Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Psychologist
Reference:

Anxiety-depressive symptoms in the context of the type of attitude to pregnancy of women in the postpartum period

Kuzmina Anna Sergeevna

PhD in Psychology

Associate Professor, Department of Clinical Psychology, Altai State University

656049, Russia, Altai Krai, Barnaul, Lenin str., 61, office 302

annakuz87@yandex.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 
Praizendorf Ekaterina Sergeevna

ORCID: 0000-0002-9014-8927

Senior Lecturer of the Department of Clinical Psychology of Altai State University

656049, Russia, Altaiskii krai, g. Barnaul, ul. Lenina, 61, of. 302

catherinears@list.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8701.2023.3.38268

EDN:

RUZMKS

Received:

14-06-2022


Published:

05-07-2023


Abstract: The subject of the study is the anxiety-depressive symptoms of women in the postpartum period. The aim of the study is to identify the interrelationships of anxiety-depressive symptoms of women in the postpartum period and the type of their attitude to pregnancy. The author identified differences in anxiety-depressive symptoms of women with different types of residence and the use of maternity care. The results on the relationship of anxiety and depression with the type of attitude to pregnancy of women in the postpartum period were obtained. Research methodology: typology of the psychological component of the gestational dominant I.V. Dobryakova. Empirical basis of the study: the study was conducted on the basis of the Altai Regional Clinical Center for Maternal and Child Health with women in the early postpartum period.The existence of interrelations between the appearance of anxiety-depressive symptoms of women in the postpartum period and the type of attitude to pregnancy is theoretically substantiated and empirically proven. Qualitative characteristics of differences in the type of attitude to pregnancy of women with different types of residence and the use of maternity care are determined. The main conclusions of the study are : Anxious symptoms in the postpartum period are more typical for women from rural areas; Women who have undergone natural childbirth are more likely to experience depression and anxiety in the postpartum period; Rural women are more characterized by a hypogestognosic type of attitude to pregnancy, urban women - a depressive type of attitude to pregnancy; Anxious and depressive types of attitude to pregnancy associated with fears, expressed fears, tearfulness are risk factors for the development of anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period.


Keywords:

Pregnancy, Psychology of pregnancy, attitude to pregnancy, gestational dominant, Natural childbirth, Postpartum period, Anxiety, Depression, Anxiety-depressive symptoms, Preparation for childbirth

This article is automatically translated.

The problem of studying anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period and the features of its relationship with the type of attitude to pregnancy is currently becoming increasingly important and is an important area of research located at the intersection of medicine, perinatal and clinical psychology [4, 9, 12]. The postpartum period is a new stage in a woman's life, the acquisition of a different female identity, a time of emotional and psychological upheaval, and the course of this period is largely related to the specifics of a woman's attitude during pregnancy to herself and her condition [6, 16].

In addition, the psychological health of a woman in the postpartum period and the peculiarities of her emotional background determine the health of the child and the peculiarities of its development. Anxiety-depressive symptoms in the postpartum period are also dangerous due to the risk of postpartum depression, suicidal tendencies and self-harm in women [3, 20, 21].

Postpartum depression is one of the most socially significant and common problems that significantly affect the health of the mother and many aspects of her life: the family as a whole, relatives and friends, and especially the child. Analysis of scientific sources indicates that a typical depressive episode is experienced by 10-15% of women worldwide after the birth of a child [5, 23, 24]. Depressive disorder for women can develop into a significant problem, since adequate help may either be late due to late diagnosis, or it may not be at all, since women quite often do not admit and do not talk about their feelings [10, 15, 17].

A woman's behavior and her experiences during pregnancy acquire specificity due to the peculiarities of her personality and attitude to pregnancy. The first pregnancy is often designated as a critical moment in the development of female identity, a certain point of no return to the previous relationship with oneself and the world around [1, 8, 22].

Modern trends in the development of psychological science lead to an understanding of the pregnancy period as a special period in a woman's life, focusing on transformational processes associated with lifestyle changes: the social situation of personality development is changing, roles are changing, the circle of people involved in interaction is changing, the whole range of solved problems and opportunities, lifestyle in general [11, 18, 19].

