Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Psychologist
Reference:

Lucid Dreaming Experience in the Context of Meditation Experience

Kukharenko Sergei Vladimirovich

ORCID: 0000-0002-0561-4912

PhD in Philosophy

Head of Educational department,Confucius Institute, Blagoveshchensk State Pedagogical University

675004, Russia, Amur region, Blagoveshchensk, Lenin str., 104, office. 200 a

kukharenko_s@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8701.2022.5.38945

EDN:

IPKKZE

Received:

14-10-2022


Published:

06-11-2022


Abstract: The subject of this study is to identify the connection between the experience obtained in lucid dreams and the experience of meditation. The object of the study is the experience that accompanies the state of awareness (Pali-sati). In the article, the author presents the results of a study aimed at establishing the connection between the experience obtained in lucid dreams and the experience of meditation. The works of the lucid dream researchers Stephen LaBerge, Jayne Gackenbach, Ursula Voss, Robert Waggoner, Tadas Stumbrys and others, as well as the work of researchers of the state of awareness - Bhikkhu Analayo, Henepola Gunaratana, Alan Wallace and others served as the theoretical and methodological basis of the study. The following research methods were used: the theoretical analysis of scientific literature, the analysis and generalization of empirical data, the formulation of conclusions. The theoretical significance and scientific novelty of the study lies in the systematization of theoretical provisions on the problem of the study of lucid dreams; discovering the features of the relationship of experience gained in lucid dreams with the experience obtained during meditation. The practical significance of the study lies in the fact that the results and conclusions of the study can be used by psychologists in their professional activities, as well as by lucid dreaming practitioners. The main conclusions of scientific research is the discovery of the similarity of experiences during lucid dreams with the experience gained in the state of meditation. The results of the survey conducted by the author show that a significant part of respondents who practice lucid dreaming also practice mindfulness meditation.


Keywords:

lucid dreaming, meditation, djhanas, awareness, sati, mindfulness, buddhism, samatha, vipassana, dream

This article is automatically translated.

 

Introduction

By "lucid dreams" we mean dreams in which the sleeper is aware that he is experiencing a dream, and is able to influence the course of sleep to one degree or another. In Western philosophical thought, mentions of this phenomenon can be found as early as the IV century BC. Aristotle in the treatise "On dreams" in "Parva Naturali" writes the following: "Sometimes, when a person is asleep, something in his consciousness allows him to understand that everything that is happening is just a dream" [6; C. 624]. In Tibetan Buddhism, dream yoga, the goal of which is to achieve awareness in a dream state, has been practiced for centuries. In the alchemical tradition of Taoism, there is also the practice of controlled dreams [5]. In the Hindu tradition, yoga nidra practitioners have also developed practical ways to become aware in a dream.

The term "lucid dreaming" was coined by the Dutch psychiatrist Frederik Van Eeden in his 1913 article "The Study of Dreams" [12]. One of the reasons why traditional science did not show much interest in lucid dreaming was the interest of parapsychologists in this phenomenon, which in the eyes of academic scientists put the phenomenon on a par with ghosts and flying saucers [3; C.69].

 The real interest in the topic of the academic community was aroused by the work of Stanford University Professor Stephen Laberge in the 80-90s of the XX century, in which he proved the reality of the phenomenon of lucid dreams experimentally.

 In the XXI century, the practice of lucid dreaming has become a really popular movement in the West, largely removed from any specific religious and philosophical ideas [18]. Today, lucid dream practitioners may be motivated to simply experience unusual sensations, have fun. Often, as a motivation to experience lucid dreams, respondents indicate the possibility of having sex in this state with a complete imitation of real sensations [26], which, of course, would be difficult to imagine if the practice of lucid dreaming remained accessible only to religious practitioners. The experience of experiencing lucid dreams at the initial stage is primarily an interesting and exciting entertainment [5, p. 300].

Thomas Snyder in his study "Individual differences associated with lucid dreams" [25] concluded that 57.5% of the population had lucid dreams at least once in their lives.

