors. The presented logos contain both the font part (mostly chopped fonts) and the graphic part (except for the National Museums of Singapore and Tokyo). The graphic part is based on silhouettes of flora and fauna (National Museum of Nature and Science of Tokyo, National Museum of Bangkok), based on religious symbols (National Museum of Korea), petroglyph (Siam Museum), geometric sign of rhythmic spots (National Museum of Indonesia), also with abbreviations (Tokyo National Museum, National Museum of Malaysia, Museum of Asian Civilizations). On all logos of museums, national names are duplicated by English-language versions. In the exterior of most buildings, European style can be noted, some have an ethnic basis. The interiors mostly differ in accordance with the content of the exposition, the corporate colors support the national symbols and brand carriers (black, gray, red, terracotta, shades of azure and yellow-green). You can notice that the brand colors are quite muted, there are no bright shades (blue, light blue, yellow). The noted features of the museums under consideration demonstrate rather the features of their industry affiliation to the museum business. Rebranding of the Henan Provincial Museum Over the past few years, the corporate image of the Henan Museum has not undergone major changes. The main reason is that the logo at that time was inspired by the appearance of the museum building. When developing a new brand, the main attention should be paid to classical cultural relics, as well as historical sources on which the culture of the Central Plains is based. It should be noted that a new corporate logo has been proposed, and it is inspired by the shape of classical cultural relics in the museum. Therefore, in order for people to understand the historical origin, it is necessary to focus on this cultural relic. When designing an exhibition hall, it is necessary to take into account the design to improve the image, including general and corporate impact. At the same time, it is also necessary to take into account the color design of the entire space: the colors should be in harmony with each other, there should not be too detached and not corresponding to the theme of the exhibition [12],[13]. In the text introducing cultural relics, the font should be unified, the text should be written in an easy-to-read font. You also need to pay attention to the harmony of the font color with the background. This is an important aspect of visiting the exhibition by the viewer. Special attention should also be paid to posters and billboards, and the exhibition should maintain a uniform style with the brand image [10],[14]. Logo development, branded media The first step in creating and developing a brand is the creation of various logo design solutions. Below is an associative series of images (Fig.5). Bronze products are the oldest type of Chinese art. With its variety of shapes, types of jewelry and the level of casting technique, Chinese bronze is a brilliant contribution to world art. Traditional Chinese ornaments refer to patterns with unique national artistic styles passed down from generation to generation. Fig.5. Associative row: a bronze glass in the shape of a bird, a traditional Chinese ornament, an image of a bird Based on the illustrative material, the following search options for logo sketches were proposed (Fig.6). Fig.6. Search options for the logo As a result of the discussions, the following final version of the Henan Museum logo was chosen, which is shown in Fig. 7, on the left. The new logo is mainly based on the famous collection of cultural relics of the Henan Museum, on a stylized glass in the shape of a bird. A packaging ornament based on a logo in the style of traditional Chinese patterns has also been developed (Fig.7, right). The use of repeating ornaments and their combinations creates a beautiful background that can be used for the production of branded graphics and packaging. Fig.7. The final version of the logo and the pattern for packaging products
The shades of terracotta were chosen as the brand colors: C:29, M:99, Y:100, K:0 and C:59, M:81, Y:100, K:44. The shades selected for the brand correspond to the colors used in the unified shades of the museum interior. Running Hand and Source Serif Variable were chosen as branded fonts, which will be used in the development of branded printing products. The booklet is a carrier of corporate identity, with the help of lines, images and text it can be combined into a creative and exquisite work to display the brand of the museum and the content of the exhibition (Fig.8). Fig.8. Museum booklet Regardless of the form in which the poster is presented, it must have a strong visual impact and artistic appeal. Museum posters should express the theme, the name of the exhibition, the time and place of the event (Fig.9). Fig.9. Posters of the museum's exhibition dedicated to musical instruments of the Great Silk Road The design of the Henan Museum's website was also proposed, which is now an important direction for the development of digitization of exhibits, and subsequent acquaintance with the museum's collection. Design concept of the exhibition hall "Musical instruments of the Great Silk Road" The Silk Road is broadly divided into the Land Silk Road and the Sea Silk Road. The overland Silk Road originates during the Western Han Dynasty (202-208 BC), when the emperor of the Han dynasty Wu sent an envoy to the western regions, through Gansu and Xinjiang to Central and Western Asia and connected the Mediterranean countries with access by land [4],[5]. The Maritime Silk Road mainly passed through the South China Sea, so it is also called