In general, today a multidirectional approach to the study of the problems of motherhood is being determined, generalizing various scientific directions. Thus, the fundamental aspects of the interaction of mother and child in early ontogenesis are presented in the works of G.G. Filippova, N.N. Avdeeva, G.V. Skoblo, etc.; A.S. Batuev, A.I. Zakharov, etc. studied the features of the emotional state of pregnant women; the issues of maternal deviant behavior are considered in the works of V.I. Brutman, O.V. Bazhenova, A.Ya. Varga and others; individual personal transformations due to the new parental status were studied by O.A. Karabanova, S.Y. Meshcheryakova and others. In most modern scientific works related to the most important aspects of pregnancy, childbirth and motherhood, the authors rely on foreign psychological concepts as a methodological basis. Freud, K. Horney, J. Bowlby, D.V. Winnikota, M. Klein, M. Ainworth.

Research in the field of neurotic reactions during pregnancy and the postpartum period is also presented in science. Thus, some authors point out that the cause that contributes to the occurrence of postpartum depression is the pain experienced and the stress suffered by J.C. Eisenach, J. Kountanis, S.A. Freedman. There is a tendency to divide neurotic disorders in women into three directions: depressive, anxiety-depressive and depressive with obsessive phenomena, presented in the works of I.A. Kolesnikov, P.P. Balashov, A.B. Smulevich and others I.V. Dobryakov indicates the complexity of diagnosing depression due to the fact that some symptoms of this disorder may be inherent in perfectly healthy women.

In perinatal psychology, there are differences in approaches to choosing the basis of the attitude to pregnancy. In general, the selection of typical variants of the attitude to pregnancy is based on the analysis of the characteristics of the mother's personality's response to her own self, to pregnancy, to the surrounding reality and to the circle of subjectively significant persons and situations in this regard.

G.G. Filippova introduces the concept of the style of experiencing pregnancy. Highlighting 6 styles of experiencing pregnancy [21]:

1. Adequate style:

2. An anxious style of experiencing pregnancy:

3. Euphoric style of experiencing pregnancy:

4. Ignoring style:

5. Ambivalent style:

6. Rejecting style.

The central concept of the work is the definition of the type of attitude to pregnancy, which in the methodology of I.V. Dobryakova is determined through the psychological component of the gestational dominant.

I.V. Dobryakov in his works indicates the occurrence of a gestational dominant during pregnancy, which has psychological and physiological components [7]. The gestational dominant ensures that all the body's reactions are directed towards creating optimal conditions for the development of the embryo, and then the fetus, for gestation, and then birth and care of the child [13]. I.V. Dobryakov defines the psychological component of the gestational dominant as a set of mechanisms of mental self-regulation aimed at preserving pregnancy and creating conditions for the development of the child, forming a woman's attitude to pregnancy and her behavior during this period [7, 14].

In his works, I.V. Dobryakov identifies 5 types of the psychological component of the gestational dominant: optimal, hypogestognosic, euphoric, anxious and depressive, which form a unique profile for each woman of the type of attitude to pregnancy, revealed through a set of scales of I.V. Dobryakov's methodology.

With the optimal type of pregnancy, as a rule, is desirable. A woman has a positive attitude to the fact of her pregnancy, promptly gets registered in a women's consultation and fulfills the doctor's recommendations. Such women are confident in their own parental competence, expect childbirth without unnecessary anxiety and gradually rebuild their lifestyle.

With the hypogestognosic type, a woman tries to ignore the somatic changes associated with pregnancy. Such women try not to change their lifestyle, often infringing on the interests of the child.

With the euphoric type of pregnancy, the background of a woman's mood is elevated throughout pregnancy. Such women are happy to change their lifestyle as soon as they learn about pregnancy, require special care and attention from their loved ones, fulfilling all their whims, but when complications arise, the woman is not ready for constructive actions.

Women with an anxious type from the very beginning of pregnancy experience a high level of anxiety and tension, often have pronounced fears, they are constantly worried about the health of the child, his well-being. After giving birth, such women continue to constantly worry about the well-being of the child, to doubt whether she is doing everything right [2].

With a depressive type, a woman remains depressed throughout pregnancy, tearfulness, it may seem to her that pregnancy has greatly spoiled her, violated her relationship with her husband. Such women have no idea about the child, but it may seem to them that it will certainly be inferior. They are sure that they will not cope with the role of a mother [4, 7].

