Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Philosophy and Culture
Reference:

Dystopia, post-apocalypse and cinematic reading

Al-Mamori Yasir Khudeir Obid

Postgraduate student, Department of Cultural Studies and Design, Altai State University

656011, Russia, Altaiskii krai, g. Barnaul, ul. Chervonnya, 5

yasiral-mamori@yandex.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0757.2022.4.37808

Received:

06-04-2022


Published:

14-04-2022


Abstract: The subject of the study is the study of such a specific genre as dystopia, which is the dominant form of society in post-apocalyptic worlds. The object of the study is dystopia and post-apocalypse in cinema, as well as their features in modern realities. In the course of the research, special attention is paid to the study of the substantive essence of such definitions as "dystopia", "apocalypse" and "post-apocalypse". Special emphasis is placed on the fundamental difference and differences between apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic events. Special attention is also paid to the reasons and factors that cause the return of popularity of dystopian narratives to cinema. In addition, the social, political and philosophical orientation of the genre of dystopia is considered.      The main conclusions of the study are the conclusion that cinema, thanks to its dynamic audiovisual nature, allows dystopia to reveal its potential as an exciting and entertaining genre, while provoking the viewer to critical reflections and actions. The author's special contribution lies in the fact that during the analysis it was possible to substantiate the statement that the vision of dystopian cinema and, accordingly, the content of films varies depending on events occurring in a certain historical period of time, which allows us to depict various characteristics of the post-apocalyptic world. The scientific novelty of the research consists in conducting a discussion about the historical background of the terms "apocalypse", "post-apocalypse" and "dystopia" within the framework of the new millennium and the events that occurred and influenced the whole world and its perception of a possible end.


Keywords:

dystopia, cinema, post - apocalypse, the end of the world, society, perception, viewer, film, criticism, culture

This article is automatically translated.

Humanity has always dealt with the concept of death, apocalypse and extinction in its mythological or religious beliefs, as well as in eschatological studies. This fear of being destroyed has led people to create mythologies and fantasies about the existence of another world after death: a heavenly utopia that will fulfill all desires and provide all pleasures to people who deserve to be there. Regardless of how the apocalypse will happen, which will destroy people from the face of the Earth, according to the main religions, the outcome is simple: this world will perish along with all people, and after the Day of Judgment all the dead will rise and find their rightful place in the afterlife [1]. However, this image of the promised life after death has been distorted by thoughts of an apocalypse that will not destroy all life on Earth, on the contrary, there may be survivors who will live until death on a planet that is no longer hospitable. Based on such a strong dominant socio-cultural/religious background, a new vision of the end is created in literature, and then in cinema in the form of fictional entertainment [2]. This concept is based on three key concepts: dystopia, apocalypse and post-apocalypse.

Today, many films are devoted to the days that await humanity far ahead, telling about how life can develop in the near or distant future. These films can be glamorous space operas, joyful plays about the scientific possibilities of the future, narratives of encounters with slimy creatures or wise civilizations from outer space, as well as gloomy predictions of terrifying events and terrible regimes in a distant time that no one wants. The world can be saved, reformed, unchanged, doomed, destroyed, reborn, or whatever.

Cinematic dystopia is hardly a new genre, but recently there has been a curious increase in the number and popularity of such films. Cinema has long been attracted to science fiction and the task of visualizing the unimaginable. Nevertheless, the recent surge of dystopian and post-apocalyptic scenarios seems more relevant and extreme.

In this context, the study of the functions and features of dystopian cinema, the reasons for its popularity and cultural potential is of great scientific and practical importance, which determines the choice of the topic of this article, and also confirms its importance in modern scientific discourse.

Analyzing the scientific heritage available today, it is necessary to pay attention to the fact that the subject of fantastic cinema is extremely fragmentary and not systematically considered by domestic authors, as well as in the literature of the Soviet period.

Among the publications during the USSR period, it is advisable to highlight the general study of Western fantastic cinema "The Reality of the fantastic World" by Yu. Hanyutin, as well as the study of the theme of utopia in the culture of E. Batalov "In the world of Utopia: Five Dialogues about Utopia, Utopian Consciousness and Utopian experiments".

Today, the works of such authors as Odegova K.I., Shesterik O.V., Mayevskaya M.E., Addamms Mututa; Frame, Gregory; Milner, A.; Klonowska, Barbara; Swarnavel Eswaran Pillai are devoted to the study of dystopia as a literary and cinematic genre.

A description of the dystopian imagination can be found in the works of Mariano Paz, Isolina Ballesteros, L?cia Nagib, Daniele Fioretti, Douglas Kellner, Andrew Milner.

The postmodern perspective of dystopia and genre convergence in dystopian cinema are reflected in the works of Ingrid Lewis, Laura Canning, Carla Grosman, Austin, G.; Lyle, L.; Morrey, D.; Anne Wagner; Le Chaneg.

