Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Psychologist
Reference:

Development of Strategic Competence Among Sales Managers

Surenskaya Nataliya Sergeevna

ORCID: 0000-0001-6116-1885

PhD student, Department of Social and Age Psychology, Tambov State University named after G.R. Derzhavin

392000, Russia, Tambov region, Tambov, Sovetskaya str., 181, room 9

surenskaya2018@gmail.com

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8701.2023.2.39452

EDN:

UBRSBD

Received:

19-12-2022


Published:

04-05-2023


Abstract: In recent years, researchers in the field of psychology and related sciences have highlighted a new direction in the professional activity of sales managers – strategic sales management. Such activity is associated with building long–term partnerships between organizations and requires new skills from specialists involved in customer support - strategic competence. These studies are especially relevant for organizations whose activities are aimed at sales in the field of B2B. The subject of the research in this article is the content structure of strategic competence based on the analysis of existing literature, as well as methods of its formation and development. The article presents a meaningful analysis of the competencies included in the structure of strategic competence and suggests the structure of such competence, consisting of the following components: strategic communication, including strong skills of building long-term and trusting constructive relationships; strategic management, implying developed skills of "going beyond" the area of their direct responsibility, strategic thinking, including the use of the practice of creative ways to solve problems, strategic identification, implying understanding and acceptance of his new role as a specialist building a long-term strategy of interaction with clients. The paper presents the results of the approbation of the strategic competence development program for sales managers.


Keywords:

strategic competence, sales managers, professional development, professional success, development programs, sales methods, professional psychology, professional realisation, communication activities, psychology of professions

This article is automatically translated.

The competencies of sales managers are one of the most relevant areas of research in psychological science [1]. So, A.M. Stoyakin considers tools to increase the productivity of sales specialists from the organizational side, A.V. Dmitrieva studies the personal prerequisites for the successful activity of a sales manager [2]. E.A. Sycheva evaluates the effectiveness of sales managers [3].

At the same time, a number of foreign authors provide data on the need for a more accurate description of the professional competencies of sales managers, since companies are gradually moving from "short" sales focused on mass sales to disparate customers to "long" sales focused on serving the interests of one client [4]. As Sylvie Lacoste notes, specialists in these positions are moving from simple sales to strategic sales management [5].

Literature reviewResearchers in the field of strategic sales management note the need to build successful communication for sales professionals.

For example, J. Pine, D. Peppers and M. Rogers [6] argue that customer service specialists are a kind of "gateway" through which communication between customers and the entire enterprise is built. Mario Vafeas also suggests that communication and negotiation skills are key to building long-term sales [7]. The skills of building long-term trusting relationships with the client are also highlighted by B. Murta, G. Shalagalla and A. Koli, who separately note the ability to foresee future interaction for building long-term strategic relationships with the client [8].

Researchers of managers' competencies in the field of strategic sales separately highlight the need for such specialists to develop management skills and leadership qualities. It is noted [9] that such managers should be able to create a team and form common goals for its members, as well as manage such a team, that is, go beyond their position and perform coordination functions between the divisions of the organization [10]. Since at high levels of responsibility, sales professionals are forced to coordinate the external requirements of customers with the internal resources of the organization, such behavior is M. Steward, J. Wu and J. Hartley is described as having entrepreneurial abilities or an entrepreneurial position [11]. The presence of such a position allows managers to more actively manage the recruitment and execution of the order, flexibly manage the resources of organizations and offer customers more flexible terms within the order.

To. Storbaka (2012) [12] notes that accepting a client's position requires a manager to have strong abilities to build relationships. Such abilities include, in addition to information exchange, conflict resolution. Thus, flexible conflict resolution is one of the important professional requirements for sales managers.

J. Speakman and L. Rials [13], in addition, note separately the skills of managers in building intra-organizational relationships with other services and divisions of the organization and extracting maximum benefit from these relationships. Such skills are also called "internal" sales skills.

