Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Man and Culture
Reference:

The idea of "Heaven and man are one" in ancient Chinese aesthetic thought and its positive meaning

Li Xiaomei

PhD in Art History

Postgraduate student, Department of Semiotics and General Theory of Art, Lomonosov Moscow State University

119991, Russia, Moskvskii oblast', g. Moskva,, ul. Ul. Leninskie Gory, 1

yokilixm1226@gmail.com

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8744.2022.1.37480

Received:

05-02-2022


Published:

15-03-2022


Abstract: "A characteristic feature of the Eastern model of comprehensive thinking is a common concept and universal connection /…/ The statement about "Heaven and man are one" is the highest and most complete embodiment of the Eastern comprehensive model of thinking " [2, p.149]. The idea of "Heaven and man are one" is one of the main spirits of traditional Chinese culture. This main idea influenced ancient Chinese politics, ethics, life art, and also penetrated into ancient Chinese aesthetic thought and works of art.The idea of "Heaven and man are one" is the traditional wisdom of the ancient Chinese people.This idea was widely promoted by Chinese society in the 21st century. Comprehensive promotion of the idea of ”the unity of heaven and man" can improve the artist's understanding of the dimension and form of beauty, help break the old paradigm and promote cultural development and progress. This is embodied in artistic creativity, especially in the artistic creativity of Chinese painting, which focuses on the “artistic concept”, which allows artists to pay attention to understanding the general spirit of works of art without destroying the overall beauty because of a certain part. From this it can be seen that the idea of ”the unity of heaven and man" has strong guidance and significance in the field of aesthetic practice, such as artistic creativity. The purpose of this article is to correctly interpret the idea of “the unity of heaven and man” through the analysis of ancient Chinese literature and records in combination with philosophy, aesthetics and other fields. And thanks to the analysis of representative Chinese paintings that adhered to this idea in ancient China, it provides an example of how this idea can be applied to aesthetic practice. In conclusion, we will combine the experience of that time in order to see the positive meanings of this idea in the future.


Keywords:

heaven and man, chinese philosophy, chinese aesthetics, chinese art, Taoism, idea, The Human Tao, Heavenly Tao, nature, Chinese painting

This article is automatically translated.

What is the idea of "Heaven and man are one"

The idea of "Heaven and man are one" goes back to ancient Chinese philosophical thought. "Man" here can be understood as a natural person, or as a human being, or as what Lao Tzu called the "Human Tao". "In the writings of ancient Chinese philosophers, it sometimes seemed that "heaven" refers to God, this point of view is relatively rare. Sometimes it seems that this refers to the material sky, directly opposite the "earth". Sometimes it seems that this refers to nature with intelligence and will" [2, p.163]. In the idea of "Heaven and man are one", "heaven" is "nature with reason and will". "Heaven is the embodiment of the highest reason, justice, and its function is to regulate order, punish and reward each person in accordance with his moral appearance" [10, p.61]. Lao Tzu generically called it the "Heavenly Tao". The unity of heaven and man is to destroy the duality of subject and object and, finally, to achieve the final ideal of harmony and unity between man and nature, and so that man and heaven can perceive together.

In Chinese medicine?

From the point of view of traditional Chinese medicine, the ancients discovered that there are many coincidences between the human body and the laws of nature. Dong Zhongshu in his essay "The Abundant Dew of the Chronicle of Chunqiu" he wrote: "People have three hundred and sixty bones, which exactly corresponds to the number of days in a year; people have bones, flesh and blood, like the earth and rivers; people have ears and eyes, like the sun and moon; human the bodies have acupuncture points and a pulse, like canyons and mountains."

Therefore, ancient Chinese medicine believed that the human body can be viewed as a "small universe" that conforms to the laws of nature. The natural person's own biological clock will depend on the ups and downs of natural tides.Traditional Chinese medicine pays attention to "yin and yang" and "Wu-xing (the Fifth element)", as well as "qi(?)" flowing in the human body. People should allow their own "qi" to function properly in the body so that their internal circulation conforms to the laws of circulation of the external environment. By doing this, you can establish a proper metabolism, feel full of energy, and some functions in the body will gradually improve.