So, different types of attitudes to pregnancy determine the direction and severity of the reactions of the pregnant woman's body to create optimal conditions for the intrauterine development of the child.  

Thus, there is a problem that consists in the need to resolve the contradiction between the objective need to provide psychological assistance to women in the postpartum period in terms of eliminating the risk of developing anxiety-depressive symptoms and the lack of scientifically sound ways and means of implementing this process.

In connection with the above, it seems significant to study the anxiety-depressive symptoms of women in the postpartum period in relation to the type of attitude to pregnancy.

The aim of the study was to identify the interrelationships of anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period and the type of attitude to pregnancy.

The subject of the study is the anxiety-depressive symptoms of women in the postpartum period.

Scientific novelty of the research. The existence of interrelations between the appearance of anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period and the type of attitude to pregnancy is theoretically substantiated and empirically proven. Qualitative characteristics of differences in anxiety-depressive symptoms and the type of attitude to pregnancy in women with different types of residence and the presence of maternity care were determined.

Research methodology: typology of the psychological component of the gestational dominant I.V. Dobryakova.

An important concept in the work is the concept of the psychological component of the gestational dominant, which is operationalized through a woman's attitude to her pregnancy.

The hypothesis of the study was the assumption that there are differences in the types of attitudes to pregnancy in women in the postpartum period, depending on the type of residence and use of maternity care and the presence of correlations of anxiety and depression with the type of attitude to pregnancy in women in the postpartum period.

Empirical basis of the study: the study was conducted on the basis of the Altai Regional Clinical Center for Maternal and Child Health with women in the early postpartum period. The respondents were 120 women, average age 22.3 ± 8.2. The postpartum period is from one to seven days from the moment of delivery. The questionnaire data revealed the type of residence of women (city and village), the presence of obstetric care (natural childbirth, planned caesarean section, emergency caesarean section).

For a visual representation of the empirical research base, we present a table.

Table 1.

Description of the sample population

Name

Criteria

Quantity, %

Type of accommodation

city

61,7

village

38,3

Total

100

The presence of obstetric care in childbirth

natural childbirth

73,3

planned caesarean section

15,8

emergency caesarean section

10,9

Total

100

 

Research methods and techniques:

A questionnaire identifying age, marital status, availability of maternity care, type of residence.

Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale HADS (The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale Zigmond A.S., Snaith R.P.) is designed for the primary detection of depression and anxiety in general medical practice.

The test of a pregnant woman's relationship is TOB(b) (Eidemiller E. G., Dobryakov I. V., Nikolskaya I. M.), which contains three blocks of statements reflecting the following three aspects:

A. The attitude of a woman to herself pregnant.

B. Women's relations in the emerging mother-child system.

B. The relationship of a pregnant woman to the relationship of others to her.

In each block there are three sections in which various concepts are scaled. Each of them is represented by five statements reflecting five different types of the psychological component of the gestational dominant (PCGD). The subject is asked to choose one of them that best suits her condition.

Block A (a woman's attitude towards herself as a pregnant woman) is represented by the following sections:

I. Attitude to pregnancy.

II. Attitude to lifestyle during pregnancy.

III. The attitude during pregnancy to the upcoming birth.

Block B (the relationship of a woman in the mother-child system formed during the nine months of pregnancy) contains sections:

I.                  Treating yourself as a mother.

II. Attitude to your child.

II.               Attitude to breastfeeding.

Block B (the relationship of a pregnant woman to the relationships of others to her) is represented by the following sections:

I.                  Attitude towards me, pregnant, husband.

II.               Attitude towards me, pregnant, relatives and loved ones.

III.            The attitude of strangers towards me, pregnant, strangers. The test is given in full.

As a result of processing the test, an individual profile of the attitude to pregnancy is obtained, which contains five scales that determine the severity of the types of psychological component of the gestational dominant: optimal, hypogestognosic, euphoric. Thus, the test results for each woman include an individual profile reflecting the severity of 5 types of attitudes to pregnancy.

Methods of mathematical and statistical data processing: one-factor analysis of variance ANOVA, Student's T-test, Spearman correlation analysis.

