Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Law and Politics
Reference:

Kochetkov V.V. Comparative analysis of the key laws of the Russian Empire of 1906 and the Constitution of the Russian Federation of 1993: on the history of constitutionalization of the Russian government

Abstract: This article analyzes the original goals and results of the two attempts of constitutionalization of Russia undertaken in 1906 and 1993. Based on these fundamental laws and legal doctrine of the corresponding period, the author demonstrates that the reception of certain constitutional institutions did not result in implementation of constitutional values and principles into the fabric of the state and public life. In author’s opinion, the cause for this lies in the fact that the architypes of Russian authority – the autocracy of the head of state and distinction between the executive and subordinate administration – do not allow to constitutionalize it, which results in only an ostensible constitutionalism. The scientific novelty of this research is the very statement of the question of architypes of Russian authority on the example of analysis of the constitutional texts from the various periods of Russian history. The author comes to the conclusion that in order for constitutionalization of the Russian authority to become possible, it is necessary (based on the axiological understanding of constitutionalism proposed by the author) to overcome its architypes and sequentially implement constitutional values into the Russian state law.


Keywords:

reception, Constitution of the Russian Federation, Fundamental laws of the Russian Empire, archetype of power, legal consciousness, constitutionalization, human rights, freedom, seperation of powers, constitional values


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Kommentariy k Konstitutsii RF. /Pod red. V.D.Zor'kina, L.V.Lazareva. M.: Eksmo, 2009. S.679.
2. Kutafin O.E. Rossiyskiy konstitutsionalizm. M.: Norma, 2008. S.7.
3. Zakharov N.A. Sistema russkoy gosudarstvennoy vlasti: yuridicheskoe issledovanie. Novocherkassk: Tipografiya F. Tunikova, 1912. S.303.
4. Guchkov A.I. Rechi po voprosam gosudarstvennoy oborony i ob obshchey politike. 1908-1917. Pg., 1917. S. 18.
5. Lapaeva V.V. Tipy pravoponimaniya: pravovaya teoriya i praktika. M.: Rossiyskaya akademiya pravosudiya, 2012. S. 13.
6. Korkunov N.M. Ukaz i zakon. SPb.: B.I., 1894. S. 257.
7. Zakharov N.A. Sistema russkoy gosudarstvennoy vlasti: yuridicheskoe issledovanie. Novocherkassk: Tipografiya F. Tunikova, 1912. S.279-280.
8. Zakharov N.A. Sistema russkoy gosudarstvennoy vlasti: yuridicheskoe issledovanie. Novocherkassk: Tipografiya F. Tunikova, 1912. S.286.
9. Zakharov N.A. Sistema russkoy gosudarstvennoy vlasti: yuridicheskoe issledovanie. Novocherkassk: Tipografiya F. Tunikova, 1912. S.122.
10. Kazanskiy P.E. Vlast' Vserossiyskogo Imperatora. M.: Izdatel'stvo «FondIV», 2007. S.47.
11. Korkunov N.M. Russkoe gosudarstvennoe pravo. T. II. SPb., 1909. S. 7.
12. Gessen V.M. Osnovy konstitutsionnogo prava. M.: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN), 2010. S. 72.
13. Korf S.A. Russkoe gosudarstvennoe pravo. Chast' I. SPb., 1915. S. 49-50.
14. Kistyakovskiy B.A. V zashchitu prava. (Intelligentsiya i pravosoznanie)// Vekhi; Intelligentsiya v Rossii: Sb. st. 1909-1910. M.: Molodaya gvardiya, 1991. S.113.
15. Zakharov N.A. Sistema russkoy gosudarstvennoy vlasti: yuridicheskoe issledovanie. Novocherkassk: Tipografiya F. Tunikova, 1912. S.115.
16. Zakharov N.A. Sistema russkoy gosudarstvennoy vlasti: yuridicheskoe issledovanie. Novocherkassk: Tipografiya F. Tunikova, 1912. S.176-177.