In Chinese philosophy?

From the point of view of ancient philosophy, the earliest written evidence related to "Heaven and man are one" in China goes back to "Zhou and" ?" The Saint is unselfish. His actions obey the Tao and conform to the laws of nature; observe the laws of the action of the sun and moon and watch the four seasons change. When the time is bad, keep your head down, and when the time is good, work hard. Follow the laws of nature, do not violate the laws of nature and make appropriate adjustments when nature changes." The appearance of the phrase "Heaven and man are one" may have originated from the earliest in "Qi wu lun" Chuang Tzu says, "Heaven and earth were born with me, and all things are one with me." Chuang Tzu believes that man and nature are symbiotic, and the relationship between man and nature cannot be viewed in isolation and in opposition.

Tracing the origin, this idea was refined by Chuang Tzu from Taoist thought. In Taoist thought there is: "The Tao gives birth to one, one gives birth to two, two give birth to three, and three give birth to all beings" [1, p.91]. The basic idea, the "Tao" here is the "Heavenly Tao" proposed by Lao Tzu, which refers to the law of everything in the universe. Lao Tzu believes that the action of the "Heavenly Tao" is a direct interaction of two opposing forces, one "yin" and one "yang", and that all things are compatible and coexist. During the operation, a larger number of seats should provide fewer seats so that the strong become weaker and the weak become stronger in order to achieve balance. However, the "Human Tao", that is, the law of society, is the opposite. In society, rich people always deprive poor people of their capital and replenish their stocks. Lao Tzu believes that nature always treats all people and animals simply and fairly. Therefore, the "Heavenly Tao" is just and unselfish, therefore the "Human Tao" must correspond to the "Heavenly Tao".

Lao Tzu said in the Tao Te Ching: "The Tao has great power. It is vast and boundless, it is constantly flowing, it is flowing and expanding, and it is constantly expanding and returning to its source. Therefore, there are four powerful things in the world: Tao, heaven, earth, and man." Here Lao Tzu emphasized the status of a person. Lao Tzu believed that people have thoughts and consciousness, and they can recognize the existence of "Tao". The great philosopher Xunzi once said:"Animals can perceive, but they don't know that morality exists. People not only have qi, life and knowledge, but also understand morality. Therefore, man is the most precious being in the world"[1, p.53].

The great philosopher Xunzi said: "Animals can perceive, but they do not know that there is morality. People not only have qi, life and knowledge, but also understand morality. Therefore, man is the most precious being in the world" [14, p.127].

So, immanently, people have a higher consciousness and morality than other animals and plants in order to achieve the unity of man and neba.

Lao Tzu said that "The Heavenly Tao is just, and it often favors and rewards good people." only by mastering the "good" will he be able to appreciate the true meaning of the "Heavenly Dao". A "good person", that is, a moral person, his behavior follows the laws of the "Heavenly Tao", can treat everything with tolerance, resolve resentment in his heart and deal with everything fairly. Such people can be protected by the "Heavenly Dao" to get more luck and opportunities. Therefore, if a person wants to achieve a state of "unity between heaven and man", he must restrain his morality and do good deeds.

This idea is also key in the works of Leo Tolstoy. Many of Leo Tolstoy's works, such as The Cossacks and Childhood, express moral ideals and the harmonious beauty of human nature, naturalness and social unity. In the treatise "on life" he wrote that man is a part of nature, and nature is a part of man [17, p.45].

In Chinese aesthetics?

The idea of "Heaven and man are one" penetrated into the aesthetic and artistic spheres and influenced the formation of the Chinese aesthetic spirit. In terms of aesthetics, there are many differences between Chinese and European. For example, European aesthetics, also known as sensualism, is a branch of philosophy that studies the emotional experience of a person. The definition of Chinese aesthetics is more like a "philosophy of life". Chinese aesthetics is to "transcend" sensitivity " and strive to understand life immanently. It is not about recognizing beauty in the 'empirical' world, but about experiencing beauty in the 'transcendental' world"[3, p.2]. Compared to the "external beauty" of the European world of aesthetic research and experience, Chinese aesthetics values the "inner (in the heart)" more.