 

The Nature of Lucid Dreaming

A number of researchers of the phenomenon of lucid dreams tend to compare lucid dreaming with a waking state that combines the cognitive elements of waking consciousness with the hallucinatory quality of dreaming [28], representing a unique combination of waking consciousness and dreaming.

However, at the same time, many researchers note the fact that the quality of perception during lucid sleep may actually be higher than in the normal waking state [15]. The descriptions of the lucid dream experience often note a higher degree of awareness in a lucid dream than in a normal waking state: "I have never experienced such clarity and perception" [20; C. 1-2], "I have never felt so good, with such a clear consciousness, with such an inexpressibly "free"" [14; C. 32-33].

There is also a hypothesis that some types of lucid dreams can be considered as a type of spontaneous meditative state that occurs during dreams [17]. It is believed that some of the skills developed in the practice of meditation, including the stability of attention and the ability to track your current state, are useful for experiencing lucid dreams [5]. Mindfulness meditation training can improve cognitive skills such as attention [21] and metacognitive abilities [8]. Recent studies have confirmed that people who have been meditating for an extended period of time are more likely to have lucid dreams compared to people who have no experience of meditation. These studies also confirm the link between increased awareness during wakefulness and during sleep [9].

If we look at this phenomenon of lucid dreaming from the point of view of the concept of mindfulness, lucid dreaming is the meta—awareness of the stream of consciousness in the dream state. The difference, therefore, is only that the stream of consciousness in the rem sleep phase is built into a bizarre plot and an abundance of visual images and other sound, tactile, olfactory and other vivid experiences. During wakefulness, this is usually an internal monologue, emotional reactions and sensations received by the senses.

 In this context, the comparison of lucid dreaming experience with meditative experience is of considerable interest. 

The connection between meditative experience and lucid dreaming experience

         Different schools of meditation combine two common components, which in the terminology of Buddhist psycho-culture are described as: samatha, which can be translated from Pali as "serenity", "peace", "inner peace" and vipassana, from Pali can be translated as "awareness", "seeing the world as it is".  These components are certainly also necessary for the successful practice of lucid dreaming.

From April 22, 2022 to May 12, 2022, 116 respondents practicing lucid dreaming were interviewed. The respondents were from the USA, Mexico, Great Britain, Sweden, South Africa, Denmark, the Netherlands, Romania, France and Brazil. To the question "Do you practice any mindfulness meditation techniques on a regular basis?" 64% of respondents answered positively, 36% - negatively.

The results of surveys of lucid dream practitioners show that most of them (77%) felt a greater degree of awareness in a lucid dream than in a normal waking state [18; p. 11].

Mindfulness is the practice of purposefully drawing attention to the present moment without evaluation [7]. The Buddhist term translates as "mindfulness, mindfulness" and comes from the Pali term "sati", which is identical to the Sanskrit "smriti". Both terms mean "remember." In the Satipathana Sutta, the term "sati" means to maintain awareness of reality, so that one can see the true nature of phenomena [24]. One of the leading experts in this field, Bhikkhu Analayo translates "sati" as "mindfulness" or "awareness", and satipathana as "the presence of mindfulness" [1; pp. 28-29). Bhikkhu Analayo points out that through pure "sati" a person is able to see things as they are, not distorted by habitual reactions and projections. Bringing the process of perception into the full light of awareness, a person begins to realize automatic and habitual reactions to these perceptions. [1; C. 58].

As for peace of mind, the practice of maintaining awareness in dreams is precisely related to not being involved in the plot of a dream. Strong emotions or fascination with the plot lead to a loss of awareness.

The most common unusual experiences during lucid dreaming that are not typical of the normal waking state, which are often experienced by lucid dream practitioners, include an intense sense of presence, a desire to fly, a desire to control, a strong sense of joy and euphoria [29].

Here are just a few examples. "I have never experienced such clarity and perception" [20; C. 1-2], "I have never felt so absolutely good, so clearly, so inexpressibly "free"" [14; C. 32-33]. "I" seems to be a point of conscious perception floating through all this — joyful, conscious and full of awe" [29; C. 7]. "I felt a surge of cheerfulness, joy and energy", "I felt euphoria" [29; C. 9] "I walk a few feet, but I feel an incredible desire to fly — I want to fly!" [29; C. 7]. "But I control sleep! I'm flying. I make things appear. I dream that the figures disappear, and they disappear. I really control lucid dreaming!" [29; C. 23-24].