Positively assessing the contribution of these and other scientists to the development of the subject under consideration, it should be noted that in the context of modern structural and paradigm shifts in public life, a number of issues and problematic moments of dystopias in cinema require more detailed analysis and in-depth study.

So, questions concerning how post-apocalyptic films depict the dystopian side and what creates a social dystopian image need to be worked out separately. In addition, such a little-explored layer as criticism of dystopias and moralistic messages deserves special attention.

Thus, taking into account the above, the purpose of the article is to consider the reasons why dystopia and post-apocalypse in cinema have now acquired a new breath, as well as the facts contributing to the fact that dystopia has become an integral characteristic of the image of the world after the end of the world.

First of all, we note that the term "dystopia" has long entered the circle of scientific and everyday circulation, however, despite this, the very concept and phenomenon of dystopia is a phenomenon with a rather complex and debatable definition. The peculiarity of dystopia is its supra-genre, since dystopianism is a form of cognition and perception of the world, as well as a means of self-identification of the epoch [3].

Until recently, the concept of dystopia was explained only from the point of view of ideological instructions accepted in society [4]. Many scientists perceived dystopia as a genre that inextricably combined a large number of distinctive features: the display of the most pessimistic options for the development of the future, which have their origins in the present, criticism of some utopian images that have discovered their downside in the process of evolution and development [5].

Today, dystopia in film and television is a form of fiction in which an imaginary community or society is defined by what dehumanizes and scares it. Dystopia is the antonym of utopia, which is a perfect society [6]. The plot problems of dystopia define the following functions: reflexive – comprehension of historical reality and events of the past; cognitive – study of the laws of society and its system of values; prognostic – prediction of the probable future and warning against undesirable social trends.

The apocalypse in its religious origin is interpreted as an exposure, revelation of knowledge or something like a heavenly mystery that can be adapted to worldly realities [7]. But in the modern sense, it means a large-scale catastrophic event leading to the destruction and catastrophe of the world [8]. Based on this concept, it can be noted that the post-apocalypse is a state that occurs after a cataclysmic event, and marks the beginning of a new era. This creates a paradox in the idea of the apocalypse, which implies complete, absolute and final destruction.

The difference between apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic events lies in the chronological line: apocalyptic stories take place during the end of the world; post-apocalyptic stories are mainly about how people survive and live in a changed world.

The popularity of dystopian films increased significantly in the 70-80-ies of the twentieth century. On the one hand, this can be considered the result of a general increase in interest in fantastic cinema during this period and the improvement of the technical base of its production. On the other hand, this does not explain the departure from the depiction of the world of the future in science fiction films containing elements of utopian society, in particular in the American TV series "Star Trek" (1966-1969) or Soviet science fiction films of the 1950s and 1960s, as well as the increase in the total number of released cinematic dystopias, compared with 1920-1960. Therefore, it can be assumed that there were other factors that influenced the actualization of the dystopian genre in cinema.

One of the assumptions put forward by modern authors with appropriate argumentation is that such factors include the ideology of postmodernism, which has actively begun to dominate Western society since the late 1960s [9].

There is also an opinion that these films allow people to think about the harsh realities of the present moment, about conditions that are difficult to face face to face. Although the action of the films supposedly takes place in the future, the post-apocalyptic regime can serve as a window into the present and its criticism, as stated by Fredrik Jameson in his study of science and utopian fiction "Archaeology of the Future" [10].

According to the author, the social, political and philosophical orientation of the genre of dystopia, its fundamental socio-cultural functions determine its current relevance. Currently, dystopias are getting closer to the works of science fiction and post-apocalyptic, due to rapid technological development and its impact on humanity. According to its artistic characteristics, modern dystopia organically corresponds to the worldview of today's man, who is characterized by deep disappointment in the surrounding reality, the cult of personal freedom, a critical analysis of the achievements of the past and modernity in all areas of human existence.

Thus, the new millennium can undoubtedly be called the golden age of dystopian post-apocalyptic films. The number of dystopian post-apocalyptic films created in the XXI century until November 2018 is almost the same as for the entire XX century [11].

Let's focus in more detail on what exactly defines modern post-apocalyptic dystopias in cinema.

In general, dystopias are a reflection of the social problems and fears that prevail at the time of production. Combined with the post-apocalypse of today, they create an image of a terrible end in the future based on these fears. The increased fears of the new millennium include a new world war, viruses, aliens or artificial intelligence, natural disasters and environmental problems leading humanity to almost complete extinction.

Literally until recently, the cinema industry had many limitations in the production of such visual content that would be plausible enough, but the recent, accelerating progress in computer effects has become one of the reasons that there are more such films. However, such a huge jump in the number of films after the turn of the century also indicates a tense social and political situation.