For example, in painting, European artists like to draw in nature. "Chinese artists do not paint a landscape from nature, but always create a generalized collective image of nature in silence, in their studio after a long stay in the open air"[11, p.5]. Chinese artists experience feelings within nature, and not as outside observers of nature. This difference in the creative process is the interpretation by the Chinese artist of the idea "Heaven and man are one".

In classical Chinese aesthetic thought, people believe that a person is a "disciple" of nature, and if a person obeys the laws of nature, he can be merged with nature. Everything in the world is constantly changing and being created. People must integrate into the rheology of the world and merge with the world in order to experience the true beauty of life.Thus, the artist's creative process is "the process by which people integrate nature into their state of mind in order to create"[6, p.125]. "In fact, the Tao with its related concepts of the unity of "spirit and matter", the eternal flow of all things, the reciprocity of opposites became the foundation on which the Chinese erected their art and their theories of art " [8, p.38].

This ancient and harmonious idea of the unity of heaven and man in aesthetics is not unique. In ancient Egypt and Ancient Greece, the aesthetic thought of that time also advocated "harmony". One of the evidences that our ancestors thought about this is the "Book of the Dead" of ancient Egyptian mythology. In the book, the dead will compare themselves to animals. This kind of animal worship reflects the harmony between people, animals and nature. The goddess Maat in the ancient Egyptian religion demanded that people observe the order of the universe, the order of nature and the order of human society. People always take as a basis the orderly changes of nature and maintain balance and harmony between man and nature from beginning to end [15, pp.143-144].

In Greek mythology and philosophy, there is a world order, a world whole, which, unlike Chaos, is not only ordered, but also beautiful because of the harmony that reigns in it"[16, p. 288]. For example, the Pythagorean school believes that "everything is a number," and beauty is harmony. Harmony can be achieved if opposing factors can be combined, and the uncoordinated can be turned into coordination, such as music. In astronomy, music, geometry and arithmetic, the Pythagoreans saw common numerical proportions, harmonic relations, the knowledge of which, according to them, is the knowledge of the essence and structure of the universe [5, p.51]. They believe that a certain proportion of quantity can lead to wonderful effects, such as the "golden ratio" of architecture. This principle of "number and harmony" is also applicable to the whole of nature. They discovered that cosmic celestial bodies rotating at a certain distance can create a kind of harmonious music[18, p.33]. The great ancient Greek philosopher Heraclitus believed that the world is united by confrontation. He advocated war and believed that confrontation promotes harmony [19, pp.57-58]. This idea is similar to the ancient Chinese idea that the two forces "Yin" and "Yang" are opposed to each other, interact and compensate for each other.

 

1. The embodiment of the idea of "Heaven and man are one" in classical Chinese works of art

The traditional Chinese idea of "Heaven and man are one" says that life, the universe and beauty are one, and they are all a complex consisting of different elements, not one. Therefore, ancient Chinese aesthetics often linked beauty and kindness, and also drew attention to the "interweaving of feelings and images", that is, the integration of landscapes and people's moods. Such thoughts flowed into artistic activity and aesthetics, forcing ancient Chinese works of art to focus on the expression of the inner spirit of the subject and emphasize the power of spiritual perception of the subject. The idea of the unity of heaven and man is embodied in many ancient Chinese works of art.

"In classical Chinese art, works of art are not only the embodiment of the artist's personality, but also the embodiment of the principles of the universe" [7, p.11]. The Chinese painting "Travelers among Mountains and Rivers" by the artist of the Northern Song Dynasty Fan Kuang is the artist's life experiences. The artist lives in seclusion in the mountains all year round, feeling the wind and rain in the mountains and enjoying the beauty of the four seasons. In this picture we see that the artist is not a contemplator of nature, but draws the world of life that he "experiences" from a special point of view.