The Student's t-test revealed differences in anxiety-depressive symptoms and types of attitude to pregnancy in women with different types of residence (see Table 2, Fig. 1, 2).

 

Table 2.

The results of the Student's t-test in women in the postpartum period, depending on the type of residence

 

habitation

N

Mean

Std. Deviation

p

optimal

city

74,00

4,17

1,50

0,31

 

village

46,00

3,85

1,54

hypogestognosic

city

74,00

0,47

0,70

0,05*

 

village

46,00

1,05

1,09

euphoric

city

74,00

3,02

1,60

0,27

 

village

46,00

2,66

1,54

anxious

city

74,00

1,10

1,22

0,33

 

village

46,00

1,32

1,01

depressive

city

74,00

0,25

0,44

0,05*

 

village

46,00

0,12

0,33

Anxiety

city

74,00

7,27

3,97

0,05*

 

village

46,00

8,49

4,59

Depression

city

74,00

6,05

3,59

0,16

 

village

46,00

7,17

4,35

Symbols:N is the sample size, M is the arithmetic mean, SD is the standard deviation, p is the significance level, * is the significance level p=0.05.

 

Figure 1. Comparative analysis of the average values for anxiety symptoms in women in the postpartum period, depending on the type of residence, p= 0.05.

 

The analysis of Figure 1 showed that rural women are significantly more likely to experience increased anxiety in the early postpartum period. They are experiencing tension, restless thoughts are spinning in their head, they are experiencing excitement and fear, they are extremely concerned about the organization of household life and economy in their absence, they worry and think that something terrible may happen. They are also concerned about the issues of providing medical care to them and the child. Perhaps this may be due to the difficulties of obtaining medical services in rural areas.

Figure 2 shows significant differences in the types of attitudes towards pregnancy in women during the postpartum period, depending on the type of residence.

 

Figure 2. Comparative analysis of the average values of indicators of the types of attitude to pregnancy in women in the postpartum period, depending on the type of residence, p= 0.05.

 

The analysis of Figure 2 showed that rural women are significantly more characterized by a hypogestognosic type of attitude to pregnancy, in which women tend to underestimate the importance and seriousness of what is happening to them. After giving birth, they are not inclined to change their lifestyle. Child care, as a rule, is entrusted to other persons (grandmothers, older children). For urban women, the depressive type of attitude to pregnancy is significantly more characteristic, depressive experiences manifest themselves, first of all, in a sharply reduced background of the mood of pregnant women. So, a woman who dreamed of having a child may begin to claim that now she does not want him, does not believe in her ability to raise a healthy child. Women believe that pregnancy has "disfigured them", they are afraid of being abandoned by their husband, they often cry. In severe cases, super-valuable, and sometimes delusional hypochondriac ideas, ideas of self-abasement appear, suicidal tendencies are found in women with high values on the depressive type of attitude to pregnancy scale.

We present the results of a comparative analysis of the presence of anxiety-depressive symptoms and attitudes to pregnancy in women in the postpartum period, depending on the use of obstetric care (natural childbirth, planned cesarean section, emergency caesarean section).

The results of the ANOVA one-factor analysis of variance are presented in Table 4 in Figures 4, 5.

Table 4

Results of single-factor ANOVA in women with different types of use of obstetric care in the early postpartum period

Indicator

Type of birth

Average value

F

p

Depression

Natural childbirth

7,3

3,15

0,01**

Planned caesarean section

5,3

Emergency Caesarean section

5,2

Anxiety

Natural childbirth

8,4

2,67

0,05*

Planned caesarean section

6,53

Emergency Caesarean section

6,6

Symbols: F – the strength of differences, p – the level of significance * - the level of significance p= 0.05, ** - the level of significance p= 0.01,

 

 

As can be seen from Figure 4, the highest values on the depression scale were obtained in women who gave birth to a child without the use of obstetrics.

Symbols: e – natural childbirth, pks – planned caesarean section, ex – emergency caesarean section

Figure 4. Comparative analysis of the average values of depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period, depending on the use of obstetric aids, p=0.05

 

Figure 5 shows higher values on the anxiety scale in women who gave birth to a child without the use of maternity care.