the South China Maritime Silk Road. The Maritime Silk Road was formed during the Qin and Han dynasties, developed and flourished under the Sui, Tang, Song, Yuan and Ming dynasties. The traditional Silk Road starts from the ancient capital of China Chang'an, and reaches the Mediterranean Sea through the countries of Central Asia, ends in Rome, with a total length of 6440 kilometers. This road is considered the crossroads of ancient civilizations of the East and West, and silk was the most representative cargo. For thousands of years, nomads, tribes, traders, believers, diplomats, soldiers and research scientists have traveled along the Silk Road. Over time, the Silk Road became a collective name for all political, economic and cultural exchanges between ancient China and the West. The main contribution of the Silk Road to the development of ancient Chinese society was economic, it allowed the inhabitants of the Central Plains to conduct commodity trade with their western neighbors. In addition to the economic contribution, another contribution of the Silk Road was the cultural aspect to the development of ancient Chinese society. Many rulers of the Central Plains have begun to adopt an open diplomatic strategy towards neighboring countries in Central and Western Asia. Mutual absorption has significantly contributed to cultural exchange between China and the countries of Central and Western Asia. At the Henan Museum, many exhibitions are open at the same time, among them "Musical Instruments of the Great Silk Road" – the last exhibition. This allows visitors to immerse themselves in history and culture, thanks to musical instruments that were traded on the Silk Road, and acquaintance with historical information. The exhibition aims to tell people about the historical aspects and the significant influence of the Silk Road. Figure 10 shows traditional musical instruments, typical temple architecture, ethnic drawings and national ornaments of Southeast Asian countries in the form of a table [6]. By visual comparison, one can notice the national peculiarities of the culture and art of these countries. They have something in common, unifying, at the same time they have their own nuances, signs indicating ethnicity.
Exhibition hall design The exhibition space should have many functional areas, such as an exhibition area, a meeting area, storage, passage, recreation area, etc. The recreation area for tourists is an integral part of the interior space of exhibitions and public service areas [14],[15]. When planning various exhibitions, it is necessary to take into account the audience, control the route of the visit to enhance the effect of the exhibition. The main forms of organization of the flows of the internal space of the museum building include: sequential, radial and tunnel. Sequential implies a step-by-step transition through exhibition spaces. With a radial organization, the exhibition space is gathered around a single center. The tunnel organization refers to the presence of a passage between the exhibition spaces. Usually these trajectories are intertwined within the same museum space. The Henan State Museum mostly uses a radial scheme for organizing the flow of visitors, the four main exhibition halls form the central part of the museum space. When designing, it is also necessary to take into account the density of the placement of exhibits of cultural relics, which is the most important issue in the design of exhibitions. The shape of the exhibition hall is square, the floor plan is shown in Fig. 11, the display cases with cultural relics are placed according to the principle of symmetry. Fig.11. Plan of the exhibition hall "Musical instruments of the Great Silk Road" The color design of the museum space should be closely related to the theme of the exhibition in order to attract the attention of the audience. The color scheme should reflect the theme of the exhibition hall and the expectation of visitors. The design style of the exhibition hall should be simple and original, as well as take into account unique national and cultural characteristics. The location of the display cases of cultural relics in the exhibition hall should be regular, they should not interfere with people's visits due to the incorrect location of the display cases [16],[17]. Based on the above criteria, a three-dimensional model of the room was created, showcases and exhibits were placed taking into account the route of visiting the exhibition. In the future, materials, textures were assigned to the objects of the hall, lighting sources were installed [18]. Figures 12, 13 show visualizations of various angles of the exhibition hall, which clearly show the exhibits, musical instruments and cultural relics [19]. Fig.12. Visualization of the exhibition hall "Musical instruments of the Great Silk Road" Fig.13. Visualization of the exhibition hall "Musical instruments of the Great Silk Road" Based on the created three-dimensional model, a video flight of the exhibition premises was taken, which complements the possibilities of a virtual tour, remote access. Further, within the framework of the results obtained, we will discuss some modern trends in the design of museum space on the example of domestic and foreign museums. Discussion: museum space in modern conditions Usually, the physical boundaries of the room are considered to be under the museum space, but this has not been true for a long time. Today museums have become not only a cultural and educational organization, this factor must be taken into account when developing the design of the museum space. The paper [20] discusses the design features of museums in Novosibirsk in modern realities. Museums are becoming venues for teaching classes that develop interest in modern folk art and science. Therefore, there is an increasing need for a universal, easily transformable space for educational purposes. And the original museum room, as a shell of collections, plays a high socio-cultural role. The article [21] is devoted to the transformation of a modern museum into a promising center of multicultural communication. It is necessary to determine the response of museums to the challenge of intercultural communication in the modern world. It is noted that at the moment there has been a shift in the functional structure of the museum from its custodial functions to communication functions. Visitors are increasingly posting their photos online while visiting museums. This is especially evident in the social network Instagram, in the work [22] the issues of creating posts by visitors of immersive digital spaces (spaces with the effect of immersion in the environment) are investigated. Combining these spaces with visual social media platforms is becoming commonplace in the modern world. The key audience among visitors is the family, which requires a special form of participation. The article [23] presents the results of research conducted at the large international art museum Tate Modern (London) on the study of family needs in the museum space. For a family visit, the usual needs become important: playing, sitting, talking, eating and relaxing. While the social purpose of museums continues to be discussed, it is necessary to better understand the possibilities of modern museums. The article [24] is devoted to the analysis of available museum technologies for people with sensory impairments. A small amount of research suggests tactile telepresence robots, multi-sensory works of art, 3D multimedia, multilingual devices and augmented reality applications. These new technologies can change the museum experience for people with sensory impairments and disabilities.
Museum space design issues. Design covers all spheres of human activity: architecture and landscape, interior, clothing, objects, expositions, etc. It reflects the lifestyle, worldview, aesthetic tastes of society [25]. Difficulties in developing the design of the museum are explained by the versatility of the form and content of museum expositions. The paper [26] explores the importance of the process of design design of museum expositions, as it changes over time, therefore, it is a dynamically developing field of museology. The work [27] is devoted to the analysis of modern trends in museum identity and identifies the reasons for museum rebranding. Innovative, creative activity in the field of museum branding creates new directions in visual identity. The branding of the museum is understood as a set of measures aimed at building visitors' confidence in the new image of the museum. The article [28] discusses the issues of designing the interiors of the museum space. It is necessary to show each exhibit in a unique way while respecting the integrity of the entire exposition. Currently, not much attention is paid to the issues of illumination in the design of museum premises. The combination of daylight and artificial lighting affects the perception of museum expositions. The article [29] describes the process of designing daytime lighting for the museum premises, its external facades in order to support an interesting spatial atmosphere. Multimedia technologies in the museum exposition. The article [30] describes the process of rethinking the current state of the museum, regarding the use of multimedia technologies. When creating expositions with multimedia technologies, it is also necessary to take into account the visual shell of the room, so as not to cause disharmony with the overall design of the museum space. The review [31] explores the use of virtual and augmented reality in the museum space for social learning. Examples of using virtual/augmented reality for learning are described, while attention is paid to accessibility, interaction between physical and virtual environments. The article [32] is devoted to the application of a very interesting modern museum technology - the use of museum guide robots with artificial intelligence in the space of the science museum. Forty-seven museum guides were interviewed, who described their impressions of robot training. This research will help to substantiate the debate about machine learning paradigms in the spaces of modern museums. Conclusion To implement the plan, it is necessary to draw inspiration from cultural legends and turn to historical sources, as they carry the experience and knowledge passed on by ancestors. Each graphic and symbol presented at the exhibition is designed to convey meaning. Therefore, in the developed design it is necessary to combine individual and combined meaning of symbols. As a result, it can be noted that the analysis of the current state of the brand of South Asian museums was made, the features of the history of the creation and subsequent development of the museum of Henan province were described, historical aspects of the existence of the culture of the Great Silk Road were revealed. The components of the rebranding of the museum have been developed, a new design concept has been proposed, the room of the hall "Musical Instruments of the Great Silk Road" has been modeled, visualizations have been made and a video flight of the hall has been created, with a visual representation of the exhibits for remote access and viewing. Modern trends in the design of museum space were also discussed, noting the growing influence of multimedia technologies.