This painting seems to depict landscapes, but it contains a philosophy of life. The artist used the "lubai" parts as intervals, so that the painting consisted of three parts. The lower part seems to be depicted from the point of view of a person looking down. This person is looking down at dense strange rocks that seem to block the road ahead. The middle part seems to be depicted from the point of view of a person looking up. We see a gentle slope. There is a road on a gentle slope. On the way there are several people and donkeys carrying goods. It seems that a monk is vaguely visible in the forest. The upper part, which accounts for about 2/3 of the picture, is a huge, towering, stable mountain. From this corner of the mountain, it seems that the artist is looking up at it. Three perspectives of looking down, looking forward and looking up appear in Chinese painting simultaneously. The artist allowed three perspectives to appear in a Chinese painting at the same time, without feeling dissonance.

The three parts depicted from these three points of view represent the artist's perception of life, that is, three levels of life. In the first level, people can only see the stones in front of them, the dilemmas and failures facing them, and it seems that there is no way out. On the second level, people are like travelers riding donkeys carrying heavy loads to deliver goods, as if they have forgotten about the beautiful scenery around them. Or, like a monk in the forest, he goes step by step to a Taoist temple in search of the Tao. The third level is that towering mountain. At this time, people hear the roar of waterfalls in the mountains and see birds flying in the sky. Surrounded by clouds and fog, people and mountains are united. Man feels the supreme will of heaven, and man resonates with nature. In the magnificent nature, in the vast universe, at this time, people's own little joys and sorrows are no longer important. From the "little self" to the "big nature", from the limited to the infinite - this is the artist's artistic expression of the idea of the unity of heaven and man.

 

2.        The positive meaning of the idea "Heaven and man are one"

In a narrow sense, thanks to the idea of "Heaven and man are one", ancient Chinese works of art often focus on a common aesthetic and spirit, rather than destroying the whole due to the depiction of certain details. In the process of drawing, artists often do it in one go, they can not only pay attention to understanding the general artistic concept, but can also express the charm of natural landscapes. Such paintings are even more majestic, giving the viewer a noble spiritual feeling. Chinese art advocates the coexistence of various factors and reasonable coexistence as a kind of rich beauty. Based on this general beauty, let the part resonate with the whole, so that the content and form of the work of art can be organically combined, and the work of art itself can be more harmonious.

"I think that the idea of "Heaven and man are one" is the oldest and most important statement of ancient Chinese culture"[13, p.93]. As Mr. Qian Mu said, "The word "tianxia" is comprehensive and broad, and its meaning is. It unites human cultures all over the world into one whole, all ethnic groups peacefully coexist, and humanistic nature adapts to each other. Other conclusions can also be drawn from this meaning"[13, p.94]. The traditional spirit of Chinese culture is the crystallization of the wisdom of the ancient Chinese. Since ancient times, the ancient Chinese could notice that man is part of nature and part of the world. A person should not violate nature, a person should be integrated with nature. Mr. Qian Mu believes that all people in the world are members of the earthly civilization, and people should be supported by the idea of "Heaven and man are one", that is, cultures of different countries and nationalities on earth should peacefully coexist, cooperate with each other and, finally, integrate into a single whole. People from all over the world work together to achieve the goal of mutual integration and harmonious development of world cultures.

In a broad sense, the 21st century is the era of information globalization. thanks to economic and trade exchanges between different countries, various countries continue to carry out in-depth exchanges in the field of culture. Generally speaking, the positive meaning of this idea lies in adhering to the idea of "Heaven and man are one", let the people of the whole world communicate peacefully and amicably, and let the cultures of different countries and nationalities develop in harmony, which will contribute to the development and progress of society. This is the positive meaning of the idea "Heaven and man are one", which has influenced Chinese politics and life from ancient times to the present day and can be applied to today's society.

 