 

Symbols: e – natural childbirth, pks – planned caesarean section, ex – emergency caesarean section

Figure 5. Comparative analysis of the average values for the indicator of anxiety symptoms in women in the postpartum period, depending on the use of obstetrics, p= 0.05

 

Women who have undergone natural childbirth are more likely to experience depression and anxiety in the postpartum period, which is due to their high personal responsibility and active participation in childbirth, as well as insufficient psychological preparation for childbirth.

An analysis of the questionnaire data showed that only 16% of women attended prenatal training courses, and most often these are women with planned cesarean section who prepare for childbirth and motherhood more carefully.

Spearman's correlation analysis showed a positive relationship between the anxiety scale and the indicator on the anxiety type of attitude to pregnancy scale (r=0.421; p=0.01) and a negative relationship with the indicator on the optimal type of attitude to pregnancy scale (r=-0.348; p=0.01).

Positive correlations of the depression scale with such scales of types of attitude to pregnancy as anxious (r=0.564; p=0.01), depressive (r=0.462; p=0.01), and a negative relationship with the euphoric type of attitude to pregnancy (r=-0.521; p=0.05) were obtained.

The appearance of anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period is interrelated with the type of psychological component of the gestational dominant. A woman's acceptance of pregnancy, physiological changes associated with pregnancy, a positive emotional background, confidence in her own parental competence contribute to resistance to the development of anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period. Anxious and depressive types of attitude to pregnancy associated with fears, expressed fears, tearfulness contribute to the development of anxiety-depressive symptoms in the postpartum period.

Thus, the following conclusions are made in the work:

1. Anxiety symptoms in the postpartum period are more characteristic of women from rural areas, which may be associated with difficulties in obtaining medical services in rural areas, which increases anxiety about their health and the health of the child. Women who have undergone natural childbirth are more likely to experience depression and anxiety in the postpartum period, which is due to their high personal responsibility and active participation in childbirth, as well as insufficient psychological preparation for childbirth. Women with planned cesarean section are characterized by the lowest level of anxiety-depressive symptoms.

2. Rural women have higher rates of hypogestognosic type of attitude to pregnancy, urban women have higher rates of depressive type of attitude to pregnancy.

3. Anxious and depressive type of attitude to pregnancy, associated with fears, expressed fears, tearfulness are risk factors for the development of anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period. The optimal type of attitude to pregnancy is most favorable for the emotional well-being of women in the postpartum period

The study shows qualitative differences in anxiety-depressive symptoms in women due to the presence of the use of maternity care and the type of residence. Differences in the types of attitudes to pregnancy in women with different types of residence were revealed. The interrelationships of anxiety and depression with the type of attitude to pregnancy in women in the postpartum period are analyzed.

The results of the study demonstrate that the type of attitude to pregnancy is a risk factor for the development of anxiety-depressive symptoms in the postpartum period.

Prospects for further research may be related to the study of differences in anxiety-depressive symptoms in women due to the presence of chronic diseases, complications in childbirth, the presence of children, characteristics of marital relations.

The results of this study may be useful for medical psychologists to organize a program of psychological support for pregnant women in terms of psychological education of women at the stage of pregnancy planning and preparation for childbirth. The results may also be interesting for obstetricians and gynecologists in choosing the optimal ways of interaction in the formation of perinatal compliance in childbirth.