References
1. Babaeva A.V. Modern museum space: development or destruction // Modern problems of the humanities and social sciences: Series "Social and political development of Russian society".-Issue. 2(19).-Voronezh: Scientific book, 2018.-P.13-20.
2. Materials of open online courses (MOOCs) "Education by history" [Electronic resource]//-Access mode: https://edu.kpfu.ru/mod/page/view.php?id=170569 (accessed 18.02. 2022)
3. Maistrovskaya M.T. Museum as an Object of Culture: The Art of the Exposition Ensemble.-M.: Progress-Tradition Publishing House, 2016.-678s.
4. Culture of China [Electronic resource]//-Access mode: http://www.china.org.cn/english/culture/34435.htm (accessed 09.11.2021)
5. Encyclopedia of Chinese regions [Electronic resource] //-Access mode: http://russian.china.org.cn (accessed 02/07/2022)
6. Museums of China [Electronic resource]//-Access mode: https://www.sohu.com/a/290162987_100237836 (accessed 07/16/2021)
7. Henan Provincial Museum [Electronic resource] //-Access mode: https://www.chinahighlights.ru/zhengzhou/attraction/henan-national-museum.htm (accessed 07/16/2021)
8. Kang Qi. Creation Notes-Creation of the Henan Museum.-Architectural magazine, 1999.-102 p.
9. Deshui Zhang. History of the Henan Museum.-Original text in Chinese. 2002.-158 p.
10. Leonard M. What Does China Think? Bargain Price, 2008.-176 p.
11. Gray J.H. China: A History of the Laws, Manners and Customs of the People. Dover Publications, 2003.-992 p.
12. Algazina N.V. Design. Exhibition space.-Omsk: OGIS, 2012.-186 p.
13. Stallabrass J. Branding of the museum. History of Art,-2014,-265 p.
14. Shcherbina A.V. Museum design: teaching aid.-Tolyatti: TSU,-2011.-68 p.
15. Sun Weiyi. Studying the various functions and ways of using museum recreation areas [Electronic resource]-Access mode: https://www.fx361.com/page/2020/0227/7599487.shtml (accessed: 02/27/2022)
16. Analysis of the architectural design of the Henan Museum [Electronic resource] //-Access mode: https://www.xzbu.com/2/view-572324.htm (accessed 06/14/2021)
17. Abbasov I.B., Sanchez K. Design of the museum space of Inca culture “Museo del Sol” //Culture and Art. 2018. No. 8. P.40-53. DOI: 10.7256/2454-0625.2018.8.27096
18. Abbasov I.B. Basics of three-dimensional modeling in the graphics system 3 ds Max 2018. Tutorial (approved by UMO). Moscow: DMK Press. 2017.-186 p.
19. Abbasov I.B., Du Yifei. Stages of formation of the Museum of Henan Province (China). Collection of materials of the XVI All-Russian Conference "Information Service in the Age of Electronic Communications", November 2–3, 2021, St. Petersburg: TsGPB im. V.V. Mayakovsky, 2021.-184 p. pp.69-78.
20. Maryasova M.K., Maksimenko V.I. Museum space design and educational function // Regional architectural and art schools. – 2020. – no. 1. S.135-140. DOI: 10.37909/978-5-89170-275-2-2020-1022
21. Altukhova S.A. Modern museum as a space of multicultural communication: a review of the cases of Russia and Great Britain // History and modern outlook. 2020. Vol. 2. No. 3. pp.103-111. DOI: 10.33693/2658-4654/-2020-2-3-103-111
22. Budge K. Visitors in immersive museum spaces and Instagram: Self, place-making, and play // The Journal of Public Space.-2018.-V.3 (3). – P.121-138. DOI:10.32891/jps.v3i3.534
23. Hood L., Bailey A. R., Coles T., Pringle E. Liminal spaces and the shaping of family museum visits: a spatial ethnography of a major international art museum //Museum Management and Curatorship. 2022. P.1-24. https://doi.org/10.1080/09647775.2021.2023897
24. Carrizosa H.G., Sheehy K., Rix J., Seale J., Hayhoe S. Designing technologies for museums: accessibility and participation issues // Journal of Enabling Technologies, 2020, V.14 (1), P.31-39 . https://doi.org/10.1108/JET-08-2019-0038
25. Nishonova K. Modern exhibition design in museums of Uzbekistan // Theoretical & Applied Science. 2019. no. 3. C.357-359 https://dx.doi.org/10.15863/TAS.2019.03.71.24
26. Solodovnikova N.V. Design as a means of artistic design of a museum exhibition // Science. Research. Practice. 2020. S. 18-22.