The research question is whether the modern practice of lucid dreaming is a separate phenomenon that has some characteristics in common with the meditative experience.

In the Buddhist tradition, the next step after gaining sati (awareness of awareness) is to detach one's awareness from "mechanical impulses" in order to make it pure awareness, and the ultimate goal is primordial awareness [19].

The sphere that opens with awareness is not limited to the absence of identification with one's thoughts, it is something more. It is through this window of consciousness awareness that joy, peace and love come [27].

Eckhart Tolle in his book "The Power of the Present", although not calling it "awareness", actually describes the same process with a deep understanding of the practice as follows: "you distract consciousness from the activity of the mind and create a gap of no-mind in which you are very alert and aware, but do not think. This is the essence of meditation [27; C. 18].

The same properties following the establishment of mindfulness can be found in the description of the experience of being in the initial jhanas of Theraveddian Buddhist meditation. The feeling of joy, sukha [30]. Much attention is paid to the feeling of "joy" in the Sufi tradition: "Freshness and deep joy are signs of a current." [13; C.54]. "I broke through another layer of joy" [13; C. 134].

We can assume that the euphoria of lucid dreams may be related to Piti na pali (Sanskrit: Preeti), a mental factor associated with the development of jhana (Sanskrit: dhyana) in Buddhist meditation. According to Buddhadasa Bhikkhu, piti is a stimulating, stimulating and energizing quality [10; C. 69]. Piti is defined as "cheerfulness, joy, fun, pleasant excitement, exultation and contentment of the mind", this state is attributed to the possession of delight and spiritual uplift [2; p. 61]

 It is interesting to note that the sensation of lifting the body above the ground is also referred to in the jhanas as uplifting delight (ubbega piti) as one of the 5 forms of delight [16; C. 182-183].

The desire of lucid dreamers to control the dream plot and actively behave in a higher state of consciousness may be related to the cultural preferences of modern lucid dreamers [18; C. 14]. It is worth noting that this desire may well be more characteristic of novice lucid dreamers, who later realize that they can control the focus of their attention rather than the entire plot of the dream [29; pp. 22-23].

 

Conclusions

Lucid dreaming is different from simple awareness in a dream state, it is certainly something more than waking up in a dream. Most lucid dreamers experience in lucid dreams a more intense sense of presence, peace, joy, euphoria. This experience is similar to the states experienced in meditation, which is described, among other things, in the sutras of the Pali canon when describing jhanas, as well as in the works of modern spiritual teachers, for example, Eckhart Tolle. A significant proportion of respondents who practice lucid dreaming practice mindfulness meditation.