References
1. Akhmadeeva, E.N., Enikeeva, Yu.D. (2012) Comparative assessment of the components of the life of maternity women in the postpartum period depending on the method of delivery. Women's health problems, 7 (4), 27-33.
2. Balashov, P.P., Kolesnikova, A.M., Mamysheva, N.L. (2014) Clinical features of anxiety disorders in pregnant women. Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry, 11, 20-23.
3. Galyautdinova, S.I., Kutusheva, R.R., Gumerova, R.B. (2016) Psychological readiness of pregnant women for parenthood. Russian Humanitarian Journal, 5 (2), 243-250.
4. Gardanova, Zh.R., Anisimova, K.A., Vasilyeva, A.V., etc. (2016) Anxiety-depressive disorders in pregnant women with arterial hypertension. Obstetrics and gynecology, 8, 54-59.
5. Garnizov, T., Hadzhideleva, D. (2015) Postpartum depression. Bulletin on Pedagogy and Psychology of Southern Siberia, 3, 58-69. 6.
6. Gorkova, I.A., Ryazanova, O.V., Alexandrovich, Yu.S. et al. (2017) Psychoprophylaxis of postpartum depression in women with different delivery options . Bulletin of the Udmurt University. Philosophy series. Psychology. Pedagogy, 28 (4),. 437-442.
7. Dobryakov, I.V. (2010) Perinatal psychology. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg
8. Emelyanova, D.I. (2014) Health-related quality of life and the level of anxiety and depression in women whose pregnancy occurs against the background of arterial hypertension (literature review). Vyatka Medical Bulletin, 2, 36-41.
9. Zolotova, I.A. (2021) Investigation of the features of the psychological component of the gestational dominant as an indicator of the formation of dysfunctional relationships in the "mother –child" system in women of various age categories. Bulletin of Kostroma State University. Series: Pedagogy. Psychology. Sociokinetics, 27 (2), 135-142.
10. Ivashinenko, D.M., Kultygina, S.V. (2011) Comprehensive assessment of the condition of women with postpartum depression. Bulletin of New Medical Technologies, 18 (3), 233-234.
11. Ignatko, I.V., Kinkulkina, M.A., Florova, V.S. [et al.] (2018) Postpartum depression: a new look at the problem. Questions of gynecology, obstetrics and perinatology, 17(1), 45-53.
12. Kedyarova, E. A., Rysyatova, M. S., Uvarova, M. Yu. (2018) Characterological features and types of attitude to pregnancy in young women. Izvestiya Irkutsk State University. Psychology series, 24, 45-57. doi: 10.26516/2304-1226.2018.24.45.
13. Kolchik, E.Yu., Ushakova, V.R. (2020) The specifics of the attitude to pregnancy of women with different family status The world of science. Pedagogy and psychology, 3, 1-10.
14. Korgozha, M.A. (2019) Dynamics of emotional states in women in the postpartum period: dis. ... candidate of medical Sciences. Saint Petersburg, 205.
15. Kornetov, N.A. (2015) Postpartum depression-the central problem of mental health protection of early motherhood. Bulletin of Siberian Medicine, 4 (6), 5-24.
16. Lanzbur, M.E., Krysanova, T.V., Solovieva, E.V. (2016) Psychological and psychosomatic disorders during pregnancy and childbirth: a review of modern foreign studies. Modern foreign psychology, 5 (2), . 78-87.
17. Makarova, M.A., Tikhonova, Yu.G., Avdeeva, T.I. et al. (2021) Postpartum depression – risk factors of development, clinical and therapeutic aspects (2021). Neurology, neuropsychiatry, psychosomatics, 13(4), 75-80.
18. Medvedev, D. A., Malysheva, D. S. (2017) The inner world of a pregnant woman at the age of early adulthood. News of Irkutsk State University. Series: Psychology, 22, 30-41.
19. Reznik, V.A., Kozyrko, E.V., Ryazanova, O.V., et al. (2018) Prevalence and laboratory markers of postpartum depression.Journal of Obstetrics and Women's Diseases, 67 (4), 19-29. doi: 10.17816/JOWD67419-29
20. Ryazanova, O.V. (2021) Influence of anesthesiological strategy during delivery on the development of postpartum depression: dis. ... doctor of medical sciences., St. Petersburg, 213.
21. Filippova, G.G. (2018) Psychology of motherhood. Moscow: Yurayt.
22. Di Florio, A, Putnam, K, Altemus, M, et al. (2017) The impact of education, country, race and ethnicity on the self-report of postpartum depression using the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale Psychol Med. 2017. 47(5). 787-799.
23. O'Hara, M.W., Swain, A.M. (1996) Rates and risk of postpartum depression-a meta-analysis Int Rev Psychiatry. 1996. 8. 37-54.
24. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Screening for perinatal depression (2018) ACOG committee opinion ¹ 757 Obstet Gynecol. 132. 208-212