27. Barsukova N.I. Modern trends in museum rebranding / Issues of the development of modern science and technology / Sat. Art. III Intl. scientific and practical. conf. // Melbourne: Scientific View, 2021. no. 1. S.160-165. DOI:10.24412/cl-36006-2021-1-160-165
28. Surova E.M., Shumakova T.A. Design features of the museum space // Museums of decorative art, art industry and design: yesterday, today, tomorrow. 2018. P.83-87.
29. Fathy F., Mansour Y., Sabry H., Refat M., Wagdy A. Conceptual framework for daylighting and facade design in museums and exhibition spaces // Solar Energy.2020. V.204. P.673-682. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2020.05.014
30. Lobanova O.S., Makarova T.S., Glazyrina T.A. The role of multimedia technologies in the museum exposition // Architecton: Izvestiya vuzov. 2020. no. 4. S.1-11. DOI:10.47055/1990-4126-2020-4(72)-21
31. Scavarelli A., Arya A., Teather R.J. Virtual reality and augmented reality in social learning spaces: a literature review //Virtual Reality. 2021. V.25(1). P.257-277. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10055-020-00444-8
32. Candello H., Pichiliani M., Wessel M., Pinhanez C., Muller M. Teaching robots to act and converse in physical spaces: participatory design fictions with museum guides // Proceedings of the Halfway to the Future Symposium 2019. 2019 P.1-4. https://doi.org/10.1145/3363384.336339
First Peer Review
Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.
The incorrectness of the title immediately makes it difficult to identify the issues – it seems that you will not even read the article, but already a lot of questions arise at the start. First of all, does the name mean that the whole province of Henan (probably a Chinese province?) is it a museum space? It is doubtful, however, based on the name, one can imagine exactly such a picture. Or are we talking about specific museums or a single significant museum? Probably, the author also meant that some kind of design concept should be implemented (still, apparently, it is necessary to hyphenate) the museum space of an entire province or, nevertheless, any museum complex. There are a lot of questions, will we get clear answers to them? Let's turn to the content of the article. It draws attention to the clear structuring of the work – each structural element has a name – this allows you to trace the logic of scientific research and generally assess the heuristic potential of the entire work. In addition, the author focuses on illustrative material, which undoubtedly decorates the article from the point of view of the visual range above all. And yet, an important detail escapes the author, which sets the tone for the whole study, as it usually happens. We are talking about the analysis of scientific discourse on the topic – it simply does not exist in the article. In this case, how should we assess the author's mastery of the problem, how his approach fits (and perhaps does not fit) into the research context of the corresponding orientation. Strangely, there is no description of the research methodology at the beginning of the work, the content of key concepts is not defined – for example, the author does not reveal the meaning of the concept of "museum space"; a museum is understandable, but what is a museum space: is it the inside of the museum, or is it still about the whole museum complex, etc. There is also no clarity in the use of the concept of "design concept"; will it be some kind of project or will it be a description of a specific visual series? The questions appear again in progression, and the author, it seems, is still not ready to give them proper answers. In addition, the author generally connects the scientific hypothesis with a completely different phenomenon – the brand of the museum; I would like to ask: how does the author intend to correlate the brand of the museum, the museum space and the "design concept"? Probably, art criticism should be indicated among the methods, otherwise a set of only general scientific methods (for example, logical analysis – which, by the way, is pretty lame for the author himself, despite the fact that I noted above that the names of the parts of the work help to trace the logic of the research – but I overreacted with this conclusion). The author does not describe his choice of Henan province – and another question hangs in the air. What is remarkable about this province, why did the author choose it, which museums are represented here, what are their specifics compared to similar and other museums? Further, the concept of museum space completely disappeared in the text, naturally the author lost interest in this phenomenon, and I, in turn, completely lost interest in the entire article. I suspect that other potential readers may follow my example, which is quite bad for this kind of material. Unfortunately, quite good illustrative material does not save the situation, but rather dissonates with the author's not very expressive, I would say crumpled narrative. Serious and unhurried adjustments are needed that would radically improve this article.