 
References
1. Lao Tzu. Tao Te Ching. M., 2015, P 91. P 53.
2. Ji Xianlin Zen. Culture and literature. M., 2003-9, P 149 .P 163.
3. Zhu Zhilian . Fifteen Lectures on Chinese Aesthetics. M., 2006.4
4. Mou Zhenghua. Explain: Heaven has no relatives, always be with kind people // Charity, 2017(1):1.
5. Gaidenko P.P. The history of Greek philosophy in its connection with science. M., 2009. P 51.
6. Fang Xiao. Philosophical reflections on the technique of Chinese painting, art and Tao // Hunan Normal University, 2018. P 125.
7. Fan Baoying. On the aesthetic spirit of "Heaven and man are one" // Jiangxi Social Sciences, 2002 (7).
8. Danzanova E.Zh. Dualism in Chinese and Western European thought // Eurasianism and the world. - 2013. - V. 1, No. 1. CP 38.
9. Zhang Dai Nian, Cheng Yishan. Chinese cultural spirit // Theoretical education, 2015.
10. Li Wanli,The problem of relations between heaven and man in ancient Chinese philosophy //Historical, philosophical, political and legal sciences, cultural studies and art history. Questions of theory and practice. Tambov: Diploma, 2018. No. 1. P. 61-64.
11. K. M. Klimov. Chen Wei Exhibition catalogue// Udmurt State University. M., 1990
12. Feng Yu-Lan Brief history of Chinese philosophy. M., 2013.
13. Qian Mu, The contribution of Chinese culture to the future of mankind // Chinese Culture, August 1991, No. 4, P 93-96.
14. Peking University Xunzi Group, Xunzi New Note. M., 1979, P 127.
15. Jin Ling, The Concept of Harmony in Ancient Egyptian Ethics // Inner Mongolia University Journal for Nationalities, 2008-1. P 143-144.
16. Dictionary of antiquity. M., Progress, 1989. P 288.
17. Shatalov A. A. L. N. Tolstoy on nature and natural education // Socio-ecological technologies. 2013. No. 2. P 45.
18. Zhu Guangqian History of Western Philosophy. M., 2002. P 33.
19. Bertrand Russell History of Western Philosophy. M., 2010. P 57-58.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