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

This article is on a topic that, judging by the title of the work, should bring something new to the theoretical understanding of the problem of postpartum depression. The author correctly draws attention to the fact that the problem of studying anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period and the features of its relationship with the type of psychological component of the gestational dominant is currently becoming increasingly important and represents an important area of research located at the junction of medicine, perinatal and clinical psychology. Attention is drawn to the fact that postpartum depression is one of the most socially significant medical problems that significantly affects the health of the mother and many aspects of her life: the family as a whole, relatives and friends, and especially the child. All this is true and is well known. The article itself provides information from the literature on this topic. Therefore, the question arises about the relevance of the study. It seems that the author paid insufficient attention to substantiating the relevance of the study. It is necessary to finalize the introduction so that the relevance of the study of the declared subject is more convincing. We are talking about the subject of the study, which is defined by the author as the "psychological component of gestational dominance". Attention is drawn to the incorrectness of this formulation, it is incomprehensible in meaning. Therefore, the entire text is perceived out of connection with the most important component – the subject of the study. The purpose of the study is formulated in an understandable way and does not cause objections. However, it is advisable to simplify this formulation and link it to the subject of the study. So far, the formulation of the goal is presented very broadly and includes research tasks. Despite the fact that the formulation of scientific novelty is presented in a declarative form, one can agree with its content. It may be advisable to remove the word "for the first time" from it. But this is at the discretion of the author. As a methodological basis, the author notes the cultural and historical theory of human mental development by L.S. Vygotsky, the theoretical positions of G.G. Filippova regarding styles of experiencing pregnancy, the typology of the psychological component of the gestational dominant by I.V. Dobryakova. In this case, it is advisable to explain what the author means from the theory of L.S. Vygotosky. It is possible that for a methodological basis, only the typology of the psychological component of the gestational dominant of I.V. Dobryakova is quite sufficient. Otherwise, it is necessary to detail and specify both the theory of L.S. Vygotsky and the theory of G.G. Filippova. The style of presentation of the text is scientific and research. The author provides an analysis of literary data, the results of his own research, draws appropriate conclusions and draws conclusions. The structure of the work also corresponds to generally accepted ideas about the presentation of the material. The content of the article indicates a large amount of work done. The author used special techniques and examined 120 women, whose average age was 22.3 ±8.2 years. It is stated that methods of mathematical and statistical data processing were used: ANOVA one-factor analysis of variance, Student's T-test, Spearman correlation analysis. But the justification of statistical methods raises questions. An explanation is needed. The fact is that all tables and figures do not contain primary data on the methods used. They contain only statistical indicators. This is wrong in principle. Tables should contain statically processed primary data, and all necessary statistically significant values should be marked and an explanation should be provided for them. Currently, the tabular material is not readable. Further work is needed. In addition, the units of measurement are not indicated in the figures. But the methods chosen by the author for the study have units of measurement. The argumentation of the data obtained throughout the text boils down to, for example, statements such as: "Spearman's correlation analysis showed a positive relationship between the anxiety scale and the anxious type of the psychological component of the gestational dominant (r=0.421; p=0.01) and a negative relationship with the optimal type of the psychological component of the gestational dominant (r=-0.348; p=0.01)". All this may be true, but statements of this kind should be preceded by the presentation in the text of indicators of the anxiety scale and the alarming type of the psychological component of the gestational dominant in averaged units of measurement. For example, I would like to ask the author: in what units was the type of psychological component of the gestational dominant measured? After all, the data r=-0.348; p=0.01 are given. Which units of the anxiety scale were compared with which units of the anxiety type of the psychological component of the gestational dominant, which turned out to be r=-0.348, p=0.01? And so on throughout the text. In terms of scientific evidence, such remarks are very important and require clarity in order to avoid misconceptions in the interpretation of the data obtained. Moreover, in the conclusions, the author notes: "Low results on anxiety-depressive symptoms in women in the postpartum period during emergency caesarean section may also be associated with the suddenness of what is happening, a reassessment of values and a reorientation of the personality's focus on the health of themselves and their child." What are the low results for anxiety-depressive symptoms? Where in the text can I look at the low results? But this is written in the conclusions. To the author, the reviewer's comments may seem difficult to eliminate. But this is not the case at all. Moreover, even a minor revision of the text, taking into account the comments, will make it possible to present it for publication in an irresistible form. The material of this article is interesting in content, has not only theoretical, but also practical significance. The article itself, after finalizing the text, can be recommended for publication, since it is of interest to the reading audience and includes sources from different medical and psychological areas on the topic of the study, which indicates the interdisciplinary nature of the problem under study.