Second Peer Review
Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.
The subject of the study, the design of the concept of the exhibition space of the Henan Provincial State Museum (China), is considered comprehensively in order to modernize the design concept of the Henan Museum space and maximize its communicative function for further promotion of the museum's brand in the field of tourism and development of the local economy. The author traced how the historical and cultural traditions of the region and modern branding practices of museum and exhibition activities can be harmoniously combined in order to codify culture. The article consistently describes the Henan Provincial Museum, the main historical stages of its creation, problems and prospects for the development of its exhibition activities. In the context of the analysis of modern practices of rebranding historical museums of Southeast Asia, the author revealed the creative process of brand development and modernization of the design concept of the Henan Museum space, emphasizing, among other things, the relationship of the symbolism of the logo and branded media about the museum and its exhibition projects with the tasks of harmonious structuring of the museum space. The research methodology is subordinated to the logic of analysis and synthesis of data from special literature for the purpose of their further application. The author relies on the synthesis of logical and historical approaches, carrying out a systematic analysis of the elements of the language of museum expositions and presentation materials. The situational approach to the organization of the museum environment used to develop the brand of the Henan Museum is analyzed. Based on stylistic and comparative analysis, the rebranding practices of some similar museums in Southeast Asia are described. According to the reviewer, the interdisciplinary methodological synthesis was applied by the author reasonably and effectively. The applied author's solution itself is worthy of further scaling in the practices of organizing the museum exhibition space. The relevance of the research topic is due to the intensive development of the communicative practices of the modern museum. The article clearly demonstrates the positive experience of the complex organization of the exhibition space of a separate museum in the context of modern museum practices. The described experience can certainly be applied by the central and provincial historical museums of Russia. Therefore, the article is undoubtedly relevant and timely. The scientific novelty of the study, according to the author, lies in the analysis of the brands of South Asian museums of history and culture in order to rebrand a separate museum in the practice of developing the project of the original design concept of the exhibition space. The validity of the proposed interpretation of the choice of stylistic features of the original design concept of the museum's exhibition space is beyond doubt. The style is generally scientific, although some turns of speech, of which there are many in the text, need literary editing (for example, in the statement: "In general, this space unites not only the architectural basis, but also the visual shell of museum exhibitions, including their digital accompaniment (website, virtual tour)," the meaning is clear, but the text is structured with errors of agreement and punctuation; there are many similar examples, so the reviewer recommends additional literary and editorial proofreading of the article). Illustrations are used successfully and appropriately in the article, although there is a misleading typo in the comments to Fig. 7. The structure of the article reveals the logic of presenting the results of scientific research and, to some extent, smooths out the stylistic mistakes of the author's language in terms of presenting information. When finalizing the article, the reviewer recommends adding a "Discussion" section, where to review several publications of colleagues over the past 5 years concerning the development of museum space in museums in various countries. This would greatly enhance the scientific value of the article. According to the content of the text, the comments mainly relate to literary refinement in terms of coordinating the members of the sentence and, accordingly, punctuation and/or simplification of complex sentences. The bibliography and sources, including the author's reliance on empirical material, generally reflect the problematic area of research. Although, in light of the special relevance of the topic chosen by the author, the list can be strengthened by publications over the past 5 years from reputable international journals. The design of the descriptions requires revision according to the requirements of the editorial board. Appealing to opponents is generally correct. The presented article, taking into account its revision, is of interest to the readership of the magazine "Culture and Art".
Third Peer Review
Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.
The author submitted his article "Design concept of the exhibition space of the Henan State Museum" to the magazine "Culture and Art", which analyzes the current state of the museum complex and potential ways of its development. The author proceeds in studying this issue from the fact that the modern museum is an important mechanism for preserving and broadcasting the cultural heritage of a certain people. The design of the museum space is one of the most important ways to attract visitors. The museum space is created with the help of certain exposition techniques, materials, designed to reveal the meaning and message of the exposition. In general, this space unites not only the architectural basis and exhibition projects, but also their digital support in the form of a website, a virtual tour for remote access. According to the author, the museum is also a public place where people receive cultural education and spend their leisure time. Therefore, it is necessary to create a functionally convenient environment for visiting, attracting the attention of visitors as much as possible, arousing the desire to explore cultural relics and exhibits. The relevance of this issue is determined by the need to draw attention to museum activities in order to preserve cultural heritage sites and popularize the unique Chinese culture. The purpose of this study is to develop a new design concept for the Henan Museum Space, the hall of musical instruments of the Great Silk Road, as well as to develop recommendations for further brand promotion to increase tourist attractiveness and develop the local economy. The object of the study is the museum of Henan Province, China, the subject is the influence of the museum's brand on the popularization of ancient Chinese culture. To achieve this goal, the author of the article sets the following tasks: to analyze the current state of the brand of some Asian museums of history and culture; to determine the features of the development of the museum of Henan province; to identify historical aspects of the existence of the culture of the Great Silk Road, to identify and develop components of a new design concept for the museum space of Henan province on the example of the hall Musical Instruments of the Great Silk Road; to create a logo museum, advertising, and printing products. The theoretical basis of the study was the works of such scientists as Shcherbina A.V., Maistrovskaya M.T., Abbasov I.B., Sun Weyi, Scavarelli A. and others. The methodological basis of the study was an integrated approach containing general scientific methods, socio-cultural, historical, comparative, and systemic analysis. The scientific novelty and practical significance of the research lies in the analysis of the brand of the South Asian museums of history and culture in order to rebrand this museum, in the development of the project of the original design concept of the hall of the exhibition space of the Henan Museum. To form a complete picture for the reader, the author provides information on the history, geographical location of Henan Province, as well as provides detailed information on the creation, development and current state of the museum. Based on the work of museum researchers, the author presents an analysis of the educational, social and cultural role of the museum in the modern world, the process of transformation of the modern museum into a promising center of multicultural communication. The author explores the importance of the design process of museum exhibitions in a unified manner, including the placement of exhibition objects, lighting, printing and souvenir products. As the author emphasizes, in modern museum activities, not only should the role of multimedia and information technologies not be underestimated, but also try to use them as widely as possible in exposition activities. According to the author, new technologies can provide invaluable assistance in the formation of the visual identification system of the exhibition, as they allow the use of a wide range of information transmission channels, including digital ones. This makes it possible to enhance the interactive capabilities of the exhibition project, to interest a potential audience, and to ensure maximum interest in the project even for those who are physically unable to visit it. The author also conducted a comparative study of the historical museums of Southeast Asia. Ten major specialized museums in Japan, Korea, Thailand, Malaysia, and Indonesia were selected for comparison and analysis. The author has compiled tables with the logo, exterior, interior, brand bearers, and corporate colors of these museums. The author pays special attention to the development of recommendations for the rebranding of the Henan Provincial Museum, the development of a corporate logo, pattern, and printing products in a single recognizable style. The design of the Henan Museum's website was also proposed, which is now an important area for the development of digitization of exhibits, and subsequent familiarization with the museum's collection. The author has developed a detailed three-dimensional design project of the exhibition hall "Musical Instruments of the Great Silk Road", taking into account architectural features, materials, textures, lighting sources. All the author's achievements indicated in the article are illustrated with tabular and graphic material. After conducting the research, the author comes to the conclusion that in order to implement the developed projects, it is necessary to turn to historical sources, an organic combination of traditional cultural heritage with modern technologies. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing a topic for analysis, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of the peculiarities of the formation of the modern museum space is of undoubted theoretical and practical cultural interest and can serve as a source of further research. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. An adequate choice of methodological base also contributes to this. The author fulfilled his goal, obtained certain scientific results that allowed him to summarize the material. The bibliographic list consists of 32 sources, including foreign ones, which seems sufficient for generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the studied problem. It should be noted that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication.
|