References
1. Analayo, Bhikkhu. Perspectives on Satipatthana. [translated from English by D. Ustiantsev]. – Ìoscow: Ganga, 2018 – 416 p.
2. Gunaratana, Henepola. The Jhanas in Theravada Buddhist Meditation. [translated from English by D. Ustiantsev]. – Moscow: Ganga/Svatan, 2020 – 160 p.
3. LaBerge, Stephen. Lucid Dreaming: A Concise Guide to Awakening in Your Dreams and in Your Life / Translated from English. – Ìoscow: Sophia Press, 2011. – 320 p.
4. Maslov A. A. The Practice of “Controlled Dreams” in the Alchemical Tradition of Taoism. Vestnik NSU. Series: History and Philology, 2021, vol. 20, no. 10: Oriental Studies, pp. 9–23. (in Russ.) DOI 10.25205/1818-7919-2021-20-10-9-23
5. Wallace, Alan. Dreaming Yourself Awake: Lucid Dreaming and Tibetan Dream Yoga for Insight and Transformation. [translated from English by À. Muskin]. – Ìoscow: Ganga, 2016 – 400 p.
6. Analayo, Bhikkhu. (2006). Satipatthana: The Direct Path to Realization. Selangor: Buddhist Wisdom Centre. https://ahandfulofleaves.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/satipatthana_ direct-path_analayo_free-distribution-copy2.pdf. 6. Aristotle. (1941). On Dreams, in: McKeon R (Ed.), The basic works of Aristotle. Random House, New York, NY, pp. 618–625.
7. Baer, Ruth A. (2003). "Mindfulness Training as a Clinical Intervention: A Conceptual and Empirical Review" (PDF). Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice. 10 (2): 125–143. doi:10.1093/clipsy.bpg015
8. Baird B, Mrazek MD, Phillips DT, & Schooler JW. (2014). Domain-specific enhancement of metacognitive ability following meditation training. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 143(5), 1972–1979
9. Baird, Benjamin et al. “Increased lucid dream frequency in long-term meditators but not following MBSR training.” Psychology of consciousness (Washington, D.C.) vol. 6,1 (2019): 40-54. doi:10.1037/cns0000176
10. Buddhadasa Bhikkhu (Author), Santikaro Bhikkhu (Translator). (1988). Mindfulness With Breathing : A Manual for Serious Beginners.
11. Cai, D. J., Mednick, S. A., Harrison, E. M., Kanady, J. C., and Mednick, S. C. (2009). REM, not incubation improves creativity by priming. PNAS 106, 10130–10134. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0900271106
12. Eeden, F. (1913). A study of dreams. Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research, 26, 431-461. (Reprinted in: R.L. Woods (Ed.)
13. Coleman Barks (1997). The Essential Rumi. Castle Books.
14. Fox, O. (1962). Astral projection. New Hyde Park, University Books, NY
15. Gackenbach, J.I. & LaBerge, S. (Eds.) (1988). Conscious mind, sleeping brain: Perspectives on lucid dreaming, N.Y.:Plenum.
16. Gethin. (1998). The foundations of Buddhism. Oxford University Press
17. Hunt HT, & Ogilvie RD. (1988). Lucid dreams in their natural series. In LaBerge S & Gackenbach J (Eds.), Conscious mind, sleeping brain (pp. 389–417). New York, NY: Plenum.
18. Kukharenko, S. (2017). The difference of modern lucid dreamers. International Journal of Dream Research, 10(1), 10–14. https://doi.org/10.11588/ijodr.2017.1.28491
19. Kukharenko, Sergei. (2020). "Hindu and Buddhist Views Proliferation Influence on Gurdjieff’s Teaching." The International Journal of Religion and Spirituality in Society 11 (1): 49-62. doi:10.18848/2154-8633/CGP/v11i01/49-62.
20. LaBerge, S. & Rheingold, H. (1990). Exploring the World of Lu-cid Dreaming. Ballantine Books, NY.
21. Lutz A, Slagter HA, Rawlings NB, Francis AD, Greischar LL, & Davidson RJ. (2009). Mental training enhances attentional stability: Neural and behavioral evidence. The Journal of Neuroscience, 29(42), 13418–13427
22. Mendis, N. K. G. (1985). The Abhidhamma in Practice. Kandy, Sri Lanka : Buddhist Publication Society.
23. Nisbet, Matthew (2017). "The Mindfulness Movement: How a Buddhist Practice Evolved into a Scientific Approach to Life". Skeptical Inquirer. 41 (3): 24–26
24. Sharf, Robert. (2014). “Mindfulness and Mindlessness in Early Chan.” Philosophy East and West 64 (4): 933–964. https://www.jstor.org/stable/43285932.
25. Snyder, T.J., Gackenbach, J. (1988). Individual Differences Associated with Lucid Dreaming. In: Gackenbach, J., LaBerge, S. (eds) Conscious Mind, Sleeping Brain. Springer, Boston, MA. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-0423-5_10
26. Stumbrys, Tadas, Erlacher, Daniel, Johnson, Miriam, Schredl, Michael. The Phenomenology of Lucid Dreaming: An Online Survey. The American Journal of Psychology 1 January 2014; 127 (2): 191–204. doi: https://doi.org/10.5406/amerjpsyc.127.2.0191
27. Tolle, Eckhart. (2001).The Power of Now. Hodder Paperback.
28. Voss U, Holzmann R, Tuin I, Hobson JA. (2009). Lucid dreaming: a state of consciousness with features of both waking and non-lucid dreaming. Sleep. 2009 Sep;32(9):1191-200. doi: 10.1093/sleep/32.9.1191. PMID: 19750924; PMCID: PMC2737577.
29. Waggoner, R. (2009). Lucid Dreaming: A Gateway to the Inner Self. Moment Point Press.
30. Vetter, Tilmann (1988). The Ideas and Meditative Practices of Early Buddhism, BRILL

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the research in the presented article is lucid dreaming as a phenomenon of the human psyche and a special state of consciousness, different from both sleep and wakefulness. The author considers it advisable to draw a parallel with the state of meditative trance, into which a person enters through the efforts of his own will, in order to identify the specifics of this state. The research methodology consists in comparing the meditative state of consciousness and the state of lucid dreaming. The author uses methods of analogy and comparative analysis. Relevance. Research on human consciousness has recently received a new impetus due to the involvement of clinical research materials aimed at fixing the features of the human brain. Of particular interest in these studies are atypical states of consciousness, which can include the state of lucid dreaming. As the author correctly notes, lucid dreaming research is now at the very beginning and therefore any heuristic suggestions contribute to this area. The scientific novelty lies in the author's attempt to compare the state of lucid dreaming with the experience of meditation and highlight a number of common features in these states. Style, structure, content. The article is written in scientific language using basic terms of psychology, but it is unnecessarily overloaded with categories from the field of oriental meditative practices. The advantages of the article include conciseness of presentation. In the introduction, the author makes a brief digression into the history of the study of lucid dreams by academic science, but, unfortunately, does not give a clear definition of lucid dreaming. In the part "The nature of lucid dreams", a distinction is made between the state of sleep, wakefulness and lucid dreaming, the features that relate lucid dreaming to hallucinations are highlighted, in particular, brightness and emotional saturation. In the part "The connection between meditative experience and lucid dreaming experience", the author compares the description of people practicing lucid dreaming (based on Eckhart Tolle's research) with descriptions of the state of meditation, Eastern meditation practices, such as Buddhadasa Bhikkhu. The bibliography includes 30 sources, more than half of which belong to foreign aviators. The appeal to opponents is also present at the level of using the results of empirical research by other authors (for example, Eckhart Tolle) and in the form of solidarity with the conclusions and assessments of colleagues. Conclusions, the interest of the readership. The author comes to the conclusion about the relationship between the state of lucid dreaming and meditation. However, the author's problem of understanding lucid dreams is broader and the experience described in the article can be compared not only in the Eastern religious and mystical tradition, but also with the reflections of Western philosophers and psychoanalysts. Freud in his work "Interpretation of Dreams" distinguishes "night dreams", associating them with unrealized libidinal desires, emphasizing their independence from human consciousness. Continuing the research of this psychoanalyst, the German philosopher Ernst Bloch in his work "The Principle of Hope" writes about "daydreams" in which, privately and consciously, consciousness paints pictures of the desired, better world, "portraying itself as the future Self." The state of daydreams, according to Bloch, is characterized by passivity of a person, he seems to fall asleep, remaining conscious and directing his thought to the future. This psychological state is the basis of creativity and grows out of the sphere of the inner world of the Self, as a preconscious. The topic raised by the author is of interest not only to theoretical psychologists and practical psychologists, psychoanalysts and neurophysiologists (it would be interesting to touch on the topic of clinical data on the work of the brain in a state of lucid dreaming), but also philosophers, anthropologists, and educators. The philosophical component of the study of the phenomenon of lucid dreams, concerning the characteristics of the subject experiencing lucid dreaming, will expand the understanding of a person and his subjectivity. The article will be of interest both to specialists professionally engaged in the study of psychology and philosophy of human consciousness and to a wide range of readers interested in these issues at an amateur level.