In the journal "Philosophy and Culture", the author presented his article "The idea of "Heaven and man are one" in ancient Chinese aesthetic thought and its positive significance," which conducted a study of the features of the Chinese worldview about the unity of man and nature with its immutable laws. The author proceeds in studying this issue from the fact that the idea of "Heaven and man are one" assumes that people have a higher consciousness and morality than other animals and plants, and therefore can interact with higher forces to achieve perfection and harmony. Unfortunately, the author does not provide a scientific justification for the issue under study: the article lacks an introduction, which should contain material on the relevance of the research, its scientific novelty, the degree of scientific elaboration, there are no goals, objectives, theoretical justification and methodological basis. A conclusion with conclusions based on the results of the study is also missing in the article. Without these data, the article cannot correspond to the status of scientific research. The text of the article is divided into three logically justified sections. In the first section, "What is the idea of "Heaven and man are one", the author examines the essence of this idea from the standpoint of Chinese medicine, philosophy, aesthetics. According to Chinese philosophy, man and nature exist in an organic symbiosis, and the relationship between them cannot be considered in isolation and in opposition. This idea can be traced back to Chinese thinkers, starting with "Zhou Yi", and developed by supporters of Taoism. According to the author, the human body is a reflection of the laws of the surrounding world. If a person does not ignore these laws and organizes his life in accordance with them, then he will be healthy, full of strength and energy. The idea of the unity of man and higher forces also led to the formation of the Chinese aesthetic perception of the surrounding world and man's place in it: "Chinese artists experience feelings inside nature, and not as outside observers of nature." The second section of "Classical Chinese works of Art" (grammatical inconsistency!) It is devoted to the study of the embodiment of the idea of unity with the sky in Chinese artistic culture. The author notes that the works of traditional Chinese art are distinguished by the connection of the spiritual world of a person, his mood, thoughts, emotions with the outside world. The works of art focus on expressing the inner spirit of the subject and emphasize the power of its spiritual perception. Thus, the painting "Travelers among mountains and rivers" by the artist of the Northern Song dynasty Fan Kuan is not only and how much an image of the landscape, but, first of all, a reflection of the experiences of the creator, perception and philosophy of his life. In the third section, "The positive meaning of the idea "Heaven and man are one", the author studied the influence of the idea of harmony between man and nature on the formation of worldview. To the author, this idea seems to be an advantage, its positive influence lies in the fact that it attaches importance to works of art of majestic noble beauty and harmony. "Chinese art advocates the coexistence of various factors and intelligent coexistence as a kind of rich beauty." Under the influence of this idea, interpersonal communication reaches a qualitatively new level, marked by mutual respect and peaceful harmonious coexistence of representatives of different civilizations. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing a topic for analysis, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of the influence of the peculiarities of the worldview of a certain society on the development of its artistic culture and intercultural communication is of undoubted scientific and practical cultural interest and deserves further study. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. The bibliographic list of the study consists of 13 sources, which seems sufficient for the generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the subject under study. However, the text of the article needs correction. It should be stated that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication after these shortcomings have been eliminated.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the study, the idea of "Heaven and man are one" in ancient Chinese aesthetic thought, the author tried to consider comprehensively, analyzing the religious and ethical doctrine of Lao Tzu, ontological (cosmogonic) postulates of Chinese traditional medicine, individual philosophical texts and paintings. Quite appropriately, the author makes a comparison of ancient Chinese aesthetics and the ancient Greek concept of mimesis, makes an attempt to compare it with European aesthetics. However, it is more logical to compare ancient Chinese aesthetics not with a separate ancient Greek theory, but with ancient Greek aesthetics as a whole. After all, the aesthetic category of harmony (cosmos), as opposed to disharmony (chaos), lay at the heart of the ancient Greeks' worldview. If the author had managed to compare the common and distinctive features of the idea "Heaven and man are one" in ancient Chinese aesthetic thought and ancient Greek ideas of harmony, perhaps the author's thought would have gained certainty. Then we could talk about the disclosure of the subject. In the meantime, we have to state that the subject of the study has not been disclosed, and comparative judgments regarding ancient Greek and European aesthetics look speculative, demagogic, declarative and not fully justified. The research methodology as a whole is based on the logic of ascent from the analysis of empirical material (the idea of "Heaven and man are one" in ancient Chinese aesthetic thought is highlighted using specific examples) to cross-cultural comparison. The logic is clear, but not fully sustained: there is no clear definition of the arguments being compared. If ancient Chinese aesthetic thought is generally represented, then the comparison with ancient Greek and European aesthetics fails and does not stand up to criticism. For example, the author's statement that the harmonization of goodness and beauty is inherent exclusively in ancient Chinese aesthetics does not correspond to reality: the earliest mention of harmony of goodness and beauty in the history of mankind is already in ancient Egyptian mythology ("The Book of the Dead"), ancient Greek cosmogony is based on the idea of harmony, this key idea is also in the works of F.M. Dostoevsky, where the aesthetics of the soul of the Russian person is revealed. For cross-cultural comparisons, the author lacks the support of well-studied aspects of classical, Russian and European aesthetics in the world of humanities. The lack of adequate comparisons leads the author to misconception about the exceptional value of the idea "Heaven and man are one", as if it has no analogue in other cultures. The relevance of the presented topic is due to the increasing role of Chinese culture in the common integration space of cultures of the peoples of the world. Common cultural codes of peaceful neighborliness are extremely important for intercultural cooperation. One cannot disagree with the author on this. The scientific novelty and value of the material submitted for review lies, first of all, in the appeal to empirical material that reveals the meaningful side of the idea "Heaven and man are one" in ancient Chinese aesthetic thought. Of course, the author's conclusions would have sounded more convincing if he had succeeded in cross-cultural comparisons of aesthetic ideas of different peoples. Unfortunately, the style is far from the standards of Russian scientific periodicals. The sections describing the degree of knowledge of the topic (in China, in other countries) and discussion of poorly studied aspects of the topic would significantly strengthen the article. The bibliography reflects both the strengths of the article (literature by Chinese authors) and the weaknesses (complete lack of analysis of academic literature by scientists from other countries). The literature for the last 5 years is poorly represented (3 sources out of 14). The design does not meet the requirements of the journal and the standards accepted in Russian scientific periodicals. The appeal to the opponents is mainly complementary in nature to complement the thoughts of Chinese scientists. An exception is an attempt to criticize the theory of mimesis. But the author does not rely on primary sources, so it is difficult to determine who is wrong about the authorship of the theory of mimesis: the author himself or his colleague to whom he refers. In any case, the appeal is present in the study. Conclusion. The material is of some interest and, despite several comments, can be published.