Speaking about the personal component of the sales manager's work, S. Lacoste also points out the need for sales managers to form an identity of themselves as a strategically competent specialist. The formation of such an identity is a condition for the further development of their professional competencies [5].

Thus, strategic sales management is a new competence for sales managers, which includes a number of professionally important qualities. We have previously shown that strategic competence stands out as a separate factor among other competencies in successful sales managers who hold key positions in their organizations [14].

The analysis presented above allowed us to expand the strategic competence "in depth" and present the key competencies that make up it in the form of the following groups (Fig. 1).

Strategic communication. Represents solid skills of building long-term and trusting constructive relationships

Strategic management. It includes the developed skills of "going out" beyond the area of their immediate responsibility, organizing the work of other people to the extent necessary for the successful execution of the order, an entrepreneurial vision

Strategic thinking. It includes the practical application of methods of creative problem solving, in-depth analysis of the causes of conflicts and foreseeing problematic situations.

Strategic identification. It implies understanding and acceptance of his new role as a specialist building a long-term strategy of interaction, emotional responsiveness and competence in working with clients.

 

 

Figure 1. Psychological structure of the stages of formation of Strategic competence of a sales manager

 

Since strategic competence affects the success of a sales manager, we have additionally formulated criteria for the development of strategic competence components (Table 1).

 

Table 1.

 

Criteria for the development of strategic competence of sales managers.

 

Strategic competence componentCriterion of development

Strategic communication

- strong skills in building long-term and trusting constructive relationships

Strategic management

- developed skills of "going out" beyond the area of their immediate responsibility, to organize the work of other people to the extent necessary for the successful execution of the order, entrepreneurial vision

Strategic thinking

- practical application of methods of creative problem solving, in-depth analysis of the causes of conflicts and foresight of problematic situations

Strategic identification

- understanding and acceptance of his new role as a specialist building a long-term strategy of interaction, emotional responsiveness and competence in working with clients

 

The theoretical propositions formulated above were tested by us in the course of an empirical study.

Research procedureStudy participants.

To participate in the strategic competence research program, we formed a group of subjects aged 26 to 32 years, novice sales managers with 3 to 5 years of experience. The sample was randomly divided into experimental and control groups. The experimental group included subjects in the number of 27 people, in the control group in the number of 23 people.

Research methods: Diagnostics of interpersonal relationships (S. V. Dukhnovsky), Career anchors (Shane): Scales "Management", "Entrepreneurship", Analysis of one's limitations (Woodcock-Francis), scales: "Creative approach", "Problem Solving Skills", M. Davis Multifactorial Empathy questionnaire, questionnaire

To assess the validity of the theoretical propositions put forward, we have developed and tested a Program for the development of strategic competence. The program is designed for 6 months, during which the subjects in the experimental group developed strategic competence in training sessions in blocks in the following order: Strategic Communication ? Strategic Management?

Strategic thinking ? Strategic identification.

Thus, the meaning of building the program consisted in a gradual transition from communication skills to a creative rethinking of the situation, going beyond his immediate area of responsibility and as a result identifying himself as a specialist using strategic competencies in the course of his work.

To build a program for the development of strategic competence of specialists in the field of sales, we have developed a program. The competencies in this program are divided into four blocks, respectively, combined in meaning and in psychological content.

I Block "Strategic communication"

- negotiation skills

- skills of building trusting relationships

- long-term relationship

II Block "Strategic Management"

- management skills

- leadership

- entrepreneurial position

III Block "Strategic thinking"

- creative thinking

- conflict resolution

- building accurate knowledge about the client

IV Block "Strategic identification"

- identity of yourself as a specialist

- empathy

- emotional competence

It should be noted that strategic competence also includes skills common to sales managers. The proposed structure relates to the development of new skills aimed at performing more complex manager activities, which include finding and retaining more responsible customers for the company.

Research results and their discussionTo assess the effectiveness of the program in the experimental and control groups, we carried out measurements before and after the program.

Since the measured variables in the components of strategic competence did not have a normal distribution, the evaluation of the statistical significance of differences in the dynamics of indicators was carried out according to the Mann-Whitney U criterion.

The results of shifts in indicators of strategic competence components in the control and experimental groups are presented in Table 3.

Table 3.

The results of experimental work on the development of strategic competence of sales managers.

 

Strategic competence componentAverage values on the scales

Experimental group

(n=27)

Control group

(n=23)

Before the experiment

After the experiment

Before the experimentAfter the experiment

Strategic communication

14,7**

22,3**

13,2*

17,2*

Strategic management

19,2*

24,2*

18,7

21,2

Strategic thinking

9,2**

16,4**

10,1

10,9

Strategic identification

11,9*

16,5*

10,7

11,2

Note:*- differences are significant at the level of p?0.05; ** - differences are significant at the level of p?0.01.

 

Graphically, these results are presented in Figure 1.

As a result of experimental work on the development of strategic competence among sales managers, we received statistically significant shifts in Strategic communication, Strategic management, Strategic thinking, Strategic identification in the experimental group. This suggests that the program we developed turned out to be, on the whole, effective.

At the same time, the result in the control group is interesting, in which, regardless of our intervention, the results of the Strategic Communication component statistically significantly improved. This suggests that as a result of intensive professional activity, this component can develop as a result of gaining professional experience. However, other components of strategic competence do not develop independently in this situation.

Figure 3. Results of experimental work on the development of strategic competence among sales managers.

 

ConclusionThus, we have shown that the development of strategic competence in sales managers is possible in the course of experimental work.

At the same time, we have demonstrated that individual components of strategic competence can develop spontaneously during the performance of official duties. Nevertheless, the development of these competencies during the training seems to be more productive.

In addition, in this work we have not touched upon the issue of personnel selection for positions involving strategic sales management. However, it is assumed that strategic competence includes elements characteristic of the employee's personality as a whole (for example, empathy, leadership qualities). Thus, some employees may be better suited to perform strategic sales work.

We did not make a special selection to check the effectiveness of the program. However, the selection process for the selection of employees for the relevant positions may increase the effectiveness of training programs for them. The issue of diagnostics of strategic competence in order to select employees and develop specific tools for it may become the subject of additional research.

References
1. Stoyakin, A. M. Instrumenty povysheniya proizvoditel'nosti truda menedzherov po prodazham / A. M. Stoyakin // Upravlenie prodazhami. – 2018. – ¹ 4. – S. 276-281
2. Dmitrieva, A. V. Razlichiya emocional'nogo intellekta i uspeshnosti menedzherov pryamyh prodazh po polovomu priznaku / A. V. Dmitrieva // Molodoj uchenyj. – 2018. – ¹ 50(236). – S. 459-461
3. Sycheva, E. A. Sovremennoe sostoyanie i perspektivy razvitiya professii menedzher po prodazham / E. A. Sycheva // Obrazovanie i nauka bez granic: social'no-gumanitarnye nauki. – 2019. – ¹ 12. – S. 151-154.
4. Workman, J. P., Homburg C., Jensen O. Intraorganizational Determinants of Key Account Management Effectiveness. // Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science. – 2003. – 31 (1) P. 3–21. doi:10.1177/0092070302238599.
5. Lacoste S. From selling to managing strategic customers competency analysis // Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management. 2018. 38(1). P. 92-122 DOI: 10.1080/08853134.2018.1426991
6. Pine, B. Joseph, Don Peppers, and Martha Rogers. 1995. «Do You Want to Keep Your Customers Forever?» Harvard Business Review 73 (2):103–114
7. Vafeas, Mario. 2015. «Account Manager Turnover and the Influence of Context: An Exploratory Study.» Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing 30 (1):72–82. doi:10.1108/ JBIM-04-2012-0064
8. Murtha, Brian R., Goutam Challagalla, and Ajay K. Kohli. 2011. «The Threat from Within: Account Managers’ Concern About Opportunism by Their Own Team Members.» Management Science 57 (9):1580–1593. doi:10.1287/ mnsc.1100.1298.
9. Tzempelikos, Nektarios, and Spiros Gounaris. 2015. «Linking Key Account Management Practices to Performance Outcomes.» Industrial Marketing Management 45:22–34. doi:10.1016/j.indmarman.2015.02.018.
10. Jasalo, Jukka. 2001. «Key Account Management at Company and Individual Levels in Business-to-Business Relationships.» The Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing 16 (3):199–321. doi:10.1108/08858620110389803
11. Steward, Michelle D., Zhaohui Wu, and Janet L. Hartley. 2010. «Exploring Supply Managers’ Intrapreneurial Ability and Relationship Quality.» Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing 17 (2):127–148. doi:10.1080/10517120903407857
12. Storbacka, Kaj. 2012. «Strategic Account Management Pro-grams: Alignment of Design Elements and Management Practices.» Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing 27 (4):259–274. doi:10.1108/08858621211221643.
13. Speakman, James I. F., and Lynette Ryals. 2012. «Key Account Management: The Inside Selling Job.» Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing 27 (5):360–369. doi:10.1108/ 08858621211236034
14. Surenskaya, N. S. Empiricheskij analiz soderzhaniya psihologicheskih kompetencij menedzherov po aktivnym prodazham / N. S. Surenskaya, A. G. Ilyuhin // Vestnik Mininskogo universiteta. – 2021. – T. 9. – ¹ 4(37). – DOI 10.26795/2307-1281-2021-9-4-