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Review of the article "Anxiety-depressive symptoms in the context of the type of attitude towards pregnancy in women in the postpartum period" The subject of the study is anxiety-depressive symptoms of women in the postpartum period. The research methodology is based on traditional methods of psychological research. In the first part, methods of analysis, systematization and generalization of literary data are applied, a review of 24 literary sources is used, including convincing statistical data. All materials are relevant, related to the topic of the work, reveal cause-and-effect relationships. The empirical part of the study is presented quite extensively. The author compares the personality characteristics of the respondents, who were 120 women aged 22 to 30 years old, who were in the postpartum period from one to seven days after giving birth. It should be noted that such a number of subjects, given the specificity of the sample, is very worthy. Subgroups were identified among the subjects, taking into account the type of residence of women (city and village) and the availability of maternity care (natural childbirth, planned cesarean section, emergency cesarean section). The groups of subjects are representative from the point of view of the research topic, represented by a reasonable distribution in terms of age, place of residence, etc. The study used a questionnaire that revealed age, marital status, the presence of maternity care, type of residence, and also used various psychodiagnostic techniques: 1. Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale HADS (The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale Zigmond A.S., Snaith R.P.) is designed for the primary detection of depression and anxiety in general medical practice. 2. The test of the relationship of a pregnant woman – TOB(b) (Eidemiller E. G., Dobryakov I. V., Nikolskaya I. M.). Statistical methods of analysis are also used in the work: calculation of arithmetic averages, one-factor analysis of variance ANOVA, Student's T-criterion, Spearman's correlation analysis. The methods are well chosen taking into account the characteristics of the sample. The relevance of the presented article is beyond doubt. The interest in studying the personal characteristics of Zhenya in the postpartum period has always been increased. And in recent years, due to the increase in depressive cases, this interest requires detailed study. This is reflected in the practical activities of medical psychologists, who now regularly monitor such women and provide psychological assistance. It should be noted that a typical depressive episode is experienced by 10-15% of women around the world after the birth of a child. Therefore, the stated topic is more than relevant at a time of increasing uncertainty in the world around us. Scientific novelty is manifested in the fact that the authors consider a specific hypothesis, work on which can provide a lot of valuable applied information to ensure the psychological well–being of women in labor. This is an assumption about the presence of differences in the types of attitudes towards pregnancy in women in the postpartum period, depending on the type of residence and use of maternity care and the presence of correlations of anxiety and depression with the type of attitude towards pregnancy in women in the postpartum period. The work was performed as an interdisciplinary study - at the junction of medicine, perinatal and clinical psychology Style, structure, content The article has a traditional structure – introductory, main and final parts. The introductory part justifies the choice of topic. It is important that the author accompanies the literature review with reasoned statistical data. The introductory part is characterized by a high level of elaboration. The fundamental research of domestic and foreign scientists is analyzed, and their comprehensive review is made. The main part of the article provides a detailed description of the organization of the study. The author presented a description of the sample, described in detail the organizational side of the study. The methodological part of the work is quite competently presented in the article. The results of the study are presented in a table with comparative intergroup data and interpreted in detail. The graphs clearly reflect the identified dependencies. In conclusion, the author draws competent and reasoned conclusions. They are structured taking into account the peculiarities of anxiety symptoms in connection with the type of residence, the type of maternity care. The style of presentation of the material meets the requirements of science, but at the same time it is quite accessible to perception. The bibliography includes 24 sources, including editions in English. They are dated from different periods, including 2019-21. The list of references, in fact, is an exhaustive list on the stated topic. It is designed without violations. Appeal to opponents – the article can be recommended for publication. It contains the author's position, a competent review of the literature and qualitative empirical research. As a comment, one can only make a recommendation to change the name "type of residence" to "place of residence", but this does not detract from the merits and value of the presented work. Conclusions, the interest of the readership – the article will arouse the interest of the readership – psychologists and psychodiagnostics, educators, psychotherapists, medical and clinical psychologists.