In the new millennium, there was a terrorist attack in the United States, followed by two wars in the Middle East. Microbes (including viruses and bacteria) have become more complex than before because of their genetic mutations and their resistance to drugs. Moreover, it is possible to manipulate microorganisms to create weapons. Most scientists worry about the future of the world and what will happen due to climate change. As a result, the basis of dystopian, post-apocalyptic films are these scenarios, which represent a vision of the world in which at least one of these fears has come true, and humanity has lost almost everything. Here is a concrete example.

So, the consequences of climate change, the current indifference and inaction of humanity in the face of this fact is obviously what worries director Bong Joon Ho in the film "Snow Man" (Snowpiercer). The film is based on Jacques Lob's 1982 novel Le Transperceniege, which is strikingly prescient about climate change, albeit in the direction of the ice Age rather than global warming. In the movie "Bigfoot" frozen apocalypse Zh. Loba is transferred to our time, presenting it as an unintended side effect of human geoengineering. Chemicals released into the atmosphere to cool the warming planet are acting too well, turning the Earth into an uninhabitable snowball. The only survivors are the inhabitants of a fast-moving bullet train, a functionally closed ecosystem that circles the frozen Earth in a continuous loop, not daring to stop for fear of freezing.

"Bigfoot" does not depict the initial disaster directly. Like many films of this genre, he spends creative energy to present a social dystopia following the apocalypse.

Today we can see a "noticeable shift" in modern post-apocalyptic dystopian films from "imagining disaster to imagining survival." In the middle of the twentieth century, cinematographers were concerned about the spectacle of the apocalypse (as in the film "The Day when the End of the World Came"). But by the end of the century, films such as Mad Max 3: Beyond the Dome of Thunder placed a much greater emphasis on the struggle for survival in a post-apocalyptic dystopian society. Such films, according to some scientists, ultimately suggest a conservative return to patriarchal structures, a "return to the earth" and its moral values [12, 13].

Thus, today's post-apocalyptic film functions as an apotropee, a totem that drives away misfortune, restraining the catastrophe that it embodies. The hidden logic of the audience's attitude is this: if I have the freedom and technological resources to enjoy such a film, then I cannot live in the dystopia depicted in it.

Summing up the results of the study, the following conclusions can be drawn. Such an artistic form as cinema, thanks to its dynamic audiovisual nature, allows dystopia and post-apocalypse to reveal its potential as an exciting, entertaining genre, provoking at the same time an individual to critical reflections and actions. Despite the fact that cinematic dystopia is not a new genre, it continues to be relevant to this day. To start a dialogue, discussion, provoke critical reflection are the main tasks of films of this orientation today.

According to the author, the strongest feature of dystopian and post-apocalyptic narratives in cinema is manifested in the possibility of bringing society out of a state of apathy and indifference due to a powerful impulse of existential fear and the urge to see the world and oneself with new eyes, to feel real threats to existence and at the same time responsibility for the common future. This genre is ambiguous and contraversionary, but it is very necessary for modern society.

References
1. Frame, Gregory The odds are never in your favor: the form and function of American cinema's neoliberal dystopias // New review of film and television studies. 2019. Volume 17: Number 3; pp 379-397.
2. Milner, A. Darker cities: Urban dystopia and science fiction cinema // International journal of cultural studies. 2004. Vol 7; Numb 3, ðð 259-280.
3. Klonowska, Barbara On desire, failure and fear: Utopia and dystopia in contemporary cinema // New cinemas: journal of contemporary film. 2018. Volume 16: Number 1; pp 11-28.
4. Douglas Kellner Cinema wars: Hollywood film and politics in the Bush-Cheney era: Wiley-Blackwell, 2011. 296.
5. Espinoza Garrido, Felipe Reframing the post-apocalypse in Black British film: the dystopian Afrofuturism of Welcome II the Terrordome and Shank // Critical studies in media communication: CSMC: a publication of the National Communication Association. 2020. Volume 37: Number 4; pp 310-323.
6. Kránicz, Bence Humans no more: apocalypse and the post-socialist condition in Frozen May // Studies in Eastern European cinema. 2019. Volume 10: Issue 3; pp 257-271.
7. Dystopia: fantasy art, fiction and the movies / Dave Golder; foreword by Pat Mills. London: Flame Tree Publishing, 2015. 126 ð.
8. Halper, T.; Muzzio, D. Hobbes in the City: Urban Dystopias in American Movies // The journal of American culture / American Culture Association. 2007. Vol 30; Number 4; ðð 379-390.
9. Reston, Va.; Delgado, L. The Commercialization of Space in Science Fiction Movies: The Key to Sustainability or the Road to a Capitalist Dystopia? // American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics. 2010. Volume; ðð 638-649.
10. Frederic Jameson Archaeologies of the Future: The Desire Called Utopia and Other Science Fictions. London, Verso, 2005. 431 p.
11. Alita, battle angel: the official movie novelization / by Pat Cadigan. London: Titan Books, 2019. 329 p.
12. The postworld in-between utopia and dystopia: intersectional, feminist, and non-binary approaches in 21st century speculative culture / edited by Tomasz Fisiak, Katarzyna Ostalska. London: Routledge, 2021. 278 p.
13. Guynes, Sean Dystopia fatigue doesn't cut it, or, Blade Runner 2049's utopian longings // Science fiction film and television. 2020. Volume 13: Number 1; pp 143-148