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The work "Formation of strategic competence among sales managers" is presented for review. The subject of the study. The author considers the formation of strategic competence among sales managers as a subject of research. The subject is formulated correctly, affecting a certain level for conducting research. Research methodology. The author pays considerable attention to the description of the theoretical and methodological foundations that were the basis for the experimental study. As a result, the author defined the following criteria for the strategic competence of sales managers: strong skills in building long-term and trusting constructive relationships; developed skills to "go beyond" their immediate responsibility, organize the work of other people to the extent necessary for successful order fulfillment, entrepreneurial vision; practical application of creative solutions problems, in-depth analysis of the causes of conflicts and foresight of problematic situations; understanding and accepting his new role as a specialist building a long-term strategy of interaction, emotional responsiveness and competence in working with clients. The formulated provisions were tested in the course of experimental work and confirmed their effectiveness. Relevance. The relevance of the problem is considered from different perspectives and the need to form the competence of sales managers. On the one hand, they are determined by socio-economic conditions. On the other hand, there is an insufficient level of development of modern scientific research. Scientific novelty. The conducted research is relevant both from a theoretical and practical point of view. It showed that individual components of strategic competence can develop spontaneously during the performance of official duties. Nevertheless, the development of these competencies during the training seems to be more productive. Style, structure, content. The style of presentation corresponds to publications of this level. The language of the presentation is scientific. The structure of the work is clearly visible. The relevance is presented in a short introduction. The review of the literature presents the main provisions that were the basis of the theoretical study. The section "Research procedure" contains a description of the sample, the research methodology, as well as programs for the development of strategic competence. The section "Research results" contains a discussion of the results obtained, which were subjected to quantitative and qualitative analysis. The results are presented in graphs and tables. At the same time, the results of the control diagnosis are presented, which indicate the effectiveness of the adapted program. Bibliography. The bibliography of the article includes 14 domestic and foreign sources, a small part of which has been published in the last three years. The problems of the work correspond to the subject of the article. The bibliography contains research articles. The literature sources are designed uniformly, there are no deviations from the requirement. In general, the bibliographic list is designed correctly, the requirements in almost all positions have been taken into account. Appeal to opponents. In the scientific work, it is recommended to propose methodological recommendations for the implementation of the concept developed by the author, as well as to describe in more detail its main provisions. Conclusions. The article is distinguished by its undoubted relevance, theoretical and practical value, and will be of interest to the scientific community. The work may be recommended for publication.