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The author submitted his article "Dystopia, post-apocalypse and cinematic reading" to the journal "Philosophy and Culture", in which a study was conducted on the disclosure of the theme of the end of the world and the post-catastrophic development of events in world cinema. The author proceeds in studying this issue from the fact that the topic of death, the end of the world, global catastrophes has worried mankind since ancient times. That is why it has become a key issue for all world religions. The guardian before the end of the world and the irreversibility of death led to the creation of utopias, myths about the afterlife, and he also became a moral and socio-cultural determinant. The possibility of creating a spectacular video series based on apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic ideas and attracting viewers has led to interest in this topic from the world cinema. As the basis of this concept, the author uses three key concepts in his article: dystopia, apocalypse and post-apocalypse. The relevance of the research lies in the recent increasing attention to the topic of the variety of scenarios for the development of life in the near or distant future. The scientific novelty and at the same time the practical significance of the study is the study of the functions and features of dystopian cinema, the reasons for its popularity and cultural potential. Analyzing the scientific validity of the studied issues, the author draws attention to the fact that the subject of fantasy cinema is extremely fragmentary and not systematically considered by domestic authors, as well as in the literature of the Soviet period. The theoretical basis of the study was the works of domestic researchers of utopia as a socio-cultural phenomenon Y.M. Khanyutin, E.Ya. Batalov, as well as researchers of the phenomenon of dystopia I. Lewis, D. Kellner, A. Milner, etc. Assessing the contribution of scientists to the development of the subject under consideration, the author notes that in the context of modern structural and paradigm shifts in public life, a number of issues and problematic moments of dystopias in cinema require more detailed analysis and in-depth study. So, the issues concerning how post-apocalyptic films depict the dystopian side and what creates a social dystopian image need to be studied separately. In addition, such a little-explored layer as criticism of dystopias and moralistic messages deserves special attention. Empirical material was provided by the films of the post-apocalyptic genre "Bigfoot" "The Day the World Ended" and "Mad Max 3: Beyond the Dome of Thunder". The methodological basis of the study was an integrated approach containing a literature review, socio-cultural analysis, and analysis of artistic works. The purpose of the study is to analyze the reasons why dystopia and post-apocalypse in cinema have now acquired a new development, as well as the facts contributing to the fact that dystopia has become an integral characteristic of the image of the world after the end of the world. In the article, the author gives a detailed analysis of the phenomenon of dystopia, apocalypse, post-apocalypse: their essence functions, peculiarities of interpretation, the possibility of using expressive means for their spectacular display are revealed. The author states that in modern cinema, the concept of the apocalypse differs from its original religious content ("revelation") and acquires the meaning of "global catastrophe, the end of the world." Exploring the phenomenon of the popularity of dystopian films, the author identifies a number of socio-cultural reasons: on the one hand, it is an improvement in the quality of special effects, entertainment, and on the other, the position of postmodern ideology, namely deep disappointment in the surrounding reality, the cult of personal freedom, a critical analysis of the achievements of the past and modernity in all areas of human existence. In addition, the author notes that dystopias make people think about harsh realities, about possible negative ways of human development and ways to overcome them. They are a reflection of the social problems and fears that prevail in society during the production of such films. The author, using the example of some post-apocalyptic films, shows the relevance of the genre under study. Having conducted the research, the author presents conclusions on the studied materials, noting that cinema, thanks to its dynamic audiovisual nature, allows dystopia and post-apocalypse to unleash their potential as an exciting, entertaining genre, provoking at the same time an individual to critical reflections and actions, which manifests itself in the possibility of bringing society out of a state of apathy and indifference and feeling real threats to existence and at the same time responsibility for a common future. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing for analysis a topic, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of the possibilities of cinema in drawing attention to acute socio-cultural problems and their solution is of undoubted theoretical and practical cultural interest and can serve as a source of further research. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. An adequate choice of methodological base also contributes to this. The bibliographic list of the study consists of 13 foreign sources, which seems sufficient for the generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the subject under study. The author fulfilled his goal, received certain scientific results that allowed him to summarize the material. It